SHRC urges occupational safety for sanitary workers
The Sindh Human Rights Commission (SHRC), while censuring the Sindh Local Government Department over the recent deaths of two sanitary workers in Umerkot, has lamented that the rules of occupational safety are being shrugged off with impunity. The two sanitary workers, Raj Ashok Marvari and Sooraj Lonio, died while cleaning a manhole on April 26, while Ravi Marvari and Chaman Marvari, fell unconscious.
According to statistics compiled by SHRC member Boota Imtiaz, in a period of around five years till 2024, at least 21 sanitary workers died in separate incidents of poisoning in manholes and septic tanks. About 12 of them died in Karachi, and five in Hyderabad. Some of the workers worked for the municipalities while others were private workers.
SHRC's Chairman, Iqbal Ahmed Detho, in a letter addressed to the provincial and Umerkot based LG officials on Monday, stated "[The] standards of occupational safety are completely ignored while sending the sanitary workers inside sewer manholes due to which lives are endangered."
The chairman highlighted that the workers die in the manholes owing to the non-provision of Personal Protection Equipment (PPE), which the Sindh Occupation Safety and Health Act, 2017, has necessitated. He also recalled that the Sindh Occupational Safety and Health Rules, 2019, made the use of breathing apparatus, or hose masks with blowers, mandatory in atmospheres considered dangerous to life or health. Moreover, standby men are also supposed to accompany workers along with rescue equipment. Further, workers who enter a "sewer, flue, duct, or other similarly confined places, are supposed to be provided, and are required to wear, safety belts with life lines attached and held by another person stationed at the opening, ready to respond to agreed signals." The Act and the Rules also provide for workplace safety for labourers engaged in professions which expose their lives and health to certain risks.
The chairman also referred to the Occupational Safety and Health Convention, 1981, which calls for providing adequate protective clothing and equipment to the workers; and the Social Security (Minimum Standards) Convention, 1952, which stipulates the provision of employment injury benefits.
Chairman Detho asked the LG department and municipal authorities to issue clear policies for the implementation of the 2017 Act and 2019 Rules.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
SHRC, NARI Foundation hold seminar: Call for multi-sectoral action to combat malnutrition in Sindh
KARACHI: A renewed call for integrated, multi-sectoral action to combat malnutrition in Sindh echoed across the provincial consultative seminar on nutrition, jointly organized by the Sindh Human Rights Commission (SHRC) and the NARI Foundation in Karachi. The high-level dialogue brought together policymakers, parliamentarians, technical experts, and civil society actors to chart a more coordinated and rights-based approach to food and nutritional security. In his opening remarks, Iqbal Detho, Chairperson of SHRC, underscored the Commission's growing role in promoting the right to food and nutrition as a core human right. He emphasised the urgent need for inter-sectoral collaboration, policy coherence, and strong local leadership to ensure that nutrition-sensitive initiatives are embedded into district-level planning. He also announced the SHRC's pilot implementation of the Sindh Protection and Promotion of Breastfeeding and Young Child Nutrition Act 2023, starting from Sukkur. Rajveer Singh Sodha, Special Assistant to the Chief Minister on Human Rights, fully endorsed the multi-sectoral, nutrition-sensitive strategies presented by stakeholders. Applauding SHRC's integrated approach to rights — including the intersection of nutrition, legal entitlements, and business responsibility—he assured that the consultation's key recommendations will be conveyed to the chief minister for policy action and institutional follow-up. 'Access to nutrition is a constitutional right. Malnutrition in areas like Tharparkar demands urgent, targeted intervention,' he asserted. The technical sessions featured vibrant dialogue among panelists from the health, education, agriculture, social welfare, women development, and human rights sectors, highlighting systemic challenges and missed opportunities in nutrition programming. Kashif Siddiqui, public health expert, presented critical gaps such as underfunding, lack of clear rules under the Food Fortification Act 2021, and weak implementation of legal frameworks. Panelists praised existing initiatives like the Mumtaz Programme under Social Protection and the government's birth registration drives, while urging for enhanced budgetary allocations, inter-departmental coordination, gender-responsive nutrition strategies and transparency and accountability mechanisms. Dr Fozia Khan from the Education Department reaffirmed that nutrition has been included in the curriculum and emphasized the need for financial backing for effective roll-out. Legislators including Dr Fouzia Hameed, MPA and member of the Standing Committee on Health, and Dr Sham Sundar, MPA and Parliamentary Secretary for Transport & Mass Transit, echoed these concerns. Dr Fouzia called for the establishment of nutrition and daycare centers across all government departments, including the Sindh Assembly, setting a precedent for institutional support. Dr Sham Sundar emphasized the need for cross-sectoral accountability and committed to following up within parliamentary frameworks. The consultation revisited key legislation, including the Sindh Protection and Promotion of Breastfeeding and Young Child Nutrition Act 2023 and the Sindh Food Fortification Act 2021, and called for their full-scale implementation to combat the province's stubborn malnutrition trends. Anwar Mahar, Executive Director of NARI Foundation, acknowledged the valuable contributions of parliamentarians, departmental heads, and civil society leaders. He reaffirmed NARI's commitment to working with SHRC and partners to push forward the nutrition and human rights agenda across Sindh. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
19-05-2025
- Express Tribune
Nishtar officials to face action over HIV case
A joint inquiry committee has submitted its findings to the chief minister of Punjab following an investigation into the infection of 31 dialysis patients with HIV at Nishtar Hospital. The inquiry has recommended disciplinary action against several officials, including the removal of Vice Chancellor of Nishtar Medical University, Dr Mehnaz Khakwani, for administrative negligence. The recommendations, made under the Punjab Employees Efficiency, Discipline and Accountability (PEDA) Act, follow directives from Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz Sharif. The case came to light in October 2024 when over 20 dialysis patients were initially found to be HIV positive. That number later rose to 31 over four months after further screenings. Following the outbreak, the provincial government suspended key medical staff including Dr Ghulam Abbas, former Head of Nephrology; Dr Muhammad Kazim, former Medical Superintendent (MS) of Nishtar Hospital; and faculty members Dr Poonam Khalid and Dr Maleeha Johar. Head Nurse Naheed Parveen and Dr Alamgir Malik were also suspended, while a formal PEDA inquiry was initiated in December 2024. As per the inquiry report, Vice Chancellor Dr Khakwani failed to implement and monitor standard operating procedures (SOPs) across the hospital, and did not take timely action after the incident surfaced. As a result, the committee has recommended her removal and one-year suspension from public service. Former Head of Nephrology Dr Ghulam Abbas has been accused of withholding information about HIV-positive cases and failing to issue necessary written directives. The committee has recommended his compulsory retirement. Dr Poonam Khalid, Associate Professor of Nephrology, is alleged to have been frequently absent and negligent in ward management. A three-year demotion and a fine equal to one month's basic salary have been recommended in her case. The committee found that Dr Muhammad Kazim, the former MS, failed to promptly address the outbreak and was appointed without proper process as an 18-grade officer in a 20-grade position. The committee has recommended censure and withholding of his annual increment for one year. Meanwhile, Dr. Maleeha Johar, Dr. Alamgir Malik, and Head Nurse Naheed Parveen were acquitted of charges. Separately, the Pakistan Medical Association (PMA) Multan has raised concerns about the integrity of the inquiry. In an emergency meeting chaired by Dr Masoodur Rauf Haraj, the PMA alleged that the inquiry failed to determine how the virus was transmitted and focused instead on penalizing Nishtar Medical University's first female Vice Chancellor. The PMA claimed that the inquiry report may have been influenced by a senior university officer with alleged aspirations to become the next vice chancellor. According to the association, this officer reportedly had connections with the inquiry convener and predicted the report's contents in advance. The PMA also pointed out that no genetic sequencing has been conducted to confirm whether HIV transmission occurred through dialysis procedures, and questioned the absence of action against unauthorised medical practitioners.
Business Recorder
03-05-2025
- Business Recorder
BMP suggests uniform 1pc sales tax rate on all medicines
LAHORE: As the federal government enters the final phase of preparing the federal budget for 2025–26, the Federation of Pakistan Chambers of Commerce and Industry's (FPCCI) Businessmen Panel (BMP) has strongly urged the government to eliminate tax discrimination between different categories of medicines. The panel called for applying a uniform 1% sales tax rate on all medicines—whether allopathic, homeopathic, or herbal—to ensure fairness, accessibility, and consistency in healthcare taxation. The issue was discussed in detail during the meeting between Mian Anjum Nisar and a delegation from the Homeopathic Pharmac eutical and Chemist Association Pakistan (HPCA), who met him in the lead of Dr. Amanullah Bismil, Patron-in-Chief of the HPCA. The delegation included Dr. Ahsan Waris, Dr. Iqbal Hanif, Dr. Kashif Masood, and Saifurrahman Safi. The representatives shared their concerns regarding the unequal taxation structure, highlighting how it discourages the growth of the alternative medicine industry and limits consumer access to affordable treatment options. Chairman of the Businessmen Panel and former FPCCI president Mian Anjum Nisar pointed out that a significant disparity currently exists in the taxation system governing pharmaceutical and health-related products. Allopathic medicines—conventional pharmaceutical drugs—are taxed at a concessional rate of 1%, while homeopathic and herbal medicines are subject to a hefty 18% general sales tax (GST). This difference, he argued, is unjust and harmful, creating a disproportionate burden on consumers and manufacturers of non-allopathic medicines. 'The current tax system promotes inequality within the healthcare sector,' Anjum Nisar said. 'On the one hand, the government claims to prioritize public health and affordability; on the other hand, it penalizes manufacturers and users of homeopathic and herbal medicines with an unjustifiable tax rate. This contradictory policy undermines equitable healthcare access.' Dr. Bismil explained that the issue stems from outdated provisions in the Eighth Schedule of the Sales Tax Act, 1990, particularly Entry No. 81, which only refers to drugs registered under the now-repealed Drugs Act of 1976. That Act has since been replaced by the Drug Regulatory Authority of Pakistan (DRAP) Act, 2012, which regulates all therapeutic goods—allopathic, homeopathic, herbal, and nutraceutical. According to Section 32 of the DRAP Act, its provisions take precedence over earlier or conflicting laws. However, the sales tax framework has not been updated to reflect this change, resulting in a legal loophole that excludes non-allopathic medicines from receiving the same tax relief as allopathic drugs. Dr. Bismil urged the Ministry of Finance and the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to address this gap by amending the Eighth Schedule so that all DRAP-registered medicines are treated equally under the tax regime. He stressed that the amendment should be included in the Finance Bill 2025–26 and take effect from July 1, 2025. 'This is the ideal time to correct this policy anomaly,' said Dr. Bismil. 'As budget preparations are underway, the government must take this opportunity to demonstrate its commitment to inclusive healthcare, fair taxation, and support for local industries.' Anjum Nisar supported the delegation's demands and assured them he would take the issue to the highest level to seek a resolution. He emphasized that millions of Pakistanis—especially those in rural areas and low-income groups—rely on homeopathic and herbal treatments. By taxing these products at a higher rate, the government is restricting access for the underprivileged and effectively pushing patients toward more expensive alternatives. He further highlighted the economic potential of the alternative medicine sector, which has demonstrated remarkable resilience despite facing regulatory neglect and tax pressures. 'Pakistan has a rich heritage in traditional medicine systems, including homeopathy, Unani, and herbal formulations,' he said. 'If supported through progressive policy and tax fairness, these industries can contribute billions to the national economy and expand into export markets across the Middle East, Africa, and Asia.' Anjum Nisar added that a uniform 1% tax rate across all medicines would promote transparency, compliance, and a healthier business environment. It would allow all sectors of the healthcare industry to grow side by side, encouraging innovation and ensuring that patients have access to diverse treatment options at fair prices. He warned that maintaining the current dual tax system would continue to distort the market, discourage formalization, and hurt small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) that make up the bulk of the homeopathic and herbal medicine industry. 'This is not just a tax issue—it's a healthcare issue and an economic opportunity,' Nisar concluded. 'The government must seize this moment to harmonize the taxation structure, promote equity in healthcare, and support the broader goal of industrial development in Pakistan.' Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
