The island split over where to build a new high school
Residents on a Scottish island are facing an almost impossible dilemma as their council debates the location for a new multi-million-pound secondary school.
What should be a milestone of progress for the Isle of Mull's infrastructure has created tensions between the community and the local authority.
Parents in the north of the island want the new school to be built on the site of the current High School in Tobermory, in order to save their primary school.
But those in the south want a school closer to them so their children will no longer have to be sent to Oban - at the age of 11 - on the mainland, where they have to board in hostels during the week.
Argyll and Bute Council has shortlisted four options for the location of the new school, but has recommended the new school be built in Tobermory.
The local authority is expected to pause a vote on the location of the high school, which was scheduled for Thursday, until 7 March.
The isle of Mull is the fourth largest Scottish island and has an area of 338 square miles.
Currently, Mull's only high school is in Tobermory, the most populated town on the island, and encompasses a nursery and primary school.
But it is in a state of disrepair.
Many islanders are calling for the new school to be built in a more central location, such as Craignure, which is home to the main ferry port and the island's hospital.
This would would mean children from the Ross of Mull, who currently live out with Tobermory High School's catchment area, could attend school on the island.
At present, these children need to attend high school in Oban, on the Argyll mainland, and stay in a hostel during the week.
The council's preferred option is to build a replacement school in Tobermory but the "like-for-like" element of the funding means the island's capital would then lose its early years and primary provisions.
Many community members had hoped that a "split option" would be made available allowing a central high school to built as well a new primary school and nursery for the community of Tobermory, but the council says that is too expensive.
Marion MacLean lives in Tobermory and her two daughters currently attend the high school.
While the decision won't directly impact on her family, Marion feels this is the "one chance to get it right for every child that lives on the island".
While she feels its important not be "remiss of the feelings" of families in the Ross of Mull, she has concerns about the impact on the village she has called home all her life.
She told BBC Scotland News: "Tobermory can't lose it's primary school.
"It would have a huge impact on the businesses on the high street, and I think we would lose that community feel of having the children around the town during the day."
Four miles off the main road through the Ross of Mull is the village of Carsaig, which is home to Amy Simpson and her daughters Daisy, six, and Rosie, four.
Amy said that if the council's preferred option of a new school in Tobermory is selected she would feel forced to leave her village, when her kids reach secondary school age, rather than be separated from them if they had to board in Oban.
She added: "We love our life here, we have become an integral part of our community.
"We don't want to leave and we don't want to take our kids out of this community, this is where they were born and where they are growing up."
Fifty-miles south of Tobermory, a journey which takes around an hour and a half in a car due to the single track roads, is the village of Bunessan.
Rob Claxton-Ingham, who lives on a croft with his husband, said the future was uncertain as he doesn't know where his foster child will attend secondary school.
As things stand she faces travelling and boarding in Oban every week - like all children on the south of the island.
He told BBC Scotland News: "As a foster-carer, our child has faced separation and loss already from her birth family and has had to transition to us as her substitute carers
"The thought of her transitioning again at the age of 11 to a school, over the sea, where she has to get a ferry, where she won't get our day-to-day support, is hard."
Rob said high school has always been "an issue" for the community, and people have "learned to be as ok as they can be with it".
"But this situation is developing something new and it really hurts that Argyll and Bute council could develop something new and, actually while doing that plan, to continue excluding people at this end of the island," he added.
Rebekah MacLean and her four kids, also live in the village of Bunessan.
Her youngest children attend the local primary school, but for her secondary aged children things are a little bit more complicated.
She said: "For me, what I am seeking is equality across the island for all children whether that's primary age, early education or secondary students.
"One key aspect of that is the secondary school being centrally based, so all the children can attend and no child has to be put in the position of choosing between education and family."
Rebekah has managed to make arrangements with her son, Jude, 15, to stay with a family friend in Tobermory during the week so he is slightly closer to home, while her daughter, Acacia, 14, is home-schooled.
Jude is also in favour of a centrally-located school so that when it comes to his sibling's time to go to high school, they can stay at home and have a less uninterrupted education than him.
He said: "I do worry that because I have to travel so far, I have less time in school.
"I want to be an engineer, that requires straight A's.
"I worry I won't be able to get those because I have to travel so much and I'm maybe behind in class."
It is clear that the debate on where the new school should be built is an issue that in consuming islanders.
Everywhere you go, everyone has an opinion on it.
Argyll and Bute council said: "Building a new 2-18 campus on Mull is Argyll and Bute Council's single biggest investment estimated at £43m.
"Following extensive community engagement and detailed assessments, Councillors will consider a report recommending a preferred site on 27 February with a motion already tabled to hold a special meeting to consider the issue on 7 March."
Council to push ahead with £100m Mull school plan
Consultation on new secondary school for Mull

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
MSPs to vote on scaled-back social care reforms
It started life with a promise from Nicola Sturgeon that it would be most ambitious reform of the devolution era. But when MSPs vote on the final stage of the Care Reform (Scotland) Bill later, the proposals in front of them will be a shadow of what the former first minister pledged in 2021. At the heart of the revamp of social care services was meant to be a National Care Service - but this was dropped by SNP ministers following widespread opposition to how the shake-up would have worked in practice. However, the planned law to enable this flagship change has lived on and will now deliver changes to social care procurement, family care home visits and a new right to breaks for unpaid carers. When it became clear the National Care Service was not going ahead, the Scottish government was left with a Bill it was trying to get passed that was carrying the same name as its defunct policy. This was solved by renaming it the Care Reform (Scotland) Bill and now the planned law focuses on a series of important, but less high-profile, changes to health and social care across the country. One of the big changes planned under the new law is a legal right to breaks for unpaid carers. This mean councils will have a duty to decide whether a carer is able to take sufficient breaks from their caring role. If they are not, then the local authority will provide support to enable this, such as providing funding for short respite breaks. This policy, given Scotland has around 700,000 unpaid carers, will cost between £196m and £315m by 2035/36, according to the Bill's financial memorandum. However, it remains a fraction of the £13.9bn that unpaid care is currently saving Scotland every year. Improvements to the way information is shared in health and social care - to make it less likely that people will have to repeat their information - as well changes to procurement rules in the sector are also planned. Beefing up the powers that watchdogs can take against failing care providers is also part of the bill. The most high-profile part of the Care Reform (Scotland) Bill is Anne's Law, which allows people in care homes to receive visits from a named loved one even in restricted measures. It is named after Anne Duke, who died aged 63 in November 2021 after being cut off from her family while battling early-onset dementia during the Covid pandemic. Her daughter Natasha Hamilton started a petition about the issue at the height of the pandemic, which attracted nearly 100,000 signatures, and this led to a wider campaign about the rights of people in care homes. "I find it sad that it gained that much traction, it showed it was just not me who was affected, but I felt like I had to do something," she explained. "It was the most vulnerable point of my mum's life, she really needed her family and I still can't believe the separation that happened. "But I'm proud that I did this for my mum and for everyone else who had to endure the torture of isolation during Covid." Changes to ensure people living in care homes have the right to visits from a loved one were introduced by the Scottish government in 2022 via national standards for the sector. If the bill is passed by MSPs, the right to have a designated visitor into care homes to support loved ones will become a legal right instead. The original proposal for a National Care Service, inspired by the NHS, was to take social care provision and staff away from local authorities into a new national agency. That was then dropped in favour of creating a national care board to supervise service delivery and improve consistency - but this failed to win over a growing number of critics. Council body Cosla and trade unions then withdrew their support for the project, while a number of health boards and care organisations also expressed concerns. The plan, which was also subject to a series of delays, was eventually scrapped in January after £30m was spent on the process. Social Care Minister Maree Todd said at the time she was "still committed to the ambitions of the National Care Service" but added the SNP no longer had the support it needed in parliament to pass its original plans into law. What is left of the plans today is the creation of a national care service advisory board on a non-statutory basis which will try and improve social care support services. Government scraps plan for National Care Service Why was Scotland's National Care Service scrapped? Almost £30m already spent on National Care Service
Yahoo
7 hours ago
- Yahoo
Nursery parents win closure review but concerns remain
Aberdeenshire Council has agreed to pause the mothballing of four rural nurseries. Parents were told in April that Ballogie, Crossroads, Glass and Sandhaven nurseries would close at the end of term. Councillors have now agreed to put those decisions on hold while it reviews its guidance around how it consults with families. Campaigners have welcomed the move, but said they had lost confidence in the local authority. At a special meeting of the full council, councillors agreed to pause all future mothballing - which means closing premises but keeping them in a condition ready for future use - while a review of guidance was carried out. During the meeting, councillors on the local authority's ruling administration decided not to allow members of the public to give their views. Campaigner and parent Lindsay Love told BBC Scotland News: ''We all came hoping to speak on behalf of our communities and we were silenced.''' She said she had mixed emotions about the decision to pause mothballing. Ms Love said: ''I'm nervous that they are actually going to move forward with integrity. I feel like they're trying to control the narrative now. "We just need to make sure that we're protecting our nurseries and our rural communities as best as we can." She added: "Whilst is it a good thing that they've decided to pause the mothballing, I don't have a huge amount of confidence in them as an institution to do the right thing.'' More stories from North East Scotland, Orkney and Shetland Listen to news from North East Scotland on BBC Sounds Council leader Gillian Owen said the council had carefully reflected on what parents had been calling for. No timescale was given for the review. Ms Owen said: ''I think we're looking at doing a review quite swiftly but we've got to wait for the Scottish government guidelines.'' She denied families had been "silenced" by not being allowed to speak at the meeting. The councillor added: "We've actually made the changes that they want. ''They must look at that as an actual celebration, not as a slight.'' When the move to mothball the nurseries was announced at the start of the Easter school holidays, it sparked a backlash from local communities. Since then, families have been campaigning to keep them open, arguing the decision was made without proper consultation. The Scottish government also wrote to Aberdeenshire Council to highlight the need to consult parents in such cases. Last week, the local authority's ruling administration said it wanted to pause the controversial plans. Aberdeenshire Council Tory leader stands down Nursery mothballing move taking 'extreme toll' Officials mothballing school branded undemocratic Aberdeenshire Council
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Controversial Skye powerline revamp approved
Controversial plans to upgrade 99 miles (160km) of overhead powerline in the Highlands have been approved by the Scottish government. SSEN Transmission said its line from Ardmore, near Portree on Skye, to Fort Augustus on the shores of Loch Ness was reaching the end of its operational life. The £480m revamp includes burying nine miles (15km) of cable underground to avoid spoiling views of Skye's Cuillin mountains. Highland Council objected to the project in 2023 because of concerns about the impact on other landscapes, while campaigners said they were "deeply disappointed" it had now been given the go-ahead. SSEN Transmission said the green light from the Scottish government, known as Section 37 consent, was the last hurdle in the planning process for its Skye Reinforcement project. The existing power line was constructed in three sections between 1956 and 1989. SSEN Transmission said the new line would have greater capacity and could take power from new renewable projects. Managing director Rob McDonald said: "The Skye Reinforcement project is crucial to maintaining local network reliability and will play an important role in helping the UK achieve its energy security and clean power ambitions. "This project and our wider investment programme will also be a major driver of jobs and economic growth locally and across the north of Scotland, bringing substantial opportunities for communities and businesses." The Scottish government said the replacement would lead to an increase in renewable energy provision, and protect the security of electricity supply to about 32,000 homes and businesses. More stories from the Highlands and Islands News from the Highlands and Islands on BBC Sounds But Skye Wind Farm Information Group said Highland Council's opposition to the revamp should have triggered a public inquiry. Spokesman Dr Andrew Robinson said: "Instead, planning consent has been given and the council's objection ignored. "This is a failure of democracy." The group said the project would require new electricity towers, and two "giant" substations at Edinbane and Broadford on Skye. It said large camps to house construction workers would also be created near Broadford. Dr Robinson added: "Other options to build a smaller scale line, replacing the existing infrastructure and allowing some extra capacity for smaller-scale, community-owned wind farms were never properly considered." He said the group might look into seeking a judicial review, a legal process where a judge looks at a decision made by a public body. Highland Council said it would not be appropriate for it to comment. Highlands and Islands Conservative MSP Jamie Halcro Johnston accused the Scottish government of "riding roughshod" over local democracy to meet renewables targets. SSEN Transmission said new steel electricity towers would be needed on about 68 miles (110km) of the route between Fort Augustus and Edinbane. Wooden poles would carry the line from Edinbane to Ardmore. SSEN Transmission - which is responsible for the electricity network in the north of Scotland - said an overhead line at Kylerhea in Skye, to the mainland would be replaced and closely follow the route of the existing overhead line. Substations at Broadford and Edinbane in Skye would be replaced. The Cuillins are one of the best-known mountain landscapes in Scotland. Its Cuillin Ridge is described in climbing as one of Europe's best mountaineering routes. It is seven miles (11km) long and its summits include 11 Munros - which are peaks over 914m (3,000ft). Power line to be buried to avoid spoiling views Planned £400m power line upgrade moves forward SSEN Transmission