Critic asks why controversial referee was chosen for Malaysia Cup final
KUALA LUMPUR: While there were top artistes and pyrotechnics in Saturday's Malaysia Cup final at Bukit Jalil, it was the referee who stole the show.
The match between Johor Darul Ta'zim (JDT) and Sri Pahang at the National Stadium was a tightly contested affair until some controversial decisions by the ref.
And football critic Datuk Dr Pekan Ramli was not amused.
Controversy first flared when JDT's Bergson da Silva saw his first-half goal ruled out for offside after a VAR review.
But the match's real flashpoint came when Sri Pahang's Sergio Aguero was sent off just before half-time after receiving a second yellow card for kicking Da Silva.
Referee Razlan Joffri Ali then awarded JDT a "soft penalty" in the second half, which Arif Aiman Hanapi converted.
It was a decision that sparked outrage among Sri Pahang supporters, who were already aggrieved by the earlier red cards and refereeing.
Pekan said: "I applaud Pahang, they played with a high fighting spirit despite knowing it would be tough to beat JDT. Before the red card, they matched JDT in every department.
"But the referee's performance? That's another story.
"I was shocked to see Razlan Joffri Ali appointed for the final. Normally, in a prestigious match, referees with strong, controversy-free records are given the honour. That's what happens in major tournaments like the World Cup. Why wasn't that standard applied here?" he asked.
Razlan was suspended last year for a previous incident involving Perak-JDT.
"You can see red flags in his refereeing history. Some of his decisions were questionable, especially the penalty.
"Fans aren't blind. They watch, they understand. The referee shouldn't be the 'angel of death' dictating outcomes with his whistle," he said.
Pekan pointed to the penalty decision as the match's turning point.
"Every game has one, and last night it was the penalty. It changed the result."
He warned that Malaysian football risks being stuck in a cycle of mistrust unless referee integrity is taken seriously.
"For the last two Malaysia Cup finals, we've spoken about the same issues with referees. It ruins the image of our football. Integrity must be the foundation of refereeing here. It's not about power, it's about trust," he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
an hour ago
- New Straits Times
'Local players must wake up and realise that everyone needs to fight for the best version of themselves'
KUALA LUMPUR: Former international Rezal Zambery Yahya said that the growing competition for places in the national team is a healthy sign for Malaysian football. The ex-Kelantan coach sees the increase in foreign player quota for the 2025-2026 Super League season, and the addition of five naturalised players to Harimau Malaya as developments that will only intensify the challenge for local players positively. Rather than seeing this as a threat, Rezal urged local players to treat it as motivation to improve themselves. "This is the trend in modern football. If players want to keep competing, they must have strong character, a good attitude, a positive mindset, and most importantly, be willing to work harder and train consistently," he said. "If this happens, not only will individual development improve, but it will benefit the team and the country as well. The positive impact will be felt immediately." He added that it's essential for players to adapt to the modern game, which now demands more than just natural talent. "Local players must wake up and realise that everyone needs to fight for the best version of themselves," he said.
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Rugby-Erasmus backs university student Makhaza to be future Springbok
FILE PHOTO: Rugby Union - South African head coach Rassie Erasmus' Press Conference - SARU House, Tygerberg Park, Cape Town, South Africa - March 5, 2025 South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus during the press conference REUTERS/Esa Alexander/File Photo (Reuters) -Coach Rassie Erasmus does not foresee an immediate Springbok cap for Ntokozo Makhaza, but believes the winger will one day wear the green and gold having been called into the South Africa squad without playing a game of professional rugby. Makhaza, 23, who found out about his selection for the start of the international season on social media, plays for the University of Cape Town in South Africa's Varsity Cup competition and is a reliable goal-kicker and speedy on the wing. He is studying for a degree in psychology and social development and has never been tested against professional players. "It's been a pleasure to work with him," Erasmus told reporters on Thursday. "He's consistently been the top Varsity Cup player, and especially in terms of point scoring, probably one of the best in the competition's history. "You sometimes wonder, is this one of those players who slipped through the cracks? It's been good to see what he brings." Erasmus suggests the June 28 meeting with the Barbarians in Cape Town, and July's two tests against Italy and one versus Georgia, might come too soon, but believes Makhaza could wear the jersey in the future. "We definitely think he's someone who could play for the Springboks one day. It might be a bit early now. He's slotted in really well, but we're also being realistic. Having said that, he's certainly not far off the pace," Erasmus said. "I think he's going to make it one day. And if we hadn't given him this chance, we'd never know." Erasmus revealed there are several players with long-term injuries that are unlikely to feature for the Springboks this year – props Trevor Nyakane and Frans Malherbe, hooker/loose-forward Deon Fourie, and loose-forwards Elrigh Louw and Cameron Hanekom. Better news is the return to fitness in the coming weeks of several World Cup winners, including flanker Pieter-Steph du Toit, number eight Jasper Wiese and scrumhalf Grant Williams. (Reporting by Nick SaidEditing by Christian Radnedge)
New Straits Times
2 hours ago
- New Straits Times
MA plays it safe this time after 2023 flop
KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia Athletics (MA) won't ask for trouble this time. No bold gold medal-target proclaimation from the national association for the Thailand Sea Games in December. MA has wisened up. For the 2023 Phnom Penh Sea Games, Malaysia Athletics Federation (MAF) declared an eyebrow-raising 10-gold target. It turned out MAF was only 'half successful' as its athletes won only five gold. Overall, the Malaysian contingent failed to meet their target in Phnom Penh and the athletics squad were criticised for being a letdown. MA president Datuk Seri Shahidan Kassim was more cautious this time. He said that MAF would not reveal the gold-target for Bangkok. "The sports minister will announce the number of gold target for athletics soon. But we want to make sure our athletes deliver better than five golds in Bangkok. "When the athletes don't perform, the president and association get the blame. But when the athletes perform, no one praises the president or the association," said Shahidan.
