
The ‘emotional toll' of buying a home in Ireland: ‘split' deals and queueing for houses already sold
My husband and I moved here from Brazil three years ago with our infant son, with our daughter arriving shortly afterwards. We have since joined the race to buy a home, like many immigrants and plenty of Irish natives too.
At first, I was hopeful. The Help to Buy (HTB) scheme seemed like a much-needed support for first-time buyers, but that hope quickly gave way to frustration as I watched prices soar and floor plans shrink.
I lost count of how many emails, phone calls and, most of all, how much energy I poured into conversations with estate agents, desperately trying to secure a place in competitive launch queues.
READ MORE
On the line, the agent sounded embarrassed as they explained that all the HTB units had already been reserved before the sale
As an immigrant without family roots here, I tried to stay open-minded. I broadened my search and considered properties in four counties surrounding Dublin.
I viewed homes in Louth, Meath, Wicklow, and Wexford but had to limit the search as the daily commute would be too punishing.
I have finally secured a home and am waiting to get the keys, but over the course of my long house-hunting journey, I have come across many worrying proposals.
In one case, after four months of back-and-forth with an estate agent about a new development, I received a call just days before the official launch. On the line, the agent sounded embarrassed as they explained that all the HTB units had already been reserved before the sale.
In one situation, an estate agent offered me an unofficial deal for a house in Co Wicklow: pay €25,000 in cash, off the books, to secure a property that was still within the HTB scheme. The agent called it a 'split' deal.
There was a separate proposal involving a different estate agent and developer in Newtownmountkennedy, Co Wicklow, details of which are reported in The Irish Times today. Here, an agent from Sherry FitzGerald offered me a former show house priced at €525,000, which had been visited by hundreds of potential buyers.
I was told the price would be 'split' between the cost of the house - €500,000, which is the maximum price to qualify for the HTB scheme, and an additional €25,000 for the flooring in the 102sq m home.
When I queried the cost of the flooring, the agent replied to say: 'We will offer the property to the next person on the list looking for HTB.'
Sherry FitzGerald has launched an internal investigation into the matter, and Revenue says it takes 'any attempt to bypass or understate the full value of a property extremely seriously', while declining to comment on individual cases.
As an immigrant without family roots here, I tried to stay open-minded. I broadened my search and considered properties in four counties surrounding Dublin
But should it really be this hard to buy a house? In the midst of a housing crisis, first-time buyers still have to deal with situations like this.
When things that should be simple become so difficult, it is only natural to start questioning the cost, not just the financial one, but the emotional toll as well.
Clara Franco is a freelance journalist based in Dublin
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Dublin-listed Aquila European Renewables hits hurdle winding down
Aquila European Renewables (AER), the UK-based green energy company that took on a secondary listing in Dublin two years ago, has hit a hurdle in its plans to wind down as the potential buyer of a large portion of its assets scaled back its bid. The company, whose shares have been rarely traded in Dublin since the dual listing, said that it has paused the sales process with the preferred bidder, who is no longer in exclusivity. Still, it says that that 'dialogue remains open' between both sides. The unnamed bidder was originally being lined up to buy less than half of its assets. Its assets had a net value of €317.4 million at the end of March. 'After comprehensive and positive due diligence by, and extensive negotiations with, the preferred bidder resulting in a broadly agreed form share purchase agreement, a revised offer from the preferred bidder has been received,' it said. 'This revised offer has seen the preferred bidder reduce the number of assets they can currently acquire, with their current available funds. The indicated acquisition price has also been further reduced.' READ MORE It added: 'The revised offer would mean a less material proportion of the portfolio would be sold and is expected to lead to a situation which is potentially prejudicial to the marketability of the balance of the portfolio.' The board will provide an update to shareholders on the sales process once the implications and alternatives have been properly explored, the company said. AER, which floated in London in May 2019, had a wind, solar and hydro power portfolio with a capacity of 435 megawatts (MW) across Scandinavia, Greece, Spain and Portugal at the end of December, according to its latest financial report. It stated at the time of the initial public offering that it would target projects in the Republic but that never materialised. AER chose to list in Dublin to enhance the company's appeal to investors across Europe while being quoted in an English-speaking market. However, it failed to boost trading in the stock. The company decided last September to put itself into wind-down as the stock had consistently traded at a discount to its intrinsic value and other headwinds. The company sold its 18 per cent interest in an almost 108MW Portugues hydropower project last month for €16.5 million, in line with the asset's valuation on its books at the end of 2024. AER is also pursuing sales processes for other remaining assets that were not part of the exclusivity talks. These include a Finnish wind asset and other unspecified projects. Shares in Aquila have fallen by 40 per cent over the past five years in London.


Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
More than half of Irish estate agents see house prices levelling off soon
Irish home prices are expected to rise by a further 5 per cent over the next 12 months, amid ongoing supply shortages, according to a survey of estate agent members of the Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland (SCSI). Joe Brennan reports on the predicted growth. However, 60 per cent of those polled see prices levelling off soon, with a further 18 per cent saying that they have already peaked – after a dozen years of continuous growth. Joe Brennan also reports on Goodbody Stockbrokers making a number of senior hires in a bid to boost the business. A number of staff left the organisation's investment banking area in late 2023, during and after a redundancy programme. Among the appointments is Stephen Kane, a former corporate finance director with the firm, who left in October 2023 for householder Cairn Homes. READ MORE In her latest column, Pilita Clark writes about the really concerning thing about the Coldplay concert scandal. This scandal, of course, concerns the former CEO of tech company Astronomer, who was caught with his arms wrapped around the company's head of human resources. Their embrace was captured on the big screen at the band's concert in Boston and has gone viral. Pilita Clark addresses the barrage of fabricated online statements purporting to be from those with insight. 'Some governments are trying to legislate against this muck, notably in the EU. The Coldplay couple — and the misleading maelstrom that followed their exposure — are a reminder that many more authorities need to join them,' she says. The co-founder of Dublin restaurant group Kinara and president of the Restaurant's Association of Ireland, Seán Collender, revealed the details of the impact of rising input costs that are leaving hospitality businesses on 'an extremely fine line'. 'These are huge, huge costs and we don't sell gold bars, we sell food,' he told Hugh Dooley. We need to enact a specific legal mandate, in the overriding national interest, to drive forward critical projects and avoid the endless round of planning applications, appeals and judicial reviews. Had we done that for the metro, it would have been finished a decade ago, writes John FitzGerald in his weekly column. 'But unless the planning system is reformed, I'm unlikely during my lifetime to ride the metro or drink Shannon water from my tap,' he says. How will the updated National Development Plan shape Ireland in years to come? Listen | 35:59 In 2025, it is both remarkable and disappointing that progress in tackling the gender gap in leadership is taking a backwards step in Ireland, with a 24.8 per cent year-on-year drop in women hired into top jobs here. There are no women leading any of the major Irish companies listed on stock markets, writes Sue Duke , vice-president of global public policy at LinkedIn, in our Business Opinion slot. If you would like to read more about the issues that affect your finances, sign up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers.

Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Every Irish person contributes €53.20 a month to the EU. We should be prepared to pay more
The European Commission's publication of its draft of the union's €2 trillion 2028-2034 budget, the Multiannual Financial Framework ( MFF ), once again opens up a tortuous two years of likely acrimonious budget negotiations. Twenty seven states and the European Parliament must unanimously agree – in talks as complicated as four-dimensional chess – a new package of political imperatives, from defence, immigration, climate change, industrial innovation and inflation to safeguarding historic programmes such as CAP and cohesion. By all appearances, this will be an utterly impossible reconciliation. Helping to steer a path towards it will be the onerous central challenge of next year's Irish presidency . And complicating that challenge for cash-strapped Dublin negotiators will be a plethora of threats to programmes that are particularly important to us to us – CAP; changes to delivery mechanisms; new demands such as defence; and arguments about the scale of increasing burdens on budget net contributors. In truth, according to Zsolt Darvas from think tank Bruegel , MFF spending needs to double to finance the climate transition and pay off its Covid-19 debts. His views echo those in an important report last year from former Italian prime minister Mario Draghi, calling for an additional €800 billion a year of private- and public-sector investment to revive Europe's economic competitiveness. READ MORE The commission's budget is more modest, some €1.816 trillion (plus €165 billion in pandemic recovery debt repayments), up from the current 1.1 per cent of union gross national income to 1.15 per cent. And all at a time when member states are all adamant they will not pay a penny more, although commission president Ursula von der Leyen insists unconvincingly their contributions do not need to go up. [ The Irish Times view on the EU budget: major barriers to getting an agreement Opens in new window ] Irish farmers should be pleased to see direct income payments to farmers ring-fenced. However, agricultural economists here worry that rural development and environmental support payments are to be hived off into a broader regional fund pot and are likely to be squeezed – similar to the cohesion fund for poorer regions, which was once an important Irish staple. MEPs from the regions are also already screaming blue murder at the 'renationalisation' or centralisation of regional funding – 27 national plans would replace more than 500 current programmes. They are alarmed it would substantially reduce regional autonomy and funding which makes up more than one-third of the current budget. Von der Leyen's juggling trick also involves fancy footwork in respect of expanding the union's 'own resources' – or funding from non-member state sources. Such taxation needs to be targeted so that it does not impinge on the domestic tax base and revenues of governments. Most controversially this time is the suggestion of levying a tax on companies with a net annual turnover of at least €100 million. This is expected to generate only €6.8 billion but is already facing determined opposition. Speaking like an Irish finance minister, Germany's chancellor Friedrich Merz has warned that 'there is no question of the EU taxing companies, as the EU has no legal basis for this'. Other proposed new 'own resources' include taxes targeting electric waste (around €15 billion annually), tobacco products/companies (€11.2 billion), a carbon border tax (€1.4 billion), and a tax on revenues generated by emissions trading (€9.6 billion). EU capitals will also worry how the new budget would affect the politically sensitive difference between national contributions and receipts. [ Proposed €2tn EU budget would increase funding for defence Opens in new window ] From 1973 to 2018 Ireland was a net recipient, in nominal terms, of more than €40 billion in EU funds. By 2023, 10 countries, including Ireland, were net contributors, and 17 were net beneficiaries. Top of the net contributors were Germany (€19.8 billion), France (€9.3 billion), with Ireland in eighth place (€1.3 billion). Poland was the top net beneficiary, receiving €7.1 billion. Ireland was second in net contribution per head, at €240 per person. Courtesy of our growing relative wealth (measured dubiously by 'GDP per cap') we displaced Luxembourg in 2024 in paying the most to the EU budget on a gross per capita basis – with every Irish person contributing some €53.20 a month to the union's coffers compared to the EU average of €25.20 and Germans' €29.70. Bulgarians contributed €10.70 a month. Net cash contributions have been seized on by many national politicians and the press as evidence that the countries of the supposedly indolent south are unfairly milking the system at the expense of fiscally responsible northerners. But the real benefits of membership to the countries of the north amount to far more than can be measured by such direct transfer figures. Apart from the progressive aims of redressing EU-wide economic imbalances, helping poorer neighbours and levelling the playing field, the EU provides huge indirect and non-cash benefits disproportionately to net contributing members such as Ireland. These include financial rewards from the European Central Bank in maintaining financial stability and financial returns, valuable access to the single market and research grants through the Horizon programme. Making the political case for increasing our contribution yet again will not be easy but it must be done.