Companies are pouring billions into AI. It has yet to pay off.
Corporate spending on artificial intelligence is surging as executives bank on major efficiency gains. So far, they report little effect to the bottom line.
Nearly four decades ago, when the personal computer boom was in full swing, a phenomenon known as the 'productivity paradox' emerged.
It was a reference to how, despite companies' huge investments in new technology, there was scant evidence of a corresponding gain in workers' efficiency.
Today, the same paradox is appearing, but with generative artificial intelligence (Gen AI). According to recent research by McKinsey & Co, nearly eight in 10 companies have reported using Gen AI, but just as many have reported 'no significant bottom-line impact'.
AI technology has been racing ahead with chatbots such as ChatGPT, fuelled by a high-stakes arms race among tech giants and super-rich startups, and prompting an expectation that everything from back-office accounting to customer service will be revolutionised. But the payoff for businesses outside the tech sector is lagging behind, plagued by issues including an irritating tendency by chatbots to make stuff up.
That means that businesses will have to continue to invest billions to avoid falling behind – but it could be years before the technology delivers an economy-wide payoff, as companies gradually figure out what works best.
Call it the 'gen AI paradox,' as McKinsey did in its research report. Investments in Gen AI by businesses are expected to increase 94 per cent in 2025 to US$61.9 billion (S$79.5 billion), according to IDC, a technology research firm.
But the percentage of companies abandoning most of their AI pilot projects soared to 42 per cent by the end of 2024, up from 17 per cent the previous year, according to a survey of more than 1,000 technology and business managers by S&P Global, a data and analytics firm.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore I want to divorce my husband and be a single mother: More victims speaking up on emotional abuse
World Trump drops Ukraine ceasefire demand after Putin summit
Singapore Buying hope: Inside S'pore's love affair with the lottery
Singapore She won big in Genting, but getting $240k winnings back to Singapore was dicey
Opinion Confessions of a born-again Singaporean
Business Manage your household finances like a business for clarity, say entrepreneurs
Business Silence does not work when dealing with job loss blues
Singapore Singapore congratulates Indonesia on 80th Independence Day
Projects failed not only because of technical hurdles, but often also because of 'human factors' like employee and customer resistance or lack of skills, said S&P Global senior analyst Alexander Johnston.
Gartner, a research and advisory firm that charts technological 'hype cycles', predicts that AI is sliding towards a stage it calls 'the trough of disillusionment'.
The low point is expected next year, before the technology eventually becomes a proven productivity tool, said Gartner chief forecaster John-David Lovelock.
That was the pattern with past technologies such as personal computers and the internet – early exuberance, the hard slog of mastering a technology, followed by a transformation of industries and work.
The winners so far have been the suppliers of AI technology and advice. They include Microsoft, Amazon and Google, which offer AI software, while Nvidia is the runaway leader in AI chips.
Executives at those companies have bragged how AI is reshaping their own workforces, eliminating the need for some entry-level coding work and making other workers more efficient.
AI will eventually replace entire swaths of human employees, many predict, a perspective that is being widely embraced and echoed in the corporate mainstream. At the Aspen Ideas Festival in June, Mr Jim Farley, chief executive of Ford Motor, said: 'Artificial intelligence is going to replace literally half of all white-collar workers in the US.'
Whether that type of revolutionary change occurs, and how soon, depends on the real-world testing ground of many businesses.
'The raw technological horsepower is terrific, but it's not going to determine how quickly AI transforms the economy,' said Mr Andrew McAfee, a principal research scientist and co-director of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology's (MIT) Initiative on the Digital Economy.
Still, some businesses are finding ways to incorporate AI – although in most cases the technology is still a long way from replacing workers.
One company where AI's promise and flaws are playing out is USAA, which provides insurance and banking services to members of the military and their families.
After several pilot projects, some of which it closed down, the company introduced an AI assistant to help its 16,000 customer service workers provide correct answers to specific questions.
USAA is tracking its AI investments, but does not yet have a calculation of the financial payoff, if any, for the call centre software.
But the response from its workers, the company said, has been overwhelmingly positive. While it has software apps for answering customer questions online, its call centres field an average of 200,000 calls a day.
'Those are moments that matter,' said Mr Ramnik Bajaj, the company's chief data analytics and AI officer. 'They want a human voice at the other end of the phone.'
That's similar to an AI app developed more than a year ago for fieldworkers at Johnson Controls, a large supplier of building equipment, software and services.
The company fed its operating and service manuals for its machines into an AI program that has been trained to generate a problem summary, suggest repairs and deliver it all to the technician's tablet computer.
In testing, the app has trimmed 10 to 15 minutes off a repair call of an hour or more – a useful efficiency gain, but hardly a workplace transformation on its own.
Fewer than 2,000 of the company's 25,000 field service workers have access to the AI helper, although the company is planning an expansion.
'It's still pretty early days, but the idea is that over time, everyone will use it,' said Mr Vijay Sankaran, the chief digital and information officer at Johnson Controls.
The long-term vision is that companies will use AI to improve multiple systems, including sales, procurement, manufacturing, customer service and finance, he said.
'That's the game changer,' said Mr Sankaran, who predicts that shift will take at least five years.
Two years ago, JPMorgan Chase, the nation's largest bank, blocked access to ChatGPT from its computers because of potential security risks. Only a few hundred data scientists and engineers were allowed to experiment with AI.
Today, about 200,000 of the bank's employees have access to a general-purpose AI assistant – essentially a business chatbot – from their work computers for tasks such as retrieving data, answering business questions and writing reports.
The assistant, tailored for JPMorgan's use, taps into ChatGPT and other AI tools, while ensuring data security for confidential bank and customer information. Roughly half of the workers use it regularly and report spending up to four hours less a week on basic office tasks, the company said.
The bank's wealth advisers are also employing a more specialised AI assistant, which uses bank, market and customer data to provide wealthy clients with investment research and advice. The bank says it retrieves information and helps advisers make investment recommendations nearly twice as fast as they could before, increasing sales.
Ms Lori Beer, the global chief information officer at JPMorgan, oversees a worldwide technology staff of 60,000. Has she shut down AI projects? Probably hundreds in total, she said.
But many of the shelved prototypes, she said, developed concepts and code that were folded into other, continuing projects.
'We're absolutely shutting things down,' Ms Beer said. 'We're not afraid to shut things down. We don't think it's a bad thing. I think it's a smart thing.'
Mr McAfee, the MIT research scientist, agreed.
'It's not surprising that early AI efforts are falling short,' said Mr McAfee, who is a founder of Workhelix, an AI consulting firm. 'Innovation is a process of failing fairly regularly.' NYTIMES
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Modi's tax overhaul to strain finances but boost image amid US trade tensions
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox The latest initiative by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi marks the largest tax overhaul since 2017. NEW DELHI - Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's deepest tax cuts in eight years will strain government revenues but are winning praise from businesses and political pundits who say they will bolster his image in an ongoing trade fight with Washington. In the biggest tax overhaul since 2017, Mr Modi's government on Aug 16 announced sweeping changes to the complex goods and services tax (GST) regime which will make daily essentials and electronics cheaper from October, helping consumers and also companies like Nestle, Samsung and LG Electronics. At the same time, in his Independence Day speech on Aug 15, Mr Modi urged Indians to use more goods made domestically, echoing calls from many of his supporters to boycott US products after US President Donald Trump hiked tariffs on imports from India to 50 per cent as of Aug 27. The tax cut plan comes with costs given GST is a major revenue generator. IDFC First Bank says the cuts will boost India's GDP by 0.6 percentage points over 12 months but will cost the state and federal government US$20 billion (S$25.6 billion) annually. But it will improve weak stock market sentiment and bring political dividends for Mr Modi ahead of a critical state election in the eastern state of Bihar, said Mr Rasheed Kidwai, a fellow at New Delhi-based Observer Research Foundation. 'GST reduction will impact everyone, unlike cuts to income tax, which is paid by only 3 to 4 per cent of the population. Modi is doing this as he is under a lot of pressure due to US policies,' said Mr Kidwai. 'The move will also help the stock market, which is now politically important as it has a lot of retail investors.' Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Asia Mandarin with Taiwanese characteristics: Taipei leverages language as soft power tool Singapore I want to divorce my husband and be a single mother: More victims speaking up on emotional abuse Singapore She won big in Genting, but getting $240k winnings back to Singapore was dicey Singapore Buying hope: Inside S'pore's love affair with the lottery Asia Dozens injured after magnitude 6.0 quake strikes Sulawesi, Indonesia, official says Singapore Motorcyclist dies after multi-vehicle collision on TPE Life Stefanie Sun makes emotional concert return to Taiwan, where she made her debut India launched the major tax system in 2017 that subsumed local state taxes into the new, nationwide GST to unify its economy for the first time. But the biggest tax reform since India's independence faced criticism for its complex design that taxes products and services under four slabs - 5 per cent, 12 per cent, 18 per cent and 28 per cent. Last year, India said caramel popcorn would be taxed at 18 per cent but the salted category at 5 per cent, triggering criticism about a glaring example of GST's complexities. Under the new system, India will abolish the 28 per cent slab - which includes cars and electronics - and move nearly all of the items under the 12 per cent category to the lower 5 per cent slab, benefitting many more consumer items and packaged foods. Government data shows the 28 per cent and 12 per cent tax slabs together garner 16 per cent of India's annual GST revenue of roughly US$250 billion last fiscal year. 'A brighter gift' and politics Bihar is a key state politically and goes to the polls by November. A recent survey by the VoteVibe agency showed Mr Modi's opposition has an edge largely because of a lack of jobs. 'Any tax cut has wide public appreciation. But of course, the timing is purely determined by political exigencies,' said Mr Dilip Cherian, a communications consultant and co-founder of Indian public relations firm Perfect Relations. 'It seems to be an indication of some mixture of frustration as well as recognition that there is a broad public pushback against high and crippling rates of taxation.' Mr Modi's ruling Bharatiya Janata Party has seized on his tax announcement, posting on X that on the Hindu festival of lights, Diwali, 'a brighter gift of simpler taxes and more savings is waiting for every Indian.' Mr Modi has vowed to protect farmers, fishermen and cattlemen , following Mr Trump's surprise tariff announcement on India, after trade talks between New Delhi and Washington collapsed over disagreement on opening India's vast farm and dairy sectors and stopping Russian oil purchases. The latest round of trade talks between the two nations set for August 25 to 29 has also been called off.
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Can we just have one day when no one mentions AI?
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox The gap between hype and reality is frustratingly wide and growing. The writer says that since ChatGPT's launch, the gap between insider and amateur AI knowledge seems to be widening rather than narrowing. On the first Monday of August, artificial intelligence made it into headlines around the world more than 2,100 times. AI was reported to be scamming people in Malaysia; learning the Luganda language in Uganda; reshaping the Indian tech sector; and creating billionaires across the US and China.
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
German breweries are forced to adapt as Gen Z goes alcohol-free
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Some German breweries have begun to adapt by introducing alcohol-free beer, of which more than 800 varieties are now available in the country. Over the course of its 172-year-history, the Lang-Bräu brewery in the north of Bavaria has weathered two world wars and the fall of the Iron Curtain, whose defences once stood less than thirty minutes away. But money troubles in recent years proved more than the small operation could handle. Facing €12 million (S$18 million) in costs for much-needed upgrades, the owners decided last summer to shut everything down. 'Breweries are capable of incredible suffering,' said Mr Richard Hopf, who led the family business and is now overseeing its closure. 'But when sales fall and costs keep going up, it leaves little room for long-term considerations.' Lang-Bräu is in a situation that's familiar to many German brewers. Between inflation and higher energy prices, financial pressures on beermakers are mounting. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore I want to divorce my husband and be a single mother: More victims speaking up on emotional abuse World Trump drops Ukraine ceasefire demand after Putin summit Singapore Buying hope: Inside S'pore's love affair with the lottery Singapore She won big in Genting, but getting $240k winnings back to Singapore was dicey Life These cats may have disabilities, but they are resilient and capable of being affectionate Singapore PM Wong's National Day Rally speech to begin at 6.45pm on Aug 17 Singapore Motorcyclist dies after multi-vehicle collision on TPE Opinion Confessions of a born-again Singaporean Adding to this uncertainty is another sobering development: in a country long defined by its beer culture, fewer young people want to consume alcohol. For many Germans in Gen Z – which includes anybody born between 1997 and 2012 – beer is no longer a daily ritual but a rare indulgence. And when they do enjoy the occasional wheat beer or pilsner, they're increasingly likely to choose an alcohol-free option. Some breweries have made moves to adapt – more than 800 varieties of alcohol-free beer are now available in Germany – but this hasn't offset a broader decline. The average German now consumes 88 litres of beer in a year, down from 126 in 2000. And in the first half of 2025, the nation's statistics office registered a 6.3 per cent drop in beer production, a new low. 'It's frankly worrying,' said Mr Holger Eichele, who leads Germany's brewer association. 'The conditions aren't good. Even those who've run their business for many centuries might be forced to give it up now.' Gen Z's abstention from alcohol isn't only happening in Germany, which produces the most beer on the continent. Young people are also drinking less across Europe and in the US. There are various reasons for this: younger people have less disposable income than previous generations, wellness movements are on the rise, and there is greater awareness of the health risks associated with drinking. 'I'd never order it,' Ms Carla Schüßler, a student in southwestern Germany, said of beer. In her generation, 'it's clear to everyone that alcohol isn't good for your body.' Beer's high calorie content also doesn't sit well with image-conscious Gen Zers. Fitness influencers routinely post about alcohol's adverse effects, warning that it hampers fat burning and muscle building. 'It's just hard to improve your fitness level while drinking,' said Mr Luke Heiler, a 22-year-old who works in a chemical laboratory and exercises regularly. As these views become more common, Germany's roughly 1,500 breweries are having to adapt. And not all have been able to: between 2023 and 2024, 52 breweries closed across the country – the largest decline in at least three decades. Those who can are rethinking their product range to include more beers mixed with soda, known as radlers, and sparkling juice drinks. Billboards at train stations and ads on TV now promote alcohol-free fun – a once unthinkable development in a country known for Oktoberfest, and which still upholds a 500-year-old law mandating that beer contain no more than four essential ingredients. Amid all these changes, perhaps the biggest is the boom in alcohol-free beer. While nine out of 10 beers sold in Germany still contain booze, production of non-alcoholic beer – defined as anything containing less than 0.50 per cent alcohol by volume – has nearly doubled over the past decade. 'We don't think our flagship beer, which contains alcohol, will achieve major growth in the coming decades in Germany,' acknowledged Mr Peter Lemm, a spokesperson for Krombacher, one of the nation's largest beermakers. 'Clearly, the growth area is low- or non-alcoholic beer.' For brewers, developing alcohol-free versions of their beer isn't a problem. The challenge is getting them to taste like the real thing. Those who can afford to will often opt for a process in which beer is brewed normally, with the alcohol removed in an extra step once fermentation is finished. At Krombacher's plant in the Western German city of Kreuztal – where beer flows through pipes across different parts of the building – this is integrated into a weeks-long process. That level of precision manufacturing, however, isn't available to everybody. 'Small breweries usually can't afford to take out the alcohol after,' said Munich-area professor Thomas Becker, who specialises in beermaking. The equipment alone, he added, requires 'an investment in the region of €1 million.' Instead, small breweries often resort to an easier method, which involves stopping the fermentation process before it's completed. While it doesn't require additional investment, in most cases, drinkers do notice the difference as the result is usually sweeter than normal. Entering the alcohol-free market as a smaller brewer also presents other challenges. It's tough to break into a field that's already saturated, especially when bigger players are better positioned to release new drinks quickly and buy up the trademarks of established brands. To local breweries like Lang-Bräu, which are already under heavy financial stress after years of dwindling sales, these obstacles can be fatal. The brewery never attempted to make its own alcohol-free beer, Mr Hopf said. But given how many options are already on the market, he added, he doesn't think it would have made much of a difference. BLOOMBERG
