The key moments from the mushroom cook murder trial
1. Erin Patterson gives evidence and admits foraging
After weeks of prosecution evidence, she was announced as the defence's only witness in her murder trial.
She took to the witness box for eight days, including several under gruelling cross-examination by crown prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC. She admitted beginning mushroom foraging during Victoria's first Covid-19 lockdown in 2020.
"They tasted good and I didn't get sick," she told the jury, about preparing and eating wild fungi for the first time. Patterson said she loved her former in-laws and they were her only living family.
ADVERTISEMENT
She also claimed she'd thrown up remnants on the meal after eating it as she suffered from bulimia, and admitted to lying about owning a dehydrator and foraging to police.
1News Australia correspondent Aziz Al Sa'afin speaks to Breakfast in the wake of yesterday's verdict. (Source: Breakfast)
2. Sole lunch survivor Ian Wilkinson enters witness box
The only lunch guest to survive eating Patterson's poisoned beef Wellington, Ian was one of the first witnesses called during week two of the trial.
Ian, Simon Patterson's uncle and pastor at Korumburra Baptist Church, locked eyes with the woman who tried to kill him as he sat in the witness box and gave emotional evidence about losing his wife Heather.
He said Patterson had served himself, his wife Heather, and Don and Gail Patterson on grey dinner plates which were different to her own plate.
Ian laughed as he recalled banter at the dinner table over how Don had eaten his portion and half of his wife Gail's.
ADVERTISEMENT
3. Estranged husband Simon Patterson called as witness
Simon was the first witness called by prosecutors and he discussed their up and down relationship in the years leading up to their permanent separation in 2015.
He gave evidence for three days and explained that he did not attend the fatal lunch, although he was invited, because he felt "too uncomfortable".
Simon also became emotional as he recalled seeing his father and mother dying in their hospital beds.
"Dad was substantially worse than mum, he was really struggling ... He wasn't right inside. He was feeling pain," he said, between tears.
The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including what the jury saw at the mushroom murder trial, where house prices are climbing, and why YouTube's biggest star has business plans in NZ. (Source: 1News)
4. Medical experts explain how her lunch guests became ill, but Patterson did not
ADVERTISEMENT
Several doctors, nurses and toxicologists detailed how the four lunch guests' conditions deteriorated over several days after going to hospital with diarrhoea, vomiting and stomach pain and they tried to save their lives.
Initially, doctors and victims had assumed they all had gastro, but soon it became clear they had consumed death cap mushrooms.
Patterson, on the other hand, took herself to hospital two days after the meal and quickly discharged herself.
She returned and then was taken to a Melbourne hospital but was found to not have been poisoned.
5. Computer devices reveal death cap mushroom searches
Searches of computers, tablets and mobile phones seized from Patterson's home revealed she had navigated to science website iNaturalist in May 2022 and looked at death cap mushroom sighting post for Moorabbin, in Melbourne.
6. Patterson's angry messages over child support
ADVERTISEMENT
A child support issue between Simon and Erin started to involve his parents, Don and Gail, towards the end of 2022 - about six months before the toxic meal.
Messages sent by Patterson to her Facebook friends revealed she called Simon a "deadbeat" and said she wanted nothing to do with her parents-in-law. "This family, I swear to f*****g god," another message said.
Prosecutors said this showed how her relationship with the Patterson family had begun deteriorating.
7. Cell phone tower pings after online death cap sightings
Patterson's phone had pinged at cell towers in the Gippsland towns of Outtrim and Loch after posts on iNaturalist about death cap mushroom sightings in those areas.
Her defence argued this evidence was unreliable, but prosecutors said it showed she had gone to these areas to pick the deadly fungi.
8. Patterson's missing mobile phone
Several mobile phones were seized from Patterson's home except one, Phone A, and prosecutors told the jury they had never recovered this phone. Its sim card was swapped during a police search of her Leongatha home on August 5, 2023.
Another phone, known during the trial as Phone B, had been factory reset on the day police were at her home and again while sitting in a locker at Victoria police's homicide HQ.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
11 hours ago
- 1News
US man sentenced to life in prison for shooting and beheading father
A Pennsylvania man who posted a video of his father's severed head on YouTube was convicted of murder overnight and sentenced to life without parole. Bucks County Judge Stephen A. Corr found Justin D. Mohn, 33, guilty in the January 2024 shooting death of his father at their home in the Philadelphia suburb of Levittown. After the sentencing, Bucks County District Attorney Jennifer Schorn told reporters Mohn had exhibited a "complete and utter lack of remorse," calling it an "unimaginable, unfathomable crime". "We are satisfied that this was the right outcome to guarantee that the community at large is safe from Justin Mohn," Schorn said. His defence attorney called it an "undoubtedly difficult case to preside over". ADVERTISEMENT "Cases involving the loss of life are always the most difficult, and that difficulty is compounded when the prosecution seeks the death penalty. The commonwealth originally sought the death penalty in this case, and based on the defence that was presented on behalf of Mr. Mohn, my client will not face that penalty," said Mohn's lawyer, Steven M. Jones, in an email. He declined to comment on whether Mohn will appeal. Prosecutors said Mohn shot his father, Michael F. Mohn, 68, with a newly purchased pistol, then decapitated him with a kitchen knife and machete. The 14-minute YouTube video he posted was live for several hours before it was removed. Mohn testified during the trial that he shot his father while trying to arrest him on what he said were false statements and treason, but his father resisted, so he fired at him. He said he severed his head to send a message to federal workers to meet his demands, which included their resignation among other things. In victim impact statements read in court Friday, family members and others recalled Michael Mohn as a loving husband and father, a man of humility and humour who enjoyed reading, exercising and playing the guitar. Flowers rest at the front door of the Mohn residence in Upper Orchard section of Levittown Pennsylvania (file image). (Source: Associated Press) Justin Mohn was arrested later on the day of the murder after scaling a fence at Fort Indiantown Gap, the state's National Guard headquarters. Prosecutors said he called for others to join him in attempting to overthrow the US government. Mohn had a USB device containing photos of federal buildings and apparent instructions for making explosives when he was arrested, authorities said. ADVERTISEMENT He also expressed violent anti-government rhetoric in writings he published online, going back several years. During the trial, the judge heard from Justin Mohn's mother, who said police came to the house he shared with his parents and warned him about his online postings before the killing. Denice Mohn testified that she and her husband had been offering financial support and guidance as Justin Mohn looked for a job. "It's unimaginable what the defendant did to his father and to his family," Schorn said. "I know this verdict does provide some level of justice, but it will never heal their wounds." He was also convicted of possession of an instrument of crime, gun charges, criminal use of a communication facility, terroristic threats, defiant trespassing, and abuse of a corpse. Prosecutors described the homicide as "something straight out of a horror film." They said Justin Mohn killed his father — who had been an engineer with the geoenvironmental section of the US Army Corps of Engineers' Philadelphia District — to intimidate federal workers, calling it a "cold, calculated, organised plan." The YouTube video included rants about the government, immigration and the border, fiscal policy, urban crime and the war in Ukraine. In the video posted on YouTube, Justin Mohn described his father as a 20-year federal employee and called him a traitor. During a competency hearing last year, a defence expert said Mohn wrote a letter to Russia's ambassador to the United States seeking to strike a deal to give Mohn refuge and apologizing to President Vladimir Putin for claiming to be the czar of Russia. The judge ruled Mohn was competent to stand trial. Evidence presented at the trial included graphic photos and the video posted to YouTube. The judge warned members of the public at the trial about the images and said they could leave before the photos were shown. The proceedings are known as a bench trial, with only a judge, not a jury.
Otago Daily Times
15 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Tributes flow for postie struck by vehicle
Tributes continue to flow for rural Canterbury postie and well-known bowler Dave Bullock, who was tragically killed last week. Bullock, 78, was struck by a vehicle at the intersection of Leeston, Lakes and Harts Rds last Friday night. He was on his way to Christchurch and had stopped to drop off missed mail, but got his car stuck in grassy mud. His son-in-law arrived to help get the car out of the mud, but they were both struck by a vehicle about 7.40pm. Bullock died at the scene and his son-in-law received a broken leg. Bullock was a life member and president of the Canterbury Indoor Bowls Association (CIBA). On the CIBA Facebook page more than 100 tributes have been made. 'This is shocking news for everyone. Dave was a great man who poured his heart and soul into Canterbury indoor bowls over many years,' one person wrote. 'Dave was so admired by many in the bowls community and I'm sure that was the same with everything that he was involved with,' another said. 'It is such sad news to hear that Dave has passed away. A true gentleman, a great bowler and a tireless worker for the game.' 'Oh my I am so shocked & saddened to hear this news. I had the honour of playing with Dave last Sunday all day in the rep game in Ashburton he was a great skip to play with. Condolences to his family he will be sadly missed.' 'He was such a down-to-earth guy, easy to talk to and a great bowler. Sending my thoughts to his family and friends.' Bullock was due to meet his friend Carolyn Swanson on Friday night to set up a bowls event and have dinner. He had text her to say he was running late after getting his car stuck while dropping off some mail which had been missed. But after some time passed, Swanson tried calling him, but it kept going to voicemail, she later found out what had happened from Bullock's family. Inquiries into the circumstances of the crash are ongoing. Bullock had been a rural contractor for NZ Post in the Leeston area for 28 years, with Friday supposed to be his last day of work, having sold his mail run. After Friday, he was going to spend two weeks training the next postie. 'His whole life was just bowls,' Swanson said. 'He was just dedicated. If he wasn't running events, he was playing them.' He was awarded the Queen's Service Medal in 2022 for administrative services to bowls. Alongside being the president of CIBA since 2002, Bullock saw the rebuild of the CIBA stadium in Bromley after the earthquakes, before a fire destroyed it in 2014. He was critical to keeping Canterbury indoor bowls alive during the Covid-19 pandemic, Swanson said. 'He was a lovely, dedicated soul. He was the most pleasant person you could ever want to meet,' Swanson said.
1News
2 days ago
- 1News
Jury sees Julia DeLuney's first police interview after mother's death
A high court jury has seen footage of murder-accused Julia DeLuney's video interview with police the day after her mother's death, where her story is first put under the microscope. Police questioned why she changed her clothes on two different occasions, and as they begin to interrogate the details, she asks: "Do you think I could do something like that? It's just, what are you suggesting? You're making me out to be a f***ing monster." DeLuney is on trial at the High Court in Wellington for the murder of her 79-year-old mother, Helen Gregory, which she denies. The Crown says DeLuney attacked her mother before staging it to look like she had fallen from the attic, but the defence says someone else caused those injuries in the 90 minutes in which she had gone to get help. This week the jury has seen CCTV footage captured by Gregory's neighbour of DeLuney arriving at her mother's address and going up the steps to the house. ADVERTISEMENT The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including a homicide arrest after a Hamilton manhunt, concern over a new Covid variant, and Red Bull sacks its Formula 1 team boss. (Source: 1News) She leaves again three and a half hours later, before briefly ascending the steps for a second time for only a few minutes, coming down again, and then getting in her car and driving away at 9.47pm. There has also been footage of DeLuney disposing of a black rubbish bag in a passing rubbish truck the morning after her mother's death. On Wednesday afternoon, a video interview with detective constable Christopher Clarke was played to the court. The interview lasts two hours and 40 minutes, recorded from about 8.40pm on January 25, 2024, at the Porirua police station. The interviewer, detective constable Chris Clarke, asks DeLuney to go through her version of events multiple times, in increasing detail, and then begins to question it. DeLuney is dressed in a bright red shirt and pants and, in the interview, she wraps herself in a green patterned dressing gown, which another officer has brought to her from her apartment, which was at that point being searched. Clarke describes Gregory's injuries to DeLuney. ADVERTISEMENT "She had a black eye and bruising on the right-hand side of her jaw. Part of her scalp was found in the hallway and the bedroom. "What? Say that again." "The scalp." Clarke gestures to his own head. "Oh my god, no." "There was an open wound on the right-hand side, I believe, of her head and a cut to her arm," Clarke tells her. "They're significant injuries. Right now we have CCTV showing you changing your outfits, significant injuries to your mum-" "I didn't do those injuries to my mother." Clarke also asks about a discrepancy in timing. He said there was a 25-minute gap between when she should have arrived back at her mother's and calling the ambulance. ADVERTISEMENT In the interview, DeLuney denied there had been a delay, and CCTV footage would later confirm her version of events. A neighbour's security camera, the footage of which was played to the court on Tuesday, showed there was a gap of just 10 minutes between DeLuney arriving at Gregory's address, and the first ambulance arriving. But at the time of the video interview, police believed there to be a larger gap. Clarke explained this was due to a delay in ambulance staff passing on the call to police. While DeLuney was being interviewed at the police station, officers and a forensic photographer were going through her Paraparaumu apartment. They were, among other things, searching for the various clothing items DeLuney had been pictured in the night before. CCTV footage showed she arrived at her mother's wearing a bright green shirt, blue jeans and white sneakers. Then, she changed her clothes before leaving her mother's to fetch her husband Antonion DeLuney to help. ADVERTISEMENT She explained this was because she did not want to go out in public with blood on her clothes, which had happened while helping her mother, who she said had cut her head falling from the attic. So she was pictured at the Mobil station in Johnsonville, where she stopped to buy a lighter, wearing items of her mothers — a pink long-sleeved top, black pants and black slippers. She said she and her mother shared clothing all the time. "I didn't want to be in public with blood [on me]," she told the detective. "If I was going straight back to see Antonio, then I wouldn't have changed." She changed her clothes again when she got back to her apartment, explaining she just felt more comfortable in her own clothes. The prosecution confirmed all clothing she was pictured in had later been accounted for. But Clarke questioned her priotrities. ADVERTISEMENT "You've gone to your mum's address, she's fallen, you were saying by accident, you get blood on your top, you don't call an ambulance but you change your outfit, put your green top in your handbag, that's what you just said, and then left wearing your mum's clothing." He said three outfit changes was not something you would expect in this situation. DeLuney denied being capable of killing her mother. "I have never been a violent person, particularly to my mother, ever, ever," she says, vehement. "I never even hit my kids." She admitted she did consider calling an ambulance at the house when her mother first fell, but decided against it, as her mother hated hospitals and was protesting. She told Clarke: "I made a mistake, I should have called the ambulance straight away... I shouldn't have let her go up in the f***ing attic and I should have rung 111. I get that." The trial continues.
