Health staff found ‘ingratiating themselves financially' will be referred to gardaí, HSE chief says
If people working in the public health system are 'ingratiating themselves financially' they will be referred to
An Garda Síochána
, the
HSE
's chief executive has said.
Bernard Gloster
said on Sunday that nobody had told him about an internal investigation at
Children's Health Ireland (CHI)
which allegedly found a consultant abused the State's waiting system while also delaying operations for sick children up to three years.
The Sunday Times reported that according to the unpublished findings, the consultant breached HSE guidelines by referring patients he was seeing in his public practice to weekend clinics he was operating separately.
Speaking on
RTÉ
Radio 1's This Week programme, Mr Gloster said what was being reported was 'absolutely shocking'.
READ MORE
'I'm even more shocked because nobody has told me about it and, in light of everything we were doing in the last number of months for CHI, I'm just quite shocked.'
Mr Gloster said he had spoken to the CHI chief executive Lucy Nugent and has asked for a copy of the report, which 'save for highly personal information . . . should be published in the public interest'.
'I have made it clear that I reserve my position based on what I see in that report as to whether or not further questions arise, and if any question arises, I assure you if anything connected with, or near connected with alleged people ingratiating themselves financially in the public health system, the first step I'll be taking is to refer that matter to the gardaí,' he said.
Separately, Mr Gloster said Minister for Health
Jennifer Carroll MacNeill
was considering 'all of the issues' associated with the delivery and governance of children's healthcare in the State.
He said the option of subsuming CHI back into the HSE 'has to be' one of the moves considered.
CHI was established in January 2019 as a new entity to govern and deliver acute paediatric services and currently operates hospitals in Crumlin, Temple Street and Tallaght.
An independent audit published this week found that almost 500 children who underwent hip operations in two hospitals should be recalled,
as close to 70 per cent of the sample examined were not necessary
.
One child who received surgery for developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH), despite not meeting the criteria for the procedure, experienced an 'adverse outcome' from the operation, the audit said.
[
'A national scandal': Answers demanded after audit highlights over 100 unnecessary hip surgeries on children
Opens in new window
]
CHI and the National Orthopaedic Hospital Cappagh (NOHC) last July announced a joint clinical audit to examine a random and anonymised sample of 147 DDH surgeries performed between 2021 and 2023. The move was prompted following a protected disclosure, which raised concerns that CHI at Crumlin and Temple Street and NOHC may have used differing criteria to determine whether the surgery was required.
Mr Gloster said there was no doubt the scale of variance the audit found was 'of significant concern'. He said there would be further inquiries which would be beneficial to children and their families. He said he wanted to apologise to parents because of the concern they have due to 'something that's happening in the health service'.
In relation to the surgeons involved, Mr Gloster said he was not the employer as CHI and Cappagh hospital are 'separate institutions under separate statute'. However, he said the 'question of accountability cannot be taken off the table'.
'The audit itself would not be one which would ground or be grounding evidence to conclude that question, it is only after further inquiry that that could be fully assessed or not,' he said.
'So to be fair to individuals, we do have to be careful not to be precipitous in that regard. But it is a question that I want to be clear, that based on the level of extreme variation here, it is a question that has to be kept on the table until such time as we have a full view.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The 42
27 minutes ago
- The 42
'We've got to believe that we can beat anyone' - Ireland learn potential play-off opponents
IRELAND FACE INTO the Uefa Women's Nations League promotion/relegation play-offs after finishing second in Group B2. Carla Ward's side were chasing top spot, but didn't achieve the four-goal win needed to usurp Slovenia at Páirc Uí Chaoimh this evening. They won 1-0 thanks to Saoirse Noonan's first-half goal. While Slovenia secured safe passage to League A, Ireland have another shot at promotion in the play-offs in October. Their opponents — a third-placed League A outfit — will be confirmed in a Friday's draw in Nyon [12pm Irish time]. One of Austria (18th in the world rankings), Iceland (13th), Belgium (20th) and Denmark (12th) will await in a two-legged tie. 'I think that whoever we get out of those, they're top nations,' said Ward. 'But, look, we're building, we're evolving. Advertisement 'I think you've seen from game one to game six now the improvement, gaming as we've continued, five wins from six. So, we've got to believe that we can go and beat anyone. 'Players that have played for me at club and country often laugh at me because I'm somebody that believes that we can do anything if we really want to. 'So, whoever we get is going to be difficult, but we'll be prepared. That's for sure.' Austria are the only side not competing at this summer's European Championships. Ireland (26th) are unseeded, so will play at home first in the two-legged play-offs. League A status would significantly boost their 2027 World Cup qualification hopes. The Girls In Green will be without Anna Patten for the first leg of the October play-off: the Aston Villa defender is suspended after receiving a second yellow card this evening. Several other players, including Katie McCabe and Denise O'Sullivan, are one booking away from a ban. Ireland return to action later this month with a pair of friendlies away to world number one-ranked side USA. McCabe will not travel after a hectic season, which she finished as a Champions League winner with Arsenal. 'A number' of players could be unavailable, Ward confirmed. 'Katie has played an awful lot of minutes for club and country. She's on the verge of burnout, as are some others. There's going to be conversations. It won't just be Katie that won't be travelling. There's probably going to be a number. 'It's a difficult one. I mean, you've seen with Millie Bright at England coming out, mental and physical fatigue is massive. I felt it at Villa. It's the reason I needed that break. It's a really tough place to be, and I think there's a lot of players close to that. They've played a lot of minutes, so we have to protect them. 'We have to protect them as people, and we'll support anybody that needs that break.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Domestic abuse victims say their ordeals continue or even worsen despite family law proceedings
Adult and child victims of domestic abuse are being 'retraumatised' during family law proceedings, research suggests, with almost all those affected being subjected to abuse after separation and during court cases. While the prevalence of domestic violence and abuse (DVA) in all family law cases is disproportionately high, the Irish family law system as a whole 'is not sufficiently DVA informed or responsive', according to the research report. Women's Aid , which commissioned the research, said this 'systemic blind spot' left victims feeling disbelieved, silenced and at risk from further abuse. The study, which involved almost 440 victims of DVA, was carried out by Trinity College Dublin and University College Cork . READ MORE Victims described their experience of family law proceedings as 'horrific', 'retraumatising' and 'relentless', with one woman saying: 'It's essentially a stage for the abuse to continue.' The study argues that the courts and the family law system often operate under the 'flawed assumption' that once a couple separate then any violence or abuse is considered to be historical. 'This premise can lead to decisions and judgments that may not fully account for the ongoing risks or impacts of abuse on the victim-survivors, as it overlooks the possibility that abuse can continue even after separation,' it said. Among participants who were victims of DVA, 91 per cent of women and 93 per cent of men indicated that abuse continued or began post-separation and while proceedings were under way. 'The abuse never stopped after separation, it just changed,' one woman said. A common perception among participants was that perpetrators were able to 'play' the system to maintain control or cause disruption to inflict harm on former partners by repeat summoning or through multiple adjournments. Researchers found that the court's 'neutral stance' regularly failed to capture subtle, nuanced patterns of abuse. Most victims also indicated that forms of abuse such as coercive control, emotional abuse, financial abuse and stalking increased post-separation. Victims managing court-ordered access, meanwhile, reported intimidation and threats while handing their children over, with 78 per cent of victims experiencing ongoing problems or abuse connected with access arrangements. To avoid being charged with violating court-ordered access, victims were required to engage with their abuser, which 'frequently provided court-sanctioned opportunities for further abuse to occur'. Some women reported assaults, threats, intimidation and manipulation, while others perceived court-ordered access being used by abusers as an 'ongoing tactic of control and abuse'. Women also reported being wrongly accused of 'parental alienation' when they said their children did not wish to go on visits because of their experiences of DVA. A common theme arising from interviews with child participants was feeling unsafe during access or contact with their father, with a 14-year-old girl saying: 'You just don't know what he's going to do next.' Most children perceived their experiences as being discounted or disbelieved and their wishes being ignored throughout proceedings. Trinity College Professor Stephanie Holt, the chief investigator for the study, said it provided evidence and insights into a 'fundamentally flawed' family law system when dealing with victims of domestic abuse. 'The findings paint a predominantly negative picture of that journey through the family law system for adult and child victim-survivors of domestic violence and abuse,' she said. Sarah Benson, chief executive of Women's Aid, said while there were some examples of informed practices, it was 'completely inadequate when the system itself is not attuned and responsive to the tactics and impacts of domestic abuse post-separation'. Women's Aid is urging the Government to 'fundamentally reform' the family law system in a DVA-informed manner which would include compulsory domestic abuse training for all professionals.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Communications, transport and health of older people at increased risk from global warming, says EPA
There are 43 significant and immediate climate risks to Ireland, according to the first national risk assessment of the consequences of global warming. They range across all major sectors of the economy, but risk is highest in energy , transport, communications, water security and food production. Climate impacts in one sector, especially linked to critical infrastructure, 'has the potential to cascade and impact on other systems', the assessment warns. It highlights recent storms, Éowyn and Darragh, where electricity, water supply and communications were disrupted simultaneously due to power outages that quickly escalated across regions. READ MORE Published by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) on Wednesday, the assessment also analyses broader societal risks to public health and the country's biodiversity and ecosystems. It identifies and ranks 115 risks arising from climate change that is already happening, stating what should be responded to first. The most significant risks, which require action within the next five years, involves damage to communications and energy distribution infrastructure. The damage is likely to be caused by extreme wind. Separately, there is heightened risk of disruption and damage to buildings and transport infrastructure 'due to extreme wind, coastal erosion and coastal flooding'. We know Ireland is being impacted by climate change already — Laura Burke Additional risks that should be prioritised for further investigation in the next five years include the built environment and human health from flooding and prolonged heat, with older people particularly vulnerable. The assessment is designed to provide the Government, businesses and communities with the best available evidence to inform climate adaptation. It was undertaken with Government departments, State agencies and other stakeholders to assess where, when and how climate risks are likely to materialise. The assessment will guide development of sectoral adaptation plans, where key actions are set out and further investigation of threats are carried out by key government departments. 'We know Ireland is being impacted by climate change already,' said EPA director general Laura Burke. 'This comprehensive assessment highlights the need for additional urgent action to ensure Ireland is sustainably resilient to risks that we currently face, and will increasingly experience, in coming decades. '[It] clearly shows how risks cascade across sectors. Recent events, such as Storms Darragh and Éowyn, demonstrated how damage to critical infrastructure such as energy, water supply, transport and communications networks in turn give rise to impacts on human health, biodiversity and the financial system.' Addressing these risks in an integrated and consistent way will be key to achieving 'climate resilience' for the entire country, Ms Burke said. Assessing climate risk is a key component of risk management and strategic planning, said Dr Eimear Cotter, director of the EPA Office of Evidence and Assessment. [ Scientists accuse Ireland of 'accounting trick' to justify livestock emissions Opens in new window ] [ We cannot continue with dirty, scarce and expensive energy to power our society Opens in new window ] 'The assessment underscores the need for immediate action in the next five years to enhance the resilience of Ireland's critical infrastructure to climate change. The risks with the most consequential and highest urgency ratings relate to extreme wind, coastal erosion and coastal flooding,' she said. Dr Cotter added that the findings must ensure adaptation planning in Ireland 'is appropriately integrated across sectors'. The assessment does not focus on environmental pressures, such as pollution, habitat destruction or population growth. However, 'these pressures will be increasingly compounded by climate impacts as time goes on'. The report is available on the EPA website and the Climate Ireland adaptation portal.
