‘Weak, Show Of Strength For Citizens': Pakistan's FATAH Missile Claims Exposed
Pakistan Army's missile posturing was exposed by sources who said that the FATAH missiles can be intercepted using Samyukta EW systems and S-400.
Pakistan Army, which boasted 'a successful training launch of a FATAH Series surface-to-surface missile" on Monday, is misleading its citizens by claiming that it is one of the strongest missiles their military industrial complex has made.
Government sources speaking to CNN-News18 said that the FATAH missile is a 'weak missile". 'Pakistan launches another weak missile and misleads the world and misleads its own people," the sources said.
They also said that the Pakistan Army is trying to project strength in front of its citizens.
'(Pakistan Army Chief Asim) Munir seeks to project military strength to reassure the public as Pakistan grapples with economic turmoil and political uncertainty," they said.
'But focusing too much on conventional deterrence could take resources away from dealing with internal security issues, especially as groups like the TTP regain strength in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa," they further added.
The sources said that the testing of the missile during Exercise Indus only serves few strategic objectives. They said that the test was done to check the missile's advanced navigation system and precision, while ensuring its troops are prepared.
They also said that its range is 120 kilometres, which restricts its utility to short-range engagements and that its navigational system could be susceptible to jamming or spoofing. They also said that India's S-400 air defense systems, purchased from Russia and deployed along the border, could intercept such missiles and reduce their impact on the battlefield.
'The missile's GPS and INS guidance system may be open to electronic warfare tactics, such as jamming or spoofing by India's Samyukta EW systems," the sources said, adding that because it lacks MaRV technology it is also not manoeuvrable and hence easier to track and intercept.
They also said that supply chain issues could completely 'damage" production, if sanctions are imposed on China.
'Pakistan's missile program depends on Chinese components like rocket engines, guidance systems. Sanctions or supply-chain disruptions could completely damage production," they said.
They also said that the missiles could end up hurting Pakistan economically, domestically and on the global stage.
'Repeated missile tests may draw criticism from FATF or the US, complicating Pakistan's efforts to exit global watchlists or secure IMF bailouts. Developing and maintaining such systems strains Pakistan's economy where inflation is 38% and debt-to-GDP ratio is 85%," the sources said.
First Published:
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
7 minutes ago
- India.com
Another war! Iran testing Russia's S-400 air defense system? What's behind Khamenei-Putin secret deal
Iran and Israel have been in conflict for many years. Israel is getting sleepless nights once again as Iran has successfully tested the Russian S-400 air defense system. According to the media reports, Iran tested S-400 system for the first time on July 26, near Isfahan, which was where the Israeli Air Force in June destroyed Iran's S-300 air defense system, during the war. In that war, Israel had either destroyed or severely damaged nearly all of Iran's air defense systems, so Iranian skies were undefended thereafter. Open-source intelligence, using satellite images, has reportedly confirmed that Iran tested the S-400 Triumph system in Isfahan. A report from the Defense Security Asia website stated the Iranian S-400 air defense system consisted of the 91N6E acquisition radar, 92N6E engagement radar, a central command-and-control vehicle, and several 5P85TE2 transporter erector launchers. The sources indicated during the test, a 48N6E3 missile (250 km range) was launched, and it is quite probable that the long-range 40N6 missile (380-400 km strike capability) was also activated. In June during the war, Israel destroyed Iran's air defense systems and radars first. Then it conducted persistent airstrikes with flying capabilities using fighter jets on dozens of targets of Iran. Israel purported it was in control of its airspace. There are still significant tensions between Israel and Iran and numerous reports indicating there is potential for another conflict with the deployment of Iran's S-400 Air Defense System, allowing Iran to dethrone Israeli overarching air capabilities in Iranian skies.
NDTV
7 minutes ago
- NDTV
"India Like Mercedes": Pak Minister Doubles Down On Asim Munir's "Crude Analogy"
Islamabad: The Shehbaz Sharif government in Pakistan seems to be backing Army Chief Asim Munir's embarrassing admission of Islamabad's current standing vis-à-vis New Delhi. Pakistan's de facto military ruler, during his recent visit to the United States, compared India to a "shining Mercedes" and his own country to a "dump truck". Lauding Munir's leadership during the India-Pakistan military conflict, Pakistan's interior minister, Mohsin Naqvi, said that the Field Marshal used the same analogy to boast about Pakistan's prowess to a Saudi delegation that visited Pakistan in May amid war. "The Field Marshal told them, 'India is like a shining Mercedes, but we are like a dumper truck loaded with stones. Imagine the result if they collide.' The delegation remained silent," he said during a seminar in Lahore. Pakistan confirms Munir's "we are a dumper truck, India a Mercedes" statement "India is a shining Mercedes. We are a dumper truck full of gravel. If we collide, you know the impact on Mercedes. Our field Marshal Munir says", says Pakistan's interior minister Mohsin Naqvi — Sidhant Sibal (@sidhant) August 17, 2025 Contrary to publicly available proof, Naqvi claimed none of the Indian missiles landed on targets at any major military base in Pakistan. India had struck multiple Pakistani air bases during 'Operation Sindoor', damaging runways, hangars, and buildings, causing a massive blow to Pakistan. The evidence of it was visible in high-resolution satellite images released by Maxar Technologies Air Marshal AK Bharti, Director General of Air Operations, during a press briefing, said India hit selected military targets deep inside Pakistan and its response was "measured and calibrated." Munir's Crude Analogy Munir, speaking at a private dinner in Florida last week, used the unusual "crude analogy"-- as he himself called it-- to describe the two neighbours. "I am going to use a crude analogy to explain the situation... India is a shining Mercedes coming on a highway like a Ferrari, but we are a dump truck full of gravel. If the truck hits the car, who will be the loser?" Munir, who was on his second visit to the US in two months, reportedly said. His "analogy" about New Delhi drew peals of laughter on social media for its description of Pakistan, with internet users observing that even in his comparison, Munir made his own country look bad. "The only truth in Munir's statement is that India is the Mercedes, and his country is the dump truck. The rest is delusion," wrote a X user. Another user posted a picture of a missile-laden Mercedes and wrote, "India is a missile-packed beast that is straight-up deadly. It's gonna wreck you." "At least they know their are a dump truck and nothing marshal admitted that they are pathetic," posted a third user.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
37 minutes ago
- First Post
Why Trump hiked India tariffs but extended truce with China for Russian oil: Rubio cites Beijing's supply chain role
Rubio has defended Washington's decision to impose additional tariffs on India for continuing to import Russian oil, while sparing China from similar measures, warning that sanctioning Beijing could push up global energy prices. US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has acknowledged that targeting China with s econdary sanctions for refining Russian oil could drive up global energy prices, defending Washington's decision to impose additional tariffs on India for continuing to import crude from Moscow while granting Beijing an extended reprieve. Speaking to Fox News on Sunday (August 17), Rubio explained why China, Russia's largest oil buyer, has been spared from punitive measures, while India faces a 50 per cent tariff, including a 25 per cent additional penalty for oil trade with Moscow. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD He said much of the Russian oil purchased by Beijing is refined and sold into the global market, and imposing sanctions could disrupt supplies and raise prices. 'Well, if you look at the oil that's going to China and being refined, a lot of that is then being sold back into Europe. Europe's also buying natural gas still. Now, there are countries trying to wean themselves off it, but there's more Europe can do with regard to their own sanctions,' Rubio said in an interview with Fox News. Sanctions could drive up prices Rubio cautioned that sanctioning Chinese refiners would have disruptive consequences. 'If you put secondary sanctions on a country, let's say you were to go after the oil sales of Russian oil to China, well, China just refines that oil. That oil is then sold into the global marketplace, and anyone who's buying that oil would be paying more for it or, if it doesn't exist, would have to find an alternative source for it,' he explained. He added that European nations purchasing Russian oil via China have already expressed concern over potential punitive measures. 'We have heard, when you talk about the Senate bill that was being proposed — where there was a hundred per cent tariff on China and India, we did hear from a number of European countries… some concern about what that could mean,' Rubio said. Secondary sanctions on Europe? Asked whether Europe could face sanctions for continuing to buy Russian energy, Rubio said, 'Well, I don't know about (sanctions) on Europe directly, obviously, but certainly there are implications to secondary sanctions. If you impose secondary sanctions on a country, as in the case of Russian oil shipments to China, China will simply refine that oil and it will return to the global market. Anyone buying this oil will pay a higher price, or if it is unavailable, they will have to look for alternative sources.' He reiterated that European nations have already voiced unease over such measures. 'When we discussed the Senate bill proposing a 100 percent tariff on China and India, we heard from a number of European countries that they were unhappy with that possibility,' he added. India-US tensions over Russian oil Rubio's comments come after he highlighted India's energy trade with Moscow as a long-standing irritant in Washington. Speaking to Fox Radio, he said India's continued purchases of Russian oil were 'helping to sustain the Russian war effort in Ukraine' and were 'most certainly a point of irritation' in US-India relations, though not the only one. 'India has huge energy needs and that includes the ability to buy oil and coal and gas and things that it needs to power its economy like every country does, and it buys it from Russia, because Russian oil is sanctioned and cheap. In many cases, they're selling it under the global price because of the sanctions,' Rubio said. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'Unfortunately, that is helping to sustain the Russian war effort. So it is most certainly a point of irritation in our relationship with India, not the only point of irritation. We also have many other points of cooperation with them.' While the US has refrained from sanctioning China, it has acted aggressively against India. After initially imposing a 25 per cent tariff on Indian goods, President Donald Trump recently doubled it to 50 per cent, penalising New Delhi for persisting with Russian oil imports. The White House also warned that secondary sanctions could follow if India did not alter course. The move has drawn accusations of double standards, as China continues to import large volumes of Russian oil without facing similar punitive measures. Despite Trump's repeated threats, India has maintained that its Russian oil purchases have continued and accused Washington of hypocrisy.
