Schools' admission policies placing barriers to children with autism, study finds
Almost all schools inspected for a sample study had clauses in their admissions policies which could restrict the enrolment of children with autism and other learning difficulties.
The findings have prompted Minister for Education Helen McEntee to write to all school patron bodies requesting them to review their schools' admission policies to ensure they adhere to legal requirements.
It follows the publication on Wednesday of a review of admission policies for special classes at 30 schools – 15 primary and 15 post-primary – carried out by the Department of Education's inspectorate between September and December 2024.
The review found 'almost all' admission policies contained conditions which could limit access to appropriate education for autistic children such as requiring children to be able to participate in mainstream classes; restricting admission to children with a certain level of disability; or refusing to admit children on the basis of their potential behaviour.
READ MORE
The department's chief inspector Yvonne Keating described the findings as 'concerning'.
There are more than 3,335 special classes in operation across hundreds of primary and second-level schools, catering to almost 20,000 children with autism and other conditions.
The review comes as education authorities struggle to find enough appropriate school places for rising numbers of children with a diagnosis of additional needs.
Schools are required to adhere to legal requirements, guidelines and circulars issued by the Department of Education on provision for children and young people with special educational needs.
The report emphasises the importance of schools fulfilling their legislative responsibilities in a way that ensures 'children with the greatest need have priority access to special class placements'.
[
The Irish Times view on autism and education: State is still playing catch up
Opens in new window
]
Special classes for autistic children are specifically designed for those unable to access the curriculum in a mainstream class, even with support, for most or all the school day.
However, one post-primary school had a clause in its admissions stating that 'students who apply must have an ability to meaningfully participate in mainstream classes in order to be considered for enrolment in the ASD [autism spectrum disorder] class'.
In addition, some schools were found to be limiting access to enrolments based on certain levels of learning disability, such as mild, moderate or severe/profound.
In one case, a primary school's policy stated that 'if a child presents with a general learning disability, it must fall within the mild range'.
Education authorities, however, specifically state that schools should not exclude students from a special class based on their category of learning disability.
Many schools – 40 per cent of post-primary and 60 per cent of the primary schools in the study – also had clauses that prioritise students who were already enrolled in the school policies.
Other admission policies referred to the availability of resources as a potential barrier to enrolment in a special class.
In a statement, Ms McEntee said a school's admission policy was often the first point of contact between a school, prospective students and their families.
'It is vital that spaces in these classes are available to those who need them.'
In addition, she requested the inspectorate to provide an annual report on the implementation of admission policies in schools.
Privately, many school principals complain that they do not have the resources or expertise to meet the needs of children with more complex needs.
They point to 'chaotic' planning, a lack of training among teaching staff and difficulty accessing therapeutic services which are vital in many cases in fulfilling the potential of vulnerable children.
Advocacy groups for autistic children, by contrast, say families face a series of 'soft barriers' from schools and restrictive admission policies.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Maybe because I spend so much time with men, I feel less pressure to talk for the sake of talking
There was a time that, faced with the discomfort of silence, I would have told someone about my last smear test to fight the absence of sound between us. Going out for a meal with a large group of people, I'd groan internally when I realised that I was seated next to a craic vortex who would suck the energy out of me like a conversational drain, because human silence can be demanding. Then there are people with a strong quietness, like my neighbour. She seems cool, and there's scope for us to be friends, but each time I close the door after speaking to her, I slap my forehead and think, Why did I say that? There's something circumspect in her few words that ramps up my gawkiness. A friend of mine working in technology used to talk about using silence as a power tactic in the office. I didn't take any notice of it then because he also said things like 'blue sky meetings', but I'm learning how talking less can draw out buried secrets and stories, and how it can disarm and fluster your adversary. It needs to be used sparingly, and this delicate tool is not an excuse for shutting someone out, in which case, the silence is deafening. [ What Irish people really mean when they say they're grand, fine, okay or surviving Opens in new window ] Some conversations have no room for silence because the talking is competitive. Each of you is breathlessly nodding, chomping down the other's tale, at last reaching a juncture where the listener becomes the speaker and can release the story bursting from their mouth. I was travelling with a woman recently for two solid days, and we had a lovely equilibrium of exchange. I told her about how I thought there might be a poltergeist in my house. She gasped, sought more detail, and when I finished, she said, 'I'm so glad you said all that because now I can tell you about my supernatural experiences.' She gripped me with memories of a banshee's wails gliding across a black field in Cavan . We had found a happy seesaw, but there is effort in this, lest you be accused of conversational narcissism, of not genuinely listening, but rather, of greedily exploiting the unfinished point of the speaker to turn the conversation back to you. READ MORE I used to have a ferocious appetite for knowledge of other people, which meant that I would happily take on the responsibility of creating and maintaining dialogue, but lately this has waned. Recently, I met my brother-in-law, who lives in Australia. I asked him a series of questions about things that I thought might be pertinent to his life, which he duly answered. I ran out of energy quickly and I told him in good humour that I was out of questions. That's okay, he told me, and I felt that it was. I'm moving away from lining up a pop quiz based on work, friends, health, family, and holidays. It's unnerving. At a volunteer party at the football club, I walked in, slightly nervous, and sat down next to a deadpan kind of fella, whose big move is the power of mumbling. I abandoned my mental list of topics, relieved myself of meaningless jibber-jabber, and our conversation quickly turned into an unexpected and mind-altering discussion. Maybe because I spend so much time with men, I not only feel less pressure to talk for the sake of talking, but I have gone as far as to enjoy the silence. I've noticed that, particularly with my close male friends, we can allow our chat to peter out. There is so much beauty in those quiet moments, side by side. When our voices fade, emotions have a chance to surface, and in that comfortable hush, there's a feeling of security and love. [ I love being called 'love', although there are some exceptions Opens in new window ] Going to football matches in particular has taught me when to talk, and when to let go of any ego related to feeling unheard, because even earth-shattering news has no chance of getting aired if the football is good. On the sidelines is a sacred space where conversation, when offered, is unforced. I was at a match recently with six lovely lads, five of whom I barely know. The game wasn't great, giving more scope for chat, but a good bit of seat-swapping prevented any real flow or depth of conversation. A bag of Munchies was passed around and we each insipidly noted whether or not our square had any biscuit in it. The quietness on the pitch and in the stands created a sense of boredom. On the back of the Munchies chat, I asked the man to my left what chocolate he would pick if he went into a shop. Rolos, he told me. I grimaced, and everyone within earshot laid into him, setting off an animated conversation on the social acceptability of each of our nominations. We learned something about each other, and had a laugh about toffee-based treats. We were clamouring to have our preference heard when one of our players made a run for the goal with the ball at his toes, and we collectively fell into anticipatory silence.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Sky high prices leave readers baffled on behalf of older relatives
The idea that a television service provider would be taking well over €100 a month off people who can perhaps ill afford it without being able to adequately explain what is going on is pretty awful. But it enters the realm of appalling if those people are older, and might be struggling to get on top of their day-to-day finances. We have two stories connected to Sky Television that are strikingly similar, and involve family members seeking help for older people. 'I am writing on behalf of my elderly father-in-law,' begins a mail from a reader called Jacinta. READ MORE On October 30th last year, he had contacted Sky, as he was concerned about being charged a monthly fee of €120, she explains. 'He verbally agreed to a new monthly contract of €84.50 for six months and was told he should contact the company when that timeframe had elapsed to agree the next charges.' She says that on February 19th the charge was €85.14, and on March 18th the charge was €87.50. She says there was 'no notification of an increase'. [ Sky broadband blues: 'During the day, it stayed working. After 8pm, zilch' Opens in new window ] Then on April 16th 'the new charges were €105.80. This was within the six months period and there was absolutely no notification. On May 16th charges were €121 – an almost 50 per cent increase inside a few weeks with absolutely no notification." 'My father-in-law is in his 70s, and suffers chronic health, and talking at times on the phone can greatly exacerbate his breathing [problems]. It's not possible to email Sky, though you can call and be left usually up to 45 mins before you get to talk with someone and all that, apart from their charges. Sky can charge whatever they wish whenever they wish. Neither Comreg nor CCPC want to know as it's not their area.' Then there is the story about a woman in her 80s who appears to be paying an awful lot for very little. The story was shared with us by her nephew. 'I've an aunt in her late 80s who spent her life giving of herself to others,' begins the mail. 'She doesn't ask for much and uses TV to watch the news in her kitchen, and one other channel that's free on the internet. For quite some time she couldn't get Sky to work on the TV in the kitchen. I assumed it was because the TV was old, so I bought her a new one. The problem persists.' Our reader asked her aunt how much she pays, and whether she had the account details. 'The only information she could find was on her bank account, and she became upset as she realised how much they were taking from her account every month (average €150-plus). 'I work abroad, so rarely get the opportunity to resolve problems for her, but the week before last, after a lot of searching, managed to get through to Sky by phone. They went through security with my aunt and, after a few minutes, the call disconnected.' He says that he tried four times 'going through the same process, getting various levels of sympathy and assurances, but each time the calls eventually disconnected. This weekend I checked with my aunt. She'd received no mail or follow up of any sort,' he writes. 'My aunt's a trusting and generous person, and it seems as if Sky are happy to take advantage, deliberately make it incredibly difficult to contact them, and apparently impossible to get support.' It seems to Pricewatch that both of these people are is paying way over the odds for their television service but it also seems like they have both struggled to find out exactly what they are paying for. We contacted Sky. In connection with our first story a spokeswoman said Sky is 'committed to supporting all of its customers. In our efforts to provide fast and efficient customer support, our billing teams have maintained an average call response time of just 58 seconds year-to-date.' 'The customer in question regularly availed of promotional offers as a long-time customer with Sky. However, now that we are aware of the customer's health condition, we believe he would benefit from Sky's dedicated accessibility service, which provides tailored care and alternative contact methods to support customers who may need additional assistance. We have since outreached to the customer to support with this.' And when it came to the second story she said the company was 'sorry to hear about this customer's experience, which was unfortunately due to an initial miscommunication while resolving a technical issue. We have since spoken with the customer to apply the due credit on their account and ensure they are set up correctly.'
Irish Daily Mirror
4 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Families offered €2k to send kids to class to keep teacher at Gaeltacht school
A school is offering €2,000 to attract pupils to stop the Government taking one of its teachers due to falling student numbers. The €2,000 is provided as a bursary, which is a non-repayable financial aid for attending school, to bolster the number of pupils on the register. Without new students, Scoil Naomh Pádraig in the beautiful Galway gaeltacht will lose one of its two teachers in September. Its acting principal claimed the €2,000, which is to be paid in two instalments over two years, is needed as securing a second teacher is "critically important". Linda Ní Dhroighneáin said: "It isn't just a luxury; it's a necessity for delivering equitable, effective and sustainable education. It strengthens academic outcomes, supports teacher wellbeing and fosters a more inclusive and dynamic learning environment." The Irish language school near Corrib Lough in Connemara is set to lose a teacher because three of its seven pupils are leaving this month. Scoil Naomh Pádraig was established in the 1890s, was expanded in 1965, and has been attended by generations of children, including local dad Paddy Curran. Parent and committee member Paddy explained that the school needs 11 pupils to retain the second teacher so seven more enrolments are needed by September. As part of this, the parents' committee helped to raise €14,000 for the €2,000 bursaries for seven families who send their children to the school. Paddy, who attended the school in 1989 when there were 36 pupils, said: "There is loads of interest in this. We had a similar initiative in 2022. We're very confident that this is going to work. "The irony now is that there are lots of babies and toddlers in the area. There are about 14 who will start in the school in the next few years. So what is the point in losing a teacher?" He added: "During Covid, and even afterwards, families moved back here, which definitely was very positive for the school and community." He claimed that if the school loses a teacher for the coming year, the Department of Education will have to find a new one in a few years' time. The Irish Mirror asked the department for a response. Ireland has 1,271 schools with four teachers or less and these account for 39 per cent of all primary schools in the country but educate just under 13 per cent of all students. There are nine schools with just one teacher, there are 490 schools with two teachers, 363 with three and 409 with four.
