New Plymouth councillor felt 'disdain' and 'contempt' at Treaty Principles Bill meeting
Photo:
Supplied / NPDC
A New Plymouth District Councillor says he felt treated with "disdain" and "contempt" at a meeting where the regional council voted againt submitting on the Treaty Principles Bill.
A internal review has found there was agreement among councillors ahead of the December meeting to oppose making a submission on the bill and to curtail debate.
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/568462/review-condemns-taranaki-regional-council-treaty-principles-bill-decision-making
It found the decision-making process inconsistent with standing orders, meeting protocols and broader principles of good governance, transparency and natural justice.
The review said the consequences of the meeting were "severe", damaging the council's reputation, and resulted in a loss of trust and confidence from iwi partners.
Dinnie Moeahu said his pre-approved deputation - a presentation given ahead of the meeting proper on an item in the agenda - was shut down.
"The agenda item was made public for anybody to consider and I actually thought how they treated me was with disdain and contempt for me just wanting to speak.
"As I was getting up to speak, a number of councillors decided that wasn't appropriate.
"I felt like there was some clear bullying tactics from three elected members with regards to even having me speak and essentially I was shut down initially."
Moeahu was later invited to speak when the agenda item was called up and gave the talk he intended.
But when former council chair Charlotte Littlewood called for debate on the submission deputy chair and nine term veteran, Neil Walker, told council the bill was political and divisive and the TRC should leave it Parliament to sort out.
Councillor Donald McIntyre promptly moved a motion, seconded by Walker, not to send the submission or debate it, which was won.
Moeahu was left gobsmacked.
"As you can read in the report that pre-determination and collusion that happened beforehand those elected members executed that superbly on the day which caught everybody off guard.
He couldn't believe the behaviour of the regional councillors.
"They are put in there to serve and what's highlighted in the report is their failure to understand their role as elected members.
"They have statutory obligations to Māori and they say in their long term plan one of their objectives is to strengthen their relationship with Māori ... and they just shut it down with no discussion."
Moeahu said he hope recommendations in the review - which included that councillors receive training on Te Tiriti o Waitangi and its application to council work - would improve behaviour in the future.
Taranaki Regional Councillor Neil Walker.
Photo:
Taranaki Daily News
Walker hoped the review would put to an end to a messy eight month investigation.
He conceded he didn't want the TRC to send a submission, but said the decision was not pre-determined.
But Walker thought any suggestion of collusion was a bit harsh.
"There would be occasion when we see our colleagues around council and out socially, and people have views and they just share them back and forth.
"I don't consider that colluding, but we recognise that there were people who were upset and it's time to put the matter to bed.
"As for colluding, that's a strong term. I think counsellors always talk about all sorts of things and you'd expect us to do that, wouldn't you?"
Walker said the TRC wanted to work with Māori and if people were unhappy with the way things were done he was sorry for that.
"I certainly didn't support Mr Seymour's bill. I never have and we now are in a position where that bill never went anywhere, and I'm pleased it didn't."
Walker said he was open to doing some professional development on Te Tiriti o Waitangi as councillors did at the start of every new term.
TRC chair Craig Williamson said there was no doubt the controversy had set back council-iwi relations.
"It's been very damaging and it's set us back years in our relationship building and through the Treaty settlements we have to by law work closely with our iwi partners on just about everything we do."
Williamson said he was relatively new to the role and had been working hard to rebuild relationships.
"I think that the future is going to look a lot brighter than it did back in December."
He said councillors had been caught off guard by how the meeting turned.
"I'd never seen that particular motion used before where a debate can be quashed. I wasn't expecting it.
"So, we're looking at something where if a meeting does get out of hand and everything gets a bit flustered, so to speak. Then we could take a break, have a cup of tea."
Williamson said recommendations in the review offered an opportunity for councillors to learn from their mistakes.
"When I first stepped into the role as a councillor, there was no induction for me. I turned up to a meeting and that was the start of it.
"So, I think it's really important that there is an induction conducted for all councillors, which is inclusive and thorough and everybody gets a good grip on the role that they've been elected to."
Councillors will consider the review and whether to adopt its recommendations on 5 August.
Dinnie Moeahu was due to speak at that meeting.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Dead public service boss's remains brought into office
The National Library was originally going to be closed for the service, before it was moved to the Department of Internal Affairs' Wellington office. Photo: Google Maps A senior public servant's remains were taken to his Government department's office for a memorial service, after initial plans for them to be taken to the National Library were abandoned. Internal Affairs Minister Brooke van Velden says neither scenario was appropriate. The Department of Internal Affairs confirmed staff came together last week to farewell Deputy Secretary of Policy and Te Tiriti, Michael Lovett, in the department's Pipitea Street offices. Lovett's remains were brought onsite for the service. A spokesperson said: "Michael Lovett, Deputy Secretary at the Department of Internal Affairs, passed away last week after a short battle with cancer. "Michael made a significant contribution during his eight years at the Department and his loss is keenly felt." They said that on 1 August, staff from the Department and other colleagues came together at the DIA office to farewell Michael at a private event. Michael Lovett died last week after a short battle with cancer. Photo: LinkedIn Van Velden confirmed the service was originally planned to be held at the National Library and would've necessitated its temporary closure. "Firstly, my heart goes out to the grieving family and friends of the deceased - it is no doubt a very difficult time for them with the passing of a loved one. "I have expressed my view to the chief executive that I do not believe it was appropriate to plan to close the National Library for this purpose, nor for a deceased person to be present at the department's offices, and he has assured me that it will not happen again. Van Velden said the National Library remained open and the service ended up being held in a meeting room - in Internal Affair's central Wellington office - which was not open to the public. "I appreciate that staff may wish to mourn and express grief after the passing of a colleague, but I have asked the chief executive to review what occurred and look to alternatives that may be considered in future," van Velden said. A spokesperson for the Department of Internal Affairs said Lovett - who spent eight years at Internal Affairs - "passed away last week after a short battle with cancer". The Public Service Commission has been approached for comment but directed enquiries to the Department of Internal Affairs. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Education Minister David Seymour says NCEA changes will challenge students more
Associate Education Minister David Seymour. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Associate Education Minister David Seymour says changes to NCEA will challenge students more, which he believes can only be a positive thing. The government announced sweeping changes to school qualifications on Monday, including the end of the NCEA system that has been in place for more than 20 years. The National Certificate of Educational Achievement will be gone by 2030, replaced by a basic literacy and numeracy award at Year 11, and the Certificate of Education and Advanced Certificate of Education at Years 11 and 12. The new certificates would be standards-based, like the NCEA is, meaning every student passes if they demonstrate the required knowledge or skills, but they would have to study at least five complete subjects and pass four of them to get their certificate. Seymour said students wanted to be challenged more, and the overhaul to the NCEA system will provide that. "I was really interested to listen ... there were some students who seem to make a virtue of NCEA's easiness, as they saw it," he told First Up. "But there was a strong current running through those comments from the students. There was actually a desire for a bit more challenge. "One of the things that will happen is that by having a subject-based system, where there's a body of knowledge that you have to learn, where there's exams that are objectively assessed, I think that that extra challenge is going to be there. "I think for those students and for the country as a whole, that can only be a positive thing." Seymour said the only real predictor of where New Zealand's going to be in 30 years' time is the amount of knowledge that is passed from one generation to the next. He said there is an element of the European system in the changes. "There, they have more vocational pathways and I'm not saying that we're introducing a particular country system, but there's a hint of it. "That if you're somebody who wants to do something more practical, and I look at the prospects of people coming out of their studies, and I often joke, I wish I'd been smart enough to choose being an electrician over an electrical engineer, because it's those tradies that everyone's so short of." Seymour sympathised with educators having to adapt to a new policy change, to allow everyone impacted to catch up. But he is confident support will be on hand as they map out the overhaul. "I'm sure that as the implementation rolls out, that support will be at the forefront of the government's mind," he said. "But we haven't got to the point right now, we're just consulting on the shape of it. What I would say is that, because we are going back to something that is subject-based, I think some people might say it's a bit more prescriptive, then it's going to be clearer to educators, this is what the curriculum is. This is how it's assessed." Seymour said there will be less work do "creating bespoke pathways". "I think that's something generally, that after the New Zealand curriculum came out in 200 - since we've had a unit-based assessment for most of this century - it's actually been harder for teachers because we don't have, 'here's the body of knowledge, here's the assessment, go to it.' "We've had a lot more background work for educators to work out what the pathway actually is for each student, and I hope that this approach will be welcomed." Macleans College principal and ministerial advisory panellist Steve Hargreaves said the changes provided more clarity and he expected it to be implemented correctly. "I think this is going to be phased really well, we do have a pretty long lead in," he told Morning Report. "We're going to get the curriculum first and that's how it should be, so we learn what to teach and how to teach it before we start designing the assessments. "There is a lot going on in primary school, but from what I can hear from my colleagues there, those changes to structured literacy and numeracy are landing really well." Hargreaves said students will join high school better prepared, and that teachers he had spoken to were really positive about the changes. He also believed it would encourage students to extend their stay at secondary school. "This is a bit of a guess, but I think it might lift the de facto leaving age," he said. "Now, if there's this indication that, well, you've got Level 1 and that's some kind of a leaving certificate, then students might head out the door. "But now with the sort of the base level achievement occurs at Year 12, then I think we will see more students staying on." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Man running for mayor in two cities under different names
It's not every day someone runs for mayor in two cities at once - let alone under two different names. But that's exactly what the brother of Invercargill's outgoing mayor is doing - and not everyone's thrilled. Katie Todd has the story.
