Group of staff at Shanahan's on the Green left short nearly €35,000
The Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) has heard multiple statutory complaints from former employees of its operator, JMS International Holdings since the closure of the prominent restaurant and has made awards to six workers to date.
There had been a promise to staff that Shanahan's would get back in business and pay what it owed to the workers, a waiter told the tribunal last month. "These plans never came into fruition," he said.
In each case, the workers - who include chefs, front-of-house staff and the company's long-standing bookkeeper - have told the employment tribunal the company failed to pay them any wages for their last week at work.
Six workers, each with more than a decade's service, gave evidence to WRC adjudication officers that they received no notice of termination in circumstances where they were entitled to six to eight weeks each.
Waiting staff said that as well as being denied their last week's wages and other statutory entitlements, they were also left without their tips when the restaurant closed.
The tribunal heard that when tips and service charges were accounted for, some senior waiters at Shanahans were making €1,000 a week or more while working full-time hours.
'He didn't tell us anything'
"It was left to the manager to inform us what was happening, he didn't tell us anything. The company shut down; I was left a week without pay – there was also unpaid tips and service charges," waiter David Byrne told the WRC last month.
Mr Byrne, who had only started four weeks before the closure, said Shanahan's "shut down quite quickly".
"We were told the Sunday night, and from there, it was just shut down. We were emailed, we were told everything would be sorted out, that he had plans to open up again and get everyone paid. These plans never came into fruition."
Mr Byrne was due no statutory redundancy or notice pay due to his short service, but said he had not been paid for three shifts in his last week in the employment.
Adjudication officer Conor Stokes found the restaurant's management breached the Payment of Wages Act 1991 by failing to pay Mr Byrne the €360 he was owed for working three dinner shifts.
Mr Stokes also found Mr Byrne's split of the service charges for that week, €74.80, along with €47.63 in tips, was not paid out in a further breach of the Payment of Wages Act on the part of the restaurant. The total awarded to Mr Byrne was €684.93.
Left 'in the lurch'
The restaurant was coming up on its 25th anniversary when staff were informed that it had ceased trading. Five workers have secured orders for statutory notice on the basis of working there over a decade.
Waiter Luke Carragher was awarded €3,300 for unpaid wages and holiday pay. Paul Harte, another waiter, an employee of Shanahan's since 2006, won €9,855, comprising a week's gross pay and eight weeks' notice.
Assistant manager Angelo Lamberti, who was earning €1,200 a week, including tips and gratuities, won €5,280 for unpaid notice pay, wages and holiday entitlements. Chef Piotr Fraszczyk won €5,950 and bookkeeper Kathleen Friel won €9,855 on the same basis.
The total awards made against JMS International Holdings by the WRC to date now stand at €34,992.93.
The restaurant's management has not attended any of the cases decided by the WRC to date.
One of the longest-serving staff is chef Gheorge Danescu, whose case was also heard last month.WRC adjudicator Penelope McGrath told him: "I have met a number of your colleagues at this stage. You were all let go without any explanation in October of last year. It was a difficult situation, undoubtedly."
"19 years," Mr Danescu said, adding: "They've been like a family."
"I can see from the tone of the emails he [the owner] sent that he had a good rapport with his staff, but he did leave you in the lurch," Ms McGrath said.
She noted that there was an email from the owner "stating that Revenue had frozen the bank accounts and he was going to go back to the States and attempt to raise funds".
"You were given no notice, because that was effectively your last day of work," she added.
The WRC's decision on Mr Danescu's complaints has yet to be published. The chef's wife asked Ms McGrath at the hearing: "Who's going to pay the money?"
Ms McGrath said: "Some monies can be claimed through the social insurance fund. You need to talk to your colleagues; I can't give you legal advice [but] it's not without hope."
"It won't be from the respondent. The status of the respondent would be known to the [Department of Social Protection]," she added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Employee sacked after HR chief recorded him on phone call wins €10k for unfair dismissal
An employee who was sacked when a recording of him venting his 'frustrations' to his company's human resources chief was sent to the CEO months later has won €10,000 for unfair dismissal. Thomas Delaney secured the award on foot of a complaint under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977 against NSP Expert Lab Solutions in a decision just published by the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC). Mr Delaney, who lost his job of over eight years with the firm in May 2024, told the tribunal that he thought his conversation with its HR chief in February that year was 'in confidence' and that he never consented to a recording. Representing himself at a WRC hearing in August 2024, he explained that he was 'off on stress leave' at the time of the call and said that he 'vented' frustrations over the phone. READ MORE His evidence was that the company's head of HR was 'biased in her dealings' with him from the phone call to his dismissal. Mr Delaney told the WRC the recording was made in February, but 'was only sent to the CEO in May'. Within 24 hours of the recording been sent to the chief executive, he was dismissed from his €56,000-a-year job, he said. His position was that the disciplinary process followed by his employer was 'based on assumptions', 'flawed', and lacking in 'transparency'. He pointed out that he was given 'no opportunity to respond to the case' and was subjected to a disproportionate sanction. He said he never received a copy of the transcript of the phone call relied on to dismiss him and had no opportunity to address its contents or any allegations against him. Company solicitor Malachy Kearney submitted that the firm received a 'protected disclosure' in the form of 'a recorded conversation between the complainant and a member of [its] staff'. 'In that conversation, the complainant had raised issues that were considered to amount to gross misconduct. Arising from this, the complainant was summarily dismissed,' Mr Kearney submitted. 'As per the provisions of its handbook, the company reserved the right to bypass any step in the disciplinary process if it feels that severity of the action warranted it,' Mr Kearney submitted. 'It was decided that in this instance the working relationship with the complainant was irretrievable and that dismissal was the only outcome,' he added. The dismissal was effected by asking Mr Delaney to report to the company's offices, whereupon a letter of dismissal on the grounds of gross misconduct was read to him, Mr Kearney submitted. The complainant was then required to surrender his laptop, phone, credit card and company car keys, before being sent home in a taxi, Mr Kearney explained. The tribunal noted that there was 'no oral evidence' provided by company witnesses. Adjudicator Conor Stokes noted on the basis of the company's written submissions that Mr Delaney 'was not party to the investigation [or] disciplinary process'. He was 'simply called in to have the decision 'read at him',' and had no opportunity to respond to any allegations or complaints against him, or to make representations on his behalf. He concluded that Mr Delaney had been denied 'a fair and impartial determination of the issues' and that the employee was unfairly dismissed. The adjudicator noted Mr Delaney's loss of €1,085-a-week gross pay over a 14-week period of unemployment between dismissal and a WRC hearing in August 2024, and a lack of evidence of efforts to seek alternative employment during that period. Mr Stokes concluded that 'compensation amounting to €10,000 in respect of loss of earnings' was the appropriate award.
Irish Independent
3 days ago
- Irish Independent
Wicklow school's new building has no timeline for works
Delivered on behalf of the Department of Education, Coláiste Bhríde's new school is part of The Exchequer Funded Schools Programme's 'Project Dargle', which includes Avondale Community College in Rathdrum, St Kevin's Community College in Dunlavin and Arklow CBS. The proposed development at Coláiste Bhríde will see the existing school buildings, temporary classrooms and ball courts demolished and removed. The existing 1930s school building will be refurbished alongside a new extension for use as a school library. The new school building will include space for classrooms, a Special Education Needs unit with a secured rooftop play area, a general-purpose hall, a multi-use hall and a range of outdoor play and amenity areas. The existing vehicular entrance at the northeast of the site off the R725 regional road will be upgraded, with the vehicular entrance at the northwest of the site off the R725 relocated. A new pedestrian entrance off the R725 is also proposed, as well as a new set-down area adjoining the R725 for cars and school buses, along with 92 car spaces. Following a question from Wicklow-Wexford TD Malcom Byrne in the Dáil, junior minister at the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine Michael Healy-Rae said the project is currently in the final stages of stage 2b. 'The architectural process allows for detailed design and planning, obtaining the necessary statutory permissions and the preparation of tender documents. 'When this stage is finalised, the next stage is tendering for a contractor and then onwards to construction in due course. 'While at this early stage it is not possible to provide a timeline for completion of the project, the National Development Finance Agency will continue to engage directly with the school authorities to keep them fully informed of all progress.' he added. ADVERTISEMENT In response Deputy Byrne said the new school is badly needed to help meet the growing demand for places in the area. 'The neighbouring town of Gorey has three schools, the third of which was sanctioned by the previous Minister, Deputy Foley, will soon reach capacity because the population in north Wexford and south Wicklow is growing incredibly quickly so there will be pressure for additional places in the area. That is why it is critical that Carnew gets a modern school as soon as possible.' Deputy Byrne said adequate sporting facilities also need to be made available on the site. 'What the school wants to see, which makes economic sense, is that the groundworks are carried out to ensure those sporting facilities can be provided while the school is being built. It is about long-term planning in the area. This must be a priority.' he added.
Irish Times
5 days ago
- Irish Times
Nearly €35,000 owed to staff left ‘in the lurch' by Shanahan's on the Green closure
A group of staff at Dublin restaurant Shanahan's on the Green were left short nearly €35,000 when it shut abruptly last year, a tribunal has found. The Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) has heard multiple statutory complaints from former employees of its operator, JMS International Holdings, since the closure of the prominent restaurant and has made awards to six workers to date. There had been a promise to staff that Shanahan's would get back in business and pay what it owed to the workers, a waiter told the tribunal last month. 'These plans never came to fruition,' he said. In each case, the workers – who include chefs, front-of-house staff and the company's long-standing book-keeper – have told the employment tribunal the company failed to pay them any wages for their last week at work. READ MORE Six workers, each with more than a decade's service, gave evidence to WRC adjudication officers that they received no notice of termination in circumstances where they were entitled to six to eight weeks each. Waiting staff said that as well as being denied their last week's wages and other statutory entitlements, they were also left without their tips when the restaurant closed. [ Dublin steakhouse Shanahan's on the Green closed until further notice due to financial challenges Opens in new window ] The tribunal heard that when tips and service charges were accounted for, some senior waiters at Shanahans were making €1,000 a week or more while working full-time hours. 'It was left to the manager to inform us what was happening, he didn't tell us anything. The company shut down; I was left a week without pay – there was also unpaid tips and service charges,' waiter David Byrne told the WRC last month. Mr Byrne, who had only started four weeks before the closure, said Shanahan's 'shut down quite quickly'. 'We were told the Sunday night, and from there, it was just shut down. We were emailed, we were told everything would be sorted out, that he had plans to open up again and get everyone paid. These plans never came to fruition.' How the wealthy are buying up land to avoid inheritance tax Listen | 22:03 Mr Byrne was due no statutory redundancy or notice pay due to his short service, but said he had not been paid for three shifts in his last week in the employment. Adjudication officer Conor Stokes found the restaurant's management breached the Payment of Wages Act 1991 by failing to pay Mr Byrne the €360 he was owed for working three dinner shifts. Mr Stokes also found Mr Byrne's split of the service charges for that week, €74.80, along with €47.63 in tips, was not paid out in a further breach of the Payment of Wages Act on the part of the restaurant. The total awarded to Mr Byrne was €684.93. The restaurant was coming up on its 25th anniversary when staff were informed that it had ceased trading. Five workers have secured orders for statutory notice on the basis of working there over a decade. Waiter Luke Carragher was awarded €3,300 for unpaid wages and holiday pay. Paul Harte, another waiter, an employee of Shanahan's since 2006, won €9,855, comprising a week's gross pay and eight weeks' notice. Assistant manager Angelo Lamberti, who was earning €1,200 a week, including tips and gratuities, won €5,280 for unpaid notice pay, wages and holiday entitlements. Chef Piotr Fraszczyk won €5,950 and book-keeper Kathleen Friel won €9,855 on the same basis. The total awards made against JMS International Holdings by the WRC to date now stand at €34,992.93. The restaurant's management has not attended any of the cases decided by the WRC to date. One of the longest-serving staff was chef Gheorge Danescu, whose case was also heard last month. WRC adjudicator Penelope McGrath told him: 'I have met a number of your colleagues at this stage. You were all let go without any explanation in October of last year. It was a difficult situation, undoubtedly.' 'Nineteen years,' Mr Danescu said, adding: 'They've been like a family.' 'I can see from the tone of the emails he [the owner] sent that he had a good rapport with his staff, but he did leave you in the lurch,' Ms McGrath said. She noted that there was an email from the owner 'stating that Revenue had frozen the bank accounts and he was going to go back to the States and attempt to raise funds'. 'You were given no notice, because that was effectively your last day of work,' she added. The WRC's decision on Mr Danescu's complaints has yet to be published. The chef's wife asked Ms McGrath at the hearing: 'Who's going to pay the money?' Ms McGrath said: 'Some money can be claimed through the social insurance fund. You need to talk to your colleagues; I can't give you legal advice [but] it's not without hope.' 'It won't be from the respondent. The status of the respondent would be known to the [Department of Social Protection],' she added.
