Texas officials question scaled-back Weather Service's flood forecasts - but experts say the agency did all it could
Some state and local officials say the NWS didn't provide accurate forecasts ahead of Friday's destructive flooding, months after President Donald Trump's administration gutted the agency and experts warned forecasts could suffer.
Central Texas was struck by unexpected flash flooding on Friday after torrential rain caused the Guadalupe River to rise rapidly. The force of the fast-rising waters washed out homes and swept away vehicles. It also destroyed Camp Mystic, an all-girls summer camp situated on the banks of the river.
At least 51 people have been killed by the floods as of Saturday night, including 15 children. At least four of those killed were children attending Camp Mystic, and 27 attendees are still missing.
Texas Emergency Management Chief W. Nim Kidd told reporters at a press conference Friday that the NWS did not accurately predict the amount of rain Texas saw.
'The original forecast that we received Wednesday from the National Weather Service predicted 3-6 inches of rain in the Concho Valley and 4-8 inches in the Hill Country,' he said at a press conference Friday. 'The amount of rain that fell at this specific location was never in any of those forecasts.'
Kerr County Judge Rob Kelly said that 'no one knew this kind of flood was coming.'
'We have floods all the time,' Kelly said. 'We had no reason to believe that this was going to be anything like what's happened here. None whatsoever.'
Kerrville City Manager Dalton Rice echoed similar concerns, noting that the storms 'dumped more rain than what was forecasted.'
The NWS issued a 'life-threatening flash flooding' warning in Kerrville at 1:14 a.m. on Friday. The alert triggered the Emergency Alert System, meaning it would have sounded the alarm on cell phones throughout the area. Cell phone users who didn't have service or who turned off emergency alerts would not have heard the alarm.
That alert was issued more than three hours before the first reports of flooding came in, an agency spokesperson told The Independent.
'Flash Flood Warnings were issued on the night of July 3 and in the early morning of July 4, giving preliminary lead times of more than three hours before warning criteria were met,' NWS spokesperson Erica Grow Cei said.
While questions may be asked of local officials and their reaction to the warnings, Gov. Greg Abbott and other lawmakers are defending the response after what they called a once-in-a-century flood.
'There's going to be a lot of finger-pointing and a lot of second guessing and Monday morning quarterbacking,' Texas Rep. Chip Roy, a Republican, added. 'There's a lot of people saying why and how and I understand that. I understand why parents would be asking those questions and all of the media.'
Experts have previously warned that the Trump administration's decision to fire around 600 people from the agency could have drastic impacts on its ability to issue accurate forecasts. Former NWS forecaster John Toohey-Morales told The New York Times that people could die as a result.
'I am telling you, the American people are going to suffer from all this,' he said. 'Lives are being put in danger.'
Despite the cuts, nearby NWS offices had 'adequate staffing' during the storms, CNN reports. However, centers were missing a few key employees due to early retirement incentives offered by the Trump administration in an effort to reduce the government's workforce.
The Austin-San Antonio office was missing a warning coordination meteorologist — who helps link forecasters with local emergency managers — while the San Angelo office was missing a meteorologist-in-charge, according to CNN.
Some meteorologists say the forecasters at the Texas offices took all the right steps ahead of Friday's floods.
Austin-based meteorologist Troy Kimmel told the Austin American-Statesman that warnings were issued in time and that the NWS 'did its job,' even if rainfall amounts were underestimated.
'The sky fell,' Kimmel said. 'It was still the middle of the night, but that does not mean people should not be monitoring.'
Meteorologist Chris Vagasky told Wired that predicting how much rain will fall from a thunderstorm is 'the hardest thing a meteorologist can do.'
'The signal was out there that this is going to be a heavy, significant rainfall event,' he said. 'But pinpointing exactly where that's going to fall, you can't do that.'
Jonathan Porter, the chief meteorologist at AccuWeather, told the Associated Press evacuations and other proactive measures could have been undertaken to reduce the risk of fatalities.
'People, businesses, and governments should take action based on Flash Flood Warnings that are issued, regardless of the rainfall amounts that have occurred or are forecast,' Porter said in a statement.
When asked at a press conference why officials didn't issue evacuation warnings to camps near the Guadalupe River, Kelly said he didn't know, according to NPR. Rice added that it's difficult for county officials to decide when to issue evacuation orders.
"There's a balance between do you evacuate and put chaos on the road and potentially risk people getting stuck on a road?' Rice said. "A lot of our operations plans, especially with these camps, that is, the plan is sometimes shelter in place to get them to those known high grounds and then wait for rescue."
Speaking from Air Force One on the Fourth of July, Trump called the floods a 'shocking' tragedy but did not address questions about the cuts to weather agencies.
When asked whether the government would provide federal aid, Trump responded, "Oh yeah, we'll take care of them. We're working with the governor. It's a terrible thing."
Officials are continuing their search efforts as on Saturday night and have already rescued hundreds of people, as the death toll continues to rise.
"My instruction to every state official involved is to assume everybody who is missing is alive, and there's a need for speed. Not just every hour, every minute counts, which is why there's people in the air, people in the water, people at the ground right now because they're looking to save every last life and we will not give up that effort," Abbott said at a press conference.
The Independent has contacted the White House for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Why are flash floods so deadly? How to stay safe from their shocking power.
Flooding in Texas appeared swiftly and soon turned deadly, showing how deceptively powerful a flash flood can be. Amazingly, it only takes 6 inches of rapidly moving water to knock you off your feet. And according to water flowing at just 6 mph exerts the same force per unit area as air blowing at EF5 tornado wind speeds. Water moving at 25 mph has the pressure equivalent of wind blowing at 790 mph, faster than the speed of sound. Here's what to know about these incredible forces of nature ‒ and how you can prepare: A flash flood is a rapid rise of water along a stream or in a low-lying urban area, the National Weather Service said. Flash flooding can result from slow-moving thunderstorms, from numerous thunderstorms that develop repeatedly over the same area, or from heavy rains associated with tropical cyclones. "These floods may develop within minutes, depending on the intensity of the rainfall, the topography, soil conditions, and ground cover," the weather service said. In the July 4 flooding disaster, extreme flooding began in the Texas Hill Country around 4 a.m. as thunderstorms dumped more than 10 inches of rain on parts of the region. The relentless rain overwhelmed the Guadalupe River, causing it to surge over 26 feet in less than an hour, Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick said. In general, most U.S. flash flood deaths occur in vehicles when people try to drive through flooded water and eventually drown. This has prompted the well-known slogan "Turn around, don't drown" from the weather service. The national 30-year average for flood deaths is around 127 people per year, and weather service data indicates that nearly half of all flash flood fatalities are vehicle-related. The majority of victims are males, and flood deaths affect all age groups. "Once your vehicle is floating, the floodwaters become your steering wheel. If that water is moving, your vehicle could be swept away, tipped on its side, or flipped," meteorologist Jonathan Belles said in an online report. And according to the Federal Emergency Management Agency: ◾6 inches of water will reach the bottom of most passenger cars, causing loss of control and potential stalling. ◾1 foot of water will float many vehicles. ◾2 feet of rushing water will carry away most vehicles, including SUVs and pickups. Cell phones or weather radios are a key part of staying informed of incoming severe weather. "Awareness of the weather can save your life in a flash flood," Belles said in an online report. In addition to apps from your favorite weather provider, such as the Weather Channel or AccuWeather, be sure you pay attention to wireless emergency alerts (WEA) on your phone, which are emergency messages sent by authorized government alerting authorities through your mobile carrier. "Government partners include local and state public safety agencies, FEMA, the FCC, the Department of Homeland Security, and the National Weather Service," the weather service said. A few important tips to help you stay safe during a flash flood: ◾If you're caught in a flood, immediately head to higher ground. ◾Avoid walking or driving through floodwaters. ◾If you encounter rising water, "Turn around, don't drown." This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Flash floods are shockingly powerful. Here's why they're so deadly.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
What happened in the hours before, during and after a catastrophic deluge hit Texas Hill Country
For many families, the most serious warnings about the deadly and raging torrent in Texas Hill Country last week came too late. Many were asleep. Others, in a region long accustomed to extreme weather, were kept up by heavy bursts of rain and earsplitting cracks of thunder that shook buildings. 'I thought it was just lightning and thunderstorm,' recalled Caroline Cutrona, a counselor at Camp Mystic, where young girls bonded in rustic cabins with names like the Bubble Inn and the Giggle Box. 'I had no idea of the severity.' She was not alone. Still, state emergency management officials had activated emergency response resources as early as Wednesday evening, warning of potential flooding heading into the July Fourth holiday weekend. The alerts – including critical warnings the National Weather Service said gave preliminary lead times of more than three hours before flash flooding conditions occurred – would grow more dire. Torrential rains transformed the pristine Guadalupe River, unleashing roaring cascades in the predawn hours of Independence Day along 40 miles of Kerr County, claiming at least 103 lives there alone, including 36 children. The confirmed death toll in Texas was 129 as of Friday evening. At least 150 people are still missing statewide – at least 140 of them in Kerr County. More than a summer's worth of rain had fallen in the area overnight into the holiday, swelling part of the river from about 3 feet to 30 feet in just 45 minutes and turning the beloved waterway into a killer. The catastrophic deluge laid waste to communities across Kerr and Kendall counties, where neighborhoods and RV parks, as well as the 18 or so youth camps attended by thousands of kids each summer, were swept away in its fury. 'The first thing I thought, 'This is not real. Wake up, Caroline. Wake up,'' Cutrona told CNN's Anderson Cooper. ''I'm in a dream,' and that's what I wanted it to be.' Here's what we know about how a nightmare scenario unfolded in Texas:The Texas Division of Emergency Management announces activation of state emergency response resources in anticipation of 'increased threats of flooding in parts of West and Central Texas heading into the holiday weekend.' It urges residents to 'follow instructions from local officials, make an emergency plan, and prepare an emergency supply kit.'The National Weather Service issues short-term guidance, valid until Thursday afternoon, indicating morning thunderstorms and a humid, moist environment capable of producing flooding rainfall. The guidance flags the NWS office for Austin and San Antonio to note the flood NWS releases a flood outlook noting flash or river flooding is possible in parts of Central Texas over the coming days. It describes a very tropical atmosphere with the potential for producing flooding rainfall in central and southern judges and city mayors are invited to join a daily call to discuss weather forecasts. A regional coordinator reached out personally to officials in the area, making sure they 'were aware there could be flooding,' Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick later said. 'The message was sent,' Patrick said. 'It is up to the local counties and mayors under the law to evacuate if they feel the need.' 'I will tell you personally, I did not receive a call,' Kerrville Mayor Joe Herring Jr. told reporters this week, adding he could not speak for the Kerr County NWS issues a flood watch, highlighting Kerrville, among other locations, as being at risk of flash flooding through the night into Friday. It forecast 5 to 7 inches of NWS issues an updated forecast for the Guadalupe River: 'Rapid runoff is expected, with locally considerable flash and urban flash flooding possible … the nocturnal timing will also enhance the hazard potential and impacts.' It notes the potential for a historic rainfall event, though it's unclear if that messaging reached emergency managers. The weather service's forecast offices for Austin, San Antonio and San Angelo, as well as the West Gulf River Forecast Center in Fort Worth, assign extra personnel to work Thursday night into the next day, according to NWS spokesperson Erica Grow Cei. Kerrville Mayor Herring later said he went outside Thursday night before the storm and looked at the sky. 'Partly cloudy. The sky was not angry and I thought to myself, 'someone's going to get rain, but it's probably not going to be us.' And I was wrong,' he said. 'I was awakened in the middle of the night by thunder. I looked outside, we had a light rain. In fact, the city of Kerrville really didn't have a lot of rain until later in the day.'Glenn Juenke, a Camp Mystic staffer, told CNN he was monitoring the rain gauges on the Guadalupe-Blanco River Authority's website. 'Many of the rain gauges were out of order or offline and were useless. They provided no information about the level of rainfall upstream of Camp Mystic where I was acting in the capacity of night watchman.'The NWS issues a flash flood warning, upgraded from the earlier watch, for parts of Kerr Guillen, who owns an RV park and restaurant in Kerrville, told CNN she closed her restaurant around 12:45 a.m. CT after July Fourth celebrations. When rain started to pour heavier over the next two hours, she drove to the edge of the river and observed its height. The water level appeared normal, she said. She called the Kerr County Sheriff's Office to ask whether the Guadalupe would rise with the rain and put her RV tenants in danger. She said she was assured they would be safe. About an hour after the call, Guillen said, she saw lights from a rescue team. One of the park's long-term residents had heard screaming and called Camp Mystic's Bug House cabin, owner Dick Eastland and his son, Edward, a camp director, helped a group of girls – clutching pillows and blankets – evacuate in ankle-deep water to a nearby recreation hall, a 12-year-old camper told CNN. With the water rapidly rising, the campers spent the night on the second floor, illuminated by flashlights. 'Everyone was scared because there was water coming in,' said the girl, whose mother asked she not be identified to protect her privacy. The girls sang, prayed and slept until about 6 a.m. when the rain stopped. When counselors did a roll call later, the girls realized some campers were missing. At Chatterbox cabin at the same camp, girls screamed as floodwaters swept inside, according to 9-year-old twin sisters who were there. Their mother also asked they not be identified. One twin let campers keep their 'lovies' and 'stuffies' on her top bunk for safety. The twins said they watched a car they believed would rescue them wash away in a surge of water. With counselors, the campers climbed out a window and waded through chest-high waters to higher ground. They later learned three Chatterbox campers were among the missing. 'We didn't know if they got … washed away in the rapids,' one girl said. 'Whenever we were cold, they kept giving us hugs and we were crying, they would always comfort us,' one twin said of the counselors. A rainbow appeared later that morning – which the girls said was 'a sign from God.'A local firefighter calls dispatch to report high water on the main highway getting to Hunt, Texas, from the east. 'Yes ma'am … Guadalupe is starting to come up and Schumacher is no longer passable at this time,' the firefighter says, referring to the scenic Schumacher Crossing over the City Manager Dalton Rice said first responders started to get swept away by floodwaters. 'That's how quick it happened,' Rice said. 'First responders who have experience, who are swift-water qualified.'A dispatcher tells first responders about people in distress along State Highway 39, which crosses the Guadalupe and runs through Texas Hill Country: 'We're getting multiple calls off of 39. People are stating their houses are flooding. We're trying to advise them to get to higher area.'Camp Mystic counselor Caroline Cutrona said the roar of thunder and lighting kept her awake. She noticed the camp had lost power. The cabin, where she watched over 14 girls ages 9 and 10, shook violently. Around the same time, video obtained by CNN shows a cabin at the boys Camp La Junta floating away in the NWS issues a flash flood emergency warning for Kerr County, stating, 'Move to higher ground now! This is an extremely dangerous and life-threatening situation.'A firefighter calls dispatch, asking for a CodeRED emergency alert to be issued: 'Is there any way we can send a CodeRED out to our Hunt residents, asking them to find higher ground or stay home?' The dispatcher responds: 'Stand by, we have to get that approved with our supervisor.'A gauge along the Guadalupe River, in Kerrville, shows water levels hit 23.4 feet. Water levels in that spot almost certainly crested above 23.4 feet, but the gauge didn't record data for three hours – between 4:45 a.m. and 7:45 a.m. local time –before picking back up its raging river bursts from its banks around this time, sweeping homes, cars, campers and cabins downstream. It took about 90 minutes for the 20-foot flood wave to move down the Guadalupe River overnight, triggering the river's second-highest crest on Fire dispatch announces: 'The river is completely swollen … there is a car with occupants in it floating down the river.' Rice, the Kerrville city manager, started getting phone calls around 5 a.m. local time. 'By the time we got back out there, the river had already risen 20 or 25 feet. It rose significantly in that amount of time. We almost got stuck when we went back,' he told CNN. 'Nobody could have ever predicted this.'Notifications sent by Kendall County indicate the first wireless emergency message for a flood warning was sent to residents at this time. Three more alerts were issued on the wireless warning system between 7 a.m. and 8:06 a.m. CT. Herring, Kerrville's mayor, told reporters: 'I individually did not receive a warning in time. When I woke up, I got a call from the city manager' around 5:30 a.m. local time. He said he went downtown and Louise Hays Park, which is perched on the river, 'was already inundated. That was the first time I knew.'A unit identified as 'Utility 51' asks a dispatcher at Kerr County Fire Operations: 'Can you advise who's running command?' Central dispatch responds: 'Sir, we don't have an incident command right now.'The NWS issues a more dire flash flood emergency warning of an imminent threat, specifically for US Coast Guard receives an initial call, although their specific launch time is unavailable. What was supposed to be an hourlong flight took between seven and eight hours due to weather conditions, according to the air Herring Jr. told the Texas Tribune he received an alert on his phone from the CodeRED obtained by CNN showed law enforcement officers in Kerr County shouting evacuation County posted on social media: 'Flooding along the Guadalupe River is happening now. Be safe and move to higher ground. Do not drive through water. Turn Around - Don't Drown!'The Kerr County Sheriff's Office confirms people have died during the 'catastrophic flooding event' in a post on social media. 'Those near creeks, streams, and the Guadalupe River should immediately move to higher ground,' the post said.A source told CNN affiliate KSAT neither the Kerr County Sheriff's Office nor the Kerrville Police Department sent a CodeRED Alert to some residents until this County officials declare a disaster due to 'extreme, life-threatening' flooding. When everyone remaining at Camp Mystic had finished lunch, Cutrona said one of the camp's directors pulled counselors aside and informed them 27 girls and the camp's owner, Dick Eastland, were missing. 'Camp Mystic's the safest place I've ever known, and I just couldn't believe it,' Cutrona US Coast Guard's MH-65 air crew arrives in the area and begins to rescue survivors. It is uncertain what time the air crew completed rescue efforts. 'The last live rescue, unless there's new information, and I don't believe there is, was made on Friday,' Kerr County Sheriff Larry Leitha said. As searchers agonizingly scour the area for unaccounted flood victims, local officials have been adamant they could not have done more to prevent the tragedy. CNN's Pamela Brown, Andrew Freedman, Emma Tucker, Mary Gilbert, Holly Yan, Alisha Ebrahimji, Alaa Elassar and Dalia Faheid contributed to this report.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Rosie O'Donnell Blames Trump's ‘Horrible Decisions' for Texas Floods
Comedian Rosie O'Donnell believes President Donald Trump's 'horrible decisions' are to blame for the flash floods in central Texas that have killed at least 70. 'What a horror story in Texas,' O'Donnell, who moved to Dublin, Ireland, earlier this year after Trump was re-elected, said in a TikTok video posted Sunday. 'When the president guts all of the early warning systems and the weathering forecast abilities of the government, these are the results that we're going to start to see on a daily basis.' The Department of Government Efficiency had previously cut hundreds of jobs at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and the National Weather Service (NWS) in its effort to cut government spending earlier this year. The NWS lost around 600 staffers at the time, according to a June report from The New York Times. 'It's because he put this country in so much danger by his horrible, horrible decisions and this ridiculously immoral bill that he just signed into law,' O'Donnell, whose feud with Trump dates back to 2006, continued. 'As Republicans cheered, people will die as a result and they've started already.' 'Shame on him … Shame on every GOP sycophant,' she concluded. Catastrophic flooding first struck central Texas on July 4 after torrential rains caused the Guadalupe River to rise around 26 feet within just 45 minutes. The surge washed out roads and destroyed property across six counties. Texas Emergency Management Chief W. Nim Kidd bemoaned inaccurate forecasts from the NWS in a press conference Friday, saying that 'the original forecast that we received Wednesday from the National Weather Service predicted 3-6 inches of rain in the Concho Valley and 4-8 inches in the Hill Country.' 'The amount of rain that fell at this specific location was never in any of those forecasts,' he said. The president has since issued a Major Disaster Declaration prompting the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) to be activated in Texas. Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem has also indicated that alongside emergency, on-ground support, the White House is also 'currently upgrading the technology' at the NWS and NOAA 'to renew this ancient system that has been left in place with the federal government for many, many years.' 'I do carry your concerns back to the federal government and to President Trump, and we will do all we can to fix those kind of things that may have felt like a failure to you and to your community members,' Noem continued. 'We know that everybody wants more warning time, and that's why we're working to upgrade the technologies that been neglected [for] far too long.'
