Presiding officer 'acted in a neutral manner' as Douglas Ross questions impartiality
Holyrood's presiding officer has insisted that she 'acted in a neutral manner' after ejecting former Tory leader Douglas Ross from the chamber.
Alison Johnstone has denied accusations of bias after ejecting Ross from the debating chamber for the rest of the day following his interjections during First Minister's Questions on Thursday.
Ross was ordered to leave after shouting from his seat while John Swinney was speaking.
Johnstone said the former Tory leader had 'persistently refused' to abide by Holyrood's standing orders, which make clear MSPs should treat each other courteously.
Following the incident, Ross accused the presiding officer of 'blatant bias'.
Johnstone was elected as a Green MSP, but the presiding officer is expected to be neutral and incumbents give up their party affiliation when taking on the role.
'For a member to be expelled from the chamber with no warning at all, I think may be unprecedented,' Ross said on Tuesday.
The MSP challenged Johnstone from the chamber floor, claiming she had refused requests to meet with him to discuss the incident.
'If you are closing down all attempts to raise this and refuse to meet with me, how can you be acting in a neutral manner and treating all members equally as required by parliament?' Ross asked.
However, Johnstone repeatedly order Ross to sit down, and evaded discussion.
'I have acted in a neutral manner,' she said.
'As far as I am aware, I have not received a request to specifically meet with you.'
She added: 'In this chair, I treat all members equally and act in the interest of all members of this Parliament.'
Johnstone repeated that she would not discuss 'matters outwith standing orders'.
'I am not continuing to have a dialogue about when I'm meeting you in this chamber,' she said.
STV News has seen emails exchanged on behalf of Ross with Holyrood chief executive David McGill requesting a meeting with McGill and the presiding officer.
On Friday, Mr McGill's officer replied: 'I have just been informed that the presiding officer is unavailable on Tuesday morning.'
Ross subsequently repeated his request to meet with Johnstone before the start of parliamentary business on Tuesday.
Johnstone has been contacted for comment.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Spectator
4 hours ago
- Spectator
What James Cleverly gets wrong about net zero
The Conservatives were nearly wiped out at last July's general election, and the party is currently trailing Nigel Farage's Reform in the polls. You might think then that the handful of remaining 'big beasts' on the Tory benches would decide to try and work together. Instead, a split appears to be emerging in the party over net zero. James Cleverly took a thinly-veiled swipe at Kemi Badenoch's green policy in a speech to the Conservative Environment Network (CEN) last night. In one of her first major policy interventions as leader, Badenoch abandoned the Conservatives' support for the country reaching net zero emissions by 2050. But Cleverly has now argued that the party should not give up on the climate agenda. In his speech, he took aim at what he called 'neo-luddites' on the right who seem scared of using green technologies to protect the environment:
The Herald Scotland
6 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Green men urged to make way for ‘radical women' candidates
Niall Christie, who has entered the race for a spot on the Greens' Glasgow list, said men in leadership positions should refuse to take the top spot on the Holyrood ballot. Patrick Harvie and Ross Greer (Image: Andrew Milligan) He said he would step aside for a woman or non-binary candidate even if fellow members ranked him number one. "It is entirely within a candidate's purview to say that they'll allow themselves to be balanced in for women and non-binary people, and I would fully intend to do that. 'If I were to get the most votes in Glasgow, I would not dare sit top of the list, because we need a woman in Glasgow,' he said. 'We have had a Green MSP for 23 years, and we need a woman to lead that.' He named Ellie Gomersall and Iris Duane as 'excellent candidates' who had already put themselves forward, and said there was 'no doubt' others would follow. READ MORE Party members are currently in the process of selecting candidates for next year's Holyrood election. The final order on each regional list will be determined by the level of support each contender receives from fellow activists. At the 2021 election, Mr Harvie secured the top spot on the Glasgow list, while Mr Greer led the ballot in West Scotland. Niall Christie has called for Patrick Harvie and Ross Greer to stand aside (Image: Scottish Greens)Mr Christie — who secured the Greens' best-ever general election result in Glasgow South last year — challenged male colleagues in winnable regions to voluntarily rank themselves lower on the ballot. He said this could still see them returned to Holyrood depending on the party's performance. "I do think that, regardless of how well I do in this election race, and how well somebody like Patrick or somebody like Ross does, they should be looking at themselves and thinking, 'Actually, I'll be better served by having radical women who can represent something different within the party and a fresh start within the party.' "I would challenge them to do that, because actually, both of them are in seats where we will be wanting to elect more than one MSP this time." 'It is not about whether there is a job or not,' he added. 'Because if they finish top, they would be balancing themselves down to second and — all going well — they would still be returning to Holyrood. But actually, what it is about is raising up other people. It is about boosting voices that currently are not there.' Mr Christie's intervention follows reports in Holyrood magazine that the Scottish Greens' National Council has voted to suspend the party's trans-inclusive gender-balancing mechanism amid legal concerns, following a Supreme Court ruling that said the words 'man' and 'woman' in the Equality Act refer to biological sex. The system — which had helped deliver the election of five women among the party's eight MSPs in 2021 — is to be replaced by 'alternative measures to support and encourage women, trans and non-binary candidates to stand'. In a statement, office-bearers admitted the move would be 'deeply disappointing' to many members, but insisted the decision was taken 'with solidarity at its heart'. READ MORE: Responding to Mr Christie's call, Mr Harvie told The Herald said it was not clear why he and Mr Greer has been singled out. He said: "I'm proud that the Scottish Greens have developed a good record of gender balance in recent years, electing five women and three men at the last Holyrood election, and I have no doubt that the whole party wants to continue that. "Candidate selection is for our local members to decide, in every branch, and I hope that everyone respects their right to choose their candidates. "It's not clear why anyone would single out two individuals in this way, but I'll treat our selection as the democratic process it should be. "I look forward to setting out the work I've done in helping to achieve the greatest political impact our party has ever had, for example the thousands of pounds tenants in Glasgow and across Scotland have saved as a result of the rent freeze, and the long term rent controls to come. "That's what I hope our members debate in the selection process - how to build on the unprecedented progress we've made in this session, and keep making change happen for the people of Scotland." Mr Greer said: "Next year we can build on the record number of women we elected as Green MSPs in 2021. I'm really pleased that a number of women I've supported and encouraged to run have already lodged their nominations. 'I'm gutted that a transphobic court ruling has blocked our usual gender balance system. Despite that, I'm confident we will have a diverse top team of candidates once again. Members in the West region don't need the usual suspects from Glasgow branch trying to change the results before a single vote is cast.' 'From expanding free school meals to tackling the scandal of domestic abuse survivors being forced to pay off their abuser's debts, I've had the privilege of turning Green policies into reality as an MSP. I'm looking forward to sharing that record of delivery with members when voting opens.' The party's leadership is currently undergoing something of a reset, with Mr Harvie announcing that he will stand down as co-leader of the Scottish Greens at the end of the summer. Last week, Mr Greer told The Herald he was 'seriously considering' standing for co-leadership. The West of Scotland MSP said he had been encouraged by other members to throw his hat in the ring. Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater in the Scottish Parliament (Image: PA) Party rules mean at least one of the co-leaders must be female, with Lorna Slater confirming she is standing to remain in post. Gillian Mackay, the party's health spokesperson, has also confirmed her leadership bid.
Daily Record
7 hours ago
- Daily Record
Reform has shamefully dragged this by-election into the gutter with vile race baiting
Graeme Souness is a football legend who was feared and respected on the pitch. His contributions to politics have been rare but his intervention in the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election is spot on. With Reform expected to perform well, Souness has issued a timely warning to voters that Nigel Farage cannot be trusted. He dismissed Farage as a 'chancer' who does not care one jot for the people of Scotland – an analysis we wholeheartedly endorse. The reality is Reform have shamefully dragged this by-election into the gutter with vile race baiting. Their online 'advert' falsely claiming Anas Sarwar will 'prioritise' Pakistanis was blatant racism – and totally made-up. Doubling down by shelling out even more money on that awful ad just showed how little they care for the truth. Reform have been a toxic presence in this campaign and it is heartening to see them called out by notable Scots. The reason some voters are tempted by Reform is dissatisfaction with the performance of the established parties. They are furious with the last Tory government and feel let down by decisions made by Keir Starmer's administration. Many voters also have concerns over the SNP government's record on public services. But nobody should fool themselves that Farage and his Reform rabble have any of the answers we need. Farage in power would destroy the NHS, tear-up workers' rights and cut tax for his super-rich pals. Voters have a chance to send Farage packing today and they should embrace this opportunity with gusto. Crisis on wards Scotland's NHS is in need of some major surgery to make it fit for purpose. And in reforming our health service, the Scottish Government could do a lot worse than listening to the frontline workers who save lives every day. Today, the Daily Record reports on concerns from NHS cancer specialists over staff shortages causing massive waiting times for diagnosis and treatment. The Royal College of Radiologists (RCR) describes the situation as a 'ticking time bomb', with further shortages expected in the next five years. With so many families affected by cancer, it is vital we have enough trained medics to get people treated quickly. We all know early detection can be a life saver. Nobody should have to wait for treatment knowing every passing day could see their condition getting worse. There are no silver bullets that will fix our health service – which is in desperate need of resources and reform. But listening to warnings from frontline medics is vital to any solution.
