Meet the Senate parliamentarian, the official tying Republicans in knots over their tax bill
WASHINGTON (AP) — A few Republicans reacted with indignation Thursday after the Senate parliamentarian advised that some of the measures in their tax and immigration bill could not be included in the legislation.
Sen. Tommy Tuberville, R-Ala., tweeted on X that Senate Parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough should be fired, 'ASAP.' Rep. Greg Steube, R-Fla., intimated that she was partisan, asking why an 'unelected swamp bureaucrat, who was appointed by Harry Reid over a decade ago' gets to decide what's in the bill?'
It's hardly the first time the parliamentarian's normally low-key and lawyerly role has drawn a blast of public criticism.
MacDonough also dashed Democratic plans over the years, advising in 2021 that they couldn't include a minimum wage increase in their COVID-19 relief bill. Later that same year, she advised that Democrats needed to drop an effort to let millions of immigrants remain temporarily in the U.S. as part of their big climate bill.
But the attention falling on MacDonough's rulings in recent years also reflects a broader change in Congress, with lawmakers increasingly trying to wedge their top policy priorities into bills that can't be filibustered in the Senate. The process comes with special rules designed to deter provisions unrelated to spending or taxes — and that's where the parliamentarian comes in, offering analysis of what does and doesn't qualify.
Her latest round of decisions Thursday was a blow to the GOP's efforts to wring hundreds of billions of dollars from Medicaid over the next decade. Senate Republicans could opt to try to override her recommendations, but they are unlikely to do so.
Here's a closer look at what the Senate parliamentarian does and why lawmakers are so focused on her recommendations right now.
The crucial role of the parliamentarian
Both the House and Senate have a parliamentarian to provide assistance on that chamber's rules and precedents. They are often seen advising whoever is presiding over the chamber on the proper procedures to be followed and the appropriate responses to a parliamentary inquiry.
They are also charged with providing information to lawmakers and their respective staff on a strictly nonpartisan and confidential basis.
The parliamentarians and their staff only offer advice. Their recommendations are not binding. In the case of the massive tax and spending bill now before both chambers, the parliamentarian plays a critical role in advising whether the reconciliation bill's provisions remain focused on fiscal issues.
How MacDonough became the first woman in the job
MacDonough, an English literature major, is the Senate's first woman to be parliamentarian and just the sixth person to hold the position since its creation in 1935.
She began her Senate career in its library before leaving to get a law degree at Vermont Law School. She worked briefly as a Justice Department trial attorney before returning to the Senate in 1999, this time as an assistant in the parliamentarian's office. She was initially appointed parliamentarian in 2012 by Democrat Harry Reid of Nevada, Senate majority leader at the time. She was retained by Sen. Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., when he became majority leader in 2015.
She helped Chief Justice John Roberts preside over Trump's 2020 Senate impeachment trial and was beside then-Sen. Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., for Trump's second trial the following year. Trump was acquitted both times.
When Trump supporters fought past police and into the Capitol in hopes of disrupting Congress' certification of Joe Biden's Electoral College victory, MacDonough and other staffers rescued those ballots and hustled mahogany boxes containing them to safety. MacDonough's office, on the Capitol's first floor, was ransacked and declared a crime scene.
Can the Senate ignore the parliamentarian's advice?
Yes. The parliamentarian makes the recommendation, but it's the presiding officer overseeing Senate proceedings who rules on provisions in the bill. If there is a dispute, it would be put to a vote.
Michael Thorning, director of structural democracy at the Bipartisan Policy Center, a think tank, said he doubts Republicans will want to go that route. And indeed, some Republican senators said as much Thursday.
'It's the institutional integrity, even if I'm convinced 100% she's wrong,' said Sen. Kevin Cramer, R-N.D.
Thorning said lawmakers from both parties view MacDonough as 'very much an honest broker.'
'And the Senate relies on her,' Thorning said. 'Sometimes, those decisions cut your way, and sometimes, they don't. I also think members recognize that once you start treating the parliamentarian's advice as just something that could be easily dismissed, then the rules start to matter less.'
Have parliamentarians been fired?
Majority leaders from both parties have replaced the parliamentarian. For more than three decades, the position alternated between Robert Dove and Alan Frumin depending upon which party was in the majority.
Thorning said the two parliamentarians weren't far apart though, in how they interpreted the Senate's rules and precedents.
MacDonough succeeded Frumin as parliamentarian. He said the small number of calls Thursday for her dismissal 'tells you all people need to know about the current parliamentarian.'
'Senators know this isn't somebody playing politics,' Thorning said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Calgary Herald
36 minutes ago
- Calgary Herald
Competition Bureau warns Canadian landlords and property managers about illegal discussions on rents
The Competition Bureau issued a warning to Canadian property managers and landlords on Wednesday about engaging in illegal agreements with competitors. Article content The Bureau said it is aware that some landlords and property managers may be engaging with competitors, and while some of these discussions may be justified, others could be illegal. Article content Article content 'Agreements between landlords to 'make the most of the booming rental housing market' or 'find ways to ensure that all players benefit from the strong demand equally' raise concerns under the law and could be illegal,' the Bureau said in a press release. Article content The Bureau warned that engaging in illegal agreements with competitors, 'such as price-fixing, market allocation, restricting supply, or wage-fixing and no-poaching agreements,' is a criminal offence under the Competition Act, with potential prison sentences of up to 14 years and hefty fines. Article content It also noted that some landlords and property managers may be engaging with competitors through discussion groups on social media. Article content Geneviève Chassé, a Bureau spokesperson, told Financial Post in an email that the Bureau would not speculate on the prevalence of the social media groups but added that it wanted to send 'a clear message to the industry' that certain topics cannot be discussed between competitors. Article content Article content Dania Majid, a staff lawyer at the Advocacy Centre for Tenants Ontario (ACTO), said ACTO first became aware of such groups on platforms such as Reddit and Facebook during the COVID-19 pandemic when tenants raised concerns about potential discussions concerning bad faith evictions amid eviction moratoriums. Article content Article content Majid said ACTO had come across chatter among landlords regarding lease terms and how to evict tenants during that time but added that she had not been active on these forums in a couple of years. Article content 'If you're on a forum, and everyone's saying they're pushing out their sitting tenants and this is how they do it … then that illegal activity … seems like standard business practice.'
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Boutique shop makes jump to grocery shelf
Scooping it all by hand is no longer feasible at Fête Ice Cream & Coffee. At least, not to meet the demand of the roughly 30 Winnipeg stores it's inked deals with over the past few months. The company's new second location, its daily caterings, its constant event pop-ups and its main locale — at 300 Assiniboine Ave. — still serve ice cream, in cones and pints, hand-scooped by workers with strong thumbs. BROOK JONES / FREE PRESS Fête Ice Cream & Coffee co-owners Elise Page (left) and Teri-Lynn Friesen are all smiles at their storefront location at 300 Assiniboine Ave. in Winnipeg. 'The one thumb is really strong,' said Élise Page, co-owner of Fête, while sticking out her digit inside the downtown shop, near a freezer stocked with pints to go. Customers trickled in. A sunny day might draw 200 to 300 transactions, Page and co-owner Teri-Lynn Friesen estimated. Lately, Fête seems to be catering daily, Friesen said. Further, 20 event appearances a month is a regular occurrence during farmers market season. But the six-year-old shop hit a new pace in April: it placed its first grocery store-bound 500 millilitre containers in a Tuxedo-area Safeway. And since then, it's added more Safeway and Sobeys chain locations to its roster. Five Red River Co-op stores and a number of Vita Healths have also signed on. 'There's so much opportunity right now,' said Friesen, 36. 'I … constantly feel the tug of war of wanting to chase the growth, and then also keep the business sustainable.' It's hard to know whether a 'Buy Canadian' push has amplified stores' desire for Fête products. But it's there — it's knocking in Brandon and Steinbach, Friesen said. She and Page started with their Assiniboine Avenue shop (holding a 400-square-foot kitchen) in 2019. Staff create ice cream and mix-ins such as jams and crumbles in the back. There's a rotating list of flavours. Strawberry rhubarb crumble, salted caramel crunch and chocolate fudge brownie have risen in popularity. When the COVID-19 pandemic erupted, Fête bought three ice cream carts and hit the road. Ice cream seemingly became a comfort food, Friesen relayed — sales were good. Catering orders boomed as in-person events and return to work mandates appeared. It's continued: coolers filled with pints regularly trek to birthday parties, weddings and staff gatherings. 'Sometimes, I go into the backroom like, 'Just so you know, you're making literally 2,000 people thrilled today,'' Friesen said. But she's had an eye on further growth. She's birthed two children since launching Fête; Page also has a child. 'I think when you have kids, it forces you to be specific about what you want to do with your time,' Friesen stated. Not long after her second child was born, she joined a virtual 'restaurant to retail' program by a Saskatchewan organization. There, Fête was introduced to Sobeys, per Friesen's recollection. The Manitoba company was nowhere near meeting retailers' requirements in 2024. So Friesen and Page joined another accelerator that assisted food brands like theirs. Labelling and product traceability were among the topics covered. Earlier this year, the co-owners went back to Sobeys. Their reach-out came as tariffs between Canada and the United States dominated headlines; shoppers began swearing off American products and searching for local goods. In short order, Fête inked agreements with chain retailers. It's producing its large shipments — perhaps 1,000 pints at a time — at the University of Manitoba's dairy facility. Machinery replaces hand-scooping for such orders. 'It felt like such a reward to land on the shelf,' Friesen said. 'Then you realize, 'Now we're next to the big names — OK. And we're twice the price of the big names — OK.'' The challenge will be drawing people to Fête amid the competition, she added. Fête can't bulk order ingredients like larger brands, and staff create many of the components found in the company's ice cream. It's why Fête's prices are higher, Page explained. Expanding rurally will 'probably happen faster than we think,' Friesen forecast. She's aiming to eventually stock other provinces' shelves. Meanwhile, the company launched its second location — a kiosk on the Esplanade Riel footbridge — in late May. Its current lease ends in October. 'This is a great way to try out (a second location) without jumping in,' Page said. Food & Beverage Manitoba's executive director has watched Fête grow from a café. Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. 'It's exciting,' Michael Mikulak said. 'I hope that they're able to take advantage of this 'Buy Local' movement. 'Retailers … seem to be much more open to at least giving some of these companies a chance. Whether or not they're successful is up to the companies, it's up to consumers.' Fête appeared as one of Winnipeg's top ice cream hubs during Lorne Adrain's Google search. He tried four different flavours Wednesday while visiting from Rhode Island. Having the brand in grocery stores 'seems like a good thing,' he said. Gabrielle PichéReporter Gabrielle Piché reports on business for the Free Press. She interned at the Free Press and worked for its sister outlet, Canstar Community News, before entering the business beat in 2021. Read more about Gabrielle. Every piece of reporting Gabrielle produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Globe and Mail
2 hours ago
- Globe and Mail
Medicaid changes in Trump's budget bill found to violate Senate rules, sending the GOP scrambling
The Senate parliamentarian has advised that a Medicaid provider tax overhaul central to U.S. President Donald Trump's tax cut and spending bill does not adhere to the chamber's procedural rules, delivering a crucial blow as Republicans rush to finish the package this week. Guidance from the parliamentarian is rarely ignored and Republican leaders are now forced to consider difficult options. Republicans were counting on big cuts to Medicaid and other programs to offset trillions of dollars in Trump tax breaks, their top priority. Additionally, the parliamentarian, who is the Senate's chief arbiter of its often complicated rules, advised against various GOP provisions barring certain immigrants from health care programs. Republicans scrambled Thursday to respond, with some calling for challenging, or even firing, the non-partisan parliamentarian, who has been on the job since 2012. GOP leaders dismissed those views and instead worked to revise the various proposals. Republicans in Congress agree to drop retaliatory proposal to raise taxes for Canadian companies 'We have contingency plans,' said Majority Leader John Thune of South Dakota. Friday's expected votes appeared to be slipping, but Thune insisted that 'we're plowing forward.' But Democrats, who are unified against the package as a tax giveaway for the wealthy at the expense of American safety net programs, said the procedural decisions would devastate the GOP package. Senator Ron Wyden, the top Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee, said the Republican proposals would have meant US$250-billion less for the health care program, 'massive Medicaid cuts that hurt kids, seniors, Americans with disabilities and working families.' The outcome is a setback as Senate Republicans race toward a weekend session to pass the bill and send it back to the House for another vote before Trump's Fourth of July deadline. Trump hosted House Speaker Mike Johnson and other GOP lawmakers in the East Room at the White House, joined by truck drivers, firefighters, tipped workers, ranchers and others that the administration says will benefit from the bill. 'We don't want to have grandstanders,' Trump said of the GOP holdouts. Trump said there are 'hundreds of things' in the emerging package of tax breaks, spending cuts and bolstered money to carry out his mass deportation plans. 'It's so good.' At its core, the big bill, which has passed the House and is now being revised in the Senate, includes US$3.8-trillion in tax breaks that had been approved during Trump's first term but will expire in December, imposing a tax hike if Congress fails to act. To help offset lost revenues, Republicans are relying on steep cuts to health care and food stamps, and imposing new fees on immigrants. GOP leaders were already struggling to rally support for Medicaid changes that some senators said went too far and would have left millions without coverage. The non-partisan Congressional Budget Office has said more than 10.9 million more people would not have health care under the House-passed bill; Senate Republicans were proposing deeper cuts. After the parliamentarian advised against the Medicaid provider tax change, Republicans said they would try to revise the provision to make it acceptable, perhaps by extending the start date of any changes. They are rushing to come up with similar adjustments to other proposals that have run into violations, including one to change the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or food stamps. It's all delaying action on the bill, but Republican leaders have little choice. They are counting on the health care restrictions to save billions of dollars and offset the cost of trillions of dollars in tax cuts. Senator Lindsey Graham, the Budget Committee chairman, rejected calls to fire the parliamentarian, and said in a statement he was working with the office to 'find a pathway forward.' States impose the so-called provider tax on hospitals and other entities as a way to help fund Medicaid, largely by boosting the reimbursements they receive from the federal government. Critics say the system is a type of 'laundering,' but almost every state except Alaska uses it to help provide health care coverage. The House-passed bill would freeze the tax, while the Senate would cut the tax that some states are allowed to impose. Several GOP senators have opposed cutting the Medicaid provider tax, saying it would hurt rural hospitals that depend on the money. Hospital organizations have warned that it could lead to hospital closures. Senator Josh Hawley, among those fighting the change, said he had spoken to Trump late Wednesday and the President told him to revert to the earlier proposal from the House. 'I think it just confirms that we weren't ready for a vote yet,' said Senator Thom Tillis, who also had raised concerns about the provider tax cuts. More than 80 million people in the United States use the Medicaid program, alongside the Obama-era Affordable Care Act. Republicans want to scale Medicaid back to what they say is its original mission, providing care mainly to women and children, rather than a much larger group of people. To help defray lost revenues to the hospitals, one plan Republicans had been considering would have created a rural hospital fund with US$15-billion as backup. Some GOP senators said that was too much; others, including Senator Susan Collins of Maine, wanted at least US$100-billion. The parliamentarian has worked around the clock to assess the legislation and ensure it complies with the so-called Byrd Rule, named for the late Senator Robert C. Byrd of West Virginia. It essentially bars policy matters in budget reconciliation bills. If leaders moved ahead without altering the provisions, the measures could be challenged, requiring a 60-vote threshold to overcome objections. That would be a tall order in a Senate divided 53-47 and with Democrats unified against Trump's bill. 'It's pretty frustrating,' said Senator Rick Scott, who wants even steeper reductions. Overnight Wednesday the parliamentarian advised against GOP student loan repayment plans, and Thursday the parliamentarian cited those that would have blocked access to Medicaid and other health care programs from immigrants who are not citizens. Earlier, plans to gut the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau were also found to violate the rules. But Senator Kevin Cramer said there's no desire to challenge the parliamentarian's advice. 'It's the institutional integrity,' he said. 'Even if I'm convinced 100 per cent she's wrong.' At the same time, Republicans lost another potential revenue source Thursday after agreeing to a request from Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent to remove the so-called revenge tax provision, Section 899, that would have allowed the government to impose taxes on companies with foreign owners and investors from certain countries. Bessent said he has reached a separate agreement with such countries.
