logo
What we've learned from the SAAQclic fiasco inquiry

What we've learned from the SAAQclic fiasco inquiry

CBC26-05-2025

Social Sharing
It's been a month since a public inquiry was launched to shed light on the chaotic rollout of an online platform for Quebec's automobile insurance board and the eye-popping $500-million cost overrun it came with.
The February 2023 launch of the SAAQclic online platform faced a series of major failures and sparked a customer service crisis.
These problems were highlighted in a scathing report by the auditor general in February 2025. After the report's release, a Coalition Avenir Québec minister stepped down.
The platform was intended to centralize most of the services from the Société de l'assurance automobile du Québec (SAAQ). Instead, users across the province struggled to access and navigate it, and for weeks, frustrated drivers lined up in the cold outside SAAQ offices as technical issues dragged on.
The public inquiry — presided by Denis Gallant and known as the Gallant commission — began on April 24.
There have been several revelations, including a fourfold increase in the hourly rates of consultants.
If you missed the past month's hearings, streamed online, here are some of the key takeaways.
Several calls for tenders ended with a single bidder
Prosecutors for the Gallant commission discovered that many tender calls related to the CASA project — the SAAQ's broad IT modernization project that included the SAAQclic platform — ended with a single bidder.
Martin Lapierre, former internal auditor at the SAAQ, told the commission that several people who won calls for tenders for "strategic resources" had professional ties with Karl Malenfant, the former vice-president of the SAAQ's digital experience and the project director for CASA.
Commission prosecutor Alexandre Thériault-Marois cited the example of Madeleine Chagnon who knew Malenfant because she had worked with him at Hydro-Québec and at RD3, a private IT solutions firm. In 2015, in the early days of the CASA project, she was the only bidder deemed compliant with the criteria for a SAAQ contract.
Lapierre said he was astonished to find a clause in the call for tenders stating that the successful bidder had to "hold a master's degree, which could not be offset by years of relevant experience."
"I haven't seen that often … It was peculiar," he testified.
Lapierre explained during the session that he reported this to his superiors, who assured him that all the rules surrounding the call for tenders had been followed to the letter.
SAAQclic inquiry reveals massive jumps in hourly wages, tailor-made calls for tender
3 days ago
Duration 2:24
Consultants' hourly rates rose from $82 to $350, says former auditor
The commission also revealed that employees from external firms working on the online platform were promoted from "integrators" to "leading experts" during the course of the project.
As a result, according to former SAAQ internal auditor Martin Després, their wages more than quadrupled from $82 to $350 per hour.
According to the contract between the SAAQ and a group commonly referred to as "the Alliance" — made up of the companies LGS and SAP — there were 10,793 hours of work planned over five years for these "leading experts." But less than two and a half years later, nearly 35,000 hours had already been billed under this employee profile.
Després said it constituted an overrun of around $3 million. He told the commission that he had examined the tasks performed by the employees who had received these salary increases and, according to him, "there was no significant difference" in their work.
He said he questioned his superiors and learned that the decision "came from above," from Malenfant's office.
Between 2017 and 2019, Després and his team compared the hours billed by consultants hired by the SAAQ with the time they actually spent at the head office, as stipulated in their contract.
The result: a gap of more than 12,500 hours, which Després said cost Quebec's automobile insurance board approximately $1.5 million.
Després said he reported these results to his superiors. An internal investigation was then launched.
The findings of the investigation surprised him.
"We were told [the gap in hours] was remote work that was approved," said Després.
Employees, with some exceptions, were required to work in the head office. All remote work had to be approved by the managers.
"With all the checks we had done beforehand, we found it strange that all that remote work was approved afterward," said Després.
He added that managers at the SAAQ asked the auditors to destroy the documents related to their investigation, which he says he and his team refused to comply with.
A CEO 'from another planet' with no digital experience
During his testimony, former SAAQ board chair Konrad Sioui recounted how Denis Marsolais found himself at the helm of the automobile insurance board in January 2022, just over a year before the rollout of the digital platform.
At the time, CEO Nathalie Tremblay had just retired. In the middle of the interview process, Sioui said he received a call from the Secrétariat aux emplois supérieurs, which is a government agency that the province consults with when hiring people for senior-ranking positions.
Sioui said he was told that they had found the right person: Marsolais, a longtime government official.
"We felt that the political pressure was too heavy. They should have let us do our job. We had excellent candidates. But... it's the political side that takes over and says: 'Look, this is the one we want, and that's that,'" said Sioui.
Although Marsolais was described as "willing" and "ready to roll up his sleeves," he was also "from another planet," according to Sioui.
WATCH | How the SAAQclic fiasco led to a minister's resignation:
Quebec minister resigns in wake of SAAQclic fiasco
3 months ago
Duration 2:26
Board of directors knew the project had 'all the flaws'
François Geoffrion, who sat on the SAAQ's board of directors from 2013 to 2022, told the Gallant commission the board knew that the digital transformation project was "risky" and had "all the flaws," even before the call for tenders was launched.
"We screwed up twice," said Geoffrion. "In the needs assessment and during the rollout."
According to him, several warning signs were flashing red from the very beginning of the project, including the SAAQ's lack of technological maturity, insufficient specialized resources, and not enough managers to oversee the project.
Additionally, documents submitted to the commission suggest that SAAQ administrators, including the chair of the board at the time, were made aware as early as October 2020 of the likelihood that the rollout of the website would face cost overruns, according to documents submitted to the commission.
The commission resumed Monday and the inquiry's report is due by Sept. 30, 2025.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Montreal police arrest 13 suspected of extorting restaurant owners for money
Montreal police arrest 13 suspected of extorting restaurant owners for money

CBC

time5 minutes ago

  • CBC

Montreal police arrest 13 suspected of extorting restaurant owners for money

Montreal police say they've arrested 13 people suspected of using violence and intimidation to extort money from restaurateurs. The three main suspects arrested Wednesday, men aged 25, 34, and 39, are believed to be connected to a series of extortion crimes targeting the owners of two restaurants in the Ville-Marie borough and their associates, according to a news release by the Service de police de la Ville de Montréal (SPVM). In addition to the three main suspects, the other individuals arrested are eight men and two women, aged 28 to 44. Some of the 13 suspects arrested will appear in court within the next 24 hours. The others will be released on a promise to appear, with strict conditions to follow. The two restaurants targeted belong to the same owners. These alleged crimes include one in February where a restaurant's glass facade was shot on Ste-Catherine Street West, near De Bleury Street. Another restaurant owned by the victims was also targeted, as was the residence of one of the co-owners, the SPVM says. Along with the arrests, 15 search warrants were executed in Montreal, Dollard-des-Ormeaux, Châteauguay and Laval. A total of 150 officers participated. The SPVM investigation found two independent cells that allegedly attempted to extort the same restaurateurs, police say. Members of these cells are also involved in other criminal activities, such as drug trafficking, the SPVM says. The searches conducted Wednesday resulted in the seizure of three firearms, half a kilogram of cocaine, half a kilogram of crystal methamphetamine, thousands of speed pills and nearly $120,000 in cash. "Today's operation demonstrates that when acts of intimidation against business owners are brought to our attention, the SPVM is able to deliver effective blows against the responsible criminals," said SPVM Cmdr. Pierre-Marc Houle in the news release. "We have other ongoing investigations concerning similar incidents, and we are confident they will lead to additional arrests." Dominique Tremblay, a spokeswoman for the Quebec restaurateurs association, said her organization has been collaborating with the SPVM and sending information to members about the situation — asking them to come forward if they hear anything or face extortion themselves. "If they see something, hear something around them, it's important to communicate with police, give them the information so they can act," she said. She said it is stressful for bar and restaurant owners who go through this, and sometimes they don't come forward about the extortion out of fear. Luc Rabouin, mayor of the Plateau-Mont-Royal borough and chair of the city's executive committee, said his administration knew the investigation was underway, but wasn't given exact details. "There's no place for these crimes here in Montreal," said Rabouin, who was chosen to replace Mayor Valérie Plante as leader of Projet Montréal. "And we will not tolerate anything like that right now and in the future." Extortion not a new problem Back in October 2024, Montreal police Chief Fady Dagher urged merchants and parents to work with police to help curb the increasing involvement of young teenagers in organized crime and a surge in extortion of downtown businesses. This followed several suspected extortion attempts that are believed to be behind a spate of firebombings. A that time, Francis Renaud, head of the Montreal police organized crime unit, told reporters that about 40 attempted extortion cases have come across his desk since the summer, primarily in the downtown area. He said all kinds of business are being targeted, including clean ones and those tied to organized crime. Two years ago, in April 2023, a restaurant in Laval, Que., closed as a result of repeated firebombings and an extortion attempt. The vandalism, which started happening after the restaurant refused to pay when a stranger offered it "protection," led to its insurance being revoked, Kevin Al-Sabek, the son of one the owners, said in an interview at the time. Al-Sabek said the restaurant did manage to secure another insurer, but that happened past the landlord's deadline, voiding their lease agreement and forcing them to close. He decided not to change locations over fears the extortion would follow him to the new location. Al-Sabek's closure came just a month after Montreal police arrested 19 people in connection to dozens of cases of violence and intimidation targeting local businesses.

E-bikes prove popular in Halifax while raising concerns for advocacy group
E-bikes prove popular in Halifax while raising concerns for advocacy group

CTV News

time15 minutes ago

  • CTV News

E-bikes prove popular in Halifax while raising concerns for advocacy group

Bird Canada has brought 300 e-scooters and 200 e-bikes to the Halifax region and says in the first 20 days these devices have received more usage here than when the company first introduced them to other cities. Austin Spademan with Bird Canada even says it's 'record breaking' in terms of initial usage. 'We have already clocked over 24,000 kilometers, which is crazy, and across 3,600 Haligonians have used our service. They are riding an average of 2.36 rides per rider,' says Spademan. 'I think it's great to have more active transportation options,' says Alex Setchell, a Halifax resident. Bird Canada, a Canadian company, has a goal of getting people out of their vehicles. 'Both e-scooters and e-bikes are important tools in the tool kits to give people compelling alternatives to either get straight from where they live to run errands within the community or more importantly connect more with other transit options to completely decouple from completely needing a car to get from point A to point B,' says Spademan. Brynn Budden, public affairs advisor with the Halifax Regional Municipality, says the pilot projects for the e-scooters and e-bikes aim to provide mobility options to residents. 'The system is designed to be affordable and easy to use for both residents and visitors and will complement other existing modes of transportation including Halifax Transit,' says Budden. Bird Canada hopes to grow north of Highway 102 and into Burnside, but for now they are taking things slow. 'We have entered a smaller operating area more, it mainly covers downtown and a few other main areas that are those flex flare zones that I mentioned that we built with the United Way. We are going to grow from here with fleet increases over time as the usage dictates that we could use more vehicles. We are going to do this in partnership with HR,' says Spademan. Anyone can use them but there are rules. 'Definitely should be using the road and all the bike infrastructure, not the sidewalk. In fact, if you are riding on the sidewalk, we can tell,' says Spademan. The devices have sensors that can detect if it's in an area where it's not permitted. They also automatically reduce their speed in designated slow zones. There are consequences for riders who don't follow the guidelines. 'We may give you an email as a rider saying, 'Hey, you know, that's not allowed and you might get in trouble for it so do not be riding on the sidewalks,'' says Spademan. The CNIB Foundation feels those consequences are not enough, and it has concerned for visually-impaired people. 'CNIB has done a lot of advocacies nationwide with e-scooter companies as well as municipal officials and the issues seem to be persisting so I am planning on reaching out to the city to discuss the issue further,' says Shelley Adams, CNIB manager for Atlantic Canada. Tara Niecamp, strategic leadership council co-chair with CNIB, feels not everyone is going to follow the rules. 'For those cases where the policy is not enough, there needs to be really strict penalties, whether that comes down to a financial penalty or revoking of the account for those that don't follow the rules.' says Niecamp. 'For individuals with low vision or who are blind, it's not that easy. Walking, you may not see the device which means that you could trip and fall.' Bird Canada says when they introduced these devices in Ottawa, they worked with groups like the Canadian National Institute for the Blind and have developed a lot of features to make their products less of a potential conflict. 'A lot of that revolves around that parking technology I mentioned, just making sure when our devices are parked that they are out of the public right of way,' says Spademan. The CNIB wants people held accountable. 'The municipality needs to hold the e scooter companies accountable for that and in order to do that the municipality needs to have a system in place where they can track the e-scooters being improperly used,' says Niecamp. 'When you are living with a disability, you are encountering barriers constantly and it is requiring a lot of mental energy even to advocate and report them.' Some Halifax residents say they love the idea, but feel there are a few drawbacks. 'I love this idea of having more transportation options like that aren't vehicles in the city but it was way too expensive and it cost about $15 just to get from the commons down to the waterfront and it was pretty direct and I didn't have to wait a whole lot and also it's not a comfortable ride,' says Shannon Kam. 'The cost goes up pretty quickly if you don't think about it. It will be about $3 a minute sometimes, which is a lot, you know,' says Quinn Marnitz. The municipality admits the project is still in the early stages so components like parking locations and sidewalk detection technologies are still being fine-tuned. E-scooters Hundreds of e-scooters and e-bikes have arrived in Halifax. (Source: Emma Convey/CTV News Atlantic) For more Nova Scotia news, visit our dedicated provincial page

NS Power CEO, staff questioned over data breach that saw 280,000 customers' data stolen
NS Power CEO, staff questioned over data breach that saw 280,000 customers' data stolen

Globe and Mail

time22 minutes ago

  • Globe and Mail

NS Power CEO, staff questioned over data breach that saw 280,000 customers' data stolen

Nova Scotians have lost trust in the province's largest electric utility, provincial politicians said Wednesday during a heated committee meeting that raised tough questions about the recent ransomware attack on Nova Scotia Power. The cybersecurity breach gave thieves access to personal and financial data belonging to 280,000 ratepayers – about half of the utility's customers. Members of the public accounts committee grilled Nova Scotia Power CEO Peter Gregg and two other senior staff members, asking them how the breach happened and what the company will do to protect ratepayers from financial harm. 'We understand it is very concerning, and we're working hard to address customer issues and to continue to strengthen our systems as we work to restore and rebuild,' Gregg told the committee. Hackers may have stolen up to 140,000 social insurance numbers in NS Power database breach By the time the meeting was over, however, the executives had very little new information to share. 'We have, as far as we understand, 140,000 Nova Scotians who have had their social insurance numbers stolen, and those people are furious,' NDP Leader Claudia Chender told the committee. Gregg said the company, a subsidiary of Halifax-based Emera Inc. EMA-T, identified unusual activity on their servers on April 25, but they later determined the cyber-thieves had accessed the system as early as March 19. The utility has since sent letters to customers informing them the stolen data may include their names, birth dates, e-mail addresses, home addresses, customer account information, driver's licence numbers and, in some cases, bank account numbers and social insurance numbers. The cyberattack affected almost half of the utility's 525,000 customers. Gregg confirmed the company had previously collected social insurance numbers to authenticate customers' identities in cases where multiple customers had the same name, but he said that practice has stopped. The utility now requests only the last three digits of each customer's social insurance number, which is not stored. Still, Chender pressed utility executives to explain why Nova Scotia Power continues to store the full social insurance numbers it had previously collected. But they declined to say, citing an ongoing investigation. 'I don't have an answer for you today,' Gregg said. Chender said Gregg's response was disappointing. 'With stronger safety protocols, Nova Scotians would be protected,' she said. The NDP leader went on to ask how affected ratepayers would be compensated for potential losses. Again, Gregg did not directly answer, saying the utility is offering customers a two-year subscription for credit monitoring, which might be extended. Progressive Conservative member Brian Wong said Nova Scotians deserve better. 'We have Nova Scotians that aren't just scared, they're angry,' he told Gregg. When asked by multiple committee members if Nova Scotia Power would commit to covering the costs of the breach internally rather than handing the bill to ratepayers, Gregg again avoided a direct answer. He said Nova Scotia Power's cybersecurity insurance would likely cover many expenses, but he said the utility doesn't yet know the cost of the breach. 'Until we get further into this investigation and determine total cost, I can't give you a yes or no answer.' Liberal member Derek Mombourquette said Nova Scotia Power's first step toward rebuilding public trust should be promising not to pass on costs to consumers who have long complained about soaring electricity bills and frequent power outages. 'There is no trust with Nova Scotia Power right now,' Mombourquette said after the meeting. 'I don't believe what we heard in the committee today has done any more to reassure the customers.' As the meeting concluded, Chender put forward a motion to request the province's auditor general investigate the breach, which was adopted. Meanwhile, the federal privacy commissioner has already launched an investigation. Philippe Dufresne issued a statement last week saying he started the probe after receiving complaints about the security breach in April.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store