Keir Starmer confronted over DWP disability cuts as Labour MP says she was 'ashamed'
Keir Starmer was confronted by a senior Labour MP, who said the Government's plans to slash disability benefits left her "ashamed".
In a tense exchange, Work and Pensions Committee chair Debbie Abrahams said the original plans were 'far removed' from traditional Labour values of fairness and social justice, as well as compassion and common decency'.
And she pressed the PM on what he would like to say to the disabled people plunged into "fear and anxiety" before the Government watered down its plans.
Ms Abrahams was among the Labour rebels who forced a climbdown on the legislation, which meant proposed cuts to Personal Independence Payments (PIP) were shelved until next year.
The clash came as Mr Starmer was grilled by the Commons Liaison Committee ahead of the summer recess - with child poverty and international affairs topping the agenda.
Ms Abrahams told the PM: "This was poor legislation. It was designed to save money for the Treasury by cutting support to sick and disabled people.
"It was so far removed from Labour values of fairness and social justice, let alone compassion and common decency, I have to say I felt ashamed."
Asked what values would drive the Government's reforms, Mr Starmer replied: "I think this is a really important Labour value.
"I think the fact that nearly 1 million young people are out of work, not earning or learning, is a huge challenge for our country. None of us should be accepting of a system like that, it is broken and needs to be mended."
He added: "We do need to reform the system and we should take that on as a Labour argument in my view."
Ms Abrahams replied: "Everybody agrees that reform needs to happen. It is a broken system... reform does not mean cuts to household incomes for already struggling households.
"We must do better Prime Minister. You mentioned about reducing poverty. This has the potential of actually increasing it."
Earlier, the PM told MPs that "tackling poverty and breaking down barriers" was at the heart of his agenda.
He said: "I want people to feel better off and there has to be a central focus on living standards. I want them to feel - as they will - that the health service is working much better, is there for them and their families in a way that it hasn't been for many years.
"And I want them to feel safe and secure, both in their immediate neighbourhood and as a country, both our borders and national security and defence. So, they're the three things that I'm focused on more than anything else."
Mr Starmer also restated his commitment to driving down child poverty levels. He said: "I'm very proud of the fact that the last Labour government drove down poverty, and I'm determined this Government is going to as well."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
20 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Cut red tape hindering marine restoration to boost coastal towns
The group, which includes dozens of Tory MPs, called for regulation to be streamlined for projects such as the Solent Seascape Project, an initiative to restore saltmarsh, seagrass, oyster reefs, and seabird nesting sites between the Isle of Wight and mainland England. Shadow environment secretary Victoria Atkins backed the report, calling it a 'valuable conservative contribution for consideration in our ongoing policy renewal programme'. Victoria Atkins welcomed the report (PA) 'Britain's once-buzzing seaside towns are facing growing economic and environmental pressures. The Conservatives are determined to set out a plan to protect our coastal communities and preserve them for future generations,' she said. She added: 'Needless red tape continues to hamstring investment into marine restoration projects that could bring coastal communities jobs, nature-abundant habitats, and protection against the growing threats of climate change.' The network is also calling on Labour to use the flood defences budget to fund more nature-based solutions and to designate more highly protected marine areas in English waters to protect against practices like bottom trawling, in which fishing gear is dragged across the seabed destroying habitats and scooping up a wide array of species. They also want the Government to publish blue carbon codes – frameworks that define how carbon stored in marine habitats like seagrass and saltmarsh can be measured, verified and sold as credits – to unlock more funding for coastal resilience. They say these moves will boost nature recovery as well as local economies through nature tourism and job creation as more projects could get off the ground. Some 67% of English coastal towns are in the Office for National Statistics higher deprivation category and 3,500 properties are in areas at risk from coastal erosion. Kitty Thompson, head of campaigns at CEN, said offering solutions for coastal communities could also help the Conservatives challenge Nigel Farage's Reform UK. 'The teal tide is not inevitable. Reform offers an easy outlet of anger for many coastal towns who have watched their neighbourhoods fade. 'But they won't give these communities the solutions they deserve. If the Conservatives offer a pragmatic, credible alternative that can deliver for coastal communities, then they can challenge Reform in coastal target seats, stopping them in their tracks,' she said. Jacques Villemot, marine rewilding lead for Rewilding Britain, said the current marine licensing framework is outdated and called for the application process for projects to be streamlined. 'This framework urgently needs to be updated to support marine rewilding projects. Though necessary, in its current format marine licensing acts as a blocker, a laborious and costly process which was designed for approving developments like huge oil rigs and large wind farms,' he said.
Telegraph
36 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Former councillor killed on road he tried to make safer
A former Labour councillor has been killed in a car crash on a road he campaigned to make safer. John Michael Duggan, 81, died in hospital after his car collided with a skip lorry on Aug 1 as he tried to join the A19 in North Yorkshire. The former Selby district councillor was taken to Leeds General Infirmary by air ambulance but was pronounced dead a short time later. The lorry driver, a 42-year-old man from York, was arrested at the scene and was assisting officers with enquiries, according to North Yorkshire Police. Mr Duggan had previously highlighted the junction on York Rd, which connects the village of Riccall with the major road, as one of several seriously dangerous intersections along the A19. Campaigner appealed for roundabout As a parish councillor for Riccall, he told the York Press newspaper in 2007 he was 'gravely concerned' about the safety of local drivers following a number of accidents, including fatal ones. He said: 'The stretch of the A19 that runs past Riccall is one of the fastest sections of the road, and the speed of traffic using this section is totally unacceptable to local people who are trying to enter and exit the village.' Mr Duggan had called for a roundabout to be built in the area and presented plans for one to North Yorkshire County Council. Steve Shaw-Wright, the Labour leader of Selby town council, said it was 'tragically ironic' that Mr Duggan died on a stretch of road he campaigned to make safer. 'John was one who would campaign for what he believed to be right for his community, whether that was within the bounds of his political group or outside. John was very determined to support what people needed in his community,' he told ITV. 'He campaigned for the roundabout to get access and ingress from Riccall for a long, long time, it's tragically ironic that that was the place where he lost his life.' 'Tragedy makes need for improvement clear' Keir Mather, the Labour MP for Selby, said the death of Mr Duggan, who was formerly a senior representative for the Unite union, highlighted the need for road safety improvements in the area. 'John was a well-known and much-loved local man, a father, uncle and a grandfather,' he said. 'He was known too for his time as a union convenor, a Selby district and North Yorkshire county councillor and, perhaps most poignantly, as a campaigner for better road safety in Riccall. 'This tragedy makes awfully clear the need for road safety improvements at both A19 junctions in Riccall.' Mr Mather said he would press North Yorkshire council to reconsider introducing a roundabout 'or at the very least a speed reduction' on the stretch of the A19. National Highways brought in a temporary speed limit of 50mph on part of the A19 in Teesside last year after a series of collisions. The A19 runs from Seaton Burn, north of Newcastle, to just north of Doncaster, and has a 70mph speed limit for cars for much of its length.
Metro
an hour ago
- Metro
Risk and reward, Trump's Mini-Me and planting trees for the planet
Three readers (MetroTalk, Thu) debate why migrants run the risk of crossing the Channel in dinghies to get to Britain. To answer one point, migrants do claim asylum in safe countries in Europe, but if they are rejected they try again in the UK as we are no longer subject to the EU Dublin III agreement to automatically reject them. Others come as they speak English so have a better chance here. Single young men come – as they have throughout history – as they are most likely to survive dangerous travel, intending to settle and then send for their family. Allowing applications in France and a more thorough removal of failed claimants would discourage crossing attempts. Lewis Gibson, Birmingham I totally agree with Guy Wilkins (MetroTalk, Thu). Nigel Farage is Donald Trump's Mini-Me from the Austin Powers film and follows him without question, even wearing his 'Morons And Gormless of America' hats. Farage, like Trump, will make ridiculous promises with no possible way of achieving them. Facts and the truth are totally irrelevant to him, he incites fear and loathing of various groups and fails to condemn violence by the far right. They both live for publicity and adoration from the media. Farage would go to the opening of an envelope if a camera was present and without constant unjustified newspaper articles he would crumble as Dracula in sunlight. A Lloyd, Liverpool In response to my point that Jeremy Corbyn's new party will score an 'own-goal' by splitting the far-left vote and benefiting Reform, James Freeman (MetroTalk, Tue) and Brian Dooley (Wed) insist Labour could have avoided this by catering more for the leftist voter. However, neither mention that when Labour did this previously, they quickly became unelectable. As party leader, Corbyn's aspirations reduced Labour to its worst General Election defeat since 1935, giving Boris Johnson a landslide victory in 2019. Labour's previous experiment with socialism under Michael Foot resulted in Labour's 1983 pre-election manifesto being described as 'the longest suicide note in history' and gifted a huge majority to Margaret Thatcher. Labour has little to fear by losing the niche hard Left and should let Corbyn and his disciples get on with it. Labour must stop terrifying the wealth creators in this country with counterproductive policies and focus on gaining centrist support while masses of the electorate feel uneasy about the rise of Reform and exasperated by the deficiencies of Conservative and the Lib Dems. Robert Hughes, London We hear much about the catastrophic effects of carbon on our climate but few people talks of the effect of expanding deserts. More Trending Expanding deserts are a threat to many countries – but there are signs of a fightback. The Great Green Wall is a project by the African Union to restore degraded land across 22 countries in the Sahel region. But its great success in planting trees – which will also act as a carbon sponge – will not help us as much as benefit the southern Sahara. Italy has recently suffered temperatures as high as 45C, which can be fatal. This heat comes from northern Africa. The way to reverse climate change in Europe is to emulate the Great Green Wall scheme by planting trees in northern Africa. Such a project would be more beneficial to us than the futile net zero programme, which is destroying whole industries and thousands of good jobs. Mark Hardinge, Worcester There can be no excuses for the levels of violence carried out by Mohammed Fahir Amaaz at Manchester Airport against the police and a member of the public (Metro, Thu). The guilty verdicts were correct and I look forward to robust sentencing shortly. You cannot attack any emergency worker just because you don't like them doing their duty. I look forward to the retrial Amaaz and his brother face after the jury could not reach a verdict on the charge they assaulted a male PC causing ABH. Robert Boston, Kent MORE: Oasis fan dies after falling from stands at Wembley Stadium concert MORE: Rat the size of a dog found as monster vermin run riot in Yorkshire village MORE: Police continue to hunt 'brutal' killers of mum, 22, shot dead with toddler upstairs
