Ankylosaur footprints from Canada are first of their kind in the world
Scientists have identified fossil dinosaur footprints from a new species in B.C. and Alberta. They're believed to be the first tracks found in the world to be identified as belonging to club-tailed ankylosaurs, offering new insights about gaps in the fossil record.
The new species, which has been named Ruopodosaurus clava, would have been an armoured dinosaur about five to six metres long, reports a new study published this week in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology.
Victoria Arbour, curator of paleontology at the Royal B.C. Museum and lead author of the new study, said Ruopodosaurus would have lumbered through the coastal redwood forests between the Rocky Mountains and an inland sea that covered Saskatchewan and Alberta during the Middle Cretaceous, about 100 million to 94 million years ago. Previously identified footprints suggest the other creatures it lived alongside: giant crocodiles, duck-billed dinosaurs and bird-like dinosaurs — and a related group of four-toed ankylosaurs.
But no bones of three-toed, club-tailed ankylosaurs have ever been found in North America from the Middle Cretaceous, which, until now, suggested they may have gone extinct during this time, before reappearing about 84 million years ago, perhaps by the migration of populations from Asia. The tracks from this new species suggest otherwise.
This species, Arbour said, is "new for North America. It's new for the world…. And it really helps us fill in this gap in the fossil record."
A tale of two ankylosaurs
Like two-toed and three-toed sloths, there are two closely related branches of ankylosaurs with different numbers of toes:
Ankylosaurids, which have three toes, and are famous for their tail clubs, which were either slim and stiff like a baseball bat, or round like the one on the famous well-preserved ankylosaur Zuul crurivastator, which lived around 75 million years ago.
WATCH | Dinosaur Cold Case: Armoured Dinosaurs, featuring Zuul
This "destroyer of shins" dinosaur may have used its armour as weapons |Dinosaur Cold Case
5 years ago
Duration 1:34
Victoria Arbour, an evolutionary paleontologist at the Royal BC Museum, describes how some armoured dinosaurs likely used their horns, spines and armour for fighting each other, not just for protection.
Nodosaurids, which have four toes, a flexible tail, and a longer snout. Many had big shoulder spikes, including Borealopelta ankylosaur, a well-preserved specimen found an an oilsands mine in 2011.
WATCH | Meet one of the world's best-preserved dinosaurs, featuring Borealopelta
Meet one of the world's best-preserved dinosaurs | Dinosaur Cold Case
5 years ago
Duration 0:58
Nodosaurid prints were first found at Tumbler Ridge by two boys, 11-year-old Mark Turner and eight-year-old Daniel Helm, in 2001. That led to the discovery of other dinosaur trackways and fossils in the region, and the founding of the Tumbler Ridge Museum.
What scientists learned about the new species
Arbour first saw photos of the unusual tracks in the new study about five years ago. Some were found near Tumbler Ridge and others at a gas well on the other side of the B.C.-Alberta border.
"I thought they were really strange and interesting looking and I was really curious about them," she recalled.
Then in 2023, she visited the Tumbler Ridge Museum, and Charles Helm, Daniel's father and the scientific advisor at the museum, suggested they study the tracks together, along with some new ones that he and Daniel had found. Many included not just three-toed footprints, but the crescent-shaped, five fingered handprints that ankylosaurs are known to have.
"And I got really excited," Arbour said. "I was like, 'You know, I think the only thing these really can be … is an ankylosaurid."
The research confirmed that, and named the new species Ruopodosaurus clava, which means "tumbled-down lizard with a club/mace" referring to the location they were found and the distinctive feature of this ankylosaur family.
Arbour said fossils found in China suggest that at this time, tail clubs were just starting to evolve in ankylosaurids, so this species may not have had a full round club like Zuul.
Almost all the footprints were similar in size — about 30 centimetres long — suggesting that the average size of this species was about five or six metres long, or smaller than many ankylosaurs without tail clubs. Sometimes multiple trackways were found together, all heading in the same direction and never crossing, suggesting several animals may have been travelling together.
Anthony Shillito is a University of Saskatchewan researcher who has previously studied dinosaur trackways from the Cretaceous that included four-toed ankylosaur footprints. He said footprints from three-toed ankylosaurs may have been found before, but there are so many three-toed dinosaurs that they would have been hard to identify without the distinctive handprints that were found with the footprints in Canada.
"[The study] really made me think back to some of the footprints I've seen — maybe I misinterpreted it because I didn't have this information," he said. "Now people have a better idea of what they're looking for." And that may lead to more being found, and a better idea of where else these club-tailed ankylosaurs may have lived during the Middle Cretaceous, he suggested.
The value of footprints vs. bones
Paleontologist Scott Persons studied both fossil dinosaur tracks and ankylosaurs during his PhD at the University of Alberta, and is currently working on the study of a new nodosaur species.
He said in showing that ankylosaurids lived in North America earlier than thought, the new study demonstrates the value of looking at both fossil footprints and bones. Those often get preserved under different conditions and contain different information.
He noted that trackways often show multiple species that lived together at the same time, and can reveal other information. This new trackway also shows that wide, squat ankylosaurs — sometimes described as being coffee-table-like — had a surprisingly bird-like gait, lining up left and right feet like "supermodels on a runway."
He added, "This track record shows us the coffee table analogy is a little bit flawed."
On the other hand, he acknowledged, there is one drawback of footprints compared to bones.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Calgary Herald
16-05-2025
- Calgary Herald
Ready to meet five rare dinosaur discoveries? Here are the photos from a new Tyrrell exhibit
New exhibits of rare Alberta dinosaur discoveries were unveiled Friday at the Royal Tyrrell Museum, in an exhibition called Breakthroughs. Article content Article content Visitors were treated to a gorgosaur with prey fossilized in its stomach and Canada's first preserved dinosaur eggs with embryos still inside. Article content The exhibit is important because it 'tells the stories of five extraordinary finds that changed our understanding of ancient animals, their evolution and their behaviours,' the museum says. 'These fossils supported groundbreaking research on dinosaur feeding, nesting and evolutionary relationships.' Article content Article content Article content Article content Visitors check out an incredibly detailed nodosaur fossil at the opening of Breakthroughs. The museum says it is the world's best preserved armoured dinosaur, adding: 'Borealopelta markmitchelli ate its final meal, which consisted of vegetation: mostly ferns, with some pieces of conifers, cycads, twigs, and stems. We know this today because these plants are preserved in the dinosaur's stomach, along with charcoal. It appears Borealopelta was eating in an environment that had recently burned. Shortly after Borealopelta died, its body washed out to sea. The carcass then flipped upside-down and sank. It was perfectly preserved on the sea floor by the fine sediments that covered it.' Article content
CBC
16-04-2025
- CBC
Ankylosaur footprints from Canada are first of their kind in the world
Scientists have identified fossil dinosaur footprints from a new species in B.C. and Alberta. They're believed to be the first tracks found in the world to be identified as belonging to club-tailed ankylosaurs, offering new insights about gaps in the fossil record. The new species, which has been named Ruopodosaurus clava, would have been an armoured dinosaur about five to six metres long, reports a new study published this week in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. Victoria Arbour, curator of paleontology at the Royal B.C. Museum and lead author of the new study, said Ruopodosaurus would have lumbered through the coastal redwood forests between the Rocky Mountains and an inland sea that covered Saskatchewan and Alberta during the Middle Cretaceous, about 100 million to 94 million years ago. Previously identified footprints suggest the other creatures it lived alongside: giant crocodiles, duck-billed dinosaurs and bird-like dinosaurs — and a related group of four-toed ankylosaurs. But no bones of three-toed, club-tailed ankylosaurs have ever been found in North America from the Middle Cretaceous, which, until now, suggested they may have gone extinct during this time, before reappearing about 84 million years ago, perhaps by the migration of populations from Asia. The tracks from this new species suggest otherwise. This species, Arbour said, is "new for North America. It's new for the world…. And it really helps us fill in this gap in the fossil record." A tale of two ankylosaurs Like two-toed and three-toed sloths, there are two closely related branches of ankylosaurs with different numbers of toes: Ankylosaurids, which have three toes, and are famous for their tail clubs, which were either slim and stiff like a baseball bat, or round like the one on the famous well-preserved ankylosaur Zuul crurivastator, which lived around 75 million years ago. WATCH | Dinosaur Cold Case: Armoured Dinosaurs, featuring Zuul This "destroyer of shins" dinosaur may have used its armour as weapons |Dinosaur Cold Case 5 years ago Duration 1:34 Victoria Arbour, an evolutionary paleontologist at the Royal BC Museum, describes how some armoured dinosaurs likely used their horns, spines and armour for fighting each other, not just for protection. Nodosaurids, which have four toes, a flexible tail, and a longer snout. Many had big shoulder spikes, including Borealopelta ankylosaur, a well-preserved specimen found an an oilsands mine in 2011. WATCH | Meet one of the world's best-preserved dinosaurs, featuring Borealopelta Meet one of the world's best-preserved dinosaurs | Dinosaur Cold Case 5 years ago Duration 0:58 Nodosaurid prints were first found at Tumbler Ridge by two boys, 11-year-old Mark Turner and eight-year-old Daniel Helm, in 2001. That led to the discovery of other dinosaur trackways and fossils in the region, and the founding of the Tumbler Ridge Museum. What scientists learned about the new species Arbour first saw photos of the unusual tracks in the new study about five years ago. Some were found near Tumbler Ridge and others at a gas well on the other side of the B.C.-Alberta border. "I thought they were really strange and interesting looking and I was really curious about them," she recalled. Then in 2023, she visited the Tumbler Ridge Museum, and Charles Helm, Daniel's father and the scientific advisor at the museum, suggested they study the tracks together, along with some new ones that he and Daniel had found. Many included not just three-toed footprints, but the crescent-shaped, five fingered handprints that ankylosaurs are known to have. "And I got really excited," Arbour said. "I was like, 'You know, I think the only thing these really can be … is an ankylosaurid." The research confirmed that, and named the new species Ruopodosaurus clava, which means "tumbled-down lizard with a club/mace" referring to the location they were found and the distinctive feature of this ankylosaur family. Arbour said fossils found in China suggest that at this time, tail clubs were just starting to evolve in ankylosaurids, so this species may not have had a full round club like Zuul. Almost all the footprints were similar in size — about 30 centimetres long — suggesting that the average size of this species was about five or six metres long, or smaller than many ankylosaurs without tail clubs. Sometimes multiple trackways were found together, all heading in the same direction and never crossing, suggesting several animals may have been travelling together. Anthony Shillito is a University of Saskatchewan researcher who has previously studied dinosaur trackways from the Cretaceous that included four-toed ankylosaur footprints. He said footprints from three-toed ankylosaurs may have been found before, but there are so many three-toed dinosaurs that they would have been hard to identify without the distinctive handprints that were found with the footprints in Canada. "[The study] really made me think back to some of the footprints I've seen — maybe I misinterpreted it because I didn't have this information," he said. "Now people have a better idea of what they're looking for." And that may lead to more being found, and a better idea of where else these club-tailed ankylosaurs may have lived during the Middle Cretaceous, he suggested. The value of footprints vs. bones Paleontologist Scott Persons studied both fossil dinosaur tracks and ankylosaurs during his PhD at the University of Alberta, and is currently working on the study of a new nodosaur species. He said in showing that ankylosaurids lived in North America earlier than thought, the new study demonstrates the value of looking at both fossil footprints and bones. Those often get preserved under different conditions and contain different information. He noted that trackways often show multiple species that lived together at the same time, and can reveal other information. This new trackway also shows that wide, squat ankylosaurs — sometimes described as being coffee-table-like — had a surprisingly bird-like gait, lining up left and right feet like "supermodels on a runway." He added, "This track record shows us the coffee table analogy is a little bit flawed." On the other hand, he acknowledged, there is one drawback of footprints compared to bones.
CBC
21-02-2025
- CBC
Newly discovered ancient apex predator had knife-sharp teeth and bone-crushing jaws
What had the body of a dog, the face of a cat, and jaws powerful enough to potentially crush the bones of an elephant? Meet the Bastetodon, a newly discovered species of apex predator, roughly the size of a leopard or a hyena, that roamed the lush forests of ancient Egypt some 30 million years ago. "It is really the king of the ancient forests," Shorouq Al-Ashqar, a palaeontologist at Mansoura University and the American University in Cairo, told As It Happens guest host Helen Mann. Al-Ashqar is the lead author of a new study identifying the species based on an analysis of a remarkably intact skull discovered in the Egyptian desert. The findings were published in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 'Like it died yesterday' Researchers unearthed the skull in 2020 during an expedition to the Fayum Depression, an archeologically rich site in Egypt's western deserts. For days, the scientists meticulously excavated layers of rock, when suddenly, team member Belal Salem, who is now with Ohio University, noticed a large set of teeth sticking out of the ground. Salem "shouted excitedly" to the rest of the team to come look, says Al-Ashqar. "That was a moment," she said. When she first laid eyes on the fossil, Al-Ashqar says she was blown away. It was almost perfectly intact, save for a few cracks, "like it died yesterday." "For any paleontologist to find a three-dimensional skull … or fossil, it's very rare because it's buried under the rocks for millions of millions of years," she said. After analyzing the skull, and comparing it with other fossils on record, the team determined it belonged to an extinct order of mammals called hyaenodonta — fearsome carnivores who evolved before modern-day cats, dogs and hyenas. Because of its cat-like teeth structure, the team decided to call it Bastetodon, after the cat-headed ancient Egyptian goddess Bastet, who symbolizes protection, pleasure, and good health. The researchers also compared the fossil to that of another lion-sized species of hyaenodonta discovered in Fayum more than 120 years ago, which they have dubbed Sekhmetops, after Sekhmet, the lion-headed Egyptian goddess of wrath and war. "We are super proud of our ancient Egyptian history," Al-Ashqar said. While Sekhmetops was originally believed to have originated in Europe, the team concluded both it and Bastetodon came from Africa before spreading to Asia, Europe, India, and North America. What did it eat? Hans Larsson, a Canadian paleontologist who was not involved in the study, called it "pretty cool." "It's a remarkably complete specimen from a time and place where such complete fossils are incredibly rare," Larsson, curator of vertebrate paleontology at McGill University in Montreal, said in an email. Larsson says he wonders what kind of impact the Bastetodon would have had on the food chain. "The presence of Bastetodon must have had implications for the complexity of the ecosystem to be able to support such a large carnivore," he said. "This 'top dog' in the food chain must have had an equally impressive diet." Al-Ashqar suspects it preyed on primates, early hippos and early elephants, all of which have been found on the fossil record for that time. While it only weighed roughly 27 kilograms, its knife-like teeth, powerful jaws and sheer strength meant it could take down large animals, and would not have had any predators of its own. "They were really, really fearsome animals," she said. But if hyaenodonta were so tough, why did they die out? That's a matter of debate among scientists, Al-Ashqar said. Some theorize a changing climate and dying vegetation reduced the availability of prey and caused them to perish. The desert where the skull was found, for example, was once a lush rainforest. Others, she says, believe they were wiped out when they were forced to compete with the ancestors of modern cats, dogs and hyenas, which arrived in Africa when tectonic shifts changed the shape of Earth's continents. Whatever happened to them, she says studying fossils in places like Fayum helps scientists understand how animals adapted — or, in this case, failed to adapt — to huge global changes. "When we study the impact of climate change and the ecological pressures on the past animals, we can know or have a scenario about what would happen for our ecosystem, or for us as humans in the ecosystem," she said.
