Royal College of Nursing resigns from restraint in schools taskforce
In a letter to the department, Rita Devlin, the director of the RCN in Northern Ireland, said that her organisation was being put in the "potential position of being ascribed a responsibility and accountability for a policy direction that we are unable to support".She added that due to failures to receive "clear assurances", the RCN was withdrawing from the Restraint and Seclusion Task Finish Group with "immediate effect".
She said the RCN, along with the department and other stakeholders, had hoped to be able to "shape the guidance... in the best interests of children and young people and staff alike".But she added: "It is disappointing that the department is unable to set out clearly the policy position in respect of the use of restrictive practices, restraint and seclusion in schools."The letter went on to state: "The RCN would have expected that the response would clearly state that the policy position will be the elimination of the use of seclusion in educational settings, and both the recognition and minimisation of the use of all restrictive interventions."
Some parents in Northern Ireland have campaigned for "Harry's Law" for a number of years, which would make it compulsory for schools to report when they isolated or restrained a child.Similar recent guidance from the Department of Health (DoH) said that children should never be shut in a room alone and prevented from leaving.Ms Devlin added that her advice to health staff who provide services to children and young people would be to follow the existing DoH policy as it provides a "clear direction and standards" for the minimisation of the use of all restrictive practices.Her letter concluded that the RCN had previously made clear that it needed assurances from the department about ensuring the statutory guidance is human rights compatible, in order to remain a member of the task group.It also called into question whether the minister plans to follow through on a commitment made by the last education minister to repeal Article 4 (1)(c) of Education (NI) Order 1998, which still allows use of force to maintain "good order and discipline" in schools."These assurances have not been provided. This puts the RCN in the potential position of being ascribed a responsibility for a direction that we are unable to support and was developed despite, rather than as a consequence of, our involvement," it stated.
'Incredibly serious'
Alliance assembly member Michelle Guy called for the education minister to clarify the department's position."The RCN withdrawing from this group is incredibly serious. Their letter outlined concerns as to whether the Department of Education is committed to the elimination of the use of seclusion in educational settings and the minimisation of all restrictive interventions," she added."We are in danger of continuing to have differing guidance within educational settings and health settings, which only creates unnecessary inconsistency."The outcome here must be clear guidance for our school staff that puts the needs of children and young people at its centre."The DE has been contacted for a response.Calls for tougher laws on when children can be restrained in schools have also previously been backed by the celebrity and businesswoman Paris Hilton.Ms Hilton has claimed that she was placed in solitary confinement when at boarding school in the US as a teenager.The DE had provided interim guidance on restraint and seclusion in 2021, but that did not place a legal obligation on schools to record when they restrained a pupil.Two years later the department drew up new statutory guidance for schools that was then sent out to public consultation.But some campaigners criticised that process and said there were still too many "grey areas".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
11 hours ago
- Sky News
Nurses punched, spat at and threatened with weapons over A&E wait times
Nurses are being punched, spat at and threatened with weapons by patients who are not prone to violence but are becoming angry after long waits in A&E. Figures obtained by the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) from 89 hospital trusts, out of a possible 129, show cases of physical violence against A&E staff have doubled - from 2,093 in 2019 to 4,054 in 2024. One senior A&E nurse based in east London told the RCN she had been spat at by a patient and threatened with an acid attack. She also said she had seen colleagues punched and kicked - and described how one had a gun pointed at them. "Even patients you would expect to be placid are becoming irate because of just how long they have to wait," Rachelle McCarthy, a senior charge nurse from the East Midlands, told the RCN. "You can only imagine the behaviour of those who are already prone to violence," she said. She added she was punched "square in the face" by a "drunk, six foot two bloke". Sarah Tappy, a senior sister in an A&E in east London who was knocked unconscious after being punched in the head by a patient, said: "The violence is awful. And it's just constant. Nurses, doctors, receptionists - none of us feels safe." Another nurse said: "It's not going to help with our retention and recruitment if you think you're going to be clobbered every shift." The RCN has called for action to protect NHS staff, which it said "face a rising tide of violence". "It leads to both physical and mental scarring, lengthy time off and sometimes staff never returning," warned RCN general secretary and chief executive Professor Nicola Ranger. She said the government's plans to reform the NHS would "fail" if the issue was left unaddressed. Health Secretary Wes Streeting said he was "appalled" by the findings. "Nurses dedicate their lives to helping others and deserve to go about their jobs free from violence or intimidation," he said. He said the government was committed to ending the violence by "shining a light on the extent to which corridor care plagues our NHS, as the first step to eradicating it". "We are strengthening vital support for victims, including security training and emotional support for staff affected by violence, so no NHS worker has to suffer in silence," he added. 3:03 The Liberal Democrats have called for A&E staff to be given access to a panic button, giving them a "direct line" to the police. The party's health spokesperson Helen Morgan said: "Violence against hospital staff is utterly abhorrent and those committing it should feel the full force of the law."
ITV News
13 hours ago
- ITV News
Nurses face 'abhorrent' levels of violence as A&E attacks double in five years
Nurses are facing 'abhorrent' levels of violence as attacks in A&E wards have almost doubled in the last five years, new figures reveal. Staff have been punched, spat at and even had a gun pointed at one of them in A&E departments. Long waits in A&E are also leading to anger among patients who are not prone to violence, the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) said as it called for more to be done to protect NHS staff. The nursing union submitted Freedom of information (FOI) requests to NHS hospitals with accident and emergency departments and found rates of violence towards staff had almost doubled in the last five years. Figures from 89 hospital trusts, out of a possible 129, revealed there were 4,054 cases of physical violence against A&E staff recorded in 2024, up from 2,093 in 2019. Without action to tackle long waits, corridor care and 'chronic' staffing problems, the rates of violence will continue to rise, the RCN warned. One senior A&E nurse based in east London told the RCN she has seen colleagues punched and kicked and described how a colleague had a gun pointed at them. She herself had been spat at by a patient and threatened with an acid attack. A senior charge nurse from the East Midlands, Rachelle McCarthy, told the RCN that 'even patients you would expect to be placid are becoming irate because of just how long they have to wait'. 'You can only imagine the behaviour of those who are already prone to violence,' she added. Ms McCarthy also told the union she was punched 'square in the face' by a 'drunk, six foot two bloke'. Another nurse said: 'It's not going to help with our retention and recruitment if you think you're going to be clobbered every shift.' Sarah Tappy, a senior sister in an A&E in east London, was knocked unconscious after being punched in the head by a patient. 'The violence is awful,' she said. 'And it's just constant. Nurses, doctors, receptionists, none of us feels safe.' RCN general secretary and chief executive Professor Nicola Ranger said: 'Nursing staff not only go to work underpaid and undervalued but now face a rising tide of violence." 'It leads to both physical and mental scarring, lengthy time off and sometimes staff never returning." 'Measures to keep staff safe day-to-day are crucial, but the stark reality is that unless the Government does something about lengthy waits, corridor care and understaffed nursing teams, more nursing staff will become victims of this utterly abhorrent behaviour." 'Left unaddressed, this could see plans to reform the NHS fail completely.' The Liberal Democrats have called for A&E staff to be given access to a panic button which would give them a 'direct line' to the police. The party's health spokesperson Helen Morgan said: 'The Government must urgently ensure all A&E units have a direct line to their nearest police station through a panic button ... to protect patients and staff and ensure these violent criminals are swiftly arrested.' Health Secretary Wes Streeting said: 'I am appalled by these findings. Nurses dedicate their lives to helping others and deserve to go about their jobs free from violence or intimidation. 'Anyone who violates this core principle will feel the full force of the law." 'I met with the Royal College of Nursing recently to reaffirm our commitment to standing with frontline workers, working together to stop violence against NHS staff and improving their working conditions." 'Just yesterday I announced a new graduate guarantee to get more nurses into our NHS, and I have also committed to shining a light on the extent to which corridor care plagues our NHS, as the first step to eradicating it." 'We are strengthening vital support for victims, including security training and emotional support for staff affected by violence, so no NHS worker has to suffer in silence.'
The Independent
20 hours ago
- The Independent
Nurse threatened with gun as tensions rise over A&E wait times
Nurses are facing "abhorrent" levels of violence in Accident and Emergency departments, including being punched, spat at, and even having a gun pointed at them, a union says. The Royal College of Nursing (RCN) said that prolonged A&E waits are also fuelling anger among patients, even those not typically prone to violence. The RCN stressed that more must be done to protect NHS staff. Without action to tackle long waits, "corridor care," and "chronic"staffing problems, violence rates will continue to rise, it said. The warning follows RCN Freedom of Information (FOI) requests to NHS hospitals with emergency departments, which revealed increasing rates of violence towards staff. Figures from 89 hospital trusts, out of a possible 129, revealed there were 4,054 cases of physical violence against A&E staff recorded in 2024, up from 2,093 in 2019, the RCN said. One senior A&E nurse based in east London told the RCN she had seen colleagues punched and kicked, and described how a colleague had a gun pointed at them. She herself has been spat at by a patient and threatened with an acid attack. 'Even patients you would expect to be placid are becoming irate because of just how long they have to wait,' Rachelle McCarthy, a senior charge nurse from the East Midlands, said. 'You can only imagine the behaviour of those who are already prone to violence.' Ms McCarthy also told the union she was punched 'square in the face' by a 'drunk, six foot two bloke'. Another nurse said: 'It's not going to help with our retention and recruitment if you think you're going to be clobbered every shift.' Sarah Tappy, a senior sister in an A&E in east London, was knocked unconscious after being punched in the head by a patient. 'The violence is awful,' she said. 'And it's just constant. Nurses, doctors, receptionists – none of us feels safe.' RCN general secretary and chief executive Professor Nicola Ranger said: 'Nursing staff not only go to work underpaid and undervalued but now face a rising tide of violence. 'It leads to both physical and mental scarring, lengthy time off and sometimes staff never returning. 'Measures to keep staff safe day-to-day are crucial, but the stark reality is that unless the Government does something about lengthy waits, corridor care and understaffed nursing teams, more nursing staff will become victims of this utterly abhorrent behaviour. 'Left unaddressed, this could see plans to reform the NHS fail completely.'
