Malaysia's economy and environment ministers resign after party election defeat
[KUALA LUMPUR] Malaysia's economy and environment ministers said on Wednesday (May 28) they had submitted their resignations to Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, after both lost their leadership positions in the premier's political party.
Economy Minister Rafizi Ramli said he resigned from cabinet after Anwar's daughter, Nurul Izzah Anwar, defeated him in an internal party election last week for the position of deputy president of the People's Justice Party.
Rafizi, whose resignation takes effect June 17, said his defeat meant that he no longer had a mandate from his party to deliver on its policy agenda.
'As is the practice in countries that emphasise democratic principles, leaders who lose in party elections must make way for the winning leaders to take their place in government,' he said in a statement.
Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability Minister Nik Nazmi Nik Ahmad was the only one of four vice presidents of the People's Justice Party not reelected in the party ballot. He was defeated by a deputy minister.
'I am aware that my position at the time as vice president was one of the main considerations in my appointment to the cabinet,' he said in a statement, adding his resignation would take effect July 4.
A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU
Friday, 8.30 am Asean Business
Business insights centering on South-east Asia's fast-growing economies.
Sign Up
Sign Up
'Considering that I failed to retain that position in the recent party elections, I have decided to resign as minister.'
It was not immediately clear if Anwar's daughter would be given a post in the cabinet. Reuters has contacted Anwar's office seeking comment on both resignations.
Rafizi and Nik Nazmi, who have been ministers since 2022, both said they will be on leave from ministerial duties until their resignations take effect.
Rafizi said his final mandate has been fulfilled with the completion of the 13th Malaysia Plan, which advocates comprehensive education reform and is due to be submitted to parliament in the next session.
'I hope the cabinet will maintain some of the bold reforms ... even though I will no longer be in the cabinet,' he said.
Nik Nazmi said he looked forward to focusing on his responsibilities as a member of parliament for his constituency. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
20 hours ago
- Business Times
Vietnam Tax Rule Targets 5 Million Informal Businesses
[HO CHI MINH CITY] It's a familiar scene in a bustling alley of Ho Chi Minh City's District 1: rows of motorcycles crowd the fronts of mom-and-pop shops, ranging from eateries and grocery stores to barbershops, coffee houses and street food stalls. But behind the lively hum, anxiety is brewing among them – part of a sprawling 5.2 million household businesses nationwide – over a new tax rule that could significantly reshape the way they operate. Nguyen Thanh Cuong, manager of a small French restaurant in the area, said he is working with a software provider to install a new cash register system that links to tax authorities and issues electronic invoices with authorised codes. He is among some 37,000 establishments across the country scrambling to comply with a new regulation that took effect on Jun 1, requiring household businesses earning more than one billion dong (S$49,283) a year to report their sales using e-invoices. Collectively, these non-farm household businesses, which outnumber registered businesses by five to one and employ about nine million people nationwide, generate up to 30 per cent of Vietnam's gross domestic product. However, according to the tax authority, these establishments contribute less than 2 per cent to total tax revenue – a figure mainly attributed to the previous presumptive tax regime, where shops paid fixed monthly taxes based on local officials' revenue estimates, often far below their actual sales. A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU Friday, 8.30 am Asean Business Business insights centering on South-east Asia's fast-growing economies. Sign Up Sign Up The new rule aims to close that gap as part of the government's broader push to formalise the informal economy, requiring all household businesses to eventually adopt proper bookkeeping practices for tax compliance, particularly through the use of e-invoices. 'With the system now linked to the tax authorities, few dare to underreport revenue. But some might use two separate systems to reduce their declared sales and pay less tax,' Cuong said. His eatery has been operating as a household business for more than a decade. Despite the new rule, many household businesses have continued to exploit loopholes and resist adopting proper practices, from underpaying taxes and avoiding accurate bookkeeping. Some have even refused to accept payments via bank transfers, shut down entirely or continued operating off the books without registration. 'Taxes will probably be higher, leading to increased costs for input purchases, and eventually, we will have to raise our prices,' he added. Formalising the informal sector Another pathway for those family-run businesses to minimise such payments – and be taxed on profits rather than revenue – is by transitioning into formal enterprises, a move strongly encouraged by the country's leadership. 'Forcing household businesses to register, follow accounting rules, connect with tax database and pay tax is a pillar of the formalisation push,' noted Le Truong Giang, analyst at London-headquartered consultancy Control Risks. The initiative, combined with efforts to crack down on counterfeits and smuggled goods, is expected to expand the nation's tax base, reinforce the formal economy by directing spending and investment towards registered businesses, and enhance consumer protection, Giang said. 'The promises are better public services and more public goods,' he added. '(However,) the potential downsides are significant. Impacts include huge disruption to business activity and household purchasing power as well as inflationary pressure.' The brief period of intensified enforcement over this month appears to expose gaps in the ability of bureaucrats and the regulatory and digital infrastructure to realise promised efficiency enhancements. 'There's an overwhelming amount of work. We are working at full speed but still barely keeping up with all customer inquiries,' said Bui Hai Nam, co-founder and chief executive at SoBanHang, which translates to 'sales book' in Vietnamese. The startup, backed by various foreign investors including Antler – a Singapore-based venture capital firm that focuses on early-stage investments – serves more than 650,000 small-scale sellers and household businesses in Vietnam. It offers basic sales management tools for those unable to afford traditional point-of-sale systems and has teamed up with authorised e-invoice providers to support merchants in meeting the new tax compliance requirements. 'I believe the new practices will encourage the most progressive household businesses to convert to formal enterprises, which already adopt similar accounting standards,' Nam said. 'Such a shift is critical for them to grow and be able to serve larger customers.' Quach Thi Thu Hien, deputy chief executive at a Hanoi-based distribution firm for international cosmetics brands, noted that household businesses rarely buy supplies from her company, which provides products with verified origins and value-added tax (VAT) invoices – normally at higher prices than in the informal market. 'But now it is changing. Many have started to adopt VAT-invoiced purchases and even register to become a formal enterprise. They are also actively looking for training and consulting about compliance and management,' she said. 'This move towards greater tax transparency creates a level-playing field between companies like us and those household businesses.' Finding growth engines This new direction is underscored in a landmark policy document signed by Communist Party of Vietnam general-secretary To Lam in May, which aims to develop the country's private sector, with a goal of increasing the number of formal firms from 940,000 to two million by 2030. This is not the first time it has set such a goal. However, the earlier targets of hitting one million firms by 2020 and 1.5 million by 2025 have so far gone unmet. Under the directive locally known as Resolution 68, the Politburo, Vietnam's top policy decision-making body, decided on a series of reforms. Vietnam will abolish business licence taxes and exempt corporate income taxes for small and medium-sized enterprises in the first three years of establishment, limit inspections and audits at firms to a maximum of once a year, alongside other incentives to facilitate their access to resources of land, capital and high-quality human resource training. The presumptive tax regime for household businesses will also be removed entirely by 2026, with the promotion of digitalisation and transparency in accounting, tax reporting and insurance – regardless of their revenue levels. In 2024, 64.6 per cent of the workforce, or about 33.2 million people, was still engaged in informal employment, based on Vietnam's National Statistics Office. They mainly include agricultural and rural workers, employees at household businesses, online merchants, as well as people working at underground enterprises. While foreign-invested firms and domestic private enterprises led the way with high growth rates, small household businesses recorded some of the slowest growth in the non-state sector, with year-on-year increases of more or less 6 per cent before the Covid-19 pandemic. 'Culturally, they are super important to Vietnam, but it's not a growth engine,' said Rich McClellan, principal at RMAC Advisory and vice-chair of the AmCham Environment, Social and Governance Committee. 'There were no incentives for the informal economy to formalise. If you don't want to grow, all you are trying to do is earn enough to get by and stay under the radar,' he added. Vietnam is now in a monumental phase – an 'era of national rise', as described by To Lam – with sweeping reforms underway across multiple sectors aimed at transforming the economy into a high-income status within the next two decades. Much of the attention has gone towards big corporations, which are doubling down on big-ticket projects such as high-speed railways, mega energy plants, international financial centres, as well as new international airports and seaports. The state has also significantly streamlined its bureaucracy, with about 250,000 jobs cut at local levels following the finalisation of the administrative mergers in the second half of this year. The question is how to accelerate the growth of small family-run businesses at the other end of the spectrum and generate jobs and higher incomes for more people, including those purged from the state sector. Starting with tax may be burdensome at first, but it could prove to be one of Vietnam's boldest bets yet to grow its pool of formal enterprises and sustain double-digit economic growth through the rest of the decade. 'If you could get the state-owned enterprises to privatise, get the informal economy to become part of the formal economy, then... you're actually getting close to that double-digit growth that the country wants,' McClellan said.
Straits Times
5 days ago
- Straits Times
Anwar Ibrahim denied immunity as civil sexual assault suit set for June 16.
Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim says the lawsuit may be "politically motivated, or institutionally disruptive.' ST PHOTO: JASON QUAH KUALA LUMPUR - Malaysian Prime Minister Anwar on June 4 failed in his bid for immunity from liability while in office, paving the way for a civil lawsuit involving allegations of sexual assault against him to proceed on June 16. The High Court rejected Datuk Seri Anwar's application to refer eight constitutional questions to the Federal Court. High Court judge Roz Mawar Rozain ruled that the questions did not warrant immediate constitutional referral and that the lawsuit could proceed through the regular civil process. 'From a judicial perspective, the proposed questions do not appear to meet the threshold of genuine constitutional controversy,' she said. There is 'no express constitutional or statutory immunity accorded to a sitting Prime Minister for private acts pre-office', she added. In response to the decision, Mr Anwar said in a statement: 'This matter has never been about seeking personal immunity or escaping legal scrutiny. It concerns the integrity of our constitutional system and the need to ensure that high public office is protected from litigation that may be strategically timed, politically motivated, or institutionally disruptive.' The lawsuit, brought by Mr Anwar's former research assistant Muhammed Yusoff Rawther, concerns an alleged incident that took place in 2018, before Mr Anwar's appointment as prime minister in November 2022. Mr Yusoff, now 31, claimed to have suffered serious physical, psychological and social trauma as a result of the incident. Mr Anwar, 77, has denied the claims, saying the charges had been fabricated to smear his political image. His lawyers argue that such civil suits against a sitting prime minister risk interfering with his constitutional duties and could undermine the executive's ability to function. They cite Articles 5, 8, 39, 40, and 43 of the Federal Constitution, which outline executive powers, to support the need for immunity. They say that the matter should be tested before the Federal Court before any trial proceeds. The Prime Minister had filed the application on May 23, seeking the High Court, which is hearing the suit, to refer the eight legal questions to the Federal Court. The court's ruling means the civil case is now back on track for a full hearing from June 16, 2025, placing renewed scrutiny on Mr Anwar's administration. Mr Anwar's legal team can still appeal the decision with the Court of Appeal within 30 days. Mr Yusoff's lawyer, Mr Muhammad Rafique Rashid Ali, welcomed the June 4 ruling. 'The importance of today's decision ensures that in Malaysia right now, we have a judiciary that has stamped very clearly that there is equality for everyone under the Constitution,' he told The Straits Times. 'When an executive or a person in power wants to shield himself with immunity as proposed by Anwar Ibrahim or anyone in power later on, the normal people are being shielded against that executive use of power by the courts.' The premier has had his own past battles with the legal system, having been convicted for committing sodomy and abuse of power, charges which he has always maintained are politically motivated. Mr Yusoff has been detained by the police since September 2024. He is currently on trial for charges of drug trafficking and possessing imitation firearms, and faces life imprisonment and caning if convicted. He has denied the allegations and claimed he was framed by people in power. Hazlin Hassan is Malaysia correspondent at The Straits Times. Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Business Times
5 days ago
- Business Times
Malaysia court rejects Anwar's bid to pause sex assault suit
[KUALA LUMPUR] Malaysia's High Court rejected Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim's bid to pause a civil suit by his former aide, who accused the leader of committing sexual assault in 2018. High Court Judge Roz Mawar Rozain ruled that the civil suit did not deprive Anwar of his liberty, and found no merit in arguments that he was being selectively targeted because of his office. She added that the federal constitution does not provide immunity for prime ministers. Anwar's lawyer Alan Wong said they would appeal the court's decision. The trial is due to start on June 16. The setback for Anwar comes years after earlier convictions for committing sodomy and abuse of power – charges which he denied. Those accusations, which Anwar said were politically motivated, came in the wake of the Asian financial crisis of 1997-1998, when he was deputy prime minister until his dismissal from cabinet. In the current case, the 77-year-old had sought a stay in proceedings as his lawyers seek a Federal Court ruling on whether a sitting prime minister can be sued. Former aide Yusoff Rawther filed the suit in 2021, accusing Anwar of sexually assaulting him in October 2018 in the latter's residence in Kuala Lumpur. The alleged incident occurred before Anwar became prime minister in 2022. Yusoff is seeking special, general, aggravated and exemplary damages. A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU Friday, 8.30 am Asean Business Business insights centering on South-east Asia's fast-growing economies. Sign Up Sign Up Anwar wanted the Federal Court to determine whether allowing the lawsuit to proceed would impair his ability to effectively discharge his executive duties and undermine the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers, according to Wong. Anwar's bid for immunity ahead of the sexual assault civil suit against him could hurt his credibility as the premier crosses the midpoint of his five-year term. The case would have 'far-reaching effects on the rule of law in the country,' Zaid Ibrahim, who served as law minister in 2008, said in a Facebook post last week. Civil society group Lawyers for Liberty said that any suggestion that Malaysia allows immunity for its prime minister from court actions is 'legal nonsense,' according to a May 30 statement. The group called on the Attorney-General to oppose any attempt to grant the prime minister immunity. 'This is not a concept that exists in any democratic country; it is a blatant violation of the rule of law and a flagrant feature of authoritarianism,' said Lawyers for Liberty director Zaid Malek. In September, Yusoff was arrested. He is on trial for charges of drug trafficking and possessing firearms, and faces life imprisonment and caning if convicted. He has denied any knowledge of the two fake pistols and cannabis that police said were found in his car, claiming that he was framed by people in power. BLOOMBERG
