Korean Supreme Court rules 'Baby Shark' not a case of plagiarism; scores victory for Pinkfong in 3 Million copyright case
After a six-year battle, the South Korea's Supreme Court has ruled that Pinkfong's hit children's song 'Baby Shark', is not a case of plagiarism.
The dispute began when American composer Jonathan Robert Wright alleged that Pinkfong's 2015 Korean version, and the latter 2016 English version, were copied from his 2011 arrangement of the folk tune.
He demanded damages of about ₩3 million. But, according to the court's ruling, both his work and Pinkfong's are rearrangements of a traditional song with no single copyright owner.
Reason Behind The Verdict
According to the judgment reported by Yonhap News, Wright's version lacked enough originality to be considered a secondary copyrighted work.
The Korean Copyright Commission's evaluation, cited by the court, found that his 2011 song added only instruments like electric guitar and synthesizers to a melody already sung for generations in camps and classrooms.
Under Korean law, familiarity and widespread oral tradition outweighed his claim to exclusive ownership.
Song's Record-Breaking 10 billion views
Pinkfong (then SmartStudy) gave 'Baby Shark' its now-iconic "Ah~ gi shark, doo roo doo roo" hook and bouncy animation in 2015, followed by a bubbly English version in 2016. That version went from a local children's song to world's most-viewed YouTube video in November 2020, and in January 2022, it became the first video ever to surpass 10 billion views (YouTube public data).
A win for creativity
The Supreme Court's verdict, grounded in legal reasoning but resonating with playgrounds worldwide, protects Pinkfong's adaptations while affirming that some songs are part of humanity's collective memory.
"Get the latest news updates on Times of India, including reviews of the movie
Coolie
and
War 2
."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Sunita Ahuja Breaks Down, Addresses Govinda Divorce Rumours: 'Mera Ghar Todne Ki Koshish...'
Last Updated: Govinda and Sunita Ahuja have been married for 37 years now and are parents to two children – Tina and Yashvardan. Govinda's wife, Sunita Ahuja, broke down in her first YouTube vlog, addressing her divorce rumours. The couple has been married for 37 years now and are parents to two children – Tina and Yashvardan. However, earlier this year, it was reported that Govinda and Sunita were planning to part ways. Sunita Ahuja Addresses Divorce Rumours In her vlog, Sunita visited the Maa Mahakali Temple, where a priest asked her why she prayed to the goddess for the first time. At this, Sunita broke down and said, 'When I met Govinda, I prayed that I get married to him and that my life goes well." She then addressed her divorce rumours and added, 'Koi bhi mera ghar todne ki koshish kare…jo bhi mera dil dukhayega, yeh Maa Kali sabke gale kaat k rakh degi. Ek acche insaan ko, acchi aurat ko dukh dena acchi baat nahi hai. Mujhe aur kisipe vishwas nahi hai (Whoever tries to break my home…whoever hurts me, Maa Kali will punish them. It's not right to hurt a good person, a good woman. I trust no one else)." When Govinda And Sunita Ahuja's Divorce Rumours Made Headlines In February this year, several media reports claimed that Govinda and Sunita Ahuja had decided to part ways owing to constant disagreements and varied lifestyles. It was also said that Govinda's growing closeness to a 30-year-old Marathi actress is reportedly a major factor in their alleged split. Later, their lawyer also stated that even though the couple had filed for divorce six months back, they were getting back together. Lalit Bindal, who is also the actor's family friend, shared that Govinda and Sunita are 'going strong" and that they will always be together. Sunita Also Addressed Divorce Rumours Previously Later, Sunita also called the chatter 'baseless' and stressed that no one should believe rumours without hearing the truth directly from those involved. 'Jis din confirm hoga, ya mere aur Govinda ke mu se aap log sunoge, vo alag baat hai," she said. 'But I don't think Govinda can live without me, nor can I live without Govinda. And Govinda can never leave his family for any stupid person or stupid woman." First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Logan Paul marries model Nina Agdal in romantic Lake Como ceremony ahead of John Cena clash
WWE star Logan Paul and Sports Illustrated model Nina Agdal tied the knot in a lavish wedding at Lake Como, Italy, on Friday, August 15, with close family and friends in attendance. Logan Paul and Nina Agdal tied the knot in Italy (Instagram/@jakepaul) A lakeside celebration The 30-year-old YouTube personality and WWE wrestler exchanged vows with 33-year-old Agdal at a scenic venue overlooking Lake Como, according to a report in E News. Paul wore a white tuxedo jacket with black trousers, while Agdal stunned in a traditional wedding gown. Jake Paul, Logan's younger brother, shared clips of the ceremony on Instagram, showing the couple saying their vows. He admitted the moment moved him deeply, captioning his post: 'I've seriously been crying.' A venue with a special meaning Lake Como holds special meaning for the couple. It was here in July 2023 that Logan proposed, just over a year after they were first spotted together at a London restaurant in early 2022. By the end of that year, the pair made their relationship Instagram official. Their wedding venue echoed the proposal spot, with floral arrangements surrounding a raised platform where Paul's Impaulsive podcast co-host, Mike Majlak, appeared to officiate. Family by their side The couple's 10-month-old daughter, Esmé, was present for the ceremony, along with Jake Paul and his fiancée, Dutch speed skater Jutta Leerdam. Jake also shared behind-the-scenes glimpses of the lakeside views and family photos. Milestones in their relationship Paul and Agdal dated for less than two years before getting engaged. Since then, they've marked several major milestones. On their first anniversary in May 2023, Logan paid tribute to his 'Danish queen' on Instagram, writing: 'One very special year with my Danish queen @ninaagdal.' In April 2024, the pair announced they were expecting their first child. Paul posted a photo of them holding up a sonogram, captioning it: 'Another Paul coming this Fall.' Their daughter Esmé arrived in September 2024. Career spotlight Paul's wedding comes during a peak in his professional career. Since debuting with WWE in 2022, he has seen his profile soar, recently appearing at Yankee Stadium ahead of SummerSlam and posing with baseball star Aaron Judge. He is scheduled to face John Cena in a singles match at WWE Clash in Paris on August 31, according to a New York Post report.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
'4 The People' trend - Why the film is getting love in 2025 and its cult status
(Picture Courtesy: Facebook) Two decades after its release, Jayaraj 's 2004 Malayalam film '4 The People' is enjoying an unexpected second life in 2025. Social media timelines, particularly on X, are flooded with nostalgic posts and excited rediscoveries of the vigilante thriller that once turned heads for its audacity. A 2004 film finding fresh relevance The story following four college students who take the law into their own hands to fight corruption, feels eerily relevant today, as debates over governance, accountability, and youth-led activism dominate India's political discourse. Many online users call it 'ahead of its time,' pointing to how its central message mirrors current frustrations with systemic issues. Check Out Popular Malayalam Music Audio Song 'Lajjavathiye' From Movie '4 The People' Sung By Jassie Gift Starring Bharath And Gopika (Picture Courtesy: Facebook) Style, sound, and storytelling that still feel fresh Back in 2004, '4 The People' broke the mould with its slick pacing, stylish cinematography, and high-energy soundtrack by Jassie Gift. The chartbuster 'Lajjavathiye' became a cultural phenomenon, and even now, fan edits and reels featuring the song are racking up views on Instagram and YouTube. Viewers are finding that the film's combination of social commentary and youthful swagger hasn't aged — if anything, it feels more impactful in today's climate. Film buffs on platforms like IMDb praise its raw energy and note how it influenced later vigilante dramas across Indian cinema. "I believe there is an audience for a slightly more nuanced film" - Director Jayaraj Mollywood director Jayaraj is surely one of the unique filmmakers who doesn't love to remain in a comfort zone. From drama to horror, the ace director who made 'Four the People' has indeed placed his hands on every genres. In an exclusive chat with ETimes, the filmmaker said, "'I believe there is an audience for a slightly more nuanced film. Films where everything is not so obvious to you (audience), or every thought of the character is not spelled out." Talking about his film 'Oru Perumgaliyattam', Jayaraj said, "'Oru Perumgaliyattam' also goes into that category. In this (Mollywood) industry, we feel there is also space for this kind of cinema.' A cult revival The film's current wave of popularity is also thanks to accessibility. Available on Amazon Prime and YouTube, 4 The People is reaching audiences who either missed it the first time or are eager to revisit it. Regional cinema enthusiasts frequently list it alongside other iconic early-2000s films that shaped an era. This year marks the movie's 21st anniversary, and media retrospectives — along with fan campaigns — have only intensified the buzz. From memes celebrating its dialogues to posts lauding Bharath, Arun, and Jayaraj's vision, the film has transitioned from a hit of its time to a cultural reference point. In 2025, '4 The People' isn't just a film remembered fondly — it's a story reinterpreted through the lens of a generation still wrestling with the same questions it asked 21 years ago. "Get the latest news updates on Times of India, including reviews of the movie Coolie and War 2 ."
