Qantas fined $59M for illegal pandemic layoffs
Australian Federal Court Justice Michael Lee said the outsourcing of 1,820 baggage handler and cleaner jobs at Australian airports in late 2020 was the 'largest and most significant contravention' of relevant Australian labor laws in their 120-year history.
Qantas agreed in December last year to pay AU$120 million ($78 million) in compensation to former staff after seven High Court judges unanimously rejected the Sydney-based airline's appeal against the judgment that outsourcing their jobs was illegal.
The Transport Workers Union, which took the airline to court, had argued the airline should receive the largest fine available — AU$121,212,000 ($78,969,735).
Lee ruled that the minimum fine to create a deterrence should be AU$90 million ($59 million), noting that Qantas executives had expected to save AU$125 million ($81 million) a year through outsourcing the jobs.
Lee questioned the sincerity of Qantas's apology for its illegal conduct, noting that the airline later unsuccessfully argued that it owed no compensation to its former staff.
'If any further evidence was needed of the unrelenting and aggressive litigation strategy adopted in this case by Qantas, it is provided by this effort directed to denying any compensation whatsoever to those in respect of whom Qantas was publicly professing regret for their misfortune,' Lee said.
"I do think that the people in charge of Qantas now have some genuine regret, but this more likely reflects the damage that this case has done to the company rather than remorse for the damage done to the affected workers,' Lee added.
Qantas chief executive Vanessa Hudson, who was the airline's chief financial officer during the layoffs, said in a statement after Monday's decision: 'We sincerely apologize to each and every one of the 1,820 ground handling employees and to their families who suffered as a result.'
'The decision to outsource five years ago, particularly during such an uncertain time, caused genuine hardship for many of our former team and their families," she said.
'Over the past 18 months we've worked hard to change the way we operate as part of our efforts to rebuild trust with our people and our customers. This remains our highest priority as we work to earn back the trust we lost,' she added.
Lee ruled that AU$50 million ($33 million) of the fine go to the union, because no Australian government agency had shown interest in investigating or prosecuting Qantas.
'But for the union … , Qantas' contravening conduct would never have been exposed and it would never have been held to account for its unlawful conduct,' Lee said.
'Hence the union has brought to the attention of the court a substantial and significant transgression of a public obligation by a powerful and substantial employer,' Lee added.
A hearing will be held at a later date to decide where the remaining AU$40 million ($26 million) of the fine will go.
Michael Kaine, national secretary of the union that represents 60,000 members, said he felt vindicated by Monday's ruling, which ends a five-year legal battle that Qantas had been widely expected to win.
'It is a significant — the most significant — industrial outcome in Australia's history and it sends a really clear message to Qantas and to every employer in Australia: Treat your work force illegally and you will be held accountable,' Kaine told reporters.
'Against all the odds, we took on a behemoth that had shown itself to be ruthless and we won,' Kaine added.
Qantas has admitted illegally dealing with passengers as well as employees in its responses to pandemic economic challenges.
Last year, Qantas agreed to pay AU$120 million ($78 million) in compensation and a fine for selling tickets on thousands of cancelled flights.
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, a consumer watchdog, sued the airline in the Federal Court alleging that Qantas engaged in false, misleading or deceptive conduct by advertising tickets for more than 8,000 flights from May 2021 through to July 2022 that had already been canceled.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
a minute ago
- NBC News
Best Buy launches third-party marketplace as it looks for sales drivers
Best Buy is launching a third-party marketplace, as it tries to bulk up the variety of merchandise it offers and reverse slower sales. Starting on Tuesday, shoppers who go to Best Buy's website and app will see products and brands that weren't available there before, including more tech-related accessories like custom video game controllers and some nontech items including seasonal decor and sports collectibles. The company's online marketplace riffs off those of other retailers, such as Amazon and Walmart, by relying on third-party sellers to stock, sell and ship inventory and taking a cut of their sales in the form of a commission. 'Everything we do is really centered around the customer and their technology needs, and we do see customers actually doing a lot of consumer electronics transactions through marketplaces,' Chief Customer, Product and Fulfillment Officer Jason Bonfig said. 'And as a result of that, we need to make adjustments to be where the customer's at.' He said Best Buy noticed gaps in its assortment that the new platform will help it fill. For instance, Bonfig said the company didn't carry batteries for some older cameras or cases for older smartphones. And it didn't offer some items that complement Best Buy purchases, such as furniture that goes around a big-screen TV or cookware to use with a new kitchen appliance. Along with adding those items, the marketplace makes it possible for smaller vendors with innovative products to sell on Best Buy's website when they're not yet big enough to make or distribute the volume needed for its stores, he added. Best Buy's marketplace launches at a time when its business could use a boost. Its annual sales have declined over the past three years as the company contends with a sluggish housing market, selective consumer spending and a decline in device replacements after a spike in tech purchases during the Covid pandemic. The company cut its sales outlook in May and said it expects full-year revenue to range from $41.1 billion to $41.9 billion. That would be similar to Best Buy's annual revenue of $41.5 billion in the most recent fiscal year, but below the numbers it posted in the years leading up to and during the pandemic. Best Buy will share its most recent earnings results and sales forecast on Aug. 28. Tariffs have complicated the backdrop for Best Buy, too, since the higher duties have added costs for consumer electronics vendors and distracted them from other priorities like research and development that leads to new and innovative products, said Jonathan Matuszewski, a retail analyst at Jefferies. He said Best Buy tends to win sales instead of big-box or online competitors when there's a leap forward in technology. With the platform's launch, Best Buy joins other retailers that have jumped on the trend of introducing or expanding third-party marketplaces. Lowe's and Nordstrom started marketplaces last year. Ulta Beauty plans to launch its own later this year. And Target said it will expand its existing marketplace, Target Plus. On Best Buy's earnings call in May, CEO Corie Barry described the third-party marketplace as one of the company's strategic priorities for the year. She said that new profit stream 'is even more important in this environment' and will provide greater flexibility with the range of items and price points. Plus, she said the marketplace supports the company's growing advertising business. Sellers can buy ads for their products, including by paying for better placement in search results. Marketplaces and the advertising opportunities that come with them tend drive higher profits for retailers, said Justin MacFarlane, a managing director for the global retail group of AlixPartners. Sellers buy, stock and ship products instead of the retailer, and take on both the expense of buying inventory and the risk that they may have to mark down unwanted items, he said. Yet the business model comes with risks, too, he said. For instance, sellers may not have the same standards as a retailer and it could anger a retailer's customers if they send products in torn boxes, with missing pieces or days later than expected. And he said retailers can flood their websites with so many different categories, brands and products that they overwhelm customers with choices that seem irrelevant to their company's identity. 'You get addicted to the growth and more is more until it's not,' he said. At launch, Best Buy's marketplace will have about 500 sellers, Bonfig said. He said the company vetted applicants and whittled them down to the ones who can provide a high-quality customer experience. The sellers must match Best Buy's return policy, he added.
Forbes
a minute ago
- Forbes
This Boutique Hotel Group Has The Top-Ranked Resort In Tulum
Often, when new CEOs take the helm at a hotel group, they come with a list of things they believe need to be changed, improved, renovated, or revamped. For travel industry veteran Paul Cohen, he says, his biggest job is getting the good word out in a field crowded with new hotels and lots of public relations buzz that Colibri Boutique Hotels are already well-polished gems. The current group features four hotels in Tulum, one in Nicaragua, and a separate hotel in Baja California about an hour-and-a-half south of Tijuana. However, it's the Yucatan Peninsula that is expected to be the brand's primary focus. The hotels are family-owned by an Australian entrepreneur whom Cohen got to know during the Covid pandemic, when they were both living in Nicaragua, where Cohen owned a small resort at the time. "We would have lunch quite often together. We got to know each other," Cohen says. Then, about six months ago, Cohen says he received a call from his old friend, asking him to Tulum and take a look. At the time, he was running his own sports and travel marketing business. As Cohen explains it, the hotels had been doing very well without much of a sales or marketing effort, but as competition increased in Tulum, the properties were suddenly losing ground. As a consultant, Cohen told the owner, "Operationally, everything is great. These are beautiful properties." However, he said, the group was lacking the needed outreach to travel advisors who now dominate the luxury resort market, and was not active with the destination management companies, who can arrange local experiences beyond the resorts. He also told the owner that the websites, not the hotels, needed the upgrades. Two months ago, the owner called Cohen to tell him that the CEO resigned. Would he come down and take the helm? "If I was just walking into a new hotel company, I'm too old to start studying everything and trying to hit the ground running, but here, I knew the properties, I knew the staff, I knew the systems," Cohen says, adding, "Basically coming in, the analogy of a football team, as the coach of the team, but I already knew the players, I knew the competition." Cohen says the most significant changes were in the back office, where he modernized revenue management so that rates and availability are updated, and booking is travel-agent-friendly. 'You can't make it hard to do business with you, and that's what we were doing,' he says. Now, with so much buzz around Tulum, he says, part of the challenge is to explain what the four properties are not. 'While Tulum has become known as a Caribbean hot spot for partying, that's not our vibe,' he says. The Colibri resorts offer a range of authentic and sophisticated dining options, wellness, fitness, family activities and soft adventure. "You have great beaches, you have Mayan ruins, you can swim in Cenotes, you have great restaurants. You can party because there are places to party in Tulum. We're not the place where there is loud music." In terms of geography, Cohen notes that two hotels are located in the resort area, immediately next to each other. About four kilometers away are the other two properties, both of which are next to each other, and those are in the national park area. All of its properties are on the beach. Cohen says the group is a well-known player locally. The largest property is La Zebra, with 40 rooms. It gets a 4.8 out of 5 stars on TripAdvisor and 9.4 out of 10 on Staff, service, cleanliness, property condition, and facilities were rated a 9.6. While Cohen admits, "none of our properties have the big booming nightlife… we're not the crazy beach clubs," he says that, and the fact that there is a wide range of accommodations to meet different budgets, is what gives the group's hotel a loyal following. Lula, La Zebra's next-door neighbor, gets a perfect 5.0 rating on Tripadvisor, ranking it first out of 243 accommodations in Tulum featured on the website. Cohen says the two properties in the national park, Mezzanine and Mi Amor, are adults only and thus popular with couples. They each have similarly high ratings. In a time when consumers are rebelling against sky-high hotel prices and service that doesn't seem to keep up, Cohen says his collection, currently part of Small Luxury Hotels, offers high value with offseason rates starting at around $300 per night and suites in the $1,500 per night range. Tulum's Felipe Carrillo Puerto International Airport, with international flights nonstop from the United States, is increasingly accessible; however, Cohen says many visitors still fly into Cancun, about 75 miles to the north, where there are still massively more flight options. During meetings at Virtuoso Travel Week, last week in Las Vegas, Cohen said his view of the properties and their online ratings was reinforced by travel advisors who told him an increasing number of clients are looking for authentic boutique hotel experiences with reasonable pricing. Don't look for massive expansion. Right now, Cohen says there could be some opportunities locally.
Associated Press
a minute ago
- Associated Press
Mexico says there's no agreement with DEA for new border enforcement collaboration
MEXICO CITY (AP) — Hours after the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration announced 'a major new initiative' for United States and Mexico collaboration targeting gatekeepers who control illicit trafficking routes across the countries' shared borders, Mexico's president said Tuesday there was no such agreement. President Claudia Sheinbaum was referring to 'Project Portero,' an effort announced Monday by the DEA, calling it a 'flagship operation' against smuggling routes that move drugs, guns and money across the border. 'The DEA put out a statement yesterday saying that there is an agreement with the Mexican government for an operation called Portero,' Sheinbaum said during her morning news briefing. 'There is no agreement with the DEA. The DEA puts out this statement, based on what we don't know. We have not reached any agreement, none of the security institutions (have) with the DEA.' The U.S. embassy in Mexico and the DEA did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Sheinbaum said the only thing happening was a workshop in Texas attended by four members of Mexico's police force. The DEA statement mentioned that workshop, saying it had brought Mexican investigators to one of its intelligence centers to train with U.S. prosecutors, law enforcement, defense officials and members of the intelligence community. The visibly annoyed president made her comments just days after generally positive exchanges between the two governments following another extension to ward off threatened U.S. tariffs and another shipment of 26 drug cartel figures to the U.S. from Mexico. Mexico had seemed to be repairing the security relationship with the United States after six years of tension under Sheinbaum's predecessor, Andrés Manuel López Obrador, who had reined in DEA agents operating in Mexico and accused the agency of wholesale fabrication when it arrested Mexico's former defense secretary. Sheinbaum's administration had taken a more aggressive stance toward pursuing Mexico's drug cartels and sent dozens of cartel figures sought by U.S. prosecutors to the United States. Sheinbaum did say that members of her administration had been working for months with U.S. counterparts on a broader security agreement that was practically finished. She said that agreement was based on four principles her administration has stressed for months: sovereignty, mutual trust, territorial respect and coordination without subordination. The DEA statement included a comment from agency administrator Terry Cole, who was recently tapped to lead the Trump administration takeover of the Washington D.C. police. 'Project Portero and this new training program show how we will fight — by planning and operating side by side with our Mexican partners, and by bringing the full strength of the U.S. government to bear,' Cole said in the Monday statement. ____ Follow AP's coverage of Latin America and the Caribbean at
