Dear Abby: My 2-year-old disrupted her grandmother's funeral service and my family is furious
DEAR ABBY: My husband's stepmother passed recently after a long illness, and her children specifically wanted our family, including our 2-year-old, to be at her service. When we arrived at the church, I tried to sit in the back pew so I could take her out when she was antsy, but they put us in front with the rest of the family.
Predictably, we lasted there for only about 30 minutes before my daughter started being disruptive. I took her out to the vestibule where she had a tantrum, so I then took her down into the basement playroom.
Advertisement
Immediately after the funeral, my in-laws came after me and berated me for 'ruining' the video they had professionally produced of the service. They said that not only can you see us exiting the sanctuary, but you can hear my daughter making noise outside, which messed up the recording for everyone.
There are many parts of this I don't understand, like why there is a recording, but I'm not sure what to do next. I have apologized for not insisting we sit in the back. Other than not attending at all, I think I did what I could to reduce our impact. If it matters, my older kids sat nicely through the whole 90-minute service. Advice? — DISRUPTER IN IDAHO
DEAR DISRUPTER: It is not unusual for there to be sound and video recording at funerals. Some are streamed on the internet for folks who can't be there in person.
Advertisement
The problem with 20/20 hindsight is that it isn't foresight. Yes, you should have spoken up and reminded your in-laws about how short a 2-year-old's attention span is, and yes, they should have taken that into consideration before berating you. Even so, when viewed from a different perspective, the sound of a young child at that sad time, although distracting, may have been a reminder that life renews itself even in the presence of death.
DEAR ABBY: I'm 42 and in the midst of a separation. My husband of 19 years decided he didn't want to be married anymore. We have three children, one of whom is disabled. My husband made us sell the house we lived in, and since then, I have purchased a new one.
This Dear Abby reader is in the middle of a separation with her husband.
silverkblack – stock.adobe.com
Advertisement
I'm having a very hard time moving on. Since our separation, he constantly goes on trips, and I'm feeling extremely abandoned. I don't know how I'm supposed to move on. I'm so tired all the time. Please help. — FROZEN IN COLORADO
DEAR FROZEN: You have my sympathy. Your husband is flying around free as a bird, and you have been left with a huge responsibility. Your tiredness is likely a symptom of depression. Fortunately, there is help for it in the form of talk therapy as well as medication. Please discuss this with your doctor. Once you are feeling more like yourself, discuss this whole scenario with an attorney who specializes in family law and can guide you further. You are still a young woman, and your life is not over.
Dear Abby is written by Abigail Van Buren, also known as Jeanne Phillips, and was founded by her mother, Pauline Phillips. Contact Dear Abby at www.DearAbby.com or P.O. Box 69440, Los Angeles, CA 90069.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
5 hours ago
- New York Post
Dear Abby: The love of my life died in my apartment — I'm scared to be alone now
DEAR ABBY: I lost the love of my life recently. He died here in our apartment. I am heartbroken. I'm crying a lot but trying to keep myself together. I get scared being here in our apartment by myself, especially at night. I do arts and crafts and other things during the day. I have been thinking about moving back to where we used to live because there's not a lot of public transportation here. My grandkids are close by, but most times I'm alone. I am miserable. What should I do? — ONLY ME NOW IN PENNSYLVANIA DEAR ONLY: Please accept my sympathy for the loss of your partner. You stated that his death was recent and traumatic. Because of that, I caution you to wait for about a year before making any life-changing decisions. Consult your children and grandchildren before deciding to pack up and move. If you feel you would have more social interaction if you return to where you used to live, that may be a valid reason. For now, join a grief support group (online, if transportation is a problem), and continue learning how to adjust to life as a single person. DEAR ABBY: I am a mother of six and a grandma to four. We are a close family and enjoy each other's company. My mom is nearly 80. For reasons I could never understand, she didn't enjoy my children when they were growing up and didn't connect deeply with them. She once commented to me that she was bored with women her age because they were 'obsessed' with their grandchildren and she wanted deeper conversations. Mom moved away and would mostly visit just for holidays and birthdays. When the children tried to share things that were going on in their lives, she wasn't interested, and we eventually stopped inviting her to sports events and recitals because she seemed annoyed to be there. Now that her grands have almost reached adulthood, my mother wants to connect with them. She texts them often and sometimes invites them to visit. They respond politely, and a couple have gone to visit her, but none seem interested in a deeper relationship. This bothers her, and she has been asking me to pressure them to visit her and include her in their lives more. But to them, she is a distant relative. They don't feel close to her. What is my responsibility now? I wish they had a closer relationship with my mom, but I feel awkward telling busy young adults they must plan trips to visit someone who didn't try to establish relationships with them when they were young. Any advice? — TORN DAUGHTER IN WASHINGTON DEAR DAUGHTER: Your only responsibility is to remind your mother of the truth. When it was time to establish a relationship with her grandchildren, she chose to be absent. Then explain that pressuring them to include her in their lives after she excluded them from hers won't have the desired effect because that ship sailed a long time ago. Dear Abby is written by Abigail Van Buren, also known as Jeanne Phillips, and was founded by her mother, Pauline Phillips. Contact Dear Abby at or P.O. Box 69440, Los Angeles, CA 90069.
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
Dear Abby: I took care of my late wife, but now my in-laws don't want me dating
DEAR ABBY: I lost my wife of 20 years four months ago after a prolonged illness. I retired at 62 and became her primary caretaker. The job of caretaker is endless and stressful, and yet rewarding. A female friend of many years ('Dinah') came to the memorial. I grieved, attended Grief Share and read articles about grief. I experience grief every day and will for my whole life. Recently, Dinah and I began spending time together, including worship. For clarification, we have never been intimate and won't be until our wedding night (if that ever happens). The difficulty is how my late wife's family have reacted. They are becoming more and more distant. I don't feel I'm doing anything wrong. Others have said, 'You should wait for at least a year.' My financial planner and I spoke about not making any major financial decisions for a while, but what is this 'one year' thing? — READY IN TENNESSEE DEAR READY: The 'one year thing' is the same as the suggestion your financial planner offered. The reasoning is that after one loses a spouse, the widower is often emotionally vulnerable. Out of loneliness, some have made hasty decisions in their romantic lives that they later regret. While it isn't wrong that you are dating, your former in-laws may be upset that you started so soon after your wife's death and regard it as 'disrespectful' to her memory. What they may not have taken into account is that your grieving started while you were taking care of your wife rather than after her death. DEAR ABBY: My brother has been married for 25 years to 'Gayle,' who has alienated herself and their family from everyone, including her own siblings, our siblings and the rest of our family as well. She limits when, where and with whom he can spend time. Gayle nearly always has a nasty comment or barb and picks someone to fight with at every family gathering. Rather than deal with this, my family and our siblings' families have distanced ourselves, which is especially sad because my brother and Gayle have college-aged children with whom we enjoy spending time. Abby, something happened recently that makes me wonder if it's time for someone to intervene. My brother has an increasing number of false memories about things that never happened in his life — particularly ones in which he has supposedly been grievously wronged by me. Please share some advice. — MISSING MY BROTHER IN NEW ENGLAND DEAR MISSING: The topic of false memories is not one about which I am knowledgeable enough to comment. I do, however, know they happen sometimes as people age. Your brother may be experiencing symptoms of dementia and should be examined physically and neurologically by his doctor. Discuss this with the rest of your siblings in the hope that if ALL of you suggest this to your brother's wife and adult children, it may get through to her. But don't count on it if she has worked during their entire marriage to isolate him from all of you. Dear Abby is written by Abigail Van Buren, also known as Jeanne Phillips, and was founded by her mother, Pauline Phillips. Contact Dear Abby at or P.O. Box 69440, Los Angeles, CA 90069.
New York Post
5 days ago
- New York Post
Dear Abby: I took care of my late wife, but now my in-laws don't want me dating
DEAR ABBY: I lost my wife of 20 years four months ago after a prolonged illness. I retired at 62 and became her primary caretaker. The job of caretaker is endless and stressful, and yet rewarding. A female friend of many years ('Dinah') came to the memorial. I grieved, attended Grief Share and read articles about grief. I experience grief every day and will for my whole life. Recently, Dinah and I began spending time together, including worship. For clarification, we have never been intimate and won't be until our wedding night (if that ever happens). The difficulty is how my late wife's family have reacted. They are becoming more and more distant. I don't feel I'm doing anything wrong. Others have said, 'You should wait for at least a year.' My financial planner and I spoke about not making any major financial decisions for a while, but what is this 'one year' thing? — READY IN TENNESSEE DEAR READY: The 'one year thing' is the same as the suggestion your financial planner offered. The reasoning is that after one loses a spouse, the widower is often emotionally vulnerable. Out of loneliness, some have made hasty decisions in their romantic lives that they later regret. While it isn't wrong that you are dating, your former in-laws may be upset that you started so soon after your wife's death and regard it as 'disrespectful' to her memory. What they may not have taken into account is that your grieving started while you were taking care of your wife rather than after her death. DEAR ABBY: My brother has been married for 25 years to 'Gayle,' who has alienated herself and their family from everyone, including her own siblings, our siblings and the rest of our family as well. She limits when, where and with whom he can spend time. Gayle nearly always has a nasty comment or barb and picks someone to fight with at every family gathering. Rather than deal with this, my family and our siblings' families have distanced ourselves, which is especially sad because my brother and Gayle have college-aged children with whom we enjoy spending time. Abby, something happened recently that makes me wonder if it's time for someone to intervene. My brother has an increasing number of false memories about things that never happened in his life — particularly ones in which he has supposedly been grievously wronged by me. Please share some advice. — MISSING MY BROTHER IN NEW ENGLAND DEAR MISSING: The topic of false memories is not one about which I am knowledgeable enough to comment. I do, however, know they happen sometimes as people age. Your brother may be experiencing symptoms of dementia and should be examined physically and neurologically by his doctor. Discuss this with the rest of your siblings in the hope that if ALL of you suggest this to your brother's wife and adult children, it may get through to her. But don't count on it if she has worked during their entire marriage to isolate him from all of you. Dear Abby is written by Abigail Van Buren, also known as Jeanne Phillips, and was founded by her mother, Pauline Phillips. Contact Dear Abby at or P.O. Box 69440, Los Angeles, CA 90069.
