logo
Signal chat leak: Security experts divided on impact of breach

Signal chat leak: Security experts divided on impact of breach

Yahoo27-03-2025

(NewsNation) — Security experts expressed mixed views on the sensitive national security information shared in a White House group chat, with both agreeing the incident represents a significant security breach despite what appears to be minimal operational impact.
At the center of the debate is whether Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's messages detailing planned U.S. airstrikes in Yemen constituted a classified war plan.
Journalist Jeffrey Goldberg, who was inadvertently added to a group chat on the Signal messaging app, on Monday published an account of officials accidentally leaking what he called 'war plans' to him.
Potential travel ban 'sending a chill' through airlines: editor
Retired Air Force Lt. Gen. Richard Newton called the Signal app leak 'an extraordinary breach of security' that raises serious concerns about operational communications among top national security officials.
While the leaked details about planned U.S. airstrikes in Yemen did not necessarily compromise the mission, Newton said there were broader implications of sensitive information being exposed.
Matthew 'Whiz' Buckley, a former Navy fighter pilot, characterized the incident as an 'unforced error' but maintained that the leak would not have fundamentally altered the military's operational capabilities.
'The president could have emailed Yemen these plans, and it would not have changed the outcome,' Buckley said on NewsNation's 'Elizabeth Vargas Reports.'
Social Security clawbacks become more intense beginning Thursday
Both military veterans acknowledged that while the specific Yemen strike might not have been critically compromised, the incident highlights dangerous communication practices at the highest levels of national security leadership.
Newton, who previously oversaw global operations for the Joint Chiefs of Staff, stressed that the information shared — including operational planning details and weapon systems information — would likely be classified.
He recommended moving sensitive discussions away from commercial messaging platforms such as Signal and back to secure military communication channels.
Retired Brig. Gen. Peter Zwack cautioned against underestimating the Houthis, describing them as a sophisticated adversary capable of integrating advanced military capabilities.
Trump to impose 25% tariff on cars not made in US
'Our adversaries are watching and learning,' Zwack said Wednesday on NewsNation's 'CUOMO,' saying that the incident provides unprecedented insight into U.S. military decision-making processes for China, Russia and Iran.
Tracy Walder, a former CIA and FBI agent, provided an even more pointed critique.
She said unequivocally that such a breach would typically result in immediate termination, emphasizing that sensitive operational information should never be shared on platforms such as Signal.
'If I did something like this on Signal and leaked this kind of information prior to an attack happening, I most likely would have been fired,' she told NewsNation.
Walder raised additional concerns about the leak's potential impact on intelligence gathering, saying that human assets might become less willing to provide critical information if they sense a lack of operational security.
Both experts agreed that the incident could significantly damage international intelligence-sharing relationships, particularly with the Five Eyes alliance, made up of major English-speaking nations.
Wisconsin Supreme Court race could ripple across country
Zwack stressed the importance of trust in intelligence operations, arguing that such breaches require immediate acknowledgment and corrective action to maintain collaborative relationships with key allies.
'This is all about trust, especially if you're downrange and you're really, really relying on each other,' Zwack said. 'And yes, screwups happen, but it's so important to take responsibility and work to clean it up.'
While acknowledging Signal's potential utility for routine communications, both Zwack and Walder were clear that the platform is not appropriate for sensitive operational details.
'Encrypted does not mean classified, and I think that's where everybody is getting it wrong,' Zwack said.
Walder pointed out that Signal, despite being encrypted, has been penetrated by multiple foreign intelligence services.
The White House has maintained that no war plans were disclosed, but the text messages reportedly contained precise strike timing and weapons details sent hours before the attack.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ukraine shoots down nearly 500 drones, missiles in Russian record strike, Air Force says
Ukraine shoots down nearly 500 drones, missiles in Russian record strike, Air Force says

Yahoo

time16 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Ukraine shoots down nearly 500 drones, missiles in Russian record strike, Air Force says

Ukraine's Air Force said on June 9 that it intercepted a total of 479 Russian drones and missiles during a record-high wave of strikes overnight. According to the official statement, Russia launched 499 weapons, including 479 Shahed‑type attack drones and various decoy drones, four Kh‑47M2 "Kinzhal" air-launched ballistic missiles, 10 Kh‑101 cruise missiles, three Kh‑22 cruise missiles over the Black Sea, two Kh‑31P anti‑radar missiles, and one Kh‑35 cruise missile from occupied Crimea. Ukraine had reportedly neutralized 479 of the incoming targets, with 292 were shot down, and 187 jammed or lost via electronic warfare. In Kyiv Oblast, air‑raid sirens lasted over ten hours, according to Governor Mykola Kalashnyk. Air defences shot down Russian drones. No civilian casualties were reported. Two houses, a car, and an outbuilding in Boryspil district were reportedly damaged. In Rivne Oblast, Governor Oleksandr Koval described the night as very heavy. One civilian was reportedly injured. The attack, according to Koval, was the largest since the beginning of Russia's full-scale war. In Zaporizhzhia Oblast, one person was injured, according to Governor Ivan Fedorov. Over the day, 498 strikes reportedly struck 14 populated areas. In Kherson Oblast, numerous towns were hit by drones, artillery, and airstrikes. Three apartment blocks, 13 houses, a farm, and vehicles were damaged. Four civilians were injured, the governor said. In Kharkiv Oblast, nine villages were hit. Seven civilians suffered minor injuries, according to Governor Oleh Syniehubov. Russian forces reportedly used 22 unguided aviation rockets, 18 guided bombs (KAB), 6 Geran (Shahed) drones, 4 unspecified UAVs, and 1 Molniya drone. Civil damage included houses, a store, a camp, and vehicles. In Dnipropetrovsk Oblast, Ukrainian defences downed six UAVs at night, Governor Serhii Lysak said. A farm, houses, and vehicles in the region were reportedly hit. In Sumy Oblast, Russian forces launched nearly 90 strikes across 35 settlements, injuring nine civilians, local authorities reported. Shops, a school, homes, and cars were reportedly damaged. Authorities evacuated 21 people. In Cherkasy Oblast, air defences shot down 33 Russian drones overnight. No injuries were reported, but falling debris damaged four houses, a farm outbuilding, and a car in the Cherkasy district. Read also: Ukrainian drones hit Russian electronic warfare facility in Chuvashia Republic, military says We've been working hard to bring you independent, locally-sourced news from Ukraine. Consider supporting the Kyiv Independent.

Anti-Woke Crusades Only Make Hegseth and Rubio Look Petty
Anti-Woke Crusades Only Make Hegseth and Rubio Look Petty

Bloomberg

time37 minutes ago

  • Bloomberg

Anti-Woke Crusades Only Make Hegseth and Rubio Look Petty

The actor Sean Penn has summed up the problem with Pete Hegseth, and by extension the administration of President Donald Trump. 'I've never before seen a Secretary of Defense so aggressively demote himself to the rank of Chief PETTY Officer,' Penn said upon hearing that the Pentagon boss has ordered the Navy to rename an oiler called the USNS Harvey Milk. The naming of a ship (or a gulf, or anything) is often a bureaucratic gesture of forgettable symbolism. Not in this case and a slew of others that Hegseth is currently reviewing. The effort instead points to a worrisome obsession that causes division, distraction and the diversion of scarce energy from real foreign conflicts toward domestic culture wars.

Estonian president: Ukraine will become NATO member in long term
Estonian president: Ukraine will become NATO member in long term

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Estonian president: Ukraine will become NATO member in long term

Estonian President Alar Karis has urged people not to lose hope in Ukraine's future NATO membership, even though there is currently no unanimous political will among allies to approve it. Source: Alar Karis in an interview with Lithuanian broadcaster LRT, as reported by European Pravda Details: Karis was asked whether he believes Ukraine's accession to NATO is realistic in light of former US President Donald Trump's recent remarks dismissing the idea. Quote: "It's worth remembering that Estonia began discussing NATO membership when Russian troops were still on our soil, and not everyone believed Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania would ever become NATO members. But here we are – NATO members and allies." More details: Karis added that both Finland and Sweden have recently joined NATO despite a long history of neutrality. "Ukraine also needs security guarantees. And in the long term, we are convinced Ukraine will become a NATO member as well," Karis said. Background: Estonia plans to allocate over 5% of its GDP to defence needs next year. Estonian Defence Minister Hanno Pevkur believes NATO countries can realistically raise their defence spending to 5% of GDP within five years. Read also: Support Ukrainska Pravda on Patreon!

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store