Urooj Ashfaq: How to Be a Baddie review – the edgiest One Direction fanfic on the fringe
In part, she explains, the confusion was a cultural one: back home in India, there's nothing conservative (to use one of her critics' mots injustes) about Ashfaq. She's a standup, for a start, in a country where that attracts not, ahem, intelligent reviews like this one, but vigilante attention and online insults. Ashfaq has a choice quip in response to one such, and another explaining why she's off-putting to both Hindu and Muslim men.
The promised combative material on religion does not then materialise; she reads the audience's horoscopes instead. (One off-colour response prompts a deft running joke about how Ashfaq's crowd-work is malfunctioning tonight.) More on-message with the bad-girl theme is the standout section on erotica. What starts as autobiographical standup about the books that fuelled Ashfaq's sexual awakening leads to a recital of some One Direction fan fiction, Indian-style, in which our simpering heroine has been sold into slavery to the X Factor stars.
Memories stir of Sofie Hagen's whole show about her teenage Westlife fanfic. But the Mumbai native brings a style all of her own to this literary epic, which includes Zayn Malik with an Arabic accent and jokes about Indian tweens' murderous feelings towards their would-be mothers-in-law.
The later sections don't re-ascend to these comic heights. A section on defending her sister's honour at school might feel edgier to those who better comprehend its repeated Hindi term, randi – akin to whore or slut. A closer on Ashfaq's recent surgery for haemorrhoids wrings less juice than you'd expect out of one of those perfect-for-comedy bodily indignities. You may not leave convinced of Ashfaq's delinquency, but she certainly proves that 2023's success was no flash in the pan.
At Monkey Barrel, Edinburgh, until 24 August
All our Edinburgh festival reviews
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Lorna Rose Treen: 24 Hour Diner People review – ‘best joke of the fringe' winner serves up silliness
When Lorna Rose Treen won the best joke of the fringe award two years ago with a cheetah/cheater pun, it 'killed comedy' according to the Sun newspaper. (They may see the recent cancellation of that prize as proving their point.) The character comic quotes that unlikely coverage at the start of her new set, a (marginally) more theatrical offering with which she promises to kill off theatre as well. In a show full of one-liners to rival her 2023 prizewinner, the choicest joke may be the idea that this mild-mannered, delightfully silly act poses any kind of mortal threat whatsoever. Just as her acclaimed debut Skin Pigeon showcased an array of unapologetically weird female characters, so too does 24 Hour Diner People – with the twist that, this time, they're all to be found in the same, titular location. The first is a waitress given to eating her tips. Just as Skin Pigeon featured a cowboy with guns for hands, we now meet a trucker with impossibly long arms. One recurring sketch airs the libidinous if immature fantasies of a teenage girl as prom approaches. Another, co-starring a press-ganged audience member, introduces us to a wannabe Bonnie and Clyde plotting a heist of the diner's takings. Whereas Treen herself was a largely invisible presence in Skin Pigeon, she peeks out from behind the disguises here to comment on the cartoon chaos unfolding. That adds to the generous spirit of an event whose host takes care to involve us in these outpourings of her dotty imagination. No point pretending its several strands all reach satisfactory conclusions, and there are points when endearingly messy and DIY shades into slapdash. A couple of musical numbers, too, don't play to Treen's strengths. But it's easy to submit to the show's warm embrace of stupidity, to the fine physical comedy of that spindly limbed trucker, and to a host of throwaway one-liners ('last week I did camp America – better known as San Francisco') whose quality all but the Sun newspaper must admire. Far from killing comedy, Treen proves here that it – and hers in particular – is very much alive. At Pleasance Courtyard, Edinburgh, until 24 August All our Edinburgh festival reviews
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Comedian Jimmy Carr likens Prince Harry to Kanye West, saying 'he occasionally dressed as a Nazi and he f***** up'
British stand-up comic has compared Prince Harry to Kanye West, saying both had 'dressed up' as Nazis and 'f***ed up'. The comedian and TV presenter aimed the jibe at the Duke of Sussex in his solo set, in a new clip widely shared online. Carr, 52, who is no stranger to controversy, was referring to the time Harry - then aged 20, now 40 - wore a Nazi costume to a fancy dress party in 2005. Meanwhile, multiple Grammy-winning rapper West, 48, has shared messages online suggesting pro-Nazis views - though recently insisted he ' renounced' anti-Semitism. West, previously married to reality TV star Kim Kardashian, released a track earlier this year called Heil Hitler (Hooligan Version). The newly shared gag by Carr has been shared on the star's official Instagram account, with 2.5million followers - captioned 'Prince William Vs Prince Harry'. He is seen responding to an audience member asking which of the royal brothers he preferred. Carr responds by saying: 'The royal family - well, if you can imagine, they're like our Kardashians. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Jimmy Carr (@jimmycarr) 'Prince Harry is very much our Kanye. He occasionally dresses as a Nazi - and he f***ed up.' Responses have been mixed, with comments including 'Quite a smart answer, 'Harry just can't catch a break, can he', 'You lost me. Harry is a treasure'. Carr has faced controversies himself in the past, including involvement in tax avoidance schemes as well as telling jokes criticised as being in poor taste. Earlier this week his latest earnings were revealed after a string of TV deals and a tour that saw him rake in almost £5million last year. The comedian hosts shows Battle In The Box and Last One Laughing, and is set to take his stand-up comedy show to Australia. Thanks to his successes, accounts filed at Companies House have shown that his firm, R & I Futures Ltd made £4.8million in the year to September 2024. Carr set up the firm two years ago and is earning nearly £100,000 per week. The comic lives in Primrose Hill in north London with Canadian partner Karoline Copping, a former commissioning editor for Channel 5, and the couple have a six-year-old son. The Mail told last month of latest developments in a long-running feud between Carr and his estranged 80-year-old father Jim. The TV personality reached out to his father for a favour, only for him to continue the silent treatment once it was granted, a friend of Jim's revealed. The senior Carr was left feeling 'confused and distraught', the friend said, and was left bewildered as to why his son carried on his grudge and not seek a reunion. The pair fell out shortly after Jimmy's mum Nora died in 2001 from pancreatitis at the age of 57. Up until that point, the 8 Out Of 10 Cats host had a close bond with his parents with his accountant father helping to pay for his rent and food during the early days of his career as well as giving him lifts around the country to gigs. But Jimmy cooled towards Jim and cut him out of his life without ever seemingly giving him a proper explanation why. The bad-blood simmered until rising to the surface again in 2021 when Jimmy, 52, told fellow comics Rob Beckett and Josh Widdicombe on their Parenting Hell podcast: 'I haven't seen my father in 21-years. 'You know the line, "My mother's dead and my father's dead to me" – which sounds very cold until you meet the guy. I can't have that guy in my life.' The pair fell out shortly after Jimmy's mum Nora died in 2001 from pancreatitis at the age of 57 Yet a close friend of Irish-born businessman Jim told how Jimmy rang out of the blue nearly eight years ago and asked his father to 'take on a burden' for him. The source revealed: 'It was just before Christmas in 2017 and Jimmy rang his dad to ask him for some help with a problem he had. He had been supporting someone close to him but just couldn't continue doing so. 'Jim has never told me the full details preferring to keep it private but it was a big favour to ask and obviously Jimmy felt he had nowhere else to turn, given that he hadn't spoken to his dad for that last 15 or 16-years prior to that phone call. 'He wanted Jim to take on the burden – which he duly did. But while Jim hoped this good deed could rekindle their relationship, Jimmy seemed to cut him off again. 'He didn't call to thank him or anything, it was radio silence which continues to this day. It's strange because it was him who instigated that temporary thaw in relations.' Jim, who lives in Gerrards Cross in Buckinghamshire, declined to comment when approached by the Mail, saying simply: 'I don't wish to fan the flames so I'll pass'. Representatives of Jimmy Carr were approached for comment. Carr has spoken and written in the past about being 'publicly shamed' when his tax arrangements were revealed in 2012. He had been among of thousands of people using a legal off-shore scheme to pay as little as one per cent income tax. Carr was said to have been the largest beneficiary of the K2 accountancy arrangement that reportedly sheltered £168million a year from the taxman. He said in a statement at the time: 'I've been advised the K2 tax scheme is entirely legal, and has been fully disclosed to HMRC. 'I'm no longer involved in it and will in future conduct my financial affairs much more responsibly. Apologies to everyone.' Prince Harry has previously blamed Prince William and Kate for his notorious appearance at the costume party wearing his Nazi uniform in 2005. The Duke of Sussex said in his memoir Spare the other couple thought it was funny. Harry told of considering either the Nazi uniform or a pilot's outfit to wear at a 'Native and Colonial' themed event and called his brother and sister-in-law for their opinion. He wrote: 'I phoned Willy and Kate, asked what they thought. Nazi uniform, they said. 'They both howled. Worse than Willy's leotard outfit! Way more ridiculous! Which, again, was the point.' Harry - seen here with William in 2021 - has said he asked his brother and sister-in-law for advice on whether to wear a Nazi uniform or a pilot uniform to a fancy dress party in 2005 The outfit became a huge scandal when Harry, then 20, was photographed wearing the Nazi regalia. The story made global headlines after an image of Harry in the costume featured on the front page of The Sun newspaper. The Duke of Sussex wore the Nazi uniform at a party thrown by Olympic show jumper Richard Meade. The theme of the event - held to mark the birthday of Mr Meade's son Harry - was 'native and colonial'. Harry wore the desert uniform of General Erwin Rommel's Afrika Korps, having earlier in the evening donned an army-style jacket with a German flag on the arm. Harry had arrived with his brother William, who reportedly dressed in a skin-tight black leotard with a leopard skin pattern and a matching leopard skin tail and paws. One guest told the Daily Mail afterwards: 'If this was his idea of a joke then it went down like a lead balloon.' Harry said sorry shortly after the image was published, saying: 'I am very sorry if I have caused any offence or embarrassment to anyone. It was a poor choice of costume and I apologise.' Addressing the issue in a later Netflix series, Harry said dressing as a Nazi was one of the 'biggest mistakes' of his life andd said all he 'wanted to do was make it right.' He told of meeting with the then-Chief Rabbi, the late Jonathan Sacks who died in 2020, and also spoke to a Holocaust survivor as part of efforts to repair the damage done by the gaffe. More recently, Kanye West provoked a substantial backlash to his new song Heil Hitler (Hooligan Version), which he released in May this year. On the track, the former husband of Kim Kardashian and who is now married to Bianca Censori rapped: 'With all of my money and fame I still don't get to see my children. 'N*****s see my Twitter but they don't see how I be feeling / So I became a Nazi, yeah b****, I'm the villain.' A fortnight later, he insisted on X, formerly Twitter, to his 69.4million followers: 'I am done with antisemitism. 'God forgive me for the pain I've caused. I forgive those who have caused me pain. Thank you God.' The 24-time Grammy winner explained the reason behind his rejection of his Nazi persona was because he 'simply got a FaceTime from my kids and I wanna save the world again'. He had previously tweeted in 2022 that he was going 'death con 3 on Jewish people' - which got him promptly dropped by his agency CAA, production company MRC, Adidas, Gap and Balenciaga. The Yeezy designer - who has worn swastika and 'White Lives Matter' T-shirts - has repeatedly spoken about his disdain for Jewish people and his adoration of Nazi Germany dictator Adolf Hitler. But in 2023, Ye claimed watching Jonah Hill in his 2012 action comedy 21 Jump Street made him 'like Jewish people again' in a bizarre Instagram post. 'No one should take anger against one or two individuals and transform that into hatred towards millions of innocent people,' the hip-hop star wrote at the time.
The Guardian
5 hours ago
- The Guardian
My cultural awakening: a Steve Carell film made me realise I was being abused
In the first five minutes of the 2013 comedy drama The Way Way Back, a teenage boy has a conversation with his stepfather in a car bound for Cape Cod. You can only see the stepdad's eyes in the rearview mirror, but you instantly know it's Steve Carell. At this point, I loved Carell. He's the reason that I, then a teenager, watched the film. 'Duncan … let me ask you something,' Carell's character says. 'On a scale of one to 10, what do you think you are?' Duncan responds shyly that he thinks he's a six. Any normal adult would balk and correct him. Tell him he's nothing less than a 10. 'I think you're a three,' says Carell's character, Trent. Suddenly, I hated Carell with a blind fury. He was a vision of pure evil. I didn't want to watch him in anything else, ever. As it turns out, this was a full-sized, double-strength dose of projection. I'm 27 now, and it's been six years since I rid myself of my real-life Trent. After my dad died when I was six, my mum started dating a new guy within a year. Though intensely smart and caring, she was blinded by grief and clawing around in the dark for a cure. That's when she found her Trent on A charming, self-motivated man, he seemed like the Real Deal. But Trent changed our lives almost immediately. He made us give up the dog we got when my dad died because his adult daughter didn't like dogs. He moved my mum, sister and I into the middle of the countryside, away from all our friends. He made me feel small, unsafe and unwelcome in my home. He stopped my mum from seeing her own friends, spending her own money and leaving the house. Later, we would find out that he locked his first wife in the house when he went to work 'to keep her safe'. I didn't know what I was experiencing was abuse until I watched The Way Way Back. Even then, the film never calls it that. But Carell's character is so clearly the villain, and so uncannily similar to my stepdad, that it was unavoidable. It was as if someone had made an entire film to scream to me: this is a bad guy! Get away from him! Trent utilises what people now know as 'coercive control'. He manipulates and belittles Duncan and his mum, Pam, with methods so familiar that it made me wince. To avoid Trent, Duncan lands a job at a water park, and his ragtag group of colleagues drag Duncan out of his awkward shell. By the end of the film, he stands up to Trent, freeing his mother from his clutches. As a teenager, I was too scared to fight back. But then I found my water park: Animal, a clothing chain based in the south of England, where I was a weekend shop girl from ages 17 to 19. Every awkward hello to customers and failed refund attempt made me a little bolder, more sure of myself. One day, as I was heading out to work, my stepdad pushed me over the edge, and I stood up to him. I told my mum that if she stayed with him, she'd never see me again. For a while, my mum still wanted to make the relationship work. But that was never going to be how it ended. In the final few minutes of The Way Way Back, Pam is in the front passenger seat next to Trent on the way home from Cape Cod. Suddenly, as if by epiphany, Pam clambers to the back to sit with her son. The film ends with them looking out of the rear window together, side by side. Sign up to Inside Saturday The only way to get a look behind the scenes of the Saturday magazine. Sign up to get the inside story from our top writers as well as all the must-read articles and columns, delivered to your inbox every weekend. after newsletter promotion Six months after my standoff with my stepdad, my mum clambered back to me, too. We haven't seen Trent since. And now I can watch Steve Carell movies again. In the UK, call the national domestic abuse helpline on 0808 2000 247, or visit Women's Aid. In the US, the domestic violence hotline is 1-800-799-SAFE (7233). In Australia, the national family violence counselling service is on 1800 737 732. Other international helplines may be found via Did a cultural moment prompt you to make a major life change? Email us at
