Court orders HSE to pay Wicklow firm almost €3m for breach of covid ventilators contract
Narooma Ltd, the Wicklow-based firm in question, had initially sued the HSE in the High Court in April 2020 after the health service failed to make payment for 350 ventilators it had agreed to purchase at the onset of the pandemic.
The original deal for the machines – which were in high demand for covid-hit patients – had been worth €7.5m.
In addition to the compensatory payment, believed to be close to €3m and representing the profits lost as a result of the scuppered deal, it's understood that the arbitrator ruling upon the case also directed that the HSE be held liable for all legal costs resulting from the action.
Those costs will likely amount to an additional €3m resulting from the five-year arbitration – leaving the HSE facing a bill of close to €6m as a result of the case.
Narooma was contacted for comment but did not respond.
The company also has an outstanding High Court action against the IDA resulting from the same events, its claim being that the inward investment agency allegedly advised the HSE to back out of the initial deal, leading directly to the breach of contract.
A spokesperson for the HSE did not directly address the Narooma settlement, but said regarding other monies which it has failed to recoup on foot of failed ventilator transactions with multiple companies that: 'The HSE continues the process of taking the necessary steps to recoup outstanding amounts where appropriate and possible to do so.'
The Wicklow company's case contrasted markedly with that of other companies which entered into deals with the HSE to provide ventilators from China at the start of the pandemic.
One company, Roqu – previously known for organising music festivals in the Middle East – received €14.1m from the HSE for 328 ventilators – only 72 of which were ever received, none of which were ever used as they failed to pass quality standards.
Case background
The initial agreement between the HSE and Narooma would have seen the 350 ventilators shipped to Ireland via the Far East in April and May, 2020.
When the HSE informed the company that it would not be following through with the purchase that April, Narooma brought the case to the High Court.
It claimed the HSE had been required under the contract entered into on March 27, 2020, to pay for the ventilators three days later on March 30, but had failed to do so, saying belatedly that it wished to conduct due diligence on the company.
At the High Court, the HSE argued that the case should be referred for arbitration per the contract between the two, an argument acceded to by Judge David Barniville in June 2020.
The case had been mired in arbitration for five years until the recent decision in favour of Narooma.
Defamation
Narooma also stated in court its intention to expand its claims against the HSE to include defamation, after the body complained about the company to An Garda Siochána – a complaint which directly led to the gardaí reporting to the Policing Authority that its economic crime bureau, in conjunction with Interpol, had intervened in an attempt to return the €7.5m to the HSE – despite the monies never having been paid in the first place – and had commenced a criminal investigation into the matter.
The gardaí subsequently moved to correct the record, posting a notice in the Irish Times noting that the information it had reported to the authority was 'incorrect', and that no money had ever been paid to Narooma by the HSE.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Agriland
6 hours ago
- Agriland
Tillage: Combining soil analysis with grain assessments
Soil analysis is normally carried out within a three to five-year cycle on tillage farms throughout the UK and Ireland. However, the additional benefits that can be accrued when the information generated by grain analysis is included within a crop planning process are significant. Crop physiologist at the UK-based consultancy ADAS, Dr. Sarah Kendall, explained: 'Soil testing delivers valuable information where pH, potash, phosphate, and magnesium levels are concerned. 'We can add to this information dataset with leaf analysis. "This is an approach that allows farmers to make in-season crop nutritional checks, linked to any specific deficiencies that may have been highlighted. 'Crop post mortems are new. However, we at ADAS believe they provide better monitoring to improve crop nutrition. It's a perspective totally endorsed by fellow ADAS crop physiologist, Dr. Tamara Fitters, who said: 'Reviewing is very much about making a check list. "It's a process that includes looking at what is happening mid-season as well the results derived from the harvest. 'This approach allows us to review the whole growing season, instead of just taking a snapshot of it. According to the ADAS crop physiologist, as the harvest has commenced, it is "very important" to check results. 'For example, this year no one was expecting it to be this dry. This factor alone can make a big difference to what was expected relative to what is actually happening. 'The next challenge is to work out why a difference may have arisen in the first place. 'Then it's a case of working out how this can be mitigated against into the future. In the case of the weather, this is not possible. "But there might be other reasons why final crop performance levels were lower than might have been previously expected,' Dr Fitters added. Soil assessments are the key starting point when it comes to developing a crop nutrient management plan. Dr. Fitters said: 'Soil Index values can be used to determine a crop nutrient plans for the coming season. Other factors to be added in at this stage include the availability of organic materials and chemical fertiliser options. 'We want to know the sort of yield we normally get. This gives a good ideas as to what a certain filed is capable of. 'Past harvest results are important in this regard. We also look at weather patterns. It's impossible to determine the exact nature of weather patterns at the beginning of a season. 'However, there are general weather patterns that we can avail of it and, at least, try to take this into account.' The final 2024 UK wheat harvest is 11.1 million tonnes, a decrease of 20% on 2023 In-season crop analysis requires the taking of leaf samples. Subsequent laboratory analysis delivers a full nutriment breakdown of the tissue. 'This will give us an idea of how much the plants have already taken up from the soli stores,' Dr. Fitters said. 'It will also give us an idea if the crop is on track. We know which stage of growth the tissue samples were taken. And this means we should have an idea of what the nutrient values should be. 'If these are not adequate, then we can adjust upwards, thereby boosting plant growth rates accordingly." Subsequent grain analysis can take place at the end of the growing season. This gives a definitive perspective on what has happened, from planting through to final harvest. According to Dr Fitters, this process quantifies the amount of nutrients actually taken up by the growing crop. 'We know what we put in and we know what was in the soil prior to planting,' she said. 'Grain analysis constitutes an evidence-based approach, so the information obtained is of tremendous significance in terms of decision making for the next season,' Dr. Fitters said. But other factors also come into play. 'We don't know how much nutrient is lost in the water or to the air,' stressed the ADAS crop physiologist. 'So, going forward, in terms of finding out what's happening in our fields, we want to focus on those bits that we can work out. 'Losses to the air and water will be very hard to determine. Special measuring equipment would be required to get those numbers. 'But what we can measure are the outputs. And it would be very valuable to do this on a regular basis.' Significantly, grain nutrient values can vary quite a lot. Analysis has shown that when measured across a number of fields, grain nitrogen, phosphorous, and potash levels will follow a form of normal distribution curve. However, actual in-field values for these nutrients may well vary from what are regarded as UK standard estimations. Dr. Fitters points out that current, assumed UK values for grain nitrogen are pretty much spot on, where nitrogen is concerned.. However, they may well over estimate the phosphorous and potash content of grains. She added: 'We can't always rely on standard numbers. Each farm will be different: each field will be different. So it's important for farmers to identify exactly what is going on within their own crops. 'However, we can use average numbers to provide a form of benchmark." Significantly, actual grain nutrient values can allow for the calculation of fertiliser response values. Nitrogen is particularly important in this regard and, according to the ADAS representative, performs quite neatly to this form of analysis. 'We can effectively work out the optimal response rate by using this approach,' she said. 'This is an economic optimal value. 'If insufficient nitrogen is applied, there will be quite a high yield penalty. Adding nitrogen fertiliser above the optimal value can quickly lead to significant economic losses being incurred. Dr. Fitters pointed out that similar response curves have been generated with regard to nitrogen applications on wheat and barley crops. However, she said where oats are concerned, the drop-off in relative response rate to nitrogen is "much more significant beyond the optimal input level". 'It's important to realise that we can accurately quantify this loss in come from non-optimal nitrogen usage," she said. 'The end objective is to get both a good crop yield and optimal grain nitrogen content. 'The data that is generated for particular fields and specific crop varieties can then be checked against standard figures. 'If there are major differences, then it's a case of working out how these came about.' Within a feed wheat scenario, ADAS figures show that grain protein values that are 1.5% below optimal values can result in losses of up to £50/ha. And all of this comes down to securing optimal nitrogen fertiliser application rates in the first place. Three factors now come into play - crop offtake, crop capture, and crop application. 'It should also be possible to calculate a crop residue, which can be used for the next season,' the ADAS crop physiologist commented. 'Another thing we can do with grain analysis is diagnose nutrient deficiencies and excesses." Dr Fitters said this process starts with the development of a full inventory of all fertiliser sources used, including organic manures. 'It's then a case of calculating the nutrient harvest from each field. This is the yield multiplied by the percentage of each nutrient." she explained. 'So to do this we need our grain analysis results. 'We can then do a field nutrient count. The difference between the soil and grain analysis will tell us if the crop left significant nutrient analysis for the benefit of the next crop or there is a requirement to build up soil nutrient stores again.'
The Irish Sun
18 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
How Morecambe FC faces possible EXTINCTION amid financial mess as fans despair with just 11 days left to find new owner
Fans blame the club's demise on Essex-based owner Jason Whittingham for not fulfilling his promise to sell the crisis-hit club BRING BACK THE SUNSHINE How Morecambe FC faces possible EXTINCTION amid financial mess as fans despair with just 11 days left to find new owner STARING at the giant Morecambe FC flag bearing the legend Bring Me Sunshine, tears fill club worker Colette Davies' eyes. 'There's no sunshine right now,' weeps the mum of three. 'It's more like dark, black clouds.' Advertisement 8 Morecambe have missed the final deadline and are on the brink of being kicked out the National League 8 Bring Me Sunshine — the signature tune of the town's most famous son, Eric Morecambe isn't likely to echo around the stadium any time soon Credit: Alamy 8 Colette, whose job is 'housekeeper' for the players, says she and other fans are experiencing 'absolute heartbreak' Belted out by fans on match day, Bring Me Sunshine — the signature tune of the town's most famous son, Eric Morecambe — is unlikely to echo around the Shrimps' stadium any time soon. Mired in a financial mess, the club has been suspended by the National League for its first three games this season. If the Lancs club is not sold by August 20, they may be kicked out of the league altogether. Possible extinction of this 105-year-old institution would be a devastating blow for a seaside resort that has seen its tourism industry decimated by cheap package holidays abroad. Advertisement Standing next to the club's well-manicured pitch, Colette, whose job is 'housekeeper' for the players, says she and other fans are experiencing 'absolute heartbreak'. For Colette and many who pack the Halo home stand on match days, the Shrimps are a family affair. Her dad Les Dewhirst has been the club's kit man for the last 30 years and her three children are all Morecambe mad. Les told me he is too upset to be interviewed, saying: 'It's hurting so much and my head won't settle.' Advertisement Ghostly sadness As seagulls wheel overhead, Colette adds: 'There's been lots of tears and anger. When I have to go home and tell my boys that I don't know what's going on at the club, there's absolute heartbreak. They're 14 and 15. This club is their life.' Like other staff at the club, Colette has not been paid since May. With tears rolling down her cheeks, she tells me that new school uniforms for her children are 'on hold'. Tyson Fury opens up on relationship with Joseph Parker and claims he's now his 'part-time manager and financial advisor' 'It's the school holidays, so there's been no fun activities really for my kids because we just can't afford it,' she adds. The giant Bring Me Sunshine flag — complete with a silhouette of a skipping Eric Morecambe, a shrimp and the red rose of Lancashire — stands limp in the sunshine at the back of the Halo stand. Advertisement Despite being born in the resort. the comic genius was famously a Luton Town fan and club director. As with a closed-down pub, a ghostly sadness haunts a shuttered football ground where laughter and emotion once reverberated. Planned weddings, wakes and school proms booked at the 6,241- capacity Mazuma Stadium this summer have all been cancelled. One corner of the stadium is occupied by local hero Tyson Fury's gym. Many in the town are hoping the former heavyweight boxing world champ will step in as a white knight to save the club. Advertisement As yet, there has been no word on a possible takeover from the big man. Colette shows me the empty changing rooms where everything is neat and tidy for when the players should be preparing to face Brackley Town next Saturday. Like today's away fixture at Boston United, it has been postponed. Playing in England's third tier as recently as 2021, only a world war has stopped the Shrimps fulfilling their fixtures until now. Fans blame the demise on Essex-based owner Jason Whittingham for not fulfilling his promise to sell the crisis-hit club. Advertisement On Wednesday, Sir Keir Starmer said he was 'very concerned' about the plight of Morecambe FC and urged everyone involved with the club 'to do the right thing'. 8 .Season ticket holder Helen Coates, 56, buying a replica shirt for her grandson Coby, 5 8 Railway worker Russ Horrocks, 38, and son Noah, 11 8 Official kit supplier Terrace's director Carl Sewell says cash from the merchandise will not reach owner Whittingham's pockets Advertisement Supporters have this week been queuing at a pop-up shop on the promenade to buy this season's shirts, even though their team may never get to wear them. There was a forlorn sense of despondency along the usually jaunty seafront as hundreds waited for hours to make their purchase. Railway worker Russ Horrocks, 38, snapped up the away shirt for son Noah, 11, saying: 'Morecambe's a great atmosphere on match days. 'There's 4,000 on a good day, but the noise makes it sound like more. It's as much about meeting your mates as the result.' Advertisement Retired Alan McGinley, 62, whose brother John played for the club, revealed: 'The club is everything for this town now the tourism has been hit. My brother used to get a pork pie for playing and £1 if he scored.' A banner reading, 'Bring back the sunshine' was strapped to railings at the store run by official kit supplier Terrace. Its director, Carl Sewell, says cash from the merchandise will not reach owner Whittingham's pockets, adding: 'We sold around 1,500 shirts in just four hours.' Of the club's slip towards possible exclusion from the league, he said: 'It's horrendous. It will suck the blood out of the town and hit local businesses.' Season ticket holder Helen Coates, 56, buying a replica shirt for her grandson Coby, five, added: 'I don't know what I'm going to do with my Saturdays now. Advertisement 'I took my sons to watch Morecambe, I now take my grandsons. It was only £3 for little ones. It makes me want to weep.' With stunning views of the Lake District fells, Morecambe became a seaside destination for Yorkshire factory workers when a connecting rail line was built around 1850. The club is everything for this town now the tourism has been hit. My brother used to get a pork pie for playing and £1 if he scored. Alan McGinley The resort boomed in the 20th Century — with Scottish holidaymakers also being drawn to it — before no- frills flights to the Med dented its popularity. It had been home to the country's largest Pontins holiday camp, but the last Bluecoats left in 1994. Advertisement Morecambe's once iconic pair of piers are long gone, as is its famous Bubbles swimming pool and the Frontierland fairground. Hope is offered by an £80million scheme to construct a northern version of the Eden Project botanical garden on the seafront. Shrimps season ticket holder David Lambert, 63, points down the promenade and tells me: 'This town used to be packed out at this time of year. 'You couldn't walk along that prom for people. At least on Saturdays the football would give this place a buzz. Away fans would come and walk along the prom, go to the pubs and have fish and chips. That might all be gone now.' Advertisement 'Used to be packed out' Morecambe's once mighty fleet of shrimp fishing boats has also been in steep decline. Ray Edmondson still stocks his little fishmongers with shrimps caught from his boat, the Bernadette. The fisherman says there were 30 shrimp boats when he started out. Now there are just two. He blames 'too many rules and regulations'. Advertisement Ray, who has run his business for 47 years, adds: 'Away fans come in here to buy a few pots of shrimps and take them home with them.' Nearby, staff at Atkinson's Fish & Chips are worried they could lose a decent slice of trade if the football club goes under. The football helps many hospitality businesses through the lean winter months. Bernie Harkin, 52, who has grafted in the shop for 26 years, tells me: 'Fans love our chips with a bit of haddock. The football club is such an important part of the town. Advertisement 'We have our Christmas parties at the stadium.' 8 The club has been suspended by the National League for its first three games this season 8 One corner of the stadium is occupied by local hero Tyson Fury's gym Credit: Getty Barman Zac Rossall, 19, serving pints at the Eric Bartholomew — a Wetherspoon pub bearing Eric Morecambe's real name — says: 'It gets packed here on match day. Advertisement 'I'm not a football fan, but I'm a fan of what it brings to Morecambe. 'If the club closes, it will mean less footfall in the town.' So why is Morecambe in such a financial mess? In 2023, Jason Whittingham's Bond Group Investments announced it was selling the club to investment firm Panjab Warriors. The company loaned £6million to the Shrimps as the club descended into financial turmoil with unpaid bills, sackings and resignations. Advertisement Panjab Warriors are ready to take Morecambe off his hands, but Whittingham says he has an alternative buyer. 'Club is held hostage' Last month, Whittingham sacked the Shrimps' board of directors after they threatened to place the club into administration. Morecambe MP Lizzi Collinge has raised the issue in Parliament and said: 'Morecambe FC is being held hostage and it breaks my heart.' In June the Shrimps' players were only paid a third of their salaries. Many have now chosen to leave the club to pay their mortgages. Advertisement One player forced to quit, midfielder Tom White, 28, said: 'Morecambe Football Club is special. This institution needs to survive, and I'm praying.' A town that followed its football club to Wembley three times since 1974 now may lose its cornerstone. While a new Morecambe could rise from the ashes if the club is booted out of the league, it would then likely have to take its place at the bottom of the football pyramid. Bury FC, who were expelled from the Football League for financial difficulties in 2019, have invited Shrimps fans to watch their match free today 'in solidarity'. Advertisement Dozens are planning on making the journey. And they will be supporting another club that understands how football binds a community together.
RTÉ News
21 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Trump's nominee for the Fed wants to overhaul it
Having railed against the "revolving door" between the executive branch and the US Federal Reserve, Council of Economic Advisers Chair Stephen Miran may now be walking through it after President Donald Trump nominated him to the Board of Governors of an institution Miran would like to radically overhaul. In a report last year co-authored by Miran for the Manhattan Institute, the economist proposed harsh medicine for a series of ills he felt had infected the central bank, from "group think" on monetary policy, to regulatory overreach, to poor accountability and a loss of focus on its core mission of fighting inflation. It was one of two big-think ideas Miran floated last year, along with the so-called Mar-a-Lago accord for devaluing the dollar and restructuring US debt, a proposal that quickly fell into disfavor and was criticised as putting the dollar's global reserve status at risk. His views on the Fed might also be a hard sell. He has argued that the Fed's touted independence has left it unaccountable and ineffective and that it would be better served by a new system where presidents could fire the seven members of the Washington-based Board of Governors at will. To counter that presidential power, authority over monetary policy would shift to the 12 regional Federal Reserve banks, whose leaders would all vote on monetary policy and thus be able to outvote the Board, and whose oversight would come under the control of state governors. Instead of a system insulated from politics it would be a system fully infused with it, but in a form of "monetary federalism" Miran argues would increase accountability. Whether that flies with US Senators who have to confirm Miran's selection and who are already on edge about Trump's attacks on the Fed, remains an open question, as does the verdict of global bond markets concerned about the ability of a politically captive central bank to control inflation. Long-term Treasury yields and the interest rate on inflation-protected bonds rose slightly in the hours after Miran's nomination was announced. Expectations of a quarter-point cut at the Fed's September and December meetings changed little.
