The TSA may soon adopt a new liquids policy
This change in policy was announced by the DHS secretary, not by the administrator of the Transportation Security Administration (the deputy administrator is currently serving as the acting administrator). The Senate has not approved a new administrator since David Pekoske was relieved of his duties by the president on Jan. 20, 2025. Given that some senators have called for the TSA to be abolished, such cacophony likely means that a new TSA administrator will not be named too soon.
So why is this a problem?
The TSA security gauntlet is an intricate system of layers, many of which are invisible to travelers. The most visible aspects are what is deployed at airport security checkpoints, including advanced imaging technologies for passenger screening and CT scanners for passenger baggage. Some of the less visible layers include federal air marshals deployed on certain flights, hardened airplane cockpit doors, and Secure Flight, which vets passengers prior to their flight.
Risk-based security is the glue that ties all such layers together. It informs the use of security technologies and the creation of policies such that the air system can be maximally secured with minimal passenger inconvenience.
Recall that after the Sept. 11 attacks in 2001, all passengers were treated the same from a security perspective. Such a one-size-fits-all approach was expensive and inconvenient to passengers, with little evidence that it made the air system more secure. It was also unsustainable.
This led to the creation of TSA PreCheck, which gives passengers access to expedited screening lanes, where they can keep their shoes on when being screened and keep their electronic devices in their carry-on bag. TSA Precheck passengers have voluntarily gone through a background check — this is why they can be subjected to expedited, less intrusive physical screening at checkpoints.
Allowing passengers with a REAL ID to keep their shoes on when being screened is, in and of itself, not bad. It is always easier to tighten security procedures than to relax them. In practice, passengers may discover that when wearing certain types of footwear, like work or hiking boots, choosing to remove them voluntarily may end up saving them time, since the full body screener may flag them for additional screening, which will then require the footwear to be removed anyway.
What is next in airport security? Belts are likely on the docket for consideration, although the same delays may occur if the full body scanners flag certain belts for additional screening.
The one that is on most people's minds is the liquid restriction. The United Kingdom relaxed its liquid policy at certain airports when it installed CT scanners for carry-on bags. The acting TSA administrator recently indicated that this policy would stay in place in the U.S. until around 2043, given the time needed to fully deploy CT scanners for carry-on bags at all U.S. airports.
To confuse the issue further, the DHS secretary has now indicated that the liquid policy is up for discussion, provided the necessary guardrails remain in place to keep the system secure. Perhaps relaxing the liquid restriction for PreCheck passengers traveling from airports with CT scanners will be the next step forward.
Most people would welcome this policy change. But what can be done to ensure that the system's security remains sufficiently robust?
The answer is not promises from industry partners offering the newest and flashiest scanning technology to detect liquid explosives. It is, rather facial recognition.
By requiring all passengers' identity to be authenticated using facial recognition, this layer will fill in holes left by relaxing some physical screening procedures.
Facial recognition at airport security checkpoints has been a lightning rod of controversy for some time. A group of senators have called for it to be paused, based on concerns about personal privacy and civil liberties. The Travelers Privacy Protection Act of 2025 would give anyone the right to opt out of facial recognition being used to authenticate their identity. If such an act becomes law, it would set airport security back by a decade, by locking airport security into its threat item-centric paradigm, rather than focusing on threatening people, which is where the greatest risks reside.
If the DHS intends to relax more of the security layers in place to protect the aviation system, ensuring that facial recognition continues to be a centerpiece of their strategy is critical. Putting a Senate-approved TSA administrator in place would also be important, to provide confidence that the collection of security layers being used is keeping the air system secure for all travelers.
Sheldon H. Jacobson, Ph.D., is a computer science professor in the Grainger College of Engineering at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. He has researched risk-based aviation security for over 25 years, which provided the technical justification for TSA PreCheck.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
4 hours ago
- CBS News
Minnesota House Republicans ask for federal audit of state's Department of Human Services
House Republicans in Minnesota are asking for a federal audit of the state's Department of Human Services. The push is spearheaded by state Rep. Kristin Robbins, R-Maple Grove, who serves as chair of the Fraud Prevention and State Agency Oversight Committee. She and others submitted a formal request to the acting inspector general at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services for a federal audit of the state DHS on Wednesday. They say there has been extensive abuse of public funds for years within several Medicaid programs, costing taxpayers over $1 billion. That includes high-profile cases, like the Feeding Our Future scheme, which federal prosecutors called the biggest pandemic-era fraud in the country, and a new investigation into Medicaid fraud at Minnesota autism centers. WCCO learned last week that federal agents are also investigating what they call a "massive scheme to defraud" Minnesota's Housing Stabilization Services program. "This culture of corruption must end. It's time for real accountability, and that starts with a full, independent federal audit," Robbins said. "The people of Minnesota deserve to know where their money is going and why so little has been done to stop this theft." Also on Wednesday, Rep. Tom Emmer says he and the Minnesota Republican congressional delegation wrote a letter to Gov. Tim Walz demanding answers for the alleged fraud within the DHS, specifically the Housing Stabilization Services program. When the program started in 2020, it was estimated that it would cost taxpayers about $2.5 million a year. But by 2021, it cost $21 million. Last year, it ballooned to $104 million. "We ask that you provide us with the relevant information about how this fraud transpired under your administration's watch, steps you are taking to rectify the situation, and your plans to prevent future fraud within the HSS program," the letter says in part. Some lawmakers say a new office to handle issues like fraud needs to be reconsidered after being cut during special session budget negotiations.
Hamilton Spectator
5 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
House GOP seeks to censure Democrat McIver over New Jersey detention center incident
WASHINGTON (AP) — A House Republican proposed a resolution Wednesday to censure Democratic Rep. LaMonica McIver over an incident with law enforcement during a congressional oversight visit to a new immigration detention facility in her home state of New Jersey. Republican Rep. Clay Higgins of Louisiana pushed forward the measure, which also calls for removing McIver from her seat on the Homeland Security Committee, as the House was preparing to recess for the August break. As a privileged resolution, it can be considered for swift action as soon as lawmakers return in September. Higgins read from the resolution on the House floor, arguing that McIver violated the chamber rules that require a member 'to behave at all times in a manner that shall reflect creditably on the House.' He said her continued service on the Homeland Security Committee 'would represent a significant conflict of interest.' The GOP action comes as House Republicans in the majority have been quick to punish Democratic lawmakers for transgressions large and small — and in this situation, before McIver's case has played out in court. She has pleaded not guilty to charges brought by interim U.S. Attorney Alina Habba , a Republican appointed by President Donald Trump, stemming from the May 9 incident. A trial date has been set for November. The congresswoman has vowed not to be intimidated by the legal and political actions against her. 'Clay Higgins is a bigot who wants to be back in the news,' McIver said in a statement. She pointed to the way House Republicans are 'running home to hide,' having recessed for August break a day early. 'This resolution aims to kick me off the committee that presides over the Department of Homeland Security and shame me for doing the oversight work that is my job. Good luck, Clay,' she said. Members of Congress have been conducting oversight of the federal detention centers that are being stood up by the Trump administration across the nation as part of the president's mass deportation agenda. Lawmakers have been assessing how best to conduct such work amid blowback by the Trump administration. At the time, McIver, a new lawmaker first elected in 2024, was making the visit with other House Democrats and Newark Mayor Ras Baraka at the privately owned 1,000-bed facility that Immigration and Customs Enforcement is using as a detention center. McIver was indicted on three counts of assaulting, resisting, impeding and interfering with federal officials. Two of the counts carry a maximum sentence of up to eight years in prison. The third is a misdemeanor with a maximum punishment of one year in prison. Baraka was also arrested on a trespassing charge that was later dropped and is suing Habba over what he called a malicious prosecution. A nearly two-minute video clip released by the Department of Homeland Security shows McIver at the facility inside a chain-link fence just before Baraka's arrest on other side of the barrier, where other people were protesting. The video shows McIver in a tightly packed group of people and officers. At one point her left elbow and then her right elbow push into an officer wearing a dark face covering and an olive green uniform emblazoned with the word 'Police.' It is not clear from police bodycam video if the contact was intentional, incidental or the result of jostling in the chaotic scene. The prospect of a House censure used to be rare, with fewer than 30, but has become more frequent in recent years. ___ Associated Press writer Matt Brown contributed to this report. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
New York Post
5 hours ago
- New York Post
Viral story about grandpa secretly ‘deported' to Guatemala by ICE, then found ‘dead' is hoax: feds
A widely-reported story about a Pennsylvania grandfather being secretly snatched by ICE agents and deported to Guatemala is nothing but a 'hoax,' according to Homeland Security — as it emerged he may even have died six years ago. Luis Leon's family told reporters that the 82-year-old Chilean national had been handcuffed and taken away by federal officers when he went to a green card appointment in Philadelphia on June 20. They then claimed they were told he had died in ICE custody — but then he turned up alive at a hospital in Guatemala. Advertisement 3 The viral story circulating that Luis Leon, 82, was secretly deported by ICE agents turns out to be a 'hoax,' according to Homeland Security (DHS). Leon Family The story, which was initially reported by Allentown outlet the Morning Call, before being picked up by lefty outlets including the Daily Beast, the Guardian and the Independent, was shut down by the Department for Homeland Security. 'ICE never arrested or deported Luis Leon to Guatemala. Nor does ICE 'disappear' people — this is a categorical lie being peddled to demonize ICE agents who are already facing an 830 percent increase in assaults against them,' DHS Assistant Press Secretary Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement. Advertisement 'This was a hoax peddled by the media who rushed to press without pausing to corroborate the facts with DHS. This was journalistic malpractice,' she said. The DHS also said there is 'no record of the man appearing at any green card appointment in or around the area of Philadelphia' on June 20. Leon's family told the reporter that he was sent to a Minnesota detention facility and that a woman claiming to be an immigration lawyer called them to say he had died in ICE custody and offered to help them, without disclosing how she knew about the case. 3 Leon's family told reporters he was taken away by officials in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, after going to a green card appointment — but then he turned up alive at a hospital in Guatemala. Paul Martinka Advertisement They claimed they later found out he was in a hospital in Guatemala from a Chilean relative. But the Guatemalan Institute of Migration, which coordinates with ICE on all deportations from the US, said it had not received anyone matching Leon's name, age or nationality, the Associated Press reported. And while Guatemala has agreed to receive US deportees from other Central American countries, the agreement doesn't extend to South America. 3 The story of Leon's deportation circulated through many outlets before DHS shut down the story. Leon Family Advertisement Leon was granted political asylum in the US in 1987 and worked in a leather manufacturing plant for 40 years before retiring, the Morning Call reported. However, ICE states its only record of Leon entering the US is in 2015 from Chile under a visa waiver program. A death certificate matching Leon's name and date of birth from the Chilean capital of Santiago in 2019 was presented to the Morning Call by a Chilean journalist, Jose Del Pino. The Morning Call published an updated story on Monday defending its reporting, saying its reporters 'repeatedly requested information from Ice during its reporting; an Ice spokesperson previously refused to confirm details, including whether or not Leon was even at the Philadelphia office, and said Monday that Ice investigators were not able to contact the family.' Leon's supposed family told the Morning Call in a statement that they would no longer speak to the media and asked for privacy. The Morning Call did not respond immediately to requests for comment.
