Misinformation floods Indian and Pakistani social media as officials keep quiet
Mislabelled videos, recycled images and fake public advisories are taking over the information landscape, leaving hundreds of millions of anxious observers in a lurch over what to believe.
Factcheckers, government agencies and digital forensics experts have been working around the clock since the early hours of 7 May to debunk a deluge of viral content being posted in the wake of India's missile strikes on Pakistan.
Key pieces of misinformation include fake photos and videos circulated as footage from the airstrikes and unverified claims and counterclaims from the governments of the nuclear-armed neighbours.
Several news channels and journalists have fallen for fake videos and claims, amplifying unconfirmed information at a time when cross-border attacks and shelling, mock drills, and sirens blasted from loudspeakers are causing mass panic
One of the most widely circulated videos – depicting missiles streaking across the night sky – was aired by multiple Indian news channels that claimed it showed Indian strikes in Bahawalpur. However, factchecker Alt News reported the footage was from an Israeli airstrike on Gaza in October 2023.
A reverse image search traced the clip to a Sputnik Armenia report of 13 October 2023. BBC Verify also confirmed that the video had nothing to do with the South Asian conflict.
Prominent Indian and Pakistani journalists amplified the mislabelled clip on X, with captions suggesting it showed the strike in Bahawalpur.
Alt News, which has debunked dozens of such false claims over the last two days, said this was a 'clear-cut case of recycled footage misrepresented as breaking news'.
Amid claims of Indian drone attacks on Thursday in Pakistan, an old video from the Texas fires began doing the rounds on X, only to be debunked by factcheckers.
Old video from Texas https://t.co/Xb0QtqR3oO pic.twitter.com/iZpohT9L1k
— Mohammed Zubair (@zoo_bear) May 7, 2025
Other false claims used AI imagery or visuals pulled from conflicts in Gaza or Ukraine. One set of images purporting to show the strikes turned out to be from a YouTube simulation.
Unverified claims and counterclaims have also left people confused as each country has sought to shape the narrative in its favour.
False stories from the Pakistani side have included an alleged airstrike on the Srinagar airbase and the destruction of an Indian army brigade headquarters.
India's Press Information Bureau said the supposed video from Srinagar actually showed sectarian clashes in Pakistan's Khyber Pakhtunkhwa from early 2024.
Reporters and local residents also confirmed that there was no sign of an attack at the airbase in the restive Kashmir region.
'There has been a marked spike in misinformation since 3am on May 7,' a Press Information Bureau official told Hindustan Times. 'We are working 24/7 to counter each falsehood.'
A 37-second clip showing smoke, fire and gunfire was widely shared on May 7 as supposed footage of Pakistan's retaliation to the Indian strikes, with claims ranging from downed Indian jets to a blown-up brigade HQ. However, Alt News confirmed the video predated the strikes and had been circulating online since at least April 27.
Another widely shared clip, claiming to show Pakistani jets striking Indian territory, was revealed to be footage from the video game Battlefield 3. Some posts even repurposed images from unrelated Indian air force crashes in 2021 and 2024.
BBC Verify found that even viral online clips, including one from the 2020 Beirut port explosion, were being misrepresented as evidence of Pakistani retaliation.
In the absence of official footage and confirmation, confusion has persisted over downed Indian jets, including a Rafale.
India has denied losing any aircraft, but Pakistan has continued to assert that it successfully responded to the strikes by downing Indian jets.
On Thursday, Pakistan's military claimed to have downed 12 Indian drones targeting major urban centres, including Lahore and Karachi. Indian officials did not comment on this claim.
The Indian government flagged another piece of misinformation – a fake advisory circulating online that appeared to mimic civil defence protocols, urging citizens to stock up on food and medicines. The advisory was not issued by any government agency. The Press Information Bureau labelled it 'FAKE' and urged citizens to trust only official sources for updates about the military operation.
It also cautioned against 'Pakistan-linked accounts' attempting to 'flood the information space with falsehoods so quickly and overwhelmingly that it becomes difficult to separate fact from fiction'.
As of Thursday, the bureau's factcheck unit had issued at least 21 public clarifications. Factcheckers continued to warn that in a highly polarised environment, recycled content and AI fakes were now central to information warfare.
'Algorithmic engagement rewards dramatic content over accurate content,' Bellingcat founder Eliot Higgins told BBC Verify. 'Old footage from unrelated wars is often used to provoke emotional reactions.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
5 minutes ago
- CNBC
Israel's growing frustration over the war in Gaza explodes in nationwide protests
Israeli police blasted crowds with water cannons and made dozens of arrests on Sunday as thousands of protesters demanding a deal to free hostages in Gaza aimed to shut down the country with a one-day strike that blocked roads and closed businesses. Groups representing families of hostages organized the demonstrations as frustration grows in Israel over plans for a new military offensive in some of Gaza's most populated areas, which many fear could further endanger the remaining hostages. Fifty hostages remain, and 20 of them are believed to still be alive. "We don't win a war over the bodies of hostages," protesters chanted in one of the largest and fiercest protests in 22 months of war. Even some former Israeli army and intelligence chiefs now call for a deal to end the fighting. Protesters gathered at dozens of places including outside politicians' homes, military headquarters and on major highways. They blocked lanes and lit bonfires. Some restaurants and theaters closed in solidarity. Police said they arrested 38 people. "The only way to bring (hostages) back is through a deal, all at once, without games," former hostage Arbel Yehoud said at a demonstration in Tel Aviv. Her boyfriend Ariel Cunio is still being held by Hamas. One protester carried a photo of an emaciated Palestinian child from Gaza. Such images were once rare at Israeli demonstrations but now appear more often as outrage grows over conditions there for civilians after more than 250 malnutrition-related deaths. An end to the conflict does not seem near. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is balancing competing pressures, including the potential for mutiny within his coalition. "Those who today call for an end to the war without defeating Hamas are not only hardening Hamas' position and delaying the release of our hostages, they are also ensuring that the horrors of Oct. 7 will be repeated," Netanyahu said, referencing the Hamas-led attack in 2023 that killed some 1,200 people and sparked the war. The last time Israel agreed to a ceasefire that released hostages earlier this year, far-right members of his cabinet threatened to topple Netanyahu's government. Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich on Sunday called the demonstrations "a bad and harmful campaign that plays into Hamas' hands, buries the hostages in the tunnels and attempts to get Israel to surrender to its enemies and jeopardize its security and future." The new offensive would require the call-up of thousands of reservists, another concern for many Israelis. Hospitals and witnesses in Gaza said Israeli forces killed at least 17 aid-seekers on Sunday, including nine awaiting U.N. aid trucks close to the Morag corridor. Hamza Asfour said he was just north of the corridor awaiting a convoy when Israeli snipers fired, first to disperse the crowds, then from tanks hundreds of meters (yards) away. He saw two people with gunshot wounds. "It's either to take this risk or wait and see my family die of starvation," he said. The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which runs the Israeli-backed and U.S.-supported distribution points that have become the main source of aid since they opened in May, said there was no gunfire "at or near" its sites, which are located in military-controlled areas. Israel's military did not immediately respond to questions. Israel's air and ground war has displaced most of Gaza's population and killed more than 61,900 people, according to Gaza's Health Ministry, which does not specify how many were fighters or civilians but says around half were women and children. Two children and five adults died of malnutrition-related causes Sunday, according to the ministry, which is part of the Hamas-run government and staffed by medical professionals. The U.N. and independent experts consider it the most reliable source on casualties. Israel disputes its figures but has not provided its own. The United Nations has warned that levels of starvation and malnutrition in Gaza are at their highest since the war began. Most aid has been blocked from entering Gaza since Israel imposed a total blockade in March after ending a ceasefire. Deliveries have since partially resumed, though aid organizations say the flow is far below what is needed. It is not clear when Israel's military will begin the new offensive in the crowded Gaza City, Muwasi and what Netanyahu has called the "central camps" of Gaza. The military body that coordinates its humanitarian aid to Gaza, COGAT, this weekend noted plans to forcibly evacuate people from combat zones to southern Gaza "for their protection." Designated "safe zones," however, also have been bombed during the war. War-weary Palestinians on Sunday insisted that they won't leave, arguing that there is "no safe place" in Gaza. "There are no humanitarian zones at all," said Raghda Abu Dhaher, who said she has been displaced 10 times during the war and now shelters in a school in western Gaza City. Mohamed Ahmed also insisted that he won't move south. "Here is bombing and there is bombing," he said. Israeli airstrikes hit Yemen's capital Sunday, escalating strikes on the Iran-backed Houthi rebels, who since the war in Gaza began have fired missiles at Israel and targeted ships in the Red Sea. The Houthi-run Al-Masirah Television said the strikes targeted a power plant in the southern district of Sanhan, sparking a fire and knocking it out of service. Israel's military said the strikes were launched in response to missiles and drones aimed at Israel. While some projectiles have breached its missile defenses — notably during its 12-day war with Iran in June — Israel has intercepted the vast majority of missiles launched from Yemen. Its military later Sunday said it had intercepted another.
UPI
an hour ago
- UPI
Israelis strike, protest in call for release of hostages, end of war
Aug. 17 (UPI) -- A nationwide strike on Sunday commenced in Israel as several hundred thousand people protested, demanding the government secure the release of 50 hostages still held by the militant group Hamas in Gaza. The Hostages and Missing Families Forum and October Council, which represents family members of hostages or relatives of those killed, organized the strike and demonstrations. The council wanted nearly one million people to go through Hostages Square in Tel Aviv and others to join in activities at cities throughout the nation. "Today, we stop everything to remember the supreme value of the sanctity of life," Anat Angrest, mother of hostage Matan Angrest, said at Hostage Squae. "Today, we stop everything to join hands -- right, left, center and everything in between." The largest demonstrations were in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv, where they blocked major roads and closed businesses. They passed out yellow ribbons at intersections and protested outside the homes of government ministers. The demonstrations are among the largest ones since the war began on Oct. 7, 2023. They started at 6:29 a.m., the exact time when Hamas launched its attack on Israel. Israeli police said 38 protesters were arrested in Israel for disturbing the peace as of early Sunday afternoon. They deployed a water cannon to disperse the crowd who sat inside a tunnel along a road that leads to the capital in Jerusalem. Families of hostages announced in Tel Aviv an "emergency break" until they are released. "Today, we stop everything to save the lives of 50 hostages and soldiers," Anat Engrest, whose son, Matan, is held hostage in Gaza, during a news conference Sunday with October Council. "Today, we stop everything to remember the supreme value of the sanctity of life." Israeli President Isaac Herzog, during a visit to Hostage Square in Tel Aviv, voiced his support for the families. "We want them back home as soon as possible," Herzog said. "The world should want them back home as soon as possible. Stop being a bunch of hypocrites. Press -- because when you know how to press, you press -- press and tell Hamas, 'No deal, no nothing, until you release them,' " He said the hostages are the "most important issue on world affairs." Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu blasted the demonstrations. "Those who are calling today to end the war without defeating Hamas not only harden Hamas' stance and delay the release of our hostages -- they are also ensuring that the horrors of Oct. 7 will repeat themselves again and again," he said at a cabinet meeting. The strike was a "cynical political maneuver on the backs of the hostages," Itamar Ben Gvir, the far-right Minister of National Security, said. The Hostages and Missing Families Forum said: "You can continue to hide behind spins and political calculations, but you cannot escape responsibility." The group plans to set up an encampment on the Gaza border. "Waypoint 50" will represent the 50 hostages to pressure the government to get their release. "I know firsthand what it's like to be in captivity. I know that military pressure doesn't bring hostages back -- it only kills them," released hostage Arbel Yehoud, whose boyfriend, Ariel Cunio, is still held captive, said. "The only way to bring them back is through a deal, all at once, without games." "We are united in one simple demand directed at the Israeli government: Put an Israeli proposal on the table today for a comprehensive deal -- to end the war in exchange for the return of the last hostage," Vicky Cohen, whose son, Nimrod, is a hostage, said. "No slogans, no sabotage, no demands that we know the other side won't accept. "It's time to end the horrific nightmare the entire country has been living in for 22 months. It wasn't disclosed how long the strike would last. Histadrut, Israel's largest labor organization, didn't join the strike, though they encouraged employers to allow their workers to participate. "If I knew that a strike -- not just for one day but longer -- would end the matter, stop the war and bring back the hostages, I would go for it with full force," Histadrut chair Arnon Bar-David, senior representatives of the business sector, said to the Times of Israel. "Unfortunately, and although my heart is bursting with anger, it has no practical outcome." Technology companies, law firms, academic institutions and others in the public and private sector plan to take the day off or refrain from business transactions. Last week, the strike was announced after they said the hostages' lives are in danger when Israel's security cabinet voted to expand the war and take over Gaza City. An estimated 90% of Gaza's 2.4 million residents have been displaced, the Agency for Palestinian Refugees said in May. There was a cease-fire between Jan. 19 to March 1, during which 25 Israeli living hostages and 1,737 Palestinian prisoners were released. Israeli believe 20 hostages are still alive. In late March, Hamas agreed to release five hostages, including the American-Israeli Edan Alexander, as part of a 50-day cease-fire proposal from Egypt and Qatar. Alexander was released in May, but there was no cease-fire. A 60-day ceasefire was later proposed by the United States. In July, the last round of negotiations ended without any deal when Israel and the United States withdrew their teams in Doha, Qatar. They accused Hamas of not negotiating in good faith.
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Nationwide strike erupts across Israel demanding hostage deal, end to Gaza war
Thousands of protesters took to the streets across Israel on Sunday, launching a nationwide general strike backed by the families of the hostages taken by Hamas — while demanding a ceasefire deal to free the captives and end the war in Gaza. Demonstrators gathered in Jerusalem, Tel Aviv and on major highways around the major Israeli cities, blocking the streets in defiance of the ongoing conflict, which escalated last week after lawmakers approved plans to invade Gaza City. At least 30 protesters were arrested Sunday after flooding the streets, some burning cars and tires on roadways, sparking clashes with police trying to reopen the thoroughfares, The Times of Israel reported. The mass strike and protest was called by the October Council, a group composed of the families of the 251 people who were kidnapped and the more than 1,200 killed during the Oct. 7, 2023, terrorist attack on Israel. Advertisement 7 Thousands took to the streets across Israel to protest the ongoing war in Gaza, with demonstrators demanding a cease-fire deal to free the hostages. AP 7 At least 30 people were arrested in the general strike after blocking major roads leading to Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. AP The group has repeatedly expressed fears that an expansion to the war in Gaza would only put the lives of their loved ones at risk after more than 680 days in captivity. Hamas is believed to still be holding some 50 hostages in Gaza, of whom just about 20 are believed to still be alive. Advertisement The families' desperate pleas were answered by hundreds of local businesses, schools and authorities, all of whom announced that they were either joining the strike directly, or allowing their employees to take time off to protest if they so desired. While Histadrut, Israel's main labor union, said it would not be joining the strike, union chief Arnon Bar-David spoke at Sunday's demonstration in Tel Aviv's Hostage Square with a message of solidarity. 7 Protesters burned tires on the highway connecting Jerusalem and Tel Aviv on Sunday. REUTERS 7 The protest was backed by the October Council, which consists of the families of those killed and kidnapped during the Oct. 7, 2023, terrorist attack. REUTERS Advertisement 'This is not an issue of left and right. This is an issue of bringing people back, bringing back people who were kidnapped, kidnapped from their bed, kidnapped from their shift and from their tank,' Bar-David told demonstrators. Israeli President Isaac Herzog said Sunday's demonstrations made it clear that the overwhelming majority of people in the Jewish state back an end to the war with Hamas to save the remaining hostages. 'There's no Israeli who doesn't want them back home,' Herzog said. 'We can argue about philosophies, but truly, the people of Israel want our brothers and sisters back home.' 7 Israeli police arrest a protester in Jerusalem during Sunday's nationwide strike. REUTERS Advertisement 7 A group of demonstrators wearing all pink released a pink smoke flare as they called for an immediate end to the war. AFP via Getty Images Herzog also urged the international community to put pressure on Hamas to secure a ceasefire deal after the peace talks with the terror group were reignited last week. While Hamas officials have claimed that they're open to step down as the de facto governors of the Gaza Strip, the terror group has rejected all proposals that would see it disarm without first establishing a Palestinian state. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has long-rejected any proposals for a two-state solution, claiming that recognizing one would only reward Hamas following the Oct. 7 assault. 7 The war with Hamas has claimed more than 60,000 lives in Gaza, including 7-year-old who was killed following an Israeli airstrike in Gaza City over the weekend. AP Netanyahu reiterated over the weekend that the war will not end until Hamas is completely eradicated and the Gaza Strip is demilitarized, with the premier backing plans for full occupation of the Palestinian enclave and exodus of its 2 million refugees. When it comes to the hostages, Netanyahu has repeatedly claimed that military pressure is the best way to free the hostages — a sentiment rejected by former captive Arbel Yehoud, whose boyfriend, Ariel Cunio, is still being held by Hamas. Advertisement 'I know firsthand what it's like to be in captivity. I know that military pressure doesn't bring hostages back — it only kills them,' Yehoud told the crowd in Tel Aviv on Sunday. 'The only way to bring them back is through a deal, all at once, without games.'
