SNP planning tax on cruise ships
The levy – which would be the first of its kind in the UK – is being considered amid evidence that more cruises and passengers are visiting Scotland than ever before.
Ministers have ruled out a compulsory blanket tax, but said legislation could be passed that would give councils discretionary power to impose a cruise ship levy.
A consultation paper by the Scottish government argues that cruise ships bring economic benefits to places such as Invergordon, Orkney, Edinburgh, Lerwick in Shetland, and Greenock.
It also warns that they bring 'pressures' to some coastal and island communities which, though not spelled out in the paper, typically include concerns around overcrowding, strain on local infrastructure and potential environmental damage.
Launching the consultation on Thursday, the Scottish government said: 'We are aware that a cruise ship levy in Scotland would be [the] first such levy in the United Kingdom, and we will need to carefully consider market implications and the effect on local economies and communities of such a levy.'
Orkney Islands Council already backs the idea in principle after hearing that a £5 levy on passengers could raise £1 million a year. It is also supported by the Scottish Greens.
Ariane Burgess, the party's local government spokesperson, said: 'Cruise ships are one of the dirtiest and most polluting forms of travel, and it is right that we tax them.'
She added that a levy 'is an important step for our climate and for local government [and] will make a big difference for port communities across Scotland, from Ullapool to Greenock, Kirkwall to Edinburgh, Stornoway to Rosyth.
'The tourism that these ships bring can have a lot of benefits, but we also know that it can put a lot of pressure on the local environment, infrastructure and services.'
The SNP said the idea of a cruise ship tax was first raised during work to explore levies for tourists in 2019.
It did not feature in the Visitor Levy Act passed by the Scottish parliament last year – which allows a tax to be charged on certain overnight stays – but was discussed at four round-table events hosted by the Scottish government in Greenock, Inverness, Kirkwall, and Edinburgh.
The consultation paper states that the 'intention behind any cruise ship levy would be to have the levy apply to those ships that are carrying paying passengers, on a journey involving two or more nights on the ship, and which give the passengers the option to disembark from the vessel onto the Scottish mainland or a Scottish island.'
It said ferry services in Scotland and those visiting Scottish waters in private boats or yachts that are not carrying paying passengers would be excluded.
The paper explores how a levy might be calculated and suggests it could be based on the gross tonnage of a vessel, its total passenger capacity, the actual number of passengers on board when it moors at a port or on the number that disembark.
It highlights that there were about 1,000 cruise ship visits to Scottish ports in 2024, bringing 1.2 million passengers, up from 2019, when an estimated 893 cruise ship calls brought 817,000 passengers.
The paper states that cruise passengers make up about 2 per cent of the total number of overnight stays by visitors in Scotland but points out that some regions are more impacted than others. In 2018, 84 per cent of overnight visitors in Orkney, and 79 per cent of those in Shetland, were cruise ship passengers.
The busiest day identified at a single port in 2024 was in Invergordon, where 9,600 people were due to arrive on one day in September.
Shona Robison, Scotland's finance secretary, added: 'The tourism sector is a crucially important part of the Scottish economy and cruise visits are increasing.
'The consultation will help to inform the Scottish Government's decision over whether or not to bring forward legislation and it is really important that we hear from a wide variety of voices on this matter.
'Last year, we held events to hear the views of the cruise ship industry, local government, and others. We want to continue the helpful dialogue which started at those events, and explore further what a cruise ship levy could mean in a Scottish context.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
an hour ago
- Boston Globe
Israel's Netanyahu set to give final approval for Gaza City takeover despite protests
Advertisement Israeli strikes meanwhile killed at least 36 Palestinians across Gaza on Thursday, according to local hospitals. A renewed offensive could bring even more casualties and displacement to the territory, where the war has already killed tens of thousands and where experts of have warned of imminent famine. Many Israelis fear it could also doom the remaining 20 or so living hostages taken by Hamas-led militants in the Oct. 7, 2023, attack that ignited the war. Gaza City operation could begin in days Israeli troops have already begun more limited operations in the city's Zeitoun neighborhood and the built-up Jabaliya refugee camp, areas where they have carried out several previous major operations over the course of the war, only to see militants later regroup. Advertisement The military says it plans to operate in areas where ground troops have not yet entered and where it says Hamas still has military and governing capabilities. So far, there has been little sign of Palestinians fleeing en masse, as they did when Israel carried out an earlier offensive in Gaza City in the opening weeks of the war. The military says it controls around 75 percent of Gaza and residents say nowhere in the territory feels safe. Hundreds gathered for a rare protest in Gaza City on Thursday against the war and Israel's plans to support the mass relocation Palestinians to other countries. Women and children held placards reading 'Save Gaza' and 'Stop the war, stop the savage attack, save us,' against a backdrop of destroyed buildings as Palestinian music played. Unlike in previous protests, there were no expressions of opposition to Hamas. 'We want the war on Gaza to stop. We don't want to migrate. Twenty-two months … it's enough. Enough death. Enough destruction,' said Bisan Ghazal, a woman displaced from Gaza City. Protests in Israel In Israel, families of some of the 50 hostages still being held in Gaza gathered in Tel Aviv to condemn the expanded operation. Israel believes around 20 hostages are still alive. 'Forty-two hostages were kidnapped alive and murdered in captivity due to military pressure and delay in signing a deal,' said Dalia Cusnir, whose brother-in-law, Eitan Horn, is still being held captive. Eitan's brother, Iair Horn, was released during a ceasefire earlier this year. 'Enough to sacrifice the hostages. Enough to sacrifice the soldiers, both regular and reservists. Enough to sacrifice the evacuees. Enough to sacrifice the younger generation in the country,' said Bar Goddard, the daughter of Meni Goddard, whose body is being held by Hamas. Advertisement Additional protests are planned for Thursday night in Tel Aviv. Plans for widening the offensive have also sparked international outrage, with many of Israel's closest Western allies — but not the United States — calling on it to end the war. 'I must reiterate that it is vital to reach immediately a ceasefire in Gaza, and the unconditional release of all hostages to avoid the massive death and destruction that a military operation against Gaza City would inevitably cause,' United Nations chief António Guterres said at a conference in Japan. Dozens killed across Gaza At least 36 Palestinians were killed by Israeli fire across the Gaza Strip on Thursday, including 14 who were seeking humanitarian aid, according to local hospitals. The Israeli military did not have any immediate comment on the strikes but has frequently accused Hamas militants of hiding among civilians and placing military infrastructure in civilian areas. Witnesses, health officials and the U.N. human rights office say Israeli forces have killed hundreds of people since May as they headed toward sites run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, an Israeli-backed American contractor, and in the chaos surrounding U.N. aid convoys, which are frequently attacked by looters and overrun by crowds. The Israeli military says it has only fired warning shots at people who approach its forces. GHF says there has been almost no violence at the sites themselves, and that its armed contractors have only used pepper spray and fired into the air on some occasions to prevent deadly crowding. Israeli strikes destroy evacuated tent camp Israeli airstrikes also destroyed a tent camp in Deir al-Balah, the only city in Gaza that has been relatively unscathed in the war and where many have sought refuge. Residents said the Israeli military warned them flee shortly before the strikes set the camp ablaze, and there were no reports of casualties. Advertisement Families, many with children, could later be seen sifting through the ashes for the belongings they had managed to take with them during earlier evacuations. Mohammad Kahlout, who had been displaced from northern Gaza, said they were given just five minutes to gather what they could and evacuate. 'We are civilians, not terrorists. What did we do, and what did our children do, to be displaced again?' The Gaza Health Ministry said Thursday that at least 62,192 Palestinians have been killed in the war. Another two people have died from malnutrition-related causes, bringing the total number of such deaths to 271, including 112 children, the Health Ministry said. The ministry is part of the Hamas-run government and staffed by medical professionals. It does not say whether those killed by Israeli fire are civilians or combatants, but it says around half are women and children. The U.N. and many independent experts consider its figures to be the most reliable estimate of wartime casualties. Israel disputes its toll but has not provided its own. Hamas-led militants started the war when they attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, killing some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducting 251. Most of the hostages have been released in ceasefires or other deals. Hamas says it will only free the rest in exchange for a lasting ceasefire and an Israeli withdrawal. ___ Abou Aljoud reported from Beirut and Lidman reported from Jerusalem. Mari Yamaguchi contributed from Tokyo.
CBS News
2 hours ago
- CBS News
At least 5 states are deploying National Guard troops to D.C.
At least five Republican-led states have moved to deploy members of their National Guard forces to the nation's capital as part of the Trump administration's effort to overhaul policing in Washington, D.C., through a federal crackdown on crime and homelessness. The governors of Mississippi and Louisiana on Monday announced they would be sending 200 and 135 Guard troops, respectively. On Saturday, West Virginia said it was deploying between 300 to 400 Guard troops, while South Carolina pledged 200 and Ohio said it would send 150 in the coming days. Tennessee has also provided 160 Guard troops, according to The Associated Press. The Tennessee National Guard has been deployed "to assist with monument security, community safety patrols, protecting federal facilities, and traffic control," a spokesperson for Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee told AP. The move comes as federal agents and National Guard troops have begun to appear across the heavily Democratic city after President Trump's executive order last week, federalizing local police forces and activating about 800 D.C. National Guard troops. West Virginia Gov. Patrick Morrisey announced Saturday that he was sending a contingent of 300 to 400 Guard troops to Washington, while South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster authorized the deployment of 200 of his state's National Guardsmen. Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine said his state would send 150 military police at the request of the Defense Department. "West Virginia is proud to stand with President Trump in his effort to restore pride and beauty to our nation's capital," Morrisey said. Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry wrote Monday on social media: "I am proud to support this mission to return safety and sanity to Washington DC and cities all across our country, including right here in Louisiana." Mississippi Gov. Tate Reeves wrote on X that "crime is out of control" in Washington, D.C., adding: "I know the brave men and women of our National Guard will do an excellent job enhancing public safety and supporting law enforcement." Maj. Gen. James Seward, West Virginia's adjutant general, said in a statement that members of the state's National Guard "stand ready to support our partners in the National Capital Region," and that the troops' "unique capabilities and preparedness make it an invaluable partner in this important undertaking." Gov. Phil Scott, a Republican from Vermont, declined on Friday to send the state's National Guard troops to the nation's capital. Scott's chief of staff, Jason Gibbs, told Vermont Public that while public safety is a "legitimate concern" in cities across the country, "the governor just does not support utilizing the guard for this purpose, and does not view the enforcement of domestic law as proper use of the National Guard." The activations suggest the Trump administration sees the need for additional manpower after the president personally played down the need for Washington to hire more police officers. By adding outside troops to join the existing National Guard deployment and federal law enforcement officers temporarily assigned to Washington, Mr. Trump is exercising even tighter control over the city. It's a power play that the president has justified as an emergency response to crime and homelessness, even though district officials have noted that violent crime is lower than it was during Trump's first term in office. A White House official told CBS News on Saturday that National Guard members deployed to D.C. "may be armed," but that they would not make arrests. This was a reversal from earlier in the week, when a Defense Department official told CBS News that deployed Guard members would not be armed at the request of local law enforcement partners. The official also said at the time they would not have weapons in their vehicles. "The National Guard is not making arrests at this time – they may be armed, consistent with their mission and training, to protect federal assets, provide a safe environment for law enforcement officers to make arrests, and deter violent crime with a visible law enforcement presence," the White House official said Saturday. A protest against Mr. Trump's intervention drew scores to Dupont Circle on Saturday afternoon before a march to the White House, about 1.5 miles away. Demonstrators assembled behind a banner that said "No fascist takeover of D.C.," and some in the crowd held signs that said "No military occupation." Mr. Trump was at his Virginia golf club after Friday's summit with Russian President Vladimir Putin in Alaska. Federal agents have appeared in some of the city's most highly trafficked neighborhoods, garnering a mix of praise, pushback and alarm from local residents and leaders across the country. City leaders, who are obliged to cooperate with the president's order under the federal laws that direct the district's local governance, have sought to work with the administration, though they have bristled at the scope of the president's takeover. On Friday, the administration reversed course on an order that aimed to place the head of the Drug Enforcement Administration as an "emergency police commissioner" after the district's top lawyer sued to contest. After Friday's court hearing, Attorney General Pam Bond issued a memo that directed the Metropolitan Police Department to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement regardless of any city law. District officials say they are evaluating how to best comply. In his order last week, Mr. Trump declared an emergency due to the "city government's failure to maintain public order." He said that impeded the "federal government's ability to operate efficiently to address the nation's broader interests without fear of our workers being subjected to rampant violence." In a letter to city residents, D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser, a Democrat, wrote that "our limited self-government has never faced the type of test we are facing right now." She added that if Washingtonians stick together, "we will show the entire nation what it looks like to fight for American democracy — even when we don't have full access to it."
Business Wire
2 hours ago
- Business Wire
Verantos to Present Practical Approaches in High-Validity Real-World Evidence Generation at ISPE's 41st Annual Meeting
MENLO PARK, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)-- Verantos, the global leader in high-validity real-world evidence at scale, announced today that it will present practical approaches for generating high-validity real-world evidence (RWE) at the International Society for Pharmacoepidemiology (ISPE) 41st Annual Meeting in Washington, D.C. The goal isn't just to measure data reliability; it's to optimize it and to do so using peer-reviewed, published methods so metrics can't be gamed. Share CEO Dan Riskin will share approaches to achieve fit-for-use RWD based on real-world learnings from large pharma collaborations and the FDA-sponsored Verantos-led TRUST and VERIFY studies. He will discuss 'Data reliability: implementing accuracy, completeness, and traceability in practice.' 'The goal isn't just to measure data reliability; it's to optimize it and to do so using peer-reviewed, published methods so metrics can't be gamed,' said Riskin. 'Evidence generated using low-quality or untested RWD remains suspect as it always has been.' Symposium snapshot ISPE 41st Annual Meeting, Washington, D.C. Real-world evidence fit for regulatory applications — what does good look like? Tuesday, August 26, 10:30am EDT Verantos will detail practical implementation approaches to quantify and improve accuracy, completeness, and traceability consistent with peer-reviewed methods and learnings from the TRUST and VERIFY studies. Early findings from this work have been published in JAMA Network Open, providing a transparent foundation for reliability measurement and optimization. About Verantos Verantos is the global leader in high-validity real-world evidence for life sciences organizations. By incorporating robust clinical narrative data and artificial intelligence technology, Verantos is the first company to generate high-validity evidence at scale across therapeutic areas with measured accuracy, completeness, and traceability. Credible evidence accelerates clinical development, market access, medical affairs, pharmacovigilance, and regulatory initiatives.
