Historian blames post-war 'chaos' for Harvard Magna Carta 'copy' confusion
A British historian who discovered a copy of the Magna Carta was a genuine manuscript has shared his theory on why the document was misidentified.
Harvard Law Library bought a version of the royal charter at auction for just $27.50 in 1946, the equivalent of around $450 (£328) today.
The vellum document was described as a "copy made in 1327... somewhat rubbed and damp-stained" - but two historians it was actually a rare original worth millions of pounds.
The document was just one of seven versions of the Magna Carta to survive from King Edward I's 1300 issue of the charter.
Professor David Carpenter, who made the discovery with Professor Nicholas Vincent, believes "post-war chaos" is to blame for the confusion.
Speaking at a meeting of the Pipe Roll Society at The National Archives in London, he said: "This was just after the war, there was still a measure of chaos, someone has misread the date on it.
"This is most likely how it happened."
Following the discovery, Prof Vincent traced the history of the document prior to Harvard buying it.
His research suggests that after it was issued by King Edward I to the former parliamentary borough of Appleby, it fell into the hands of a family before being passed to slavery abolitionist Thomas Clarkson.
Via his estate, it ended up in the hands of Forster Maynard, a World War One flying ace, who sold it to London book dealers Sweet & Maxwell for £42, which then sold it to Harvard.
Read more from Sky News:
Prof Carpenter, a medieval historian at King's College London, immediately realised the 'copy' looked a lot like the real Magna Carta when he spotted it in Harvard's online catalogue.
"I immediately sent the image to my colleague Nicholas Vincent asking him 'Is this what I think it is?'," he said.
Speaking at the same meeting, Prof Vincent said: "I told him immediately, you know what that is!"
The Magna Carta was originally established in 1215 under King John and outlined the rights of ordinary people under common law for the first time.
It has since formed the basis of constitutions worldwide.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
50,000 in Greater Manchester have no buses - now it'll take years to fix
More than 50,000 people in Greater Manchester have no access to daytime bus or tram service — but it's set to take years to fix. Every bus in Greater Manchester was taken into the Bee Network on January 5, a major step in Andy Burnham's mission to create an integrated 'London-style' public transport system. But daytime Bee Network buses, Metrolink trams, and 'demand-responsive transport' such as ring and ride buses fail to stop within 400-metres of 51,309 people in the city, a new report has revealed. READ MORE: LIVE: Manchester services hit after train derails causing UK travel chaos - latest updates READ MORE: Police descend on Salford street with forensic tent on scene That means the Bee Network's 'minimum baseline connectivity level' is not met in 148 places. Another 388,525 people — more than the population of Wigan — have no access to a bus service that runs at least every half-hour, the report added. One proposed benefit of taking buses into public control was the ability to change services based on residents' needs, which the mayor promised would take place with regular 'network reviews'. However, the same report revealed it will take up to three years to implement the changes recommended by network reviews, with Trafford and parts of Manchester only seeing alterations in summer 2028. The first boroughs to get Bee Network buses, Wigan and Bolton in September 2023, will be first to see modifications, in autumn 2026. Alison Chew, the Bee Network's deputy director of bus, said it will take time because bosses 'looked back at connectivity assessment to get a baseline picture of Greater Manchester'. Although a huge proportion of buses have only been in public control for several months, some councillors were incensed by how long it will take to carry out the network review. Phil Burke said: 'We have been led up the garden path. It was supposed to happen after tranche one, and after tranche two, and there was supposed to be something at the end of last year. 'We have clearly been led astray by the bus team. The bus services we have in Rochdale are really bad. We need to address them.' However, 'early intervention' is being considered to improve services in two areas where buses do not arrive every hour, namely Horrocks Fold in Bolton and West Trafford. The other areas to get bus improvements sooner include Rusholme, Whalley Range, and Blackley New Road in Manchester; Ordsall Lane in Salford; and Alexandra Park in Oldham. Despite the need for improvements in some areas, the report said buses were getting more popular, with a 14pc increase in bus usage in the first areas to get the Bee Network. Three-quarters of Bee Network services were on-time in March 2025, compared to roughly two-thirds when they were run privately.
Los Angeles Times
4 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
Cargo ship carrying new vehicles to Mexico sinks in the North Pacific weeks after catching fire
ANCHORAGE, Alaska — A cargo ship that had been delivering new vehicles to Mexico sank in the North Pacific Ocean, weeks after crew members abandoned ship when they couldn't extinguish an onboard fire that left the carrier dead in the water. The Morning Midas sank Monday in international water off Alaska's Aleutian Islands chain, the ship's management company, London-based Zodiac Maritime, said in a statement. 'There is no visible pollution,' said Petty Officer Cameron Snell, an Alaska-based U.S. Coast Guard spokesperson. 'Right now we also have vessels on scene to respond to any pollution.' Fire damage compounded by bad weather and water seepage caused the carrier to sink in waters about 16,404 feet deep and about 415 miles from land, the statement said. The ship was loaded with about 3,000 new vehicles intended for a major Pacific port in Mexico. It was not immediately clear if any of the cars were removed before it sank, and Zodiac Maritime did not immediately respond to messages Tuesday. A salvage crew arrived days after the fire disabled the vehicle. Two salvage tugs containing pollution control equipment will remain on scene to monitor for any signs of pollution or debris, the company said. The crew members of those two ships were not injured when the Morning Midas sank. Zodiac Maritime said it is also sending another specialized pollution response vessel to the location as an added precaution. The Coast Guard said it received a distress alert June 3 about a fire aboard the Morning Midas, which then was roughly 300 miles southwest of Adak Island. There were 22 crew members onboard the Morning Midas. All evacuated to a lifeboat and were rescued by a nearby merchant marine vessel. There were no injuries. Among the cars were about 70 fully electric and about 680 hybrid vehicles. A large plume of smoke was initially seen at the ship's stern coming from the deck loaded with electric vehicles, the Coast Guard and Zodiac Maritime said at the time. Adak is about 1,200 miles west of Anchorage, Alaska's largest city. The 600-foot Morning Midas was built in 2006 and sails under a Liberian flag. The car and truck carrier left Yantai, China, on May 26 en route to Mexico, according to the industry site A Dutch safety board in a recent report called for improving emergency response on North Sea shipping routes after a deadly 2023 fire aboard a freighter that was carrying 3,000 automobiles, including nearly 500 electric vehicles, from Germany to Singapore. One person was killed and others injured in the fire, which burned out of control for a week. That ship was eventually towed to a Netherlands port for salvage. Thiessen writes for the Associated Press.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Historian blames post-war 'chaos' for Harvard Magna Carta 'copy' confusion
A British historian who discovered a copy of the Magna Carta was a genuine manuscript has shared his theory on why the document was misidentified. Harvard Law Library bought a version of the royal charter at auction for just $27.50 in 1946, the equivalent of around $450 (£328) today. The vellum document was described as a "copy made in 1327... somewhat rubbed and damp-stained" - but two historians it was actually a rare original worth millions of pounds. The document was just one of seven versions of the Magna Carta to survive from King Edward I's 1300 issue of the charter. Professor David Carpenter, who made the discovery with Professor Nicholas Vincent, believes "post-war chaos" is to blame for the confusion. Speaking at a meeting of the Pipe Roll Society at The National Archives in London, he said: "This was just after the war, there was still a measure of chaos, someone has misread the date on it. "This is most likely how it happened." Following the discovery, Prof Vincent traced the history of the document prior to Harvard buying it. His research suggests that after it was issued by King Edward I to the former parliamentary borough of Appleby, it fell into the hands of a family before being passed to slavery abolitionist Thomas Clarkson. Via his estate, it ended up in the hands of Forster Maynard, a World War One flying ace, who sold it to London book dealers Sweet & Maxwell for £42, which then sold it to Harvard. Read more from Sky News: Prof Carpenter, a medieval historian at King's College London, immediately realised the 'copy' looked a lot like the real Magna Carta when he spotted it in Harvard's online catalogue. "I immediately sent the image to my colleague Nicholas Vincent asking him 'Is this what I think it is?'," he said. Speaking at the same meeting, Prof Vincent said: "I told him immediately, you know what that is!" The Magna Carta was originally established in 1215 under King John and outlined the rights of ordinary people under common law for the first time. It has since formed the basis of constitutions worldwide.
