Brother of woman who refused chemotherapy says mother ‘sacrificed' her daughter
Her mother, Kay 'Kate' Shemirani – who rose to prominence on social media while sharing Covid-19 conspiracy theories, is alleged to have been 'abusive' to her children and was involved in Paloma's alternative 'treatment programme'.
Paloma's twin brother, Gabriel Shemirani, told the inquest at Kent and Medway Coroners Court, in Maidstone: 'I blame my mother entirely for my sister's death', by 'obstructing' his sister from receiving treatment.
'In short I believe that she sacrificed Paloma's life for her own principles, I believe that she should be held accountable for Paloma's death,' said Mr Shemirani.
Ms Shemirani was struck off as a nurse in 2021, and a Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) committee found she had spread Covid-19 misinformation that 'put the public at a significant risk of harm'.
Mr Shemirani's parents split in 2014 after a relationship which had involved domestic abuse 'both ways', he told the court.
He alleged that he and his siblings 'felt unsafe' around their mother and that she had been 'emotionally distant' and physically abusive to them as children.
He further alleged during his evidence that his father, Doctor Faramarz Shemirani, was also physically abusive to him and his brother.
At the time of Paloma's cancer diagnosis in autumn 2023, she was estranged from her mother, who then advised her against conventional medicine, the court heard.
Mr Shemirani said: 'Paloma had a complicated relationship with our mother, maybe it is because she had a complicated relationship that she decided to rekindle that relationship when she became ill.
'In my opinion, Kay Shemirani directed her resentment that she held towards my other siblings and I towards Paloma.'
Mr Shemirani brought a High Court case to assess his sister's ability to exert her capacity to take medical decisions while living with her mother in April 2024.
He claimed that when Paloma was first diagnosed, she was considering chemotherapy, before their parents started to pressure her against it.
Her father sent a message to his daughter saying 'don't consent to anything from the doctors they try and kill you' and that Ms Shemirani had said 'I'm the only one that can help you, don't bite the hand that feeds', the inquest heard.
'There was no disagreement from her that this was cancer, she never expressed that to me and she never expressed it to doctors either,' said Mr Shemirani.
His parents asked questions as interested persons which alleged that Mr Shemirani was influenced and funded by others to bring the High Court case and that his actions were a factor in Paloma's death during his evidence.
'My sister didn't die from stress from the court case, my sister died from cancer and I think that's clear,' said Mr Shemirani.
Before the High Court case, Mr Shemirani also referred the situation to social services but he felt they were 'slow moving', the court heard.
He added that his younger sister had been taken away from their mother when she was 16 and that the case was 'only driven by my love and concern for my twin sister'.
Dr Shemirani claimed his son was an 'irrational' and 'unreliable witness', and that his actions had been a 'major contributing' factor to her death.
'This is not a public forum to air grievances,' Coroner Catherine Wood said.
'I don't have any aggrievances, I don't have any aggrievances,' Dr Shemirani said.
'Sounds like it,' Mr Shemirani responded.
When his questions concluded, Dr Shemirani said: 'Finally may our lord almighty exercise you from the demons that possess you amen.'
Previously, Dr Ali Ajaz, a forensic psychiatrist, provided an assessment of Paloma during High Court proceedings which read: 'I have no concerns that Ms Shemirani has been coerced or unduly influenced by any individual when making a decision about her own medical treatment.'
Mr Shemirani asserted that Dr Ajaz's sessions with his sister were 'coloured by my mother's control', which the doctor said was speculation.
On Wednesday afternoon, Mr Shemirani told the court that his sister was terrified of cancer, but used gallows humour as a defence mechanism.
'Are you a psychologist Gabriel?' his mother asked him.
'Are you a nurse?' he replied.
The inquest continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Vertex to stop developing new painkiller as solo treatment after mid-stage study setback
Aug 4 (Reuters) - Vertex Pharmaceuticals (VRTX.O), opens new tab said on Monday it will not continue development of its experimental non-opioid painkiller as a solo treatment after it failed to meet the main goal of a mid-stage trial. The next-generation drug, called VX-993, was found to be generally safe when tested in patients who had a bunion surgery, with most side effects being mild to moderate and no serious problems linked to the painkiller, the company said. Wall Street analysts and investors have been eagerly awaiting the results of this trial that would help Vertex expand beyond its non-opioid Journavx, bolstering its pain drug treatments.
Daily Mirror
6 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Cereal bars might seem healthy - but they contain additives linked to weight gain
A groundbreaking clinical trial has revealed how ultra processed foods (UPFs) can harm the body even when not high in salt, sugar or fat - suggesting the way food is made might affect our health Martin is responsible for the health and science beat at the Mirror. He has experience reporting over a decade including medical advances in everything from cancer to dementia and obesity around the world, as well as breakthroughs in the UK. Martin covered the Covid-19 pandemic and continues to scrutinise the state of the NHS. Martin runs a number of Mirror campaigns including; Dentists for All, Give a Pint Save a Life, Fair Care for All and Change the Law for Life. UPFs have been the subject of some debate in Britain ever since TV doctor Chris van Tulleken's blockbuster book Ultra-Processed People. Many suspect the additives packed into everything from cereal bars to pastries, pies, wraps and ready meals - to make them taste nice and last longer - could actually be harming us. But this is very difficult to prove because until now, observational studies have just shown that people who eat more UPFs are more likely to be ill and overweight. This is complicated by the fact that UPFs are also more likely to be high in calories, fat, sugar and salt. And people who eat a lot of UPFs are also more likely to smoke and do less exercise. So Professor van Tulleken and his colleagues at University College London have run a clinical trial to to tease out the impact of these multiple industrial processes and the addition of ingredients not typically found in home cooking. The trial involved 55 people each given eight weeks trying two diets matched exactly for levels of fat, saturated fat, protein, carbohydrates, salt and fibre. The only difference was that one diet was made up of only UPFs, and the second a diet included only minimally processed foods such as porridge oats and home cooked spaghetti bolognese. Participants lost twice as much weight on the non-UPF diet - proving for the first time there is something going on in the processing. Professor van Tulleken, of University College London, said: "The global food system at the moment drives diet-related poor health and obesity, particularly because of the wide availability of cheap, unhealthy food. This study highlights the importance of ultra-processing in driving health outcomes in addition to the role of nutrients like fat, salt and sugar." Tracy Parker, nutrition lead at the British Heart Foundation, said: 'These findings support what we have long suspected – that the way food is made might affect our health, not just the nutrients it contains.' Chris van Tulleken's book Ultra-Processed People was adapted into a BBC Two documentary called Irresistible: Why We Can't Stop Eating. They explore the addictive nature of UPFs and their impact on our health and society. UPFs typically contain preservatives, emulsifiers, artificial colours and flavours which are used to enhance taste, texture and prolong shelf life. They are hard to avoid. Most supermarket sliced bread is a UPF as well as shop-bought sandwiches, wraps, pastries, instant noodles, crisps, some breakfast cereals and ice cream. The new trial ensured both UPF and non-UPF diet options met criteria using the NHS-backed Eatwell Guide, which outlines recommendations on how to eat a healthy, balanced diet. Despite this, after eight weeks on the non-UPF diet participants lost 2% of their body weight, compared to 1% after eight weeks on the only-UPFs diet. Scaled up over a year it suggests a 13% weight reduction in men and a 9% reduction in women on the minimally processed diet, but only a 4% weight reduction in men and 5% in women after the ultra-processed diet. Those on the trial were also asked to complete questionnaires on food cravings before and after starting the diets. Those eating minimally processed foods had less cravings and were able to resist them better. The UPF diet also did not result in significant fat loss. Tracy Parker, nutrition lead at the British Heart Foundation, added: 'Completely cutting UPFs out of our diets isn't realistic for most of us. But including more minimally processed foods – like fresh or home cooked meals – alongside a balanced diet could offer added benefits too. Mediterranean-style diets, which include plenty of minimally or unprocessed foods such as fruit, vegetables, fish, nuts and seeds, beans, lentils and whole grains, have consistently been shown to reduce our risk of heart attacks and strokes.' The Eatwell Guide recommends the average woman should consume around 2,000 calories a day, while an average man should consume 2,500. Participants were generally consuming more than this before they started the trial. Senior author Professor Rachel Batterham said: "The best advice to people would be to stick as closely to nutritional guidelines as they can by moderating overall energy intake, limiting intake of salt, sugar and saturated fat, and prioritising high-fibre foods such as fruits, vegetables, pulses and nuts. "Choosing less processed options such as whole foods and cooking from scratch, rather than ultra-processed, packaged foods or ready meals, is likely to offer additional benefits in terms of body weight, body composition and overall health." UPFs have artificial additives to boost flavour and shelf life including emulsifiers, sweeteners, stabilising gums, flavour compounds and colouring agents. These are typically not used in home cooking but can be cheaper in mass produced food than natural ingredients. The findings are published in Nature Medicine.
Scottish Sun
9 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
The ‘most contagious diseases' revealed – and the one in first place could be about to surge in the UK
Plus, everything you need to know to protect yourself from the "most contagious disease" VIRAL THREAT The 'most contagious diseases' revealed – and the one in first place could be about to surge in the UK Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) WE'RE all familiar with the contagious nature of illnesses like the common cold and flu. If someone infected with one of these viruses sneezes, cough, sings, or talks nearby you, the likelihood of you catching what they've got is pretty high. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 We all know how contagious the common cold and flu are - but they're not the most contagious illnesses Credit: Getty But there are more contagious illnesses in existence definitely worth knowing about. The one that takes the top spot for being most contagious is measles. According to Dan Baumgardt, senior lecturer at the School of Physiology, Pharmacology and Neuroscience, University of Bristol, it's all based on R0 - a measure of how many other people are likely to become infected from another. He said: "The R0 measure indicates how an infection will spread in a population. "If it's greater than one, the outcome is disease spread. "An R0 of one means the level of people being infected will remain stable, and if it's less than one, the disease will often die out with time." Measles has made a resurgence globally in recent years, including in the UK - and its R0 is considered high. While several factors are said to contribute to this, the primary cause is a decline in childhood vaccination rates. Writing for The Conversation, Baumgardt said this drop has been driven by disruptions such as the Covid pandemic and global conflict, as well as the spread of misinformation about vaccine safety. He continued: "The R0 number for measles is between 12 and 18. If you do the maths, two cycles of transmission from that first infected person could lead to 342 people catching the illness. Mum's warning to all parents after her 'fit and healthy' daughter, 10, died a DECADE after 'mild bout of measles' "That's a staggering number from just one patient – but luckily, the protective power of vaccination helps reduce the actual spread by lowering the number of people susceptible to infection. Measles is extraordinarily so infectious that an unvaccinated person can catch the virus just by entering a room where an infected person was present two hours earlier. "People can also be infectious and spread the virus before they develop symptoms or have any reason to isolate." Just last week, health officials from the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) voiced fears that another surge of measles cases could be on the way. Since January 1, there have been 674 laboratory confirmed measles cases reported in England, with 48 per cent of these cases in London, 16 per cent in the North West, and 10 per cent in the East of England. And holiday travel and international visits to see family this summer could lead to rising measles cases in England when the new school term begins, the UKHSA warned. 2 Measles cases have been on the rise across Europe Credit: Getty The main symptoms of measles MEASLES is highly contagious and can cause serious problems in some people. The infection usually starts with cold-like symptoms, followed by a rash a few days later. The first signs include: A high temperature A runny or blocked nose Sneezing A cough Red, sore, watery eyes Small white spots may then appear inside the cheeks and on the back of the lips. A rash tends to come next. This usually starts on the face and behind the ears before spreading to the rest of the body. The spots are sometimes raised and join together to form blotchy patches. They are not normally itchy. The rash looks brown or red on white skin. It may be harder to see on darker skin. Complications are rare, but measles can lead to pneumonia, meningitis, blindness, seizures, and sometimes death. Source: NHS As Baumgardt mentioned, one of the best ways to protect yourself from measles is to get vaccinated. The first measles mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine is offered to infants when they turn one year old and the second dose to pre-school children when they are around three years and four months old. Around 99 per cent of those who have two doses will be protected against measles and rubella. Other infectious diseases Other infectious diseases with high R0 values, said Baumgardt, include pertussis/whooping cough (12 to 17), chickenpox (ten to 12), and Covid, which varies by subtype but generally falls between eight and 12. He said: "While many patients recover fully from these conditions, they can still lead to serious complications, including pneumonia, seizures, meningitis, blindness, and, in some cases, death." But be wary of those with a lower infectivity rate - as it doesn't necessarily mean it's less dangerous, said Baumgardt. For example, tuberculosis (TB) has an R0 ranging from less than one up to four. But the danger lies in how difficult it is to treat. Baumgardt warned: "Once established, it requires a combination of four antibiotics taken over a minimum of six months. Standard antibiotics like penicillin are ineffective, and the infection can spread beyond the lungs to other parts of the body, including the brain, bones, liver and joints. "What's more, cases of drug-resistant TB are on the rise, where the bacteria no longer respond to one or more of the antibiotics used in treatment."
