AFL Legend Leigh Matthews wants AFL to give West Coast Eagles a priority pick in the national draft
The Eagles' 83-point loss to Melbourne on Saturday guaranteed they will finish on the bottom of the ladder this year and the club is preparing a request for draft assistance from the AFL after winning just 11 matches across the last four seasons.
Matthews said it was vital that the competition didn't have one team that simply couldn't compete.
'If you're ever going to give a priority pick again, they have been bad enough for long enough,' Matthew said on Fox Footy's On The Couch.
'I know they won the premiership in 2018 and that's in the back of your mind. But if you are that bad, the first choice in the draft this year might go the Eagles and he'll think 'terrific, I've got to be down the bottom of the ladder.' You've got to try to make sure equalisation works so the draft works.
'They're rich and they're powerful but you can't buy a premiership in modern footy, which is a good thing. But they are going to have to draft really well.
'I look back at the Suns. Remember the Suns were down the bottom about six years ago and they got a priority pick. They got Rowell and they got Anderson. Great ability, great character and they stayed. The Suns have sort of built their team off the back of their example.
'This is what the Eagles' challenge is to be. You've got to do free agency to elevate yourself but you've got to draft really good character that stays the journey.'
The AFL Commission will be responsible for making the decision around West Coast's application but the club's recent success will also be taken into account. The Eagles won the premiership in 2018 and played in the 2015 grand final.
Gold Coast had missed the finals for their first nine seasons, finished in the bottom four seven times, were still on the bottom of the ladder and had struggled to retain players.
When asked if West Coast's premiership should count against West Coast's application, Matthews agreed it would be a problem.
'That is an interesting point,' he said.
'Maybe if you've won a premiership in the last decade, you become ineligible. But they've won 11 games in the last five seasons. If you're really bad, you can stay bad, but the competition is based on its equalisation pillar.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
3 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Magpies flag changes for massive Hawks clash
Key defender Jeremy Howe will make a welcome return for Collingwood in Thursday night's AFL blockbuster against Hawthorn. But small forward Bobby Hill, who returned from several games out in last week's loss to Brisbane, could be an absentee again because of illness. Coach Craig McRae said another tall backman, Billy Frampton, was also closing on a return after strong VFL form. The Magpies have lost three of their past four games and Howe has been sidelined since round 19 with a groin injury. Frampton has recovered from a calf injury. "Jeremy will definitely play, he got through (training) today well," McRae said. "Billy's name will come up into consideration, yep. I loved his game (in) the VFL, really enjoyed that. He performed well. "He'll put some question marks at match committee around his magnet." McRae added Hill, the 2023 Norm Smith Medallist, had gastro. "It's a bugger," he said. "He may be in doubt. We'll have to see how he goes in the next 24 hours." Despite losing top spot with the defeat to Brisbane, McRae remained upbeat about his team's build-up to the finals. "We did a lot right and then there are little parts of our game that we're getting feedback around," he said. "We just have to keep tidying up. "I'd much rather get those lessons learned now - or the feedback now - than in three or four weeks' time ... 'Here we are, fighting for our lives'. "There are little things that we can look at straight away and go, 'We can fix that - we can fix that'. McRae was asked if he had had any more contact with Carlton defender Jack Silvagni. After saying last week he had met with Silvagni, who is about to come out of contract, McRae did not want to add to the issue. "I will leave that alone - I think I've said enough," he said. Meanwhile, captain James Sicily's return to form looms as a massive factor for Hawthorn against the Magpies. AFL commentator and former Magpies coach Nathan Buckley noted Harris Andrews was a major headache for Collingwood last Saturday night as the star Brisbane defender repeatedly thwarted their long kicks into attack. Sicily can have a similar impact to Andrews at the MCG. "They just couldn't score off their long-down-the-lines (kicks). They usually score two in three. Harris Andrews absolutely controlled that aspect of the game," Buckley told Fox Footy's On The Couch. "If you have a player who can control that aspect against Collingwood, you're going to be well-and-truly in the match." Key defender Jeremy Howe will make a welcome return for Collingwood in Thursday night's AFL blockbuster against Hawthorn. But small forward Bobby Hill, who returned from several games out in last week's loss to Brisbane, could be an absentee again because of illness. Coach Craig McRae said another tall backman, Billy Frampton, was also closing on a return after strong VFL form. The Magpies have lost three of their past four games and Howe has been sidelined since round 19 with a groin injury. Frampton has recovered from a calf injury. "Jeremy will definitely play, he got through (training) today well," McRae said. "Billy's name will come up into consideration, yep. I loved his game (in) the VFL, really enjoyed that. He performed well. "He'll put some question marks at match committee around his magnet." McRae added Hill, the 2023 Norm Smith Medallist, had gastro. "It's a bugger," he said. "He may be in doubt. We'll have to see how he goes in the next 24 hours." Despite losing top spot with the defeat to Brisbane, McRae remained upbeat about his team's build-up to the finals. "We did a lot right and then there are little parts of our game that we're getting feedback around," he said. "We just have to keep tidying up. "I'd much rather get those lessons learned now - or the feedback now - than in three or four weeks' time ... 'Here we are, fighting for our lives'. "There are little things that we can look at straight away and go, 'We can fix that - we can fix that'. McRae was asked if he had had any more contact with Carlton defender Jack Silvagni. After saying last week he had met with Silvagni, who is about to come out of contract, McRae did not want to add to the issue. "I will leave that alone - I think I've said enough," he said. Meanwhile, captain James Sicily's return to form looms as a massive factor for Hawthorn against the Magpies. AFL commentator and former Magpies coach Nathan Buckley noted Harris Andrews was a major headache for Collingwood last Saturday night as the star Brisbane defender repeatedly thwarted their long kicks into attack. Sicily can have a similar impact to Andrews at the MCG. "They just couldn't score off their long-down-the-lines (kicks). They usually score two in three. Harris Andrews absolutely controlled that aspect of the game," Buckley told Fox Footy's On The Couch. "If you have a player who can control that aspect against Collingwood, you're going to be well-and-truly in the match." Key defender Jeremy Howe will make a welcome return for Collingwood in Thursday night's AFL blockbuster against Hawthorn. But small forward Bobby Hill, who returned from several games out in last week's loss to Brisbane, could be an absentee again because of illness. Coach Craig McRae said another tall backman, Billy Frampton, was also closing on a return after strong VFL form. The Magpies have lost three of their past four games and Howe has been sidelined since round 19 with a groin injury. Frampton has recovered from a calf injury. "Jeremy will definitely play, he got through (training) today well," McRae said. "Billy's name will come up into consideration, yep. I loved his game (in) the VFL, really enjoyed that. He performed well. "He'll put some question marks at match committee around his magnet." McRae added Hill, the 2023 Norm Smith Medallist, had gastro. "It's a bugger," he said. "He may be in doubt. We'll have to see how he goes in the next 24 hours." Despite losing top spot with the defeat to Brisbane, McRae remained upbeat about his team's build-up to the finals. "We did a lot right and then there are little parts of our game that we're getting feedback around," he said. "We just have to keep tidying up. "I'd much rather get those lessons learned now - or the feedback now - than in three or four weeks' time ... 'Here we are, fighting for our lives'. "There are little things that we can look at straight away and go, 'We can fix that - we can fix that'. McRae was asked if he had had any more contact with Carlton defender Jack Silvagni. After saying last week he had met with Silvagni, who is about to come out of contract, McRae did not want to add to the issue. "I will leave that alone - I think I've said enough," he said. Meanwhile, captain James Sicily's return to form looms as a massive factor for Hawthorn against the Magpies. AFL commentator and former Magpies coach Nathan Buckley noted Harris Andrews was a major headache for Collingwood last Saturday night as the star Brisbane defender repeatedly thwarted their long kicks into attack. Sicily can have a similar impact to Andrews at the MCG. "They just couldn't score off their long-down-the-lines (kicks). They usually score two in three. Harris Andrews absolutely controlled that aspect of the game," Buckley told Fox Footy's On The Couch. "If you have a player who can control that aspect against Collingwood, you're going to be well-and-truly in the match."
News.com.au
6 hours ago
- News.com.au
Rumours fly over list of candidates to replace Simon Goodwin as Demons coach
The race to find a replacement for Simon Goodwin is on. Melbourne dropped a bombshell on Tuesday, sacking the 2021 premiership winning coach with three games left this season and despite Goodwin having a contract for 2026. However, club president Brad Green said the Demons wanted a change made instantly for the club to go in a new direction. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. According to Code Sports, 48-year-old Goodwin will receive a one-million dollar payout as part of the contract termination. Assistant coach Troy Chaplin will step in as caretaker coach for the remainder of the 2025 season for games against the Western Bulldogs, Hawthorn and Collingwood. Attention will now turn to the Demons' search to appoint a replacement for Goodwin, with a range of candidates believed to be in the mix. Fox Footy reports former Sydney Swans coach John Longmire is Melbourne's top choice on a list featuring as many of 22 candidates to take over as Demons coach. Veteran footy reporter Caroline Wilson said Goodwin's sacking may have been made before the end of the season to allow the Demons to get a head start on other clubs who may also be looking for a new coach in the off-season. 'The coaching landscape has rarely looked richer,' Wilson said on Channel 7's Agenda Setters. 'Fox Footy is reporting John Longmire is their No. 1 target. I'm not sure about that. He hasn't been approached yet. I do agree he is wooable, although will Melbourne be a palatable option for him? 'Do Melbourne want to jump in and get the best coach before Carlton steps in? We know Michael Voss isn't safe. There is definitely a view from Melbourne that they're not the only club (looking for a new coach).' Speaking on Fox Footy's Midweek Tackle, the Herald Sun's Jon Ralph said the leading first-time coaching candidates were Brisbane football boss Danny Daly, Essendon assistant Daniel Giansiracusa and Collingwood's Hayden Skipworth. Ralph said former Essendon coach James Hird is 'very much a person of interest' for the Demons, while premiership coaches Longmire and Adam Simpson are also in the mix, along with Port Adelaide's Ken Hinkley and ex-Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley. Hird said he was 'flattered' but ruled himself out of contention for the Demons job. On Footy Classified, Eddie McGuire described Longmire, Simpson, Buckley and Hinkley as 'the big four' candidates. 'Here's the thing. They've very aware that not many coaches have won a flag, moved clubs and won another one — Leigh Matthews and Mick Malthouse only in this century,' Ralph said. Buckley is widely viewed as the leading candidate to be Tasmania's inaugural coach when the Devils enter the AFL in 2028. A subcommittee comprised of incoming CEO Paul Guerra, Brad Green, Steven Smith and Alan Richardson will make the final call on choosing Melbourne's new coach. 'There are issues cultural, with the board and stability,' Ralph added. 'There's an enormous amount of change there. It's not an incredible gig. 'If someone like John Longmire was really thinking about it, I think he might look for a better position out there. I'm sure he'll take the phone call, but I'd probably prefer Carlton than Melbourne.' Demons legend Garry Lyon said on AFL 360 about Longmire: 'You can sell 'Horse' to anyone.' The Demons are set to have significant change off the field, with a new CEO, a new president and perhaps a new footy boss. Lyon, who was shocked by Goodwin's sacking, said a void of leadership at the club in recent times set Goodwin up to fail as he attempted to rebuild on the run. 'It was the sameness (on-field) for a long time — and that was a frustration of him … it's sort of greater than that though,' Lyon continued. 'It's a football club that's confused at the moment (with) exactly where they are. It's a football club that's disconnected; I don't think there's any doubt about that. It has been for a long time. 'It was pertinent that he mentioned it four or five times today — you must have a strong, stable off-field support mechanism. I doubt he's felt that over the past couple of years.' AFL 360 host Gerard Whateley added: 'It would have been a miracle if a coach had been successful in these circumstances … the next president is not in the job, and the chief executive was appointed in April and doesn't start until September. There's no elite program in the world that has those pillars absent, and achieves success. 'I think it undermined his capacity to do the job that he knew needed to be done.' Melbourne's off-field structure has also grabbed headlines in recent years, including tensions between former chief executive Gary Pert and key club personnel. 'When they won the premiership, they were the most selfless team in the competition and it was trotted out everywhere. I don't think they are now, and I'm not sure whether the board over the journey has been particularly selfless as well.' Lyon said. 'They are screaming out for a figurehead. A strong, strong, decisive leader of this football club — apart from the coach.'
7NEWS
7 hours ago
- 7NEWS
Fresh vision emerges of Carlton coach Michael Voss and new Blues chief Graham Wright
Embattled Carlton coach Michael Voss has been spotted having an eye-catching meeting with the Blues incoming CEO Graham Wright. The vision emerged on Tuesday, the same day Melbourne's coach Simon Goodwin was sacked. Speculation has been rife this year that Carlton might also take action on Voss with Blues having a disastrous season and missing out on finals. 7NEWS chief AFL reporter Mitch Cleary unearthed the vision on Channel 7's The Agenda Setters on Tuesday. 'We've seen today Graham Wright having a coffee with Michael Voss,' Cleary said. 'So this is quite interesting today. (They were) spotted in Richmond this morning (on Tuesday). 'There, you can see Graham Wright on the left with Michael Voss in the cap and the hoodie. 'The club tells me that these conversations have been going on weekly for the last five or six weeks, and that dates back to (president) Rob Priestley coming out and saying that they will put the call off on Michael Voss's future until the end of the year. 'But clearly this is reaching a pointy end.' Cleary said it was unclear if Voss would remain in the job but believed the position of the club's football boss Brad Lloyd was 'well and truly under threat'. Asked if he thought the coffee catch-up was a 'good sign' for Voss, Cleary thought it was not definitive. 'I don't think it's a bad sign, is it?' Cleary said. 'The fact that he's having the (catch-ups over the) last five weeks ... it's the players' day off today, it's off-site.' Wright, however, has a reputation for being an agent of change and veteran AFL journalist Caroline Wilson said she still feared for Voss's future. 'I just keep remembering the way (Wright) so subtly and cleverly and, in a way, quite politely, indicated to Nathan Buckley that maybe his time was up (at Collingwood),' Wilson said. Cleary said the Goodwin sacking could 'hasten the situation'. 'Both clubs could be in the market (for a new coach) by the end of the year.'
