Israeli occupation and an armed Hezbollah are not sustainable for Lebanon
The Cabinet voted this month, after much contention, to return a complete monopoly over arms to the state. But implementing this decision is not so easy, and the matter is complicated by the fact that Israeli soldiers remain stationed as foreign invaders on Lebanese soil, despite international calls for them to depart.
In Beirut on Monday, the US envoy Tom Barrack said: 'I think the Lebanese government has done their part. They've taken the first step. Now what we need is Israel to comply with that equal handshake."
But despite the ceasefire between Israel and Lebanon that has been in place since November, Israel continues to attack parts of its northern neighbour almost daily. Just last week, the Israeli army chief Lt Gen Eyal Zamir boasted on his visit to Israeli troops in southern Lebanon about breaching the truce 600 times.
While huge numbers of Lebanese today distrust Hezbollah for very good reason, not least of which includes its decision to start a war with Israel in 2023, the longer Israeli troops remain, the greater the chances are of Hezbollah regaining some popular support among communities affected by Israeli occupation. There is a finite window, in all likelihood, for disarmament to take place, and for the Lebanese state to have a stronger future. The latter point is apparently of little concern to Ali Larjani, Iran's top security official, who was in Beirut just before Mr Barrack and threatened that tampering with Hezbollah's arsenal was not an option.
There is a finite window, in all likelihood, for disarmament to take place
As they continue to muster the courage and support needed to stand up to such interference, the government in Beirut seeks support in strengthening the Lebanese Armed Forces. Hezbollah has, for many years, operated as a state within a state, with its own economy, military, political machinery and social welfare net. In the context of the corruption and chaos that characterised Lebanese politics for so long, this was an unexceptional – though still appalling – state of affairs. Now, it ought to be intolerable if the country is to meet its long-held potential as a cultural and economic powerhouse for the region.
Lebanon's ally, the US, should see this potential, too, and help realise it. It has devoted much effort to pushing Lebanon to disarm Hezbollah, and now it must press Israel with equal passion to stick to its end of the agreement, withdraw its forces and end its campaign of violence in the country.
Armed factionalism and foreign occupation have been the undoing of Lebanon several times over in the country's young history. Now, it is time for a new chapter.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
2 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
US-Palestinian advocacy group condemns Trump administration's sanctions on ICC officials
A US-Palestinian advoacy group has condemned the Trump administration's decision to sanction ICC judges and prosecutors as a "disgrace." "When the US punishes judges for daring to pursue justice for Palestinian victims, it confirms what so many of us already fear — that international law doesn't apply to the powerful, regardless of the gravity of their crimes," Sandra Tamari, Executive Director of Adalah Justice Project, told Middle East Eye. 'Palestinians turned to the ICC because every other door was slammed in our faces. And now, even that door is being torched. These sanctions are not just political; they are moral failure. If genocide and apartheid can't even be investigated without retaliation, then what justice is left for our people?' she added.
Middle East Eye
2 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Targeted for Gaza protests: The Palestinian still in US custody
Of all the high-profile, pro-Palestine, non-US citizen arrests linked to campus protests made by the Trump administration's immigration authorities earlier this year, Leqaa Kordia is the only one still languishing in a detention centre in Alvaredo, Texas. On Monday, the 32-year-old's lawyers filed an updated petition in her federal lawsuit seeking her immediate release from the Prairieland Detention Facility based on new evidence unearthed last month in a separate case. The case in question is American Association of University Professors (AAUP) v. Rubio, which sought to challenge Secretary of State Marco Rubio's policy of what the plaintiffs describe as a "policy of ideological deportation". It was during the AAUP v. Rubio trial that government officials revealed they leaned on the pro-Israel doxxing site Canary Mission to target particular students for immigration detention. "The evidence shows that the administration's policy of targeting, investigating, surveilling, arresting, confining and seeking the deportation of noncitizens who have expressed support for Palestinians extends to anyone involved in protests on or near campuses, irrespective of affiliation with a campus or immigration status," a statement from Kordia's legal representatives at the Texas Civil Rights Project (TCRP), Muslim Advocates (MA), and the CLEAR Project at the City University of New York (CUNY) said. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters "This new evidence makes clear that Ms Kordia's targeting is part and parcel of the same, suppressive policy the administration has weaponised against so many others, including Mahmoud Khalil, Rumeysa Ozturk and Mohsen Mahdawi, whose release federal courts have compelled under the First Amendment," the statement continued. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) attempted to strip Khalil, Ozturk and Mahdawi of their legal status in the US at the time they were taken away by Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents (ICE). For Kordia, the DHS maintains that she was already out of status at the time she was arrested in New Jersey, and issued a statement on 14 March insisting she was "overstaying her expired F-1 student visa", which was terminated on 26 January 2022 for "lack of attendance". US federal judge grants bail to Turkish national Rumeysa Ozturk Read More » The DHS also cited Kordia's arrest by the New York Police Department in April 2024 during a protest against Israel's war on Gaza, organised by Columbia University students. The police, however, had arrested several students at the time, and Kordia was eventually let go after charges against her were dropped. "It is true that at that time she did not have lawful status," Amal Thabateh, a staff attorney at CLEAR who is working on Kordia's case, told Middle East Eye. She thought she was close to becoming a lawful permanent resident because her US citizen family had filed for such a status on her behalf, Thabateh explained. But upon receiving "faulty advice" from a mentor, Kordia voluntarily signed a termination notice, withdrawing from the F-1 visa program, leaving her out of status entirely. "We all know based on how other cases have gone, and just routinely [that] this happens all the time where people have losses in status," Thabateh told MEE. "They're in transition periods... and that's quickly solved and fixed." 'Forgotten prisoner' But that wasn't the case in what is now the era of enforcement under US President Donald Trump's aggressive immigration crackdown targeting pro-Palestine voices. "The ways in which the government has criminalised the visa overstay is just another attempt to target Palestinian rights activists," Thabateh said. "The question is not whether overstaying a visa is criminal or a violation, but instead it's whether the ways in which Leqaa has been punished and targeted, whether that is a justification for very innocently following false advice about her immigration status." Kordia arrived in the US from the occupied West Bank in 2016 on a Palestinian Authority passport, was initially a visitor before adjusting her status to a student as she began learning English. Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil files $20m claim against Trump administration Read More » She has lost 200 extended family members to Israel's genocide in Gaza. Thabateh told MEE that Kordia voluntarily went to meet with immigration agents to find out what was happening after learning that people who knew her were being questioned about her life, and that agents had also approached her home. It was during that meeting in Newark, New Jersey, that she was served with a notice to appear in court, and then taken away overnight to the Texas facility. Kordia has frequently described poor and discriminatory treatment at the Prairieland Detention Facility to her legal team, but they say that she's persevering. "I think that her spirits are strong, but the conditions she's enduring are not easy," Golnaz Fakhimi, the legal director at Muslim Advocates, told MEE. Authorities interfered with her ability to observe Ramadan and did not provide accommodations so she could carry out her five daily prayers as a Muslim, Kordia had told renowned Muslim scholar and civil rights activist Omar Suleiman, who was granted a visit with her in May. He had called her "the forgotten prisoner" in an op-ed published earlier this year. "In litigation, the government has taken the position that that her confinement is based on having overstayed a visa, [but] the authority that the government has asserted... is a discretionary authority," Fakhimi said. "She is not someone who, by law, has to be confined." "The underlying policy of the administration to target non-citizens - according to the government's own officials who testified - really zeroed in on association with viewpoints supportive of Palestine," she added. "I think it's pretty clear what there is to see when you read between the lines. They're confining her because they have marching orders to do that pursuant to an umbrella-level policy." On 27 June, US Magistrate Judge Rebecca Rutherford recommended to the federal judge in the case filed against DHS Secretary Kristi Noem - Kordia v. Noem - that Kordia should be released, given the main threat present is one to her own liberty. She remains in custody after a government appeal.
The National
5 hours ago
- The National
Hezbollah urges Lebanon to 'take step back' from plan to disarm group
Hezbollah has called on Lebanon's leaders to reconsider their plan to disarm the group, warning it could destabilise the country if there is no similar step back by Israel. The Lebanese cabinet voted two weeks ago to endorse a US plan to disarm Hezbollah and other militants and assert a state monopoly on weapons. The contentious decision was made in the absence of Shiite ministers, highlighting deep divisions on the issue. After meeting Lebanon's President Joseph Aoun on Monday, US envoy Tom Barrack said Lebanese leaders had 'done their part' and that 'now what we need is Israel to comply with that equal handshake '. But Hezbollah does not expect that to happen, said the group's spokesman and head of media relations Youssef Al Zein. 'We hope we're wrong, but we don't expect that Barrack will return with a positive Israeli response,' he told The National. He accused the US and allies of 'applying what the Israeli entity wants as soon as possible – even at the cost of Lebanon's stability'. Mr Al Zein called on the Lebanese government to 'take a step back and re-evaluate, not only waiting for the Israeli response or approval, but a step back to rectify a decision that could put the country in an unstable position'. Iran-backed Hezbollah has repeatedly said it will not accept a disarmament plan until Israel withdraws from Lebanese territory and stops its attacks on the country – a commitment Israel has yet to make. Israeli military's chief of staff Lt Gen Eyal Zamir boasted last week that air strikes on Lebanon had breached a ceasefire about 600 times. Hezbollah is concerned that the US and allies are dictating the pace and substance of Lebanese decision-making on national security. But the group's opponents in Lebanon accuse it of prioritising Iran's interests at the cost of Lebanon's stability. Hezbollah claims the state itself has failed to enforce the ceasefire's obligations on Israel and that the Lebanese leadership 'justifies every step it takes on the basis of foreign pressure', Mr Al Zein said. Lebanon, a small nation with a historically weak and chronically underfunded national army, has long been under the sway of competing foreign powers. Hezbollah leader Naim Qassem has warned there would be 'no life' for Lebanon if the government confronted the group, accusing it of yielding to US demands on Israel's behalf. Iran has told Lebanese leaders that the group cannot be disarmed as the prospect of a new war with Israel grows, according to sources briefed on meetings of Iran's security chief Ali Larijani in Beirut last week. Hezbollah and its arsenal serve as Iran's first line of defence against Israel, which remains determined to neutralise the threat posed by the group. Mr Al Zein said Lebanon is being pressured to offer 'free gifts' to Israel, 'without any guarantees in return,' even as Israeli forces continue to occupy five strategic positions in southern Lebanon and conduct near-daily attacks despite the ceasefire announced last November. 'The Israeli military's chief of staff walked into Lebanese territory and bragged that they've killed more than 240 Lebanese citizens and conducted over 600 air raids since the ceasefire was declared,' he said. 'And not a single Lebanese authority responded to this.' Hezbollah maintains that it has shown willingness to abide by the ceasefire by disarming south of the Litani River. 'We've shown our commitment to the ceasefire through our actions,' Mr Al Zein said. Rather than insisting on Israel's withdrawal and an end to Israeli attacks, 'the Lebanese state has not committed to the ceasefire in the same way', he added.
