Savior Or Failure? What The Critics Are Saying About ‘Superman'
In Deadline, Pete Hammond said Gunn had 'loaded this flick with tons of action, some quite ludicrous, and takes his cues from any number of inspirations, including the past movies, TV shows, and particularly Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely's All Star Superman book that has informed much of his script.'
More from Deadline
Men of Steel: Every Actor Who Has Played Superman – Photo Gallery
'Superman' World Premiere: The Best Of The Red Carpet
It's A Bird, It's A Plane, It's A Box Office Hit: 'Superman' Opening To $123M - Sunday AM Update
Overall, Hammond says Gunn's film 'might be trying to do too much' and is 'basically throwing everything against the wall and hoping some of it sticks.'
'More than enough does in this entertaining new direction, but at times Superman suffers from overload, much like Gunn's Guardians of the Galaxy trilogy, which wore out its welcome with Vol. 3, where Rocket unfortunately got the Babe: Pig in the City treatment,' he wrote.
RELATED:
In a largely negative review, The Guardian says the reboot is 'encumbered by a pointless and cluttered new backstory which has to be explained in many wearisome intertitles flashed up on screen before anything happens at all.'
In a daming conclusion, the paper wrote: 'How many more superhero films in general, and Superman films in particular, do we need to see that all end with the same spectacular faux-apocalypse in the big city with CGI skyscrapers collapsing? They were fun at first … but the thrill is gone.'
Vanity Fair praises some of the film's performances, particularly Nicholas Hoult, who the magazine said 'convincingly renders a petulant bully whose immense wealth and influence have, he presumes, given him power over his insecurities and inadequacies.'
RELATED:
The magazine says the film 'makes many smart and unexpected choices' before its CGI-heavy ending.
NME said the film puts some 'pep back in Clark Kent's pants' and concludes that the overall film is 'solid rather than spectacular.'
'Gunn's Guardians humour flashes here and there (but not enough), with nods to DC universe fictional band The Mighty Crabjoys and some crowd-pleasing cameos,' the magazine said.
Erik Kain in Forbes said the film was 'painfully mediocre' and described Nicholas Hoult's Lex Luthor as 'generic and forgettable as the rest of the film.'
RELATED:
'What a crushing disappointment,' the magazine's review ends.
Kevin Maher of The Times of London gave the film a similarly negative assessment in his review titled: 'This migraine of a movie is superhero soup.'
Although despite the two stars given to the film, Maher also states that there are 'glimmers of intrigue, as well as quirks and curios' in the film.
'Rachel Brosnahan performs miracles with her threadbare Lois Lane, making you wish for more than the paltry scenes she's given with Corenswet (a serviceable turn),' Maher writes. 'There's a handful of callbacks to the Reeve era, including the title font, as well as a belaboured running gag about office gofer Jimmy Olsen (Skyler Gisondo) being irresistible to women.'
RELATED:
G. Allen Johnson at the San Francisco Chronicle was a lot less forgiving in his criticisms, writing: 'Superman is a mess, but it's a colorful one. It's either a terrible superhero movie or an OK parody, take your pick.'
Alison Willmore at New York Magazine praised the film's originality. Willmore wrote: 'Instead of another origin story, it gives us sights we haven't yet seen — like Krypto bounding through the air after one of the many monkeys enlisted to rage-tweet from a Luthor-created pocket dimension. What a good, good boy.'
We reported this morning that Warner Bros has clocked $22.5M from previews of Superman. That figure would make the remake the best previews YTD and a record for James Gunn, as well as higher than the previews for Barbie ($22.3M) and Matt Reeves' The Batman ($21.6M, $134M opening).
Superman is currently on 82% on Rotten Tomatoes.
RELATED:
Best of Deadline
'The Buccaneers' Season 2 Release Schedule: When Do New Episodes Come Out?
'The Buccaneers' Season 2 Soundtrack: From Griff To Sabrina Carpenter
2025 TV Series Renewals: Photo Gallery
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
37 minutes ago
- USA Today
Jamie Lee Curtis slams plastic surgery industry as 'genocide of women'
Jamie Lee Curtis is stirring controversy with her latest comments on plastic surgery. The "Freakier Friday" actress, 66, a longtime critic of cosmetic surgery, doubled down on her distaste in a new interview, likening it to genocide. "I've been very vocal about the genocide of a generation of women by the cosmeceutical industrial complex, who've disfigured themselves," Curtis told The Guardian in an interview published July 26. Genocide, a term of oft-debated definition, refers to the intentional destruction, in whole or in part, of an ethnic, national, racial or religious group, according to the United Nations. Of the various acts that can result in a genocide, including the intent to prevent birth in a group, or mass killing, plastic surgery does not find a natural home. We're in the 'undetectable era' of plastic surgery. It's a beauty revolution. But the "Knives Out" actress doubled down about her use of the word, saying she employed it precisely because of the reaction it might provoke. "I've used that word for a long time, and I use it specifically because it's a strong word," said Curtis, who wore a pair of comically large plastic lips for the interview's photo shoot, as part of a tongue-in-cheek commentary on the lip injection trend that has grown in popularity in recent years. "I believe that we have wiped out a generation or two of natural human (appearance)," she continued. "The concept that you can alter the way you look through chemicals, surgical procedures, fillers – there's a disfigurement of generations of predominantly women who are altering their appearances." Celebrities often deny, keep quiet about their plastic surgery. Why that's problematic. Curtis herself previously disclosed that she regretted opting for an unspecified cosmetic procedure in her mid-20s after a cinematographer criticized her under-eye bags. Her "Freakier Friday" co-star, Lindsay Lohan, has shrugged off incessant rumors of plastic surgery in recent years. The problem Curtis sees, she told the outlet, was the industry dogma that at a certain age, you need to conform to a standard of eternal youth or risk being ousted from the screen. "It is aided and abetted by AI," she said, "because now the filter face is what people want. I'm not filtered right now. The minute I lay a filter on and you see the before and after, it's hard not to go: 'Oh, well that looks better.' "But what's better? Better is fake," she continued. "And there are too many examples – I will not name them – but very recently we have had a big onslaught through media, many of those people." Curtis walks a fine line with her commentary on plastic surgery, a subject matter long at the center of a "feminist or not" debate. While some argue that it is an inherently empowered thing to decide to change your body on your own terms, others malign it as a response to unrealistic beauty standards, created and upheld by men. The "Everything Everywhere All At Once" actress has more ire for the cosmetic industry than the women who opt in, she said. "I'm not proselytizing to them. I would never say a word," she said of others in Hollywood who have chosen to nip and tuck. "I would never say to someone: 'What have you done?' All I know is that it is a neverending cycle. That, I know. Once you start, you can't stop. But it's not my job to give my opinion; it's none of my business."
Newsweek
38 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Fortnite Super Showdown Live Event Announced – When and How to Play
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Entertainment gossip and news from Newsweek's network of contributors Fortnite's latest Live Event has been announced for this weekend as Chapter 6 Season 3 reaches its final week. Live Events are story events in Fortnite that run for a very limited time. During this time, you can log into Fortnite to play an exclusive event that expounds on the plot of the current season, which right now is all about Superheroes. With Superman and Robin at the forefront alongside a host of original superhero characters, this Live Event will see them taking on a strange threat, likely unleashed by the villain of this season, Daigo – another original Fortnite character. As for what you'll get to do in the event remains to be seen, but these frequently have unique game mechanics to offer. Superman hovering over a battlefield littered with superheroes looking up at something shadowing over them from off-screen. Superman hovering over a battlefield littered with superheroes looking up at something shadowing over them from off-screen. Epic Games The event is set to start on August 2, 2025 at 2:30pm ET/11:30am PT/7:30pm BST. To join in with this event, all you need to do is log into Fortnite and join the game shortly before the start time. Entry for the event is set to start at 2pm ET/11am PT/7pm BST, so you'll have plenty of time to get a spot to experience the event first-hand. These events normally make big changes to the Fortnite map, which is why it's interesting that this season still has one week left following the event, as the season is scheduled to end on August 7. Whether this turns out to just be part one of a two-part event or something special will occur remains to be seen, but if you want to find out, you'll have to be there.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Jamie Lee Curtis Slams Plastic Surgery, Calls It ‘Genocide of a Generation of Women'
Jamie Lee Curtis recently shared fierce criticism of the plastic surgery industry. In a candid new interview, the actress didn't hold back, calling the rise of cosmetic procedures a 'genocide of a generation of women.' She's accused of causing widespread harm to women's self-image. Jamie Lee Curtis comments on plastic surgery Jamie Lee Curtis has taken a firm and controversial stance on the growing obsession with plastic surgery. In a new interview and photoshoot with The Guardian, she held a pair of oversized, cartoonish red plastic lips, a prop she called a 'statement against plastic surgery.' Speaking to the outlet, Curtis explained that the wax lips were meant to emphasize the harm caused by cosmetic procedures. She said, 'I've been very vocal about the genocide of a generation of women by the cosmeceutical industrial complex, who've disfigured themselves.' When questioned about her use of the word 'genocide,' Curtis stood by it. 'I believe that we have wiped out a generation or two of natural human [appearance],' she said. The actress added, 'The concept that you can alter the way you look through chemicals, surgical procedures, fillers — there's a disfigurement of generations of predominantly women who are altering their appearances.' The Freaky Friday star also blamed artificial intelligence and digital face filters for escalating the problem. She criticized the influence of facial filters, noting how they push people further toward artificial standards. She said, 'The minute I lay a filter on and you see the before and after, it's hard not to go: 'Oh, well that looks better.'' While she didn't name specific public figures, Curtis added that the pressure is amplified by them. She said, 'And there are too many examples. I will not name them, but very recently, we have had a big onslaught through media, many of those people.' The post Jamie Lee Curtis Slams Plastic Surgery, Calls It 'Genocide of a Generation of Women' appeared first on - Movie Trailers, TV & Streaming News, and More. Solve the daily Crossword
