Tory peer forced to apologise for antisemitic slur over Holocaust memorial
Archie Hamilton, a former minister under Margaret Thatcher and John Major, said taxpayers' money should not be used to pay for the memorial and education centre in Victoria Tower Gardens, next to parliament.
In a debate in the Lords, he said the park is too small for the proposed project, adding: 'I do not understand why the government have volunteered taxpayers' money, when there is so little of it, to finance this.
'The Jewish community in Britain has an awful lot of money. It has a lot of education charities that would contribute towards this. I do not understand why they should not pay for their own memorial.'
The Antisemitism Policy Trust said the comments were 'ill-judged, racist and false' and it was 'shocking that his slur was not challenged by those leading the debate'.
Ex-Labour MP Ian Austin, a crossbench peer, pushed back against Lord Hamilton's comments saying the memorial is 'not for the Jewish community… it is a memorial for everybody'.
Lord Hamilton replied that the 'driving forces behind putting up this memorial are the Jewish people in this country'.
'They are people who have property everywhere. I do not see why they should not fund it. I just do not understand why the British taxpayer should be asked to pay for this when there is quite clearly a tremendous shortage of taxpayers' money to go around,' Lord Hamilton added.
He was criticised by Tory peer Daniel Finkelstein, who hit back: 'The noble Lord cannot stand up here and say, 'The Jews want the Holocaust memorial, and they ought to pay for it'.
'The Holocaust is not something that is just about the Jews.'
Lord Hamilton pushed back saying that he has 'plenty of Jewish blood' and is a member of the Conservative Friends of Israel.
The Antisemitism Policy Trust said Lord Hamilton's comments were 'ill-judged, racist and false'.
Its chief executive Danny Stone added that they 'betrayed a lack of knowledge and understanding about the Jewish community and what the Holocaust memorial is for'.
'It is shocking that his slur was not challenged by those leading the debate. We will be working with parliamentarians to ensure this appalling rhetoric does not remain unchallenged,' he added.
In a statement issued after the debate, Lord Hamilton withdrew the remarks and apologised.
He said: 'My remarks were not intended to be antisemitic and I apologise unreservedly.
'With hindsight, having read my comments , I realise that my remarks were insensitive and I apologise. I intend to meet with groups from the Jewish community in order to understand how to communicate about issues affecting British Jews.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
21 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Iran 'is hunting British spies using leaked kill list' - with fears they will be captured and used as 'bargaining chips'
Iran is plotting with the Taliban to hunt down British agents using a leaked database that exposed details of MI6 spies and UK Special Forces. Officials from Iran's Revolutionary Guards flew to Kabul last week to ask Afghanistan 's warlords for 'access' to the bombshell list at the centre of a two-year super-injunction drama in the UK. Earlier this month it was reported that Iran had begun efforts to get their hands on the highly sensitive list 'so they can hunt down MI6 spies'. But now it is understood that four IRGC officials - who are said to have travelled to Afghanistan without involving Tehran's civilian government - intend to capture British spies and use them as 'bargaining chips' in negotiations with the West over the nation's controversial nuclear programme, The Telegraph reported. In return, the Taliban wish to be formally recognised by Iran as the official rulers of Afghanistan. A senior Iranian official said the list had been handed over by the Taliban, adding: 'They [the IRGC officials] want to find British spies before the 'snapback' to have something to pressure London behind closed doors.' The spectre of Iran's extremists and the brutal Taliban regime co-ordinating efforts to hunt down British agents has been causing 'concern' in Whitehall, the Daily Mail reported earlier this month. A vital database of Afghans and UK officials putting 100,000 people 'at risk of death'. A soldier escorts a family at Stansted in May as part of a government scheme costed at £7billion smuggling migrants to Britain after a data-leak blunder exposed by the Daily Mail When the Daily Mail discovered this data breach disaster in 2023, the Government secured a draconian court order to hush it up, triggering a 23-month battle in secret courts for open justice. Last month the Government finally abandoned its super-injunction and the public discovered ministers had secretly agreed a £7billion scheme, including a mass evacuation programme to rescue thousands of Afghans who had worked for British forces. Ministers ordered lawyers to gag the Daily Mail and others with a second High Court injunction, to prevent the media revealing how the lost list had included details of more than a hundred MI6 spies, Special Forces and other UK officials. The so-called 'kill list' contains the names of 25,000 Afghans who were applying to a UK scheme to give sanctuary to those who had worked on the frontlines with British forces. The Daily Mail has seen a copy of the full dataset lost by the British government, and it is understood it also includes details of more than 100 British officials including MI6, Special Forces and senior military commanders, as well as MPs. Many of these were included to help officials verify legitimate claims. Although codes are used, and the list does not specifically identify any spies or special forces, it could be a valuable dataset for an enemy. It is understood that several people whose names appear on the list have been arrested in recent days by Iranian border forces. Daily Mail journalists faced jail by order of a Penal Notice if they revealed the Government's secret - or even breathed a word about the existence of the draconian court order Many have been released soon after, with the 'focus' said to be on detaining 'British spies'. This week, Britain, France and Germany threatened Iran with a 'snapback' - the return of economic sanctions that were imposed before 2015 if nuclear talks did not begin again by the end of this month. In 2015 a deal was struck between Iran and Western powers to curb its nuclear enrichment program in return for a lifting of banking and trade sanctions. With this deal due to expire on October 18, the official added: 'The IRGC is doing everything it can to find bargaining chips for talks before the deadline.' Meanwhile a Taliban official told The Telegraph: 'Some argued that we should not do any favours for the Iranians given how badly they are treating our refugees there, but if they were willing to recognise the Islamic Emirate [of Afghanistan] in return, that would not be a bad deal.' The so-called 'kill list' was accidentally leaked in February 2022 when a British soldier emailed the complete file to Afghan contacts instead of sending a small extract. A Government spokesman said: 'It's a longstanding policy of successive governments to not comment on intelligence matters but this once again underlines how serious the original data breach was and why the previous government have serious questions to answer about how this was ever allowed to happen.'
Daily Mail
21 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
ANDREW PIERCE: Londoners have the Tube, Sadiq Khan has a gravy train
London may be riddled with crime, soaring prices and poor-quality transport – but at least Mayor Sadiq Khan and his officials can enjoy the finer things in life. Latest figures reveal City Hall racked up a £2billion expenses bill in the past financial year. This includes a jaw-dropping £4.6million on printing, £805,000 on hotel accommodation and £57,000 on photography. Then there's the £48,000 spent on postage and another £31,000 for European and domestic flights. The Mayor himself also received tickets worth almost £8,000 to football matches and Taylor Swift concerts (he was last month cleared of wrongdoing in relation to the gifts). And, not to be outdone, his aides have cashed in to the tune of £11,000 with tickets to Glastonbury, the Brit Awards and the UEFA Champions League football finals. Nice work if you can get it... In the Spring Statement, Rachel Reeves announced the formation of the Defence Growth Board to oversee investment in our Armed Forces. Five months later, how many times has it met? Not once. Yet more window-dressing from a Chancellor woefully out of her depth. Cotswolds locals weren't the only Britons amazed by Mr Vance's 24-vehicle entourage during his trip to Britain. BBC grandee John Simpson tells how the late Queen Elizabeth would travel around Britain by train. 'She and her companions would have four seats in a first-class carriage, plus two more for her detectives, leaving the rest of the carriage for the public,' he notes. '[They] were always stunned to see her with so little security.' All eyes will be on London's Guildhall on October 13 when Tory big beasts gather for the tenth anniversary dinner of the Margaret Thatcher Centre – dedicated to the legacy of Britain's greatest post-war leader. But there'll be one notable absence – that of party leader Kemi Badenoch, who will be attending a fundraising event elsewhere on the same night. Lammy's angling is rather fishy... It seems that David Lammy has never held a fishing rod in his life, to judge from his laughably unconvincing fishing pose with US Vice-President JD Vance. The Foreign Secretary, whose Tottenham constituency borders the favourite spot of many London anglers, the Walthamstow Wetlands, could have made more of an effort. I doubt his photo opportunity will have hooked their votes. If Keir Starmer needs advice, he might try Tory MP Esther McVey's words of wisdom. ''Never-here Keir' has clocked up a massive 100,000 air miles in just over a year – more than any prime minister this century – while suffering the steepest drop in approval ratings for any recent election-winning leader,' she says. 'Maybe if Keir spent more time in the UK he might improve his ratings!' Police minister Dame Diana Johnson advised victims of crime to dial 999 if they're in trouble or '111' for less serious issues. She ought to know 111 is for NHS matters. The police are on 101. Labour MP Afzal Khan, fired as trade envoy to Turkey, once overdid the henna while dying his hair, giving him alarmingly ginger roots. From the Press seats above, he looked like Rita Hayworth.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
cvgv1n17w4ro (GIF Image, 1 × 1 pixels)
It's "D-Day at the White House", says the Daily Mail, as Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and EU leaders prepare to meet US President Donald Trump. But "will he listen to a single word they say," it poses. The death at 86 of superman star Terrance Stamp also features. The UK and EU are "at Zelensky's side for talks with Trump", reads the Guardian headline. It "seems designed to prevent a repeat of Zelensky's pubic mauling during his last trip", it adds. On the Middle East, the paper reports that Israel's army is preparing "to force one million people out of Gaza City". A striking black-and-white portrait of Mr Stamp dominates the right hand side. "Europe tells Trump: Don't give in to Putin", reports The Daily Telegraph. To the right, a shot of French President on holiday in France, atop a hydrofoil. In other news, Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps are using a leaked Ministry of Defence "kill list" provided by the Taliban to hunt British spies, the paper says. The headline for the Times this morning is "Zelensky wants security guarantees before a deal". It features reporting of "intense" fighting on the ground in Donets, as both Russia and Ukraine "race to secure territory". Peeking out from the bottom strap, a story on golden eagles possibly returning to England after more than 150 years. The leaders' talks in Washington also leads the Financial Times. Zelensky and Ukraine's European allies "seek security guarantees", it says, after Putin "demanded that Kyiv should concede land in order to reach a truce". Also featured is a report that the UK has produced enough electricity to power more than five million homes for a year through solar power alone. "Europe takes a stand" is the headline on the Mirror, alongside a picture of Sir Keir and Zelensky embracing at the entrance to 10 Downing Street. "Super star" Mr Stamp also makes the front. The Metro splashes with a black and white photo of train tickets, calling a reported rail fare rise "outrageous". Industry experts it cites say prices will go up another 5.5% next year. Students face annual tuition hikes "to bail out struggling universities", the i reports. Another £250 rise is possible next year as part of ministers' plans to use automatic increases in line with inflation. Meanwhile, "vice-chancellors warn several universities will go bust without boost to income". "And it's off", reads the Daily Star's headline as horse racing strikes begin ahead of the "chancellor's hated bet tax". All meets have been "axed for a day in protest at the tax hike betting plans of Rachel Reeves". The Star also touches on "Terence tributes". The Daily Express spotlights "Britain's 10 million junk food addicts" as some experts vie for the World Health Organization (WHO) to include food addiction as a form of substance abuse. Dr Jen Unwin, the organiser of a gathering of medics and academics in London to discuss the issue, has called it a "health disaster". It's "Strictly star's stalker terror" for the Sun, as Chris Robshaw faced a "terrifying campaign of harassment by a female stalker". The woman, who the paper says threatened the rugby player with violence twice last year, is now "being hunted by police". Sign up for our morning newsletter and get BBC News in your inbox.
