Former Supreme Court justice who cast key vote upholding abortion rights dies
Justice David Souter died peacefully at his New Hampshire home on Thursday at the age of 85. His cause of death was not revealed by the Supreme Court on Friday.
Fellow Republican President George HW Bush appointed Souter to America's highest court in 1990. He was nicknamed the 'stealth candidate' when he was nominated to replace William J Brennan Jr, who was seen as a leader of the dwindling liberal majority.
But Souter went on to shock conservatives by aligning with liberal justices in numerous cases.
In Planned Parenthood v Casey in 1992, Souter joined the majority on the bench in upholding the federal constitutional right to abortion that was first established by Roe v Wade. That right was undone three decades later with the conservative-majority court's decision in Dobbs vs Jackson Women's Health Organization.
Souter wrote that reversing Roe v Wade would mean to 'surrender to political pressure… So to overrule under fire in the absence of the most compelling reason to re-examine a watershed decision would subvert the court's legitimacy beyond any serious question'.
He leaned liberal on cases around issues including gay rights, affirmative action, separation of church and state and restricting the death penalty.
In 2000, Souter even dissented with liberals in Bush v Gore, which stopped the presidential election vote recount in Florida and allowed Bush's son, George W Bush, to win the race.
Souter retired in 2009 at the relatively young age of 69, after serving for more than 19 years. His departure allowed for then-President Barack Obama to appoint a liberal justice, Sonia Sotomayor, to replace him. More Trending
After stepping down, Souter continued to serve by regularly sitting for more than a decade on the Court of Appeals for the First Circuit.
Chief Justice John Roberts on Friday stated that Souter served 'with great distinction'.
'He brought uncommon wisdom and kindness to a lifetime of public service,' said Roberts. 'He will be greatly missed.'
Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk.
For more stories like this, check our news page.
MORE: Why was the Sycamore Gap tree cut down?
MORE: Man who strangled girlfriend on night she planned to leave him jailed for 35 years
MORE: 'Moronic' friends guilty of chopping down iconic 150-year-old Sycamore Gap tree
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Trump team releasing ‘largely uncensored' Epstein files to Congress in DAYS as fight over ‘missing client list' drags on
TRUMP'S team has agreed to hand over the largely uncensored Epstein files to congress as it tries to bury theories about a missing client list. Busting open the Epstein files was one of Trump's election promises, but since coming to power he has refused and tried to divert attention from the issue. 7 Ghislaine was found guilty of sex trafficking young girls for Epstein to abuse Credit: PA The President has come under intense pressure - including from voices within his own camp - who argue that if there is nothing to hide then the information should be set free. Some are convinced the files contain a "client list" which could incriminate public figures - and link this with conspiracy theories surrounding Epstein's suicide. Now, the campaigners have secured a major win with the administration agreeing to turning over most of the material held on the disgraced paedophile financier by the end of the week. The government's hand has been forced by Congress's House Oversight Committee, which this month issued a subpoena for "all documents and communications relating or referring to" Epstein and his former girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell. This was a rare sign of pushback against the President by Congress. Tuesday was set as the initial deadline, but chairman of the committee James Comer announced he would delay it until Friday in recognition of the Justice Department's cooperation. The Republican representative said: 'Officials with the department of justice have informed us that the department will begin to provide Epstein-related records to the oversight committee this week on Friday." 'There are many records in DoJ's custody, and it will take the department time to produce all the records and ensure the identification of victims and any child sexual abuse material are redacted.' Comer added: 'I appreciate the Trump administration's commitment to transparency and efforts to provide the American people with information about this matter.' The order, seen by US media, requests that the files are uncensored other than material which could identify Epstein's victims, shows child sex abuse or is otherwise redacted by law. EPSMystery orange figure is seen near Epstein's cell night before his death - as police video expert gives bombshell theory Epstein was in prison awaiting a major trial over sex-trafficking charges after decades of sick activity with minors, facilitated by Ghislaine. He was found hanged in his cell in August 2019, but the case has never shaken off speculation that others were involved in his death. Last month, an FBI probe concluded that Epstein committed suicide, and that the much-hyped "client list" does not exist - but even this did not quell the calls for the files to be released. In an effort to put the speculation to bed, the Justice Department released around 11 hours of CCTV footage from inside the facility where Epstein died, including the point his body was discovered. 7 James Comer, Chairman of the House Oversight and Accountability Committee, said the Department of Justice is cooperating with the subpoena Credit: Getty Images - Getty But a mysterious "lost minute" was noticed in the video soon after release, when the clock ticked from 11:58:58 straight to midnight - skipping out 62 seconds. Attorney General Pam Bondi explained this was caused by a glitch in the prison's outdated system - and claimed the same minute is missing from footage every night. Then it was revealed that the video was actually made of two clips stitched together - debunking the claim it was the "full raw" file. Further analysis showed that one clip had been trimmed before release - and the data the first clip was actively cut at the 11:58:58 mark. The FBI's conclusion that the client list is fictional directly rails against what administration officials have previously said. 7 Prince Andrew was accused of having sex with Virginia Giuffre, then 17, facilitated by Epstein Credit: PA 7 The CCTV footage of Epstein's final hours was in fact missing almost three minutes Credit: US Department of Justice In an interview on Fox News in February, Pam Bondi herself said the client list was "sitting on my desk right now to review." She later attempted to clarify that she had meant the Epstein file in its entirety. Many within Trump's MAGA movement allege that the files about the paedophile's crimes have been withheld to protect big names. US House Speaker Mike Johnson said he supported the release of the files. Speaking on a podcast with Benny Johnson, the Republican said: "It's a very delicate subject, but we should put everything out there and let the people decide it. "I'm for transparency," he added. 7 7 Other conservative figures have since demanded to see all the documents related to Epstein's crimes. Lauren Boebert, another conservative Republican said a special counsel should be appointed to investigate the financier's crimes if more Epstein files were not released. And Senator John Kennedy of Louisiana said the voters expect more accountability. Even Trump's daughter-in-law, Lara Trump, a Fox News host, has called for "more transparency" from the administration. All the while, Trump has rejected the suggestion the files contain anything of note. He said last month: "I don't understand why the Jeffrey Epstein case would be of interest to anybody. It's pretty boring stuff."
The Herald Scotland
4 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
National Guard from GOP states heading to DC: What you need to know
Republican governors have opted to bolster Trump's forces by sending their own guardsmen to Washington beginning with Ohio, South Carolina and West Virginia. "South Carolina is proud to stand with President Trump as he works to restore law and order to our nation's capital and ensure safety for all who live, work, and visit there," said South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster on Aug. 16 in a statement about sending 200 guardsmen to D.C. The mobilization of troops from Republican-led states will bring the total number of guardsmen in the capital to over 1,000. Here's what else to know about the growing force on the ground in Washington. How many soldiers are Republican governors sending? The three Republican states sending members of the National Guard to Washington, D.C. have mobilized around 750 troops: 150 from Ohio, 200 from South Carolina and between 300 and 400 from West Virginia. Gov. Mike DeWine of Ohio called sending troops from the Buckeye State the "right thing to do." He said the deployment comes in response to an Aug. 15 request from Secretary of the Army Daniel P. Driscoll. "The initial decision to deploy D.C. National Guard was not my decision. That was the president of the United States' decision," DeWine told the statehouse bureau. "But when the secretary of the Army asks for backup support to our troops that are already deployed, yes, we will back up our troops." West Virginia Gov. Patrick Morrissey said on Aug. 16 the state's deployment of troops also came at Trump's request. Morrissey said their deployment reflects our "commitment to a strong and secure America." Troops are expected to arrive on 30-day deployments that the secretary of the Army could ask to extend. South Carolina Gov. McMaster said he would recall guardsmen in the event of a hurricane or other natural disaster. How big of a force will be in D.C.? The troops from Republican-led states deploying to the District will nearly double the size of the force Trump has already deployed, from 800 to 1,550 in total. Federal troops will work alongside the city's already 3,100-officer-strong police force. Washington, D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser said last week that the city's police department was understaffed and was supposed to have 3,800 officers. But she says understaffing hasn't stopped the city from achieving its lowest levels of violent crime in 30 years. "Crime levels are not only down from 2023, but from before the pandemic," Bowser said at a televised community meeting on August 12. "Our tactics are working, and we aren't taking our foot off the gas." Trump 'has the authority to do what he did,' Ohio gov says DeWine shot back at Bowser and others questioning Trump's deployment of the guardsmen. "The people who don't like it in D.C. don't have the authority. The president of the United States has that authority," DeWine said. "Anybody can argue whether or not he should or shouldn't have the authority, but it's very clear. There is no debate he has the authority to do what he did." Trump was able to deploy about a third of the 2,400 National Guard troops in Washington, D.C. because of the city's unique status as a federal district. In the rest of the country, the president cannot deploy troops in a policing capacity without the consent of the state's governor though he deployed thousands of troops to Los Angeles over objections from California Gov. Gavin Newsom. Vermont 'politely' declines Trump request: Reports Not all who have heard the call have responded by sending in troops. Gov. Phil Scott, the Republican leader of Vermont, "politely declined" to send a request to send guardsmen to Washington, D.C., according to reporting by Vermont Public, a National Public Radio affiliate. Jason Gibbs, the governor's chief of staff, told Vermont Public on Aug. 15 that sending Green Mountain State troops to Washington was too far outside the scope of what the soldiers typically do. "In the absence of an immediate emergency or disaster that local and regional first responders are unable to handle, the governor just does not support utilizing the guard for this purpose, and does not view the enforcement of domestic law as a proper use of the National Guard," Gibbs said, according to Vermont Public. Scott's office did not immediately respond to USA TODAY requests for comment. Contributing by Cybele Mayes-Osterman, a National Security & World Affairs Reporter with USA TODAY; and USA TODAY Network reporters Jessie Balmert of The Columbus Dispatch and Bella Carpentier of The Greenville News.
The Herald Scotland
4 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
DOJ to begin turning over Jeffrey Epstein probe files: GOP chairman
The Justice Department was not immediately available for comment on what records it might turn over. On Aug. 5, Comer issued a subpoena to the Justice Department for records related to Epstein, the longtime Trump friend who died by suicide in 2019 as he was awaiting trial on federal sex-trafficking charges. Republicans on the House Committee have also issued deposition subpoenas to former President Bill Clinton and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, as well as former top federal law enforcement officials including James Comey, Loretta Lynch, Eric Holder, Merrick Garland, Robert Mueller, William Barr, Jeff Sessions and Alberto Gonzales. Those are scheduled to get underway this month. Those subpoenas seek testimony "related to horrific crimes perpetrated by Jeffrey Epstein," Comer, a Kentucky Republican, said when they were issued. The Oversight Committee voted July 23 to issue the subpoenas and to also seek the DOJ files, answering calls from lawmakers and voters alike for more information on Epstein and who else might have been involved in his underage sex-trafficking ring. While Trump supporters and MAGA influencers have said they want to see the names of prominent Democrats rumored to be in the files, Trump himself is likely in them, at least on flight logs from Epstein's private jet, according to already disclosed court records and other documents. The DOJ promise to hand over files follows weeks of intensifying drama and rare dispute between President Donald Trump, who had a long friendship with Epstein, and his MAGA base. Last month, the DOJ and FBI issued a joint statement saying they would not release Epstein investigative documents in their possession after months of promises by Attorney General Pam Bondi and FBI Director Kash Patel to make that information public. The subpoenas appear to cover when Epstein allegedly sexually assaulted young women with the help of associate Ghislaine Maxwell, which dates back more than two decades. More: Epstein accomplice Ghislaine Maxwell quietly moved out of Florida federal prison Maxwell was interviewed over two days last month about what she knows about the case by Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche, a former Trump personal defense lawyer. The interviews were held in Tallahassee, Florida, where the former British socialite is serving a 20-year prison sentence for helping Epstein sexually abuse teenage girls. She has since been moved to a minimum-security federal prison "camp" in Texas, prompting criticism from Democrats who charge that the Trump administration is giving her preferential treatment. It's unclear what exactly Maxwell told Blanche during the closed-door interviews, but her defense attorney, David Markus, said his client answered all of the government's questions, including those of about 100 different people. On July 23, a federal judge in Florida rejected a bid from the Justice Department to unseal grand jury testimony from 2005 and 2007 tied to a federal investigation into Epstein, who hanged himself in a Manhattan jail cell in 2019 while awaiting trial on sex-trafficking charges, an autopsy concluded. Maxwell is seeking to overturn her conviction and has filed a petition with the Supreme Court, which the Justice Department has opposed. Markus said he believes Ghislaine deserves relief and has appealed online to Trump for consideration, but said no such offer has been made. When asked if he would consider pardoning Maxwell, Trump told reporters, "It's something I haven't thought about."
