Outdated alcohol guidelines understate health risks, ministry documents reveal
Photo:
RNZ
New Zealand's official low-risk drinking guidelines are outdated and "understate the health risks" of alcohol, according to Health New Zealand (HNZ) documents.
Efforts to update the guidelines were halted after
alcohol lobbyists complained
to a Ministry of Health general manager Ross Bell.
Bell, who works within the ministry's Public Health Agency, says he intervened to clear up confusion about whether HNZ or the Ministry of Health (MOH) should manage the guidelines.
He said the MOH would manage them now but that work was on hold while it considered its priorities.
Documents released to RNZ under the Official Information Act show why HNZ considered updating the safe drinking guidelines was crucial and that it saw "scrutiny from the alcohol industry" as a risk factor in the process.
New Zealand's drinking guidelines say that to stay low-risk, men should have no more than 15 drinks per week and women ten.
The maximum number of drinks recommended per week to stay low-risk (for men and women) is set at two in Canada, ten in Australia and 14 in the UK.
Canada, Australia and the UK all significantly reduced their safe drinking guidelines in recent years as evidence emerged about the health risks of alcohol, which is linked to seven types of cancer.
Photo:
RNZ
A November 2024 memo from HNZ alcohol harm prevention manager Tom Devine said New Zealand's guidelines, written in 2011, were now out of date.
"The evidence around alcohol and its risks to health has evolved since then and other countries like ours, such as the United Kingdom (in 2016), Australia (in 2020), and Canada (in 2023), have updated their Alcohol & Health Advice, resulting in much lower recommended drinking limits," Devine wrote. "The current advice is complex (and) out of step with other jurisdictions."
He said the current guidelines also did not meet the needs of pregnant and breast-feeding women and young people. "A review and update are necessary to ensure the advice is clear, inclusive and based on the most up-to-date evidence."
Another HNZ document, written in January 2024, said "The current advice does not reflect the latest scientific evidence meaning that it understates the health risks from alcohol."
The documents show HNZ commissioned Massey University to work on the first phase of a review in February 2024 - at a cost of about $130,000 - but later that year Ross Bell from the Ministry of Health intervened.
Emails obtained by RNZ show a lobbyist with the Brewer's Association emailed Bell in October 2024 asking why a HNZ website was reporting that the drinking guidelines were under review.
He emailed again a month later complaining that references to the review were still on the alcohol.org.nz website, run by HNZ, and also took issue with the fact the site linked to Canadian drinking guidelines.
Bell emailed HNZ in December 2024: "All work on this project will now pause. You will update relevant Health NZ websites to remove references to the review and also to other jurisdictions' guidelines (including the Canadian one)."
Bell has declined requests for an interview with RNZ, but in a previous statement said material was removed from the website to avoid confusion, as the drinking guidelines were now led by the Ministry of Health not Health New Zealand, which runs the alcohol.org.nz website.
He said that was an internal decision by MOH and that a review of the drinking guidelines was now on hold while the ministry considered its priorities.
But the documents released to RNZ show HNZ believe it is crucial to update the guidance.
A memo from HNZ alcohol harm prevention manager Tom Devine said health professionals relied on accurate guidelines, which were "foundational" for screening, interventions and referral for treatment.
"This is where health professionals ask patients about their alcohol consumption using the advice as a baseline to assess risk, which informs the need for brief interventions or referral for counselling or treatment."
Devine's memo said one of the risks in reviewing the guidelines was "scrutiny from the alcohol industry" and his mitigation strategy included "a strategic communications plan to articulate the evidence base and reasoning".
Associate Professor Andy Towers, the co-director of the Mental Health & Addiction Programme at Massey University, worked on the initial stages of the review for HNZ.
He said the current guidelines understated the risk.
"There's more and more evidence now, especially with longitudinal health data, to show that even low levels of alcohol use over a long time can result in some significant alcohol related harms."
He said sticking with the 2011 guidelines could lull drinkers into a false sense of security.
"For us to set low risk advice thresholds that are quite high, much higher than other countries, means that we will continue to have serious alcohol related harms occurring across the country, in communities, and that will flow through into hospitals."
Cancer Society evidence and insights lead Emma Shields said a review of the drinking guidelines was needed to bring them into line with the latest evidence and international guidance.
She said alcohol caused seven different types of cancer including breast, bowel and oesophageal. "When it comes to cancer risk, there is no 'safe' level of alcohol use, and even small amounts of alcohol increase the risk of cancer."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Auckland GP sees increase in patients coming to acute clinics after being referred away from hospitals
A doctor at a private urgent care clinic, said they've been overwhelmed by patients coming with colds and flu-like illnesses over the past week. Photo: Supplied/ Unsplash - Nap studio An Auckland GP said he's seeing an increasing number of patients coming to their acute clinics after being referred away from hospitals that have been hit by winter illnesses. On Tuesday, Health NZ said the city's public hospitals were at their "upper limit", with many turning up at emergency departments with respiratory illnesses - but said it is not turning patients away in Auckland and Northland. Earlier, St John said there had been delays handing patients over to Auckland City and Middlemore Hospitals on Monday afternoon and that it was working with hospitals to manage the situation, including using telehealth and taking patients to non-hospital clinics. Carlos Lam, who works at a practice in East Tāmaki, said the acute clinic run by the practice had been filled by patients who were unable to be seen in a timely manner at hospital. "They've been a bit frustrated waiting in the hospital, or they've called Healthline, and Healthline has advised they see a doctor straight away," he said. He said there's pressure on their clinics as some staff are getting sick themselves and having to take leave. Dr Lam said they've been overwhelmed by patients coming in with colds and flu-like illnesses over the past week - with patients having to wait about three to four hours. He said many have been to Middlemore Hospital, only to be given vouchers and referred to their clinic - he noted that there were babies and older patients among them. Meanwhile, North Shore district nurse Lesley Pook said she's seeing the impact of the full hospitals through patients she's seeing in the community. Pook, speaking as a New Zealand Nurses Organisation delegate, said patients - some with respiratory infections - who otherwise would've stayed in hospital are being discharged earlier. "That puts a lot of pressure on our service to be able to deliver care for these people , we don't have the staffing to be able to do that adequately, a lot of times like last week, we were down 23 hours last Thursday, so that was 23 hours of care we couldn't deliver that day," she said. Northland emergency doctor Gary Payinda, speaking in a personal capacity, said he's noticed increasingly that patients were being referred to private urgent care in recent months. "As a result of our ED being full, we certainly have seen an increase in the number of patients we attempt to refer away, and to give patients telehealth appointments, to give them vouchers to be seen in the private sector, at for profit urgent care locally, so we have been struggling with that during times where we have increased numbers of influenza A." Dr Payinda said even during a normal season, they're struggling to give patients timely care due to overwhelmed hospitals and severe nursing shortages. "This is not just a seasonable flu thing, that might be the straw that broke the camel's back, but the camel was already sick and starved and emaciated to begin with," he said. Dr Payinda said it used to be unacceptable to be treating patients in the hospital corridors, but that was becoming more frequent. He said EDs could do a much better job if there were safe staffing levels for every shift. HNZ's northern acting deputy chief executive, Vanessa Thornton, said in a statement that no patients were being turned away in Auckland or Northland. "In Auckland and Whangārei, people may be offered other options to expedite their review if they are presenting with non-urgent illnesses," she said. She said hospitals' EDs have been very busy as expected during winter. "We also work closely with key partners such as Hato Hone St John, urgent care providers, and telehealth to manage high demand and provide points of escalation. "We work closely to ensure primary care, urgent care providers and our hospitals are able to work together and share workload to deliver the best care for our community." She said anyone who needed urgent or emergency care should go to ED without delay or call 111. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Auckland hospitals at their upper limit
health Auckland Region 21 minutes ago Significant pressure at Auckland's major hospitals this winter is being felt across almost all the different parts of the health system, including at general practice, private urgent care and in the community. The pressure is becoming so great GPs have said they are overwhelmed by the sheer number of people with winter sicknesses. One nurse said the system is so stretched she is seeing sick patients discharged into the community before they're ready. Today Health NZ said the city's public hospitals are at their "upper limit", with many turning up at emergency departments with repiratory illnesses, but said it is not turning patients away in Auckland and Northland. Lucy Xia reports.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Councillor ‘risking health' by ignoring boil water notice
Southland district councillor Derek Chamberlain says there is nothing wrong with the water coming out of his tap. Photo: LDR/supplied The country's water regulator says a Southland councillor who refuses to boil his tap water could be risking his health. However, councillor Derek Chamberlain is standing by his decision to ignore a local boil water notice despite criticism from Taumata Arowai. Chamberlain made headlines this week for saying he would sooner drink from his compromised Eastern Bush/Otahu Flat network than have Auckland water. The district councillor lives on one of 54 properties in rural Southland which has been under a boil notice since July 2024. Taumata Arowai head of operations Steve Taylor said Chamberlain's decision to ignore the notice was not safe, even though he was using a filter. There were a range of factors affecting a filter's ability to remove microorganisms including type, pore size, and whether it was used in conjunction with other treatments like boiling or UV, Taylor said. "Your councillor may feel that their water is fine to drink, but they may be risking their health." A boil notice has been in place for Eastern Bush/Otahu Flat, north of Tūātapere, since July 2024. Photo: Laura Smith / LDR One of the main issues affecting the Eastern Bush/Otahu Flat supply was turbidity - or cloudiness - which became worse when rain dirtied the Wairaki River. Taylor said high turbidity impacted treatment and indicated a higher risk of protozoa, which the supply did not have a barrier to protect against. Even if the water was visibly clear, it could still contain pathogens which could lead to serious illness, he warned. In response, Chamberlain issued the regulator a challenge "If they're that concerned about it, why don't they come down and do something about it?" he said. "My argument's at Wellington. I mean it's alright for them sitting up there bloody making all the rules, someone's got to pay for it." The boil notice was issued in July 2024 and could be in place until as late as 2027 when the treatment plant is upgraded. On Monday, the council issued a reminder to residents that boiling was still necessary. The notice is the only active one across the entire region. LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air
