The Guardian view on Maga and Jeffrey Epstein: the truth about Donald Trump and conspiracy theories
It's hard not to feel schadenfreude now that he's at the sharp end of a theory that he at times encouraged and allies eagerly pushed: claims that the prison death of the paedophile Jeffrey Epstein might not be suicide after all, and that wealthy and well-connected associates were trying to hush up connections to the financier. Mr Trump's attorney general, Pam Bondi, promised that 'truckloads' of documents would help reveal the truth and claimed that a client list was 'sitting on my desk right now'.
Then, abruptly, the department of justice said that the financier's death was not murder, that no more files on the investigation against him would be released, and that there was no list of 'clients'. The administration says that Ms Bondi was referring to general files on the case. In short: many of those who promoted the idea that vast, vile secrets were being concealed now claim that there are no secrets at all – with no clear explanation for their volte-face.
The result has been uproar in the Maga movement, with far-right politicians and media figures including Marjorie Taylor Greene, Laura Loomer and Alex Jones among the unsatisfied. Mike Johnson, speaker of the House and a key ally, said that the justice department should 'put it out there'.
Mr Trump attempted to dismiss the story as 'boring', before attacking his own supporters as 'weaklings' for '[buying] into this 'bullshit''. Then, hours after a Wall Street Journal report that he sent a 'bawdy' letter to Epstein – which he denies – he told Ms Bondi to seek the release of grand jury testimony on the sex-trafficking case.
Epstein's crimes are fact, not a 'hoax', and it's also fact that he had repeated contact with high-profile figures, including Bill Gates, Bill Clinton, Prince Andrew and Mr Trump himself – who once remarked of the financier: 'Terrific guy … It is even said that he likes beautiful women as much as I do, and many of them are on the younger side.' The files need not suggest, let alone confirm, any wrongdoing to embarrass anyone mentioned in them: highlighting the association is enough.
At the heart of all Maga conspiracies lies another kernel of truth: that the rich and powerful often get away with exploiting vulnerable people through connections to the state. Yet Trump voters fail to see how that relates to the administration's broader actions.
They are unmoved by his reverse Robin Hood budget legislation, which snatches from the poor to give to billionaires – like those in his cabinet. It's less visceral than Epstein's crimes, and its brazenness may, counterintuitively, make it less viral. Many on the right blame imaginary weather modification, rather than the global heating caused by fossil fuel dependence, for Texas's deadly floods. Conspiracy theories give those who feel powerless a sense of power; of knowing something that others can't see. Even so, the truth revealed by the Epstein scandal – that ordinary Americans are deeply angry at the unfairness and abuses created by elites – is worth heeding, and demands a better political and economic response.
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
27 minutes ago
- The Independent
Trump claims he could have made Bryan Kohberger admit to why he killed 4 students
The White House extended condolences to the families of the four University of Idaho students brutally murdered in November 2022. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt stated that President Donald Trump would have compelled Bryan Kohberger to publicly explain his motive for the killings. Bryan Kohberger received four consecutive life sentences, plus an additional 10 years for burglary, without the possibility of parole. During his sentencing hearing, Kohberger declined the opportunity to address the court or provide a reason for the horrific murders. He had previously accepted a plea deal, admitting guilt to all four counts of first-degree murder and burglary, which removed the death penalty option and did not obligate him to disclose a motive.
The Independent
27 minutes ago
- The Independent
DOJ told Trump that his name is among others in the Epstein files: report
Justice Department officials told President Donald Trump earlier this year that his name, among others, appeared in the Jeffrey Epstein documents, known as the so-called Epstein files, according to a report. Attorney General Pam Bondi informed the president back in May that his name appeared in the documents, senior officials told the Wall Street Journal. His name was one of many high-profile figures in the files, the outlet reported. The files reportedly contain hundreds of names, an official told the paper. Being mentioned in the records isn't a sign of wrongdoing. The revelation comes as the president tries to distance himself from the late financier and the fanfare surrounding the case. Last week, the Journal published a report claiming that Trump gave Epstein a 50th birthday card containing a sexually suggestive drawing and a message suggesting the men shared 'secrets.' The president vehemently denied the claims and even sued the paper and its owners for $10 billion. Attention around the case has bubbled up since the DOJ released a July 6 memo that the
Daily Mail
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Democrats slam Republicans over handling of Epstein files
Democrats are attacking Republicans' handling of the Jeffrey Epstein scandal and are hatching a strategy around the saga to hurt the GOP 's re-election chances. As Republican lawmakers toil over how to handle the late [sexual] offender's files, which are expected to include mention of high-profile American figures, possibly including President Donald Trump , Democrats see the scandal as a chink in the right's armor. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries leaned into Republicans' reluctance to release the files as emblematic of their instinct to 'protect the lifestyles of the rich and shameless, even if that includes [sexual offenders].' A more challenging piece of Democrats' strategy is to tie the Epstein controversy to the recent 'Big, Beautiful Bill,' a sweeping, $3.4 trillion piece of legislation that Republicans passed earlier this month. Democrats argue that the tax breaks and reforms to Medicaid and food stamps will strip cash from the lower and middle classes and transfer it to the richest Americans. They say the law will make tens of millions pay more for healthcare and that veterans, kids and seniors will go hungry. Epstein, a former New York billionaire financier, is the type of person Trump and Republicans are hellbent on protecting, the Democrats claimed. They hope it will be a winning message to turn voters against Republicans in the midterms because they're choosing to protect the powerful. 'The reality is that it's all connected,' Jeffries said of the Epstein scandal and Trump's domestic policy agenda. 'And what billionaires, what well connected donors, what elite people are they trying to protect?' 'Republicans are focused on their billionaire donors,' the Democrat continued. 'That was the centerpiece of the one big, ugly bill, and it's what explains Republican refusal to release the Epstein trials.' The second most powerful House Democrat, Whip Katherine Clark, similarly said Wednesday morning that the Republican base's concerns over the Epstein files could lead them away from the party. 'The Epstein case has helped their own base see what's going on, that this is a con job that they were never the center of the work that they are going to do here,' she said. 'If you don't already have a lot of wealth and power, you are not getting any attention from this Republican Party.' The House will break for August recess on Wednesday afternoon to head back to their districts for over a month. While on the road, Republicans will tout the Trump-backed bill. So will Democrats, but they are going to focus how the bill benefits billionaires like the late Epstein. If the scandal is not handled properly, and the files are not released, the GOP will faces consequences in the 2026 midterms, Republican Sen. Thom Tillis of North Carolina warned this week. 'So I think the files should be released. Let the light of day, let the sun shine through. And that's the best way to get past it,' Tillis, who is not running for re-election, said. 'This is going to be an issue all the way through next year's election,' he added. Rep. Pete Aguilar of California, the third most powerful House Democrat, cut against others in his party, downplaying the need for a strategy on the Epstein files because 'everybody knows that it's real.' 'We don't need a strategic vision for it, because the American people can just turn the TV on and see how the White House and Republicans continue to protect the rich and powerful,' he told the Daily Mail. 'I think it would surprise people like, how much folks are paying attention,' Aguilar added. Aguilar's comments demonstrate that some rank-and-file Democrats may not take Jeffries' marching orders on linking Epstein to the Big Beautiful Bill. Republicans, meanwhile, have also been calling for transparency on the files, though their push to release all the Epstein-linked files contrasts with the White House calling for a selective release. House Majority Whip Tom Emmer, R-Minn., called the push to force release of the files a 'non-issue' during an Axios event Wednesday 'If it was so important, then why weren't Democrats clamoring for this for the four years under Biden?,' Emmer asked. But that view is out of step with a fleet of Republican House members who are pushing for more transparency about who participated in Epstein's trafficking of underage girls. The difference has caused friction in the House. Speaker Mike Johnson shortened the workweek to shield some GOP members from having to vote against the release of the financier's files.
