Garda whistleblower claims financial penalisation after voicing concerns about equipment
Detective superintendent Brian O'Reilly has taken his case against An Garda Síochána (AGS) to Dublin Circuit Civil Court in a bid to have his full remuneration reinstated. He claims Garda Commissioner Drew Harris has breached protections for whistleblowers enshrined in legislation by penalising him after he had made protected disclosures.
Det Supt O'Reilly claimed in his protected disclosure that leather holsters issued to gardaí for their firearms, made and supplied by an equine saddlery in Kildare, may have been responsible for the serious accidental self-wounding of a garda on protection duty. The injured garda was on duty at the residence of the Israeli ambassador in Dublin on June 11th, 2020.
That incident was followed six days later by the murder of Detective Garda Colm Horkan, who was shot and killed by an individual who disarmed him by taking his gun from his holster. That person was later convicted of Det Garda Horkan's capital murder.
READ MORE
Rosario Boyle SC, appearing with Conor Duff BL, for Det Supt O'Reilly, on Monday told the court her client had suffered 'dire' consequences at such a large reduction in remuneration. This had resulted in difficulties paying his mortgage, it was claimed. His pay has been reduced to 50 per cent of what it ordinarily would be, as the illness that has forced him out of work is classified by AGS as an 'ordinary' sickness rather than 'injury from duty'.
Ms Boyle said that in January, the gardaí's executive director, people and development, Yvonne Cooke, rejected Det Supt O'Reilly's application for his absence to be classified as 'injury from duty'. She did so on the basis of a report by a detective chief superintendent asked to investigate the cause of the illness-injury. She also considered the views of An Garda Síochána's chief medical officer.
Conor Power SC, for the Garda Commissioner, told Judge John O'Connor there was no proof to suggest Det Supt O'Reilly's absence from work had been categorised in such a way because he made a protected disclosure. He said Det Supt O'Reilly's stance was 'this has been refused to me, therefore it's penalisation because I made a protected disclosure'.
Judge O'Connor has said he will endeavour to deliver a judgment by the end of the month, with the case listed for mention on July 25th.
Det Supt O'Reilly made his protected disclosure about the holsters in June 2021, saying he had 'ongoing significant concerns'. In the second half of 2022, he raised further concerns internally about plans for a 'defective' leather pistol holster to be tested by Garda armourers at the request of Garda Commissioner Drew Harris. Det Supt O'Reilly said he raised these concerns as he believed they were not qualified.
He believed efforts were made to undermine him, including excluding him from decision-making, and to force him out of his position as acting head of the Garda National Technical Bureau.
In late 2022, having placed a circular about 'defective' holsters on the Garda portal, he declined a request from management to withdraw it, he claims.
In April 2023, Det Supt O'Reilly began a period of sick leave which, he says, was brought about because of his work. In July of that year, he was informed he was being placed under investigation for breach of discipline. This related to his claimed actions around the commission of a second report by Garda management on the leather pistol holster.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
30 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Man appears in court charged with murder of Limerick pensioner
A man appeared before a special court sitting on Saturday night charged with murdering a pensioner in Limerick. Philip Ambrose, (43), did not reply when charged with murdering Michael Hayes, (71), gardaí told Limerick District Court. Mr Ambrose, of no fixed address, did not speak during the brief late night hearing before Judge Alec Gabbett. Mr Ambrose was arrested last Friday morning, a few hours after Mr Hayes was allegedly attacked near his home at St Michael's Court, Watergate in Limerick city centre at about 11.30pm on Thursday. READ MORE Mr Hayes was found with critical injuries near the block of apartments where he had been living. He was pronounced dead at University Hospital Limerick. Garda Aoife Quinn told the court she arrested Mr Ambrose at Henry Street Garda station at 6.35pm on Saturday, for the purpose of charging him with the murder of Mr Hayes. Garda Quinn said Mr Ambrose 'made no reply to the charge after caution'. Mr Ambrose's solicitor, Turlough Herbert, told the court that he was not applying for bail. He noted bail applications in respect of a murder charge can only be made before the High Court. Mr Herbert applied for legal aid and said his client was in receipt of a disability allowance. Judge Gabbett acceded the application and granted Mr Ambrose free legal aid. The judge ordered that a psychiatric evaluation be conducted in respect of Mr Ambrose. Judge Gabbett remanded Mr Ambrose in custody to Limerick Prison, to appear via video-link before Limerick District Court again on Tuesday, July 15th.
Extra.ie
2 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Man's jaw broken in attack after convicted killer's 'misinformed' TikTok
A Muslim man was hospitalised with a broken jaw after a convicted killer involved in a far-right 'vigilante' group wrongly accused him of inappropriately approaching children in a park. The footage, which went viral on social media before it was labelled 'misinformation' by gardaí, was filmed by Gerard McNamara and posted to his TikTok account. The group later claimed they engaged in vigilantism by bringing the man to a nearby Garda station. But this claim was also dismissed by gardaí, who said they fear someone will 'end up dead' as a result of targeted 'nonsense' published by far-right groups online. The footage, which went viral on social media before it was labelled 'misinformation' by gardaí, was filmed by Gerard McNamara and posted to his TikTok account. Pic: File A Garda spokesman also confirmed the man's 'alleged conduct was not of a criminal nature and there was nothing untoward' in his behaviour. Killer McNamara – who kicked and beat his own father to death – is part of a group that previously revealed has begun staging street patrols and has members in almost every county in the country. Sinne na Daoine, founded by failed general election candidate and former Ireland First president Anthony Casey, describes themselves as a 'community watchdog'. Sinne na Daoine, founded by failed general election candidate and former Ireland First president Anthony Casey, describes themselves as a 'community watchdog'. Pic: File They have been publicly backed by former MMA fighter and self-styled presidential candidate Conor McGregor. Last week, McNamara posted footage of a man sitting in the People's Park in Limerick city. He and other members of the group surrounded the man, whom they accused of approaching children in the park. They later claimed they brought the man to Henry Street Garda Station in the city. In the footage, the man explains he was simply saying hello to a baby who was with their parents and grandparents. But one of group responds, saying: 'It doesn't matter – you don't go near kids no matter where the f*** you are. A Muslim man was hospitalised with a broken jaw after a convicted killer involved in a far-right 'vigilante' group wrongly accused him of inappropriately approaching children in a park. Pic: TikTok A woman with an English accent is heard telling the man that it is their local playground and they want their 'kids to be safe'. The man then tried to shake a member of the group's hand but was told: 'I should smack your head off.' McNamara is heard asking the man if it is part of his religion to 'marry nine-year-olds'. The man replied 'no' and shook his head in disgust. He was then told the gardaí had been called and that they would be reporting him to the accommodation he is staying. 'F*** you, coming over here,' McNamara adds before the video cuts off. A source familiar with the incident said McNamara later shared the 'false information' about the man on social media, making him a 'walking target'. Sinne na Daoine leader Casey later claimed they brought the man to the Garda station after the video was taken. But a source familiar with the case denied this version of events. They told 'All they did was make him a walking target by sharing the false information all over social media. 'A day later, the man was targeted in an attack and hospitalised. He had his jaw broken after these vigilantes made baseless claims about him and spread it about social media.' In response to queries from McNamara insisted the group 'walked' the man they approached in the park 'to the garda station', adding 'the garda never showed up'. He also denied that he or members of his group were responsible for the subsequent brutal assault of the same man. McNamara said in a text response: 'If we broke his nose, we would of never ringing the garda. If we attacked him be stupid if we broke his nose and then walked him to the garda.' McNamara was sentenced to eight years in prison, with the final two years suspended, in 2012 for killing his father in a drink-fuelled row. He pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to the manslaughter of Joseph 'Joey' O'Donnell, 48, at Hyde Road, Prospect, in Limerick on October 1, 2010. Mr O'Donnell died in hospital from blunt force trauma to the head, hours after his son had kicked him and beaten him with a number of household items. At the time, the court heard McNamara had 16 previous convictions, including theft and possession of drugs and public order offences. The convicted killer addressed his past in a video posted to TikTok this week. He claimed he has no idea why people are commenting under his posts that he is a murderer and that he didn't want to have to 'lower himself' by explaining what actually happened. He also doubled down on the video he posted about the man in the park, saying there is 'evidence' of 'this Muslim foreign fella' approaching children, but without providing any proof. McNamara tells his followers: 'I have never, ever spent a day in prison in my life for murder. I don't know where you're getting all this from. 'I had an argument with my dad, alright. An argument with my dad. He didn't f***in' die, he didn't die there and then. We had an argument. I'm not going to go into the details. Things were said. He hit me, I hit my dad, he fell, banged his head. Got up, continued on drinking. Guards came, ambulance came. Get your facts right. I was never locked up for murder.' McNamara admitted he made a mistake, but asked: 'Who never had a drink with someone, got in a row and hit him in the head?' He added: 'He died three days later. I got charged with manslaughter. He's my dad. I love him. I miss him. I didn't go out with a balaclava and a gun. I didn't bate him with f***in' weapons.' previously reported how Sinne na Daoine publicised their first and second 'patrols' in Limerick city and Clonmel in Co. Tipperary on social media. They have also listed the names of companies or people they label 'plantation enablers' on their website. A picture from the group's first patrol in Limerick city showed Kildare South election candidate Casey posing alongside group were dressed in orange vests with the Sinne na Daoine logo. A source familiar with the group's operation told 'They are organised and anyone who wants to join is screened.' Gardaí have been closely monitoring the group as they 'patrol' the streets. A source said: 'It is a concern to gardaí and they are monitoring their activities.' In response to queries, a Garda spokesman said: 'On Monday, June 30, 2025 a number of members of the public expressed their concern to gardaí attached to Henry Street Garda Station, for the alleged behaviour of a man who had earlier been seated in the People's Park, Limerick. 'Having carried out enquiries into these concerns, An Garda Síochána is satisfied that the alleged conduct was not of a criminal nature and was nothing untoward. The male fully co-operated with gardaí during the course of their enquiries.' The spokesman also confirmed gardaí are 'investigating an assault of a male that occurred in the Parnell Street area of Limerick City at approximately 3:45 pm on the afternoon of July 1'. It is an offence to communicate threatening, abusive or insulting material that is intended, or likely to 'stir up' hatred against a group of people because of their race, colour, nationality, religion, ethnic or national origins.
The Irish Sun
3 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Cops probe €157m MV Matthew drug ship as 20-nation coke plot gang with Kinahan links exposed & Irish mobsters identified
CRIMINALS from 20 countries were backing the venture to bring 2.2 tonnes of cocaine into Europe on the MV Matthew, The Irish Sun on Sunday can reveal. Det Supt Joe O'Reilly has told how various gangs were behind the 4 The venture to bring 2.2-tons of cocaine into Europe on the MV Matthew was backed by criminals from 20 countries Credit: � 2025 PA Media, All Rights Reserved 4 Detective Superintendent Joe O'Reilly revealed various gangs were behind the drug plot Credit: � 2025 PA Media, All Rights Reserved Eight men were jailed last week for between 13.5 and 20 years for their part in trying to smuggle €157 million worth of coke. It was the largest seizure of the party drug in Irish The haul was seized following a joint Garda, Customs and Defence Forces op in September 2023. The READ MORE IN IRISH NEWS The drugs plot also involved the Gardai have now moved on to the next stages of their major probe into the shipment as they continue to work with police forces globally. A number of the men involved in the smuggling op, but still at large, were in cells higher up the chain and more protected than those already Explaining the structures in place for this venture, Det Supt O'Reilly, of the Garda National Drugs and Organised Crime Bureau said: 'What we've seen in our investigations and in particular the MV Matthew investigation is that there's a cellular structure that is international. MOST READ ON THE IRISH SUN 'They operate in a structure that one area will look at finance, one will be involved in procurement, logistics, landing the cocaine, moving the cocaine. Ross 'Miami' McGill targeted in Dubai bust-up by coke hood furious over gang war 'So it's not just one nationality or one group that's involved in these major shipments. 'All these shipments are transnational in the development and the delivery of their product onto a jurisdiction in Europe or elsewhere. 'So these investigations are global. This particular investigation into the MV Matthew has led us to 20 different countries where criminals operating in those countries supported this venture of bringing cocaine into the shores of Ireland.' We have learned that detectives have identified a number of Irish men involved in the plot. Transnational organised crime groups know no borders, they prey on people's vulnerability for their own financial gain." Assistant Commissioner for Organised and Serious Crime Angela Willis One includes a man who helped acquire the second ship that was meant to meet the MV Matthew to transfer the He also issued the two men in charge of this 'sistership' with instructions. But it's understood he fled to Others at large include a man who used the pseudonym 'Captain Noah', who issued directions on messaging apps and oversaw the plot from Dubai. Det Supt O'Reilly told the Garda Podcast: 'It's important to realise transnational organised criminal gangs have no legal jurisdiction or moral boundaries and their only intent is making profit at any cost, whether that's financial or human.' Assistant Commissioner for Organised and Serious Crime Angela Willis said the major probe shows the State's commitment to tackle organised crime. The top cop said: 'Transnational organised crime groups know no borders, they prey on people's vulnerability for their own financial gain." 4 Assistant Commissioner Angela Willis said the probe shows the State's commitment to tackle organised crime Credit: Gary Ashe-Commissioned by The Sun Dublin 4 It was the largest-ever drugs haul in Irish history Credit: Copyright remains with handout provider
