$30K for breakfast? How Napier Council is justifying the spend as job cuts loom
Napier City Council
drew public attention after it disclosed nearly $30,000 spent on a
staff Christmas breakfast
for 612 employees, plus a $480 depot morning tea, totaling $32,089.50 over three months. The expense was revealed in the Audit & Risk Committee's sensitive expenditure report for December 2024 to March 2025. With more than 100 staff positions under review, critics say the lavish outlay feels out of step with the council's financial climate.
Mayor
Kirsten Wise
defended the cost, stating it aligned with council policy on
staff recognition
. She called the breakfast 'a small but meaningful opportunity' to thank those who work early shifts and maintain essential services during the holidays.
Also Read:
Meet Professor Richard Scolyer, the scientist who just completed his 250th Parkrun while battling terminal brain cancer
Wise described the NZD 48.22 per-person cost, covering food, coffee, logistics, and set-up, as reasonable and transparently reported.
Live Events
Councillor and candidate Nigel Simpson said the tradition began under a previous CEO and could be made more cost-efficient, perhaps by switching to filter coffee.
Local caterers are surprised at the per-head cost. A cooked breakfast for 600 typically costs around NZD 22, with continental options under NZD 20. In contrast, Napier's breakfast cost NZD 48.22, presumably including logistics, equipment hire, staff, and coffee expenses.
Chief Executive Louise Miller explained that the annual breakfast at McLean Park has been the only council-funded staff recognition event since 2019. She said the event brings together colleagues who rarely meet and rewards their hard work.
The Napier council is undergoing a structural review, with proposals considering cuts to more than 100 roles. In a climate of fiscal restraint, some argue that big spending on staff events could erode public trust. Others say investing in staff morale supports service delivery, especially during periods of change.
Economic Times WhatsApp channel
)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Israel seeks US assistance to strike Iran's Fordow nuclear facility amid firepower limitations
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel Israeli officials have requested US military involvement to help destroy Iran's deeply buried Fordow nuclear facility, citing a lack of required firepower to achieve their operational goals. The request was made within the last 48 hours, according to two Israeli officials, as Israel intensifies its military operations against Fordow uranium enrichment site, a key component of Iran's nuclear infrastructure, is located inside a mountain, making it resistant to conventional airstrikes. Israel does not possess the large bomber aircraft or advanced bunker buster munitions needed to eliminate the facility. These assets, however, are within reach for US forces stationed in the read: Iran-Israel conflict: How secret friends turned bitter enemies Despite the urgency of Israel's request, the Trump administration has so far refrained from participating in the conflict. US officials have indicated that direct engagement, even a limited strike on Fordow, would effectively draw the United States into a broader war with Iran.A second US official confirmed Saturday, June 14, that Israel has urged the Trump administration to consider joining the campaign, but noted that no decision to engage has been Israeli official told Axios that President Trump had signaled willingness to support the operation in a recent conversation with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. However, a White House official disputed that claim on Friday, June 13, stating that there is no current plan for US involvement in the ongoing military action.A senior White House official, speaking to Axios on Saturday, emphasized the administration's preference for diplomacy. 'Whatever happens today cannot be prevented,' the official said, referencing Israel's strikes. 'But we have the ability to negotiate a successful peaceful resolution to this conflict if Iran is willing. The fastest way for Iran to accomplish peace is to give up its nuclear weapons program.'Also read: Dow Jones falls 400 points as Israel-Iran conflict hits risk appetite; oil, defence stocks rise Israeli Ambassador to the United States Yechiel Leiter told Fox News on Friday, 'The entire operation... really has to be completed with the elimination of Fordow.'Israeli sources said the topic of US participation in targeting Fordow has been repeatedly raised in discussions with American counterparts since the start of the firepower limitations drive request for US involvementThe failure to destroy Fordow would compromise Israel's objective of halting Iran's nuclear program. Israeli officials argue that the operation must be completed to ensure long-term security and nonproliferation Israeli source told Axios that while the United States has yet to approve direct involvement, Israel remains hopeful that the Trump administration will agree to assist in the mission.
Economic Times
6 hours ago
- Economic Times
Rare earth, rarer nod: Indian firms' magnet waitlist doubles in 2 weeks, sends industry into supply tailspin
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel New Delhi: The number of India-based companies awaiting licences from China's commerce ministry to procure rare earth magnets has nearly doubled to 21 from 11 two weeks ago, according to people familiar with the matter. These include Bosch India, Marelli Powertrain India, Mahle Electric Drives India, TVS Motor and Uno Minda , they Comstar, whose application was recently rejected by China's commerce ministry due to procedural issues, has reapplied and is among the 21 companies, said a senior industry executive.'These companies have duly filled in and got endorsed the end-user certificate and shipped the requisite documents to their suppliers for procuring rare earth magnets from China, but licences are yet to be awarded by the government there,' said the executive, who did not wish to be comes in the wake of China's April 4 order mandating exporters that ship medium and heavy rare earth magnets to seek a licence from its commerce department after getting an end-user certificate from the buyer. The certificate requires buyers to make certain include the guarantee that these items will not be used for storing, manufacturing, producing or processing weapons of mass destruction and their delivery the order had come in response to Donald Trump's tariffs, the US President this week announced a bilateral trade deal under which China will supply rare earth magnets to the Indian authorities are in the process of reaching out to their counterparts in China via diplomatic channels to secure meetings for a dialogue to resolve the issue, but not much has happened on that front yet, said the some automotive parts makers in Europe recently got approvals to source rare earth magnets, their Indian arms are yet to get a go-ahead from China's commerce ministry. The issue is complicated by the two nations' tense business and political relationship, experts per the latest data collated by the Society of Indian Automobile Manufacturers, 52 companies based in the nation source magnets from China to supply to automobile manufacturers across licences are not awarded soon, industry stakeholders fear disruptions in production as stocks are set to run out in early July. India imported 870 tonnes of rare earth magnets valued at ?306 crore in 2024-25. 'While the value of imports compared to the industry size is minuscule, vehicles cannot be manufactured even if we are short of one component where a rare earth magnet is being used,' said an executive.
Time of India
11 hours ago
- Time of India
Iran-US nuclear talks shot down by Israeli attacks; what it means for Middle East and Tehran's path to acquire nukes
Live Events Why did Israel attack now Where do US-Iran talks stand now (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel Fresh tensions in the Middle East following Israel's airstrikes on Iranian military and nuclear infrastructure and Iran's retaliation have thrown the Iran-US nuclear talks into murky waters. As conflict between Israel and Iran heats up, Oman has officially confirmed the breakdown of negotiations between Tehran and Washington on the nuclear Foreign Minister Badr Albusaidi, in a post on X, confirmed the cancellation of nuclear talks. "The Iranian-American talks scheduled for this Sunday in Muscat will now not take place. But diplomacy and dialogue remain the only path to lasting peace," he Iran also called the negotiations 'pointless' after Israel launched strikes against the Islamic Republic, killing its four senior commanders, including Maj. Gen. Hossein Salami, Iranian military chief Mohammad Bagheri, and Air Force chief Brig. Gen. Amir Ali US President Donald Trump had called on Tehran to resume negotiations and conclude a deal 'before it is too late.'In response to Israel's airstrikes, Iran late Friday (June 13) launched more than 150 ballistic missiles against Israel, marking the beginning of a retaliatory operation called True Promise III. The main target of the strike was the city of Tel Aviv, Iranian media reported. Iran claimed that it managed to hit the headquarters of the Israeli Ministry of Defense, MaKirya (also known as The Kirya or Israel's Pentagon)Many experts, closely following developments in the Middle East, believe that the Israeli attacks against Iran were no coincidence, and they clearly depicted that Israel not only wanted to derail the negotiations but also sabotage them to push Iran towards abandoning them there are multiple factors that could have been a force behind Israel's decision to launch an offensive against Iran days before its negotiation talks with of the likely reasons could have been that Iran was taking strides toward enriching uranium to a degree that would likely allow Tehran to upgrade to a weapons-grade level very rapidly, according to a report by the International Atomic Energy Association (IAEA). Also, intelligence shows that Iran was inching closer to a possible breakout status for a nuclear proxies like Hamas, Hezbollah, Houthis and some other militant groups don't present the same threat to Israel. In the past, an Israeli attack on Iran would have invited a multidirectional response from all corners of the resistance as seen in the early days after the October 7, 2023, the previous attacks launched by Israel on Iran in April and October 2024 degraded Iran's ballistic and surface-to-air missiles and air defense radar Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu has stated that his country would continue its airstrikes 'for as many days as it takes,' there are indications that Trump is still holding open the possibility of some kind of deal with Israel's attack against Iran, he warned Tehran that if it didn't come back to the table and cut a deal, the next attack would be 'even more brutal.' The attack could possibly push Iran into reengaging in the other hand, the killing of Iranian nuclear scientists and the apparent stalling of the Sunday negotiators may convince Tehran to intensify its efforts towards a nuclear weapon as the only means of deterrence against Israel.
