"Will Destroy Marriage Sanctity...": Why Court Junked Rape Case Against Man
New Delhi:
The Rajasthan High Court quashed a rape case against a man after he married the woman he allegedly assaulted. Charges were dropped after the court said criminal proceedings against the man - now the rape survivor's husband - would 'destroy the sanctity of marriage'.
Justice Anoop Kumar Dhand, legal news website Live Law said, attributed his decision to the 'peculiarity of the marriage' and, therefore, that his ruling could not be used as precedent to quash rape charges if the complainant and the accused 'reach a compromise'.
Justice Dhand also noted two Supreme Court judgement to this effects, in each of which rape charges against the man were dropped after the woman and he were married.
"Marriage is considered as a sacred union between two individuals - transcending physical, emotional, and spiritual bonds. According to ancient Hindu laws, marriage and its rituals are performed to pursue ' dharma ' (duty), ' artha ' (possession), and ' kama ' (physical desire)."
"... marriage is more than a ritual, which cannot be allowed to be destroyed by continuing the criminal proceedings against the petitioner," the judge declared.
Proceeding with these charges, the court said, would 'disturb married life'.
The eyebrow-raising judgement came after the woman complained she entered into a physical relationship with the accused based on the latter's promise of marriage. However, after she became pregnant the man reportedly fed her abortion pills and refused further communication.
But between the time her complaint was filed and the court heard it, the man and woman were wed, and a petition was then made to quash the rape charges.
Meanwhile, earlier this month the Supreme Court said failed romantic relationships need not always mean sexual relations were forced on either party. The observation came as the top court heard a plea by a man to quash rape charges levelled by his former fiancee.
The woman's lawyer pointed out the relationship in question was 'arranged' and not 'romantic' in nature, thereby raising the question of 'consent'. The court countered, saying the situation had to be examined from both perspectives, and that it had "no attachment to any one gender".
The court eventually decided it would hear the man's plea further.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
NIA takes over probe into murder of Hindu activist Suhas Shetty
Mangaluru : A team from the National Investigation Agency ( NIA ) arrived here on Saturday to formally take over the investigation into the murder of Hindu activist Suhas Shetty, who was killed in Bajpe town on May 1. The team, led by NIA Deputy Superintendent of Police Pawan Kumar, has begun coordinating with local police. Mangaluru police confirmed the arrival of the NIA team and said preliminary information has been shared with the City Crime Branch (CCB) officials. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 2 Simple Profitable Strategies That Can Make You 5K Per Day thefutureuniversity Learn More Undo The Union Ministry of Home Affairs recently transferred the case to the NIA. According to official sources, the Ministry has directed the federal agency to investigate the " targeted killing " of Shetty describing it as an act intended to "create terror in the minds of people". Live Events Citing a home ministry communique in this regard, the sources said the accused involved in the murder case are allegedly members of the Popular Front of India (PFI), a banned outfit. Several state BJP leaders have demanded an NIA probe into the murder. Police sources too said Shetty was allegedly murdered by a group of eight youths, with suspected links to the banned Popular Front of India (PFI). According to police the Investigating officer of the CCB is processing the handing over of the case to the NIA.
Hans India
3 hours ago
- Hans India
NIA Takes Over Probe into Murder of Hindu Activist Suhas Shetty in Bajpe
Mangaluru: The National Investigation Agency (NIA) has formally taken over the investigation into the brutal murder of Hindu activist Suhas Shetty, who was hacked to death in broad daylight in Bajpe town on May 1. The central agency's team reached Mangaluru earlier this week and has initiated preliminary groundwork. Mangaluru Police have officially confirmed the arrival of the NIA team, led by DSP Pawan Kumar. The team has met with City Crime Branch (CCB) officers to collect case-related documents and briefings. The Union government had transferred the case to the NIA following pressure from BJP leaders, particularly Dakshina Kannada MP Capt. Brijesh Chowta, who had written to Union Home Minister Amit Shah seeking a central agency probe. The NIA investigation may also include charge of collision of officials in aiding the murder of Suhas Shetty, which the Karnataka government was wary about. It is stated by the BJP leaders that a certain police official had checked the car of Suhas Shetty twice on the day he was murdered, the checks had been carried out twice within a span of few hours to ensure that Shetty and his co passengers in the car had no weapons. Initial investigations by the local police had pointed to the involvement of a group of eight Muslim youths, allegedly affiliated with the banned organisation Popular Front of India (PFI). The calculated nature of the attack and the possible ideological motivation behind the killing raised concerns about a broader conspiracy. The NIA is likely to revisit the evidence and re-examine the suspects in custody. It may also explore whether provisions under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) are applicable if firm links to proscribed outfits are established. There are also reports suggesting that the agency will look into possible lapses by certain local police personnel. With the NIA's entry, the case is set to widen in scope, potentially extending beyond the immediate assailants to uncover a larger network, if any, behind the murder.
Indian Express
4 hours ago
- Indian Express
3 days after communal violence rocked Maheshtala, Bengal Police transfer local SDPO, inspector-in-charge
Three days after communal violence broke out in Maheshtala near Kolkata, the West Bengal Police Saturday transferred the sub-divisional police officer (SDPO) of Maheshtala. As per a notification of the West Bengal Police Directorate, a copy of which is with The Indian Express, Maheshtala SDPO Kamrujjaman Molla has been transferred as assistant commandant of the State Armed Police (SAP) 3rd Battalion. Molla has been replaced by Syed Rezual Kabir, who was the inspector-in-charge of Rajarhat police station in the North 24 Parganas. Meanwhile, Mukul Mia, Inspector-in-Charge, Rabindranagar police station, Diamond Harbour Police District, has been transferred to Darjeeling. Sujan Kumar Ray, who was previously posted as circle inspector, Ratha, Malda, has been appointed as the new inspector-in-charge of Rabindranagar police station. Police sources, though, termed these transfers as routine. On Wednesday afternoon, clashes broke out at Ward Number 7 in Maheshtala over the setting up of a shop. It took a communal turn with some people alleging that a 'tulsi mancha' (a platform for a holy basil plant) was vandalised. The violence between the two groups quickly escalated, with mobs throwing stones at the police personnel who tried to control the situation. According to police sources, the situation is now under control. The area where the violence broke out falls under the overlapping jurisdiction of the Kolkata Police and the West Bengal Police. Till now, around 40 people have been arrested for their role in the violence. About a dozen personnel of the Kolkata Police, including the deputy commissioner of the Port area, were injured in the clashes. Seven FIRs have been registered in connection with the violence. All the arrests took place on the intervening night of Wednesday and Thursday. Bengal Leader of Opposition Suvendu Adhikari has filed a Public Interest Litigation in the Calcutta High Court demanding CRPF deployment in the area. He has also moved the high court seeking permission to meet the Hindu families whose houses and shops had been allegedly affected in the violence.
