'Wrong side of history': senator hits out at sanction
As Governor-General Sam Mostyn delivered her speech in the upper house on Tuesday for the opening of the 48th parliament, Senator Faruqi held a sign that read: "Gaza is starving. Words won't feed them. Sanction Israel".
The government's Senate leader Penny Wong introduced a motion on Wednesday to disapprove of the Greens senator's conduct.
It also requests an apology for "unparliamentary conduct" in addition to not supporting her as a potential Senate representative on any delegation during this term.
"What she wants most of all is attention," Senator Wong said.
"Australians expect us, their elected representatives, to uphold our democratic institutions, to demonstrate a degree of respect for each other as they do, and a respect for our institutions."
Labor and the coalition voted in favour of the sanction, while the Greens and WA senator Fatima Payman voted against it.
Senator Faruqi accused her colleagues of being on the "wrong side of history" for a lack of action against Israel over its response in Gaza following the October 7 attack by Hamas in 2023.
"You are more focused on cracking down on black and brown women," she said, before later accepting calls to withdraw the comment.
"The Greens will not be silent as this genocide unfolds.
"You will not be able to intimidate me or any of my colleagues, and we will never stop fighting for freedom, for Palestine."
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said people elected to the parliament have a responsibility to act like an adult.
"There's a place for demonstrations, and it's not on the floor of the Senate or the House of Reps, for that matter," he told the ABC.
Coalition Senate leader Michaelia Cash criticised the Greens senator for her "breach of respect".
"It was deliberate, prolonged and clearly intended to politicise a solemn and ceremonial event," she said.
"Rules without enforcement are meaningless ... and institutions without discipline become irrelevant."
Pro-Palestinian protester Shane Bazzi was taken out of the upper house by security guards after he began shouting from the public gallery while the motion was being discussed.
"Shame, shame," he yelled while being removed.
Hundreds of protesters called for sanctions on Israel on the lawns of parliament during its opening with one woman arrested, according to the Australian Federal Police.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Australian
37 minutes ago
- The Australian
Labor urges Israel to end Gaza war before hostage release
Labor is urging Israel to end the war in Gaza before the remaining hostages held by Hamas are returned, in a significant move away from its previous calls for the release of the Israelis to be the priority before a deal was struck to end the conflict and recognise Palestine. In her strongest language on the conflict and the urgency of achieving Palestinian recognition, Foreign Minister Penny Wong said there would 'be no Palestine left to recognise' should the global community wait much longer to do so. The comments are part of growing momentum within Labor to recognise Palestine in the near future, with Anthony Albanese revealing on Tuesday he had spoken to the leader of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas, overnight and committed to meeting him on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly next month. 'Prime Minister Albanese reiterated Australia's call for the immediate entry of aid to meet needs of people of Gaza, a permanent ceasefire, and the release of all hostages,' a readout of the call stated. 'Prime Minister Albanese also reinforced Australia's commitment to a two-state solution because a just and lasting peace depends upon it.' While Senator Wong has previously listed the return of hostages as being among the most-pressing priorities since the Hamas terror attack on October 7, 2023, the senior Labor senator said Israel needed to end the war before that outcome was achieved, not after. Senator Wong declared Australians were 'all horrified to watch the depraved spectacle' of Israeli hostages Evyatar David and Rom Braslavski 'paraded' around by Hamas, but said the onus lay with Israel now to end the war. 'What I would say is the government's view is the same as the 600 former Israeli security officials, who have written publicly, urging Prime Minister (Benjamin) Netanyahu to end the war and making the very important point that the end of the war is the only way to save the hostages,' Senator Wong told the ABC. She added that the Albanese government was clear in its view that it was a breach of international law to stop food being delivered, which she said 'was the decision Israel made in March'. Senator Wong did not rule out further sanctions on Israeli officials, but said her government would 'prefer to move with other (countries)' in taking such action in order for the move to have 'more effect'. The Foreign Minister's comments add to speculation that Australia will likely recognise Palestine in September, given other countries such as France and Canada have already committed to doing so. 'There is a risk there will be no Palestine left to recognise if the international community don't move to create that pathway to a two-state solution,' Senator Wong said. Opposition foreign affairs spokeswoman Michaelia Cash accused Senator Wong of using 'hyperbole to justify the Albanese government's premature rush to recognise a Palestinian state before there is a pathway for it to be viable'. 'Hyperbole is not foreign policy, and this is not a solution,' Senator Cash said. 'It's reactionary symbolism without substance. That may suit Labor politically but it is a deviation from Australia's longstanding foreign policy of a two-state solution. 'Australian foreign policy should not be being used to advance the domestic political priorities of the Labor Party.' The comments come amid some disquiet in Coalition ranks over the language used by the opposition foreign affairs spokeswoman, with concerns that the messaging was not palatable in some electorates. Ahead of his call with Mr Abbas this week, Mr Albanese submitted a request to speak directly with Mr Netanyahu. The request was made before Sunday's court-approved protest on the Sydney Harbour Bridge by pro-Palestinian supporters, which forced the closure of Sydney's largest road crossing for about five hours. Senator Wong said she had 'anticipated' would attract as many as it did, given 'the distress of Australians on what we are seeing unfolding in Gaza'. Executive Council of Australian Jewry co-chief executive Alex Ryvchin took a swipe at Senator Wong's calls for the war to end before hostages were released and said Israel had 'a moral obligation' to bring its people home no matter the cost. 'Israel has a moral obligation to do everything it can, diplomatically and militarily, to bring its starved and tortured people home,' Mr Ryvchin said. 'We would demand no less of our own government. 'We agree with the Foreign Minister that a permanent end to the war offers the best hope of saving the remaining hostages. 'But Israel accepted the internationally-brokered ceasefire that would have seen the unfettered flow of aid, the phased return of hostages and a pathway to a permanent end to the war. 'Hamas has rejected it since May. It is unsatisfactory for this material fact to be omitted, giving the false impression that Israel is the barrier to the ceasefire and not Hamas.' Read related topics: Israel Nation As Tim Gurner and Graham Turner blast the policy, smaller employers from the NSW-Victorian border say it's just another example of why it's easier to run a business 'across the river'. Politics Mining giant Fortescue's abandoned clean energy projects have left taxpayers exposed to millions in grants amid mounting scrutiny of government renewable subsidies.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Former Human Rights Watch chief Kenneth Roth says only Donald Trump can stop Benjamin Netanyahu and war in Gaza
The former executive director of Human Rights Watch, Kenneth Roth, says the one man who can hold Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to account and put an end to the war in Gaza is US President Donald Trump. His comments echoed those of Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, who last week called for Mr Trump to show real leadership on the ongoing war in Gaza. During an interview tonight on 7.30, Mr Roth — who is Jewish and the son of a Holocaust survivor — said world leaders must do more than voice outrage at the ongoing situation in Gaza. "There's increasing movement towards sanctioning Israeli officials who are responsible," Mr Roth told 7.30. "There's increasing legitimacy of the arrest warrants issued by the International Criminal Court, but frankly, the one person with leverage over Netanyahu is Trump. "He alone could condition arms sales and military aid to end the mass atrocity being committed in Gaza. "I don't think it's impossible to push Trump to do that. He is breaking with Netanyahu in various ways. He's spoken about that he's not yet at that stage, but it's possible to get him there. "That's what it's going to take to end these war crimes." Mr Roth's comments came after 90,000 protesters walked across the Sydney Harbour Bridge on Sunday, calling for an end to Israel's war in Gaza. Mr Roth said public opinion might be enough to force the hand of a populist leader like Donald Trump. "Trump is not indifferent to public opinion," Mr Roth said. Reasons for the shift include images of starving and emaciated children in Gaza being broadcast around the world, while the Israeli government issued multiple denials on the issue. The allegations of using starvation as a weapon of war have formed part of charges brought against Mr Netanyahu and former minister of defence Yoav Gallant by the International Criminal Court. Mr Roth, who is also a qualified lawyer, said he believed that nothing would see those charges rescinded. "Those are blatant war crimes," Mr Roth told 7.30. "They violate the Geneva Convention requirement that an occupying power allow access to humanitarian aid to a people in need. "That defines Gaza. "The fact that Netanyahu committed this crime … that he stops is not a defence to the months upon months in which he was committing the crime. Mr Roth believed the establishment of a Palestinian state would face obstacles, such as Hamas, past failures of the Palestinian Authority and Mr Netanyahu's unwillingness to see it happen. But he said the United States could play a major role in removing those obstacles. "Hamas has said that it would contemplate disarming and leaving Gaza if there were a clear path to a Palestinian state," Mr Roth said. "If we accept that as a negotiating position, then the main obstacle is Netanyahu, who basically has said, 'over my dead body, there's not going to be a Palestinian state.' "The only way to get past that comes back to President Trump. "It comes back to his enormous leverage. The $3.8 billion in annual aid he gives to Israel and massive flow of arms; if he were to say this only continues if you allow the Palestinian state, that allows us to stop the slaughter in Gaza, things like this can happen." Mr Roth told 7.30 he considered antisemitism "a real issue" for him and a real "hazard" for Jewish people, but criticised Australia's Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism, Jillian Segal, for selecting a controversial definition of antisemitism to base her work on. In her recently released report, Ms Segal urged the Australian government to "require consistent application and adoption" of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's (IHRA) working definition of antisemitism, calling it the "gold standard" in an interview with 7.30. Critics, including the definition's lead author, say it is being used to suppress legitimate criticism of Israel's policies. Mr Roth agreed. "This is a completely counterproductive approach to fighting antisemitism," he told 7.30. "The IHRA definition undermines the fight against antisemitism because it has come to be used over and over as an excuse to suppress legitimate criticism of Israel." The risk in the reliance on the IHRA definition, Mr Roth said, was to undermine the fight against antisemitism. "It cheapens the concept of antisemitism when it's very much needed. It basically prioritises defence of the Israeli government over the defence of Jews around the world," he said. "I have no problem with having a special envoy focused on fighting antisemitism, but if that envoy is really pushing a definition of antisemitism that amounts to defending and stopping criticism of Israel, that is counterproductive. "That is unhelpful for what Jews need to combat a genuine problem." Watch 7.30, Mondays to Thursdays 7:30pm on ABC iview and ABC TV Do you know more about this story? Get in touch with 7.30 here.
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Pauline Hanson's wild ceremony claims
One Nation senator Pauline Hanson believes teaching children to acknowledge country in school will condition people not to feel like they are part of Australia, and leave the nation defenceless in the face of war. Speaking on 10 News+, Senator Hanson said she wouldn't defend the country if she felt like the land belonged to one race of people. The One Nation leader defended her decision to reject Welcome to Country ceremonies in the Senate when she was questioned why her party's senators were present during ceremonies when they did not have to be there. Pauline Hanson has defended her decision to reject Welcome to Country ceremonies in an interview on 10 News+. Supplied / Channel 10 Credit: Channel 10 One Nation senators were called out by their Labor and Greens counterparts over 'childish stunts' and 'hurtful' behaviour when they turned their backs during proceedings. Senator Hanson said they had a right to be there and the new senators wanted to experience the opening of the Senate. 'But it's also to be a voice for the Australian people that have had a gut full of it and don't want to hear Welcome to Country anymore,' she said. 'It is showing leadership, that you don't have to go along with this. 'When our kids have been taught in school to put their hand on the ground and say, you know, acknowledge the land is Aboriginal, we're not making people feel part of this country. Senator Pauline Hanson said she would not defend Australia if she thought the land belonged to another race of people. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia 'And I'll ask the question, if we ever have war that touches our shores here and we've conditioned the people think this is not our land, it belongs to another race of people, how many Australians are going to get up and fight to defend it? 'I won't.' The Queensland senator hopes her legacy will be that people thought she did her best to stand up for a fair go for all Australians, without fear or favour, and promised to run again in three years time. 'I think that's important, people want that from their politicians,' she said. 'But I'm a conviction politician and I've had so much thrown at me – I've have been to prison, had everything bar the kitchen sink thrown at me. 'Guess what, I'm still standing, the problem is people have underestimated me.'
