Proof the TMO is not fit for purpose: Elliott Smith's Tight Five
A suggestion...
Someone at World Rugby must be a fan of TV shows or movies about lawyers – perhaps A Few Good Men might be appropriate because – and Jack Nicholson's Colonel Jessep is not the 'good guy' in this scene – they can't handle the truth. The truth
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
All Blacks coach Scott Robertson faces wing selection challenge
If a fake news story went out on social media that a secret factory had been found in New Zealand where world-class wings were being made, half the rugby world would have been inclined to believe it. But those good old days feel a long time ago, and the All Blacks of 2025 look to be building an impressive talent pool in most positions – bar the one they are famed for never having to try overly hard to fill. It doesn't feel like head coach Scott Robertson has to rip the whole thing up and start again, but he does have to be open to thinking about making some personnel changes after the Rugby Championship if the current cohort continue to underwhelm. The All Blacks need potency on their wings. Their ultra-fast game plan needs genuine finishers on each flank – be it through power, pace, elusiveness or – ideally – a combination of all three. Both wings have to be competent under the high ball – a non-negotiable in the box-kick-heavy world of international rugby – and both wings have to be adept chasers, able to compete in the air and win back possession. All Blacks coach Scott Robertson wants potent wingers for his side's fast game plan. Photo / Photosport Playing wing effectively for the All Blacks these days is a combination of glamour and grunt work and throughout the July series, no one wing delivered on both fronts. Rieko Ioane's instincts were rusty in the first test, where his kick-chase was poor and his timing off. He looked sharper and more alive to opportunity in the second test, but now that he has been officially listed as an outside back rather than as a midfielder, he needs to show definitively throughout the Rugby Championship that he can be the same potent force on the wing that he was between 2016 and 2018. His Blues teammate Caleb Clarke is going to have to hope he can recover in time to deliver a much-needed reminder that he can be the everything man the All Blacks are looking for. He brings a proven ability to compete for high kicks, but his body of work over the past 18 months has been inconsistent and, with Leicester Fainga'anuku set to become eligible for the end-of-year tour, there's maybe a hidden reality that only one of Ioane and Clarke are long-term propositions. Robertson will likely want a mix of body types and skillsets in his mix, and Fainga'anuku, Ioane and Clarke could all be put under the umbrella of power wings – and being broadly similar as they are, retaining all three for the 2027 World Cup may not be possible. The pressure is building on Ioane and Clarke to freshen and strengthen their case for continued inclusion, which is the same for Sevu Reece, who must surely be the most vulnerable of the current contingent. Sevu Reece (left) and Rieko Ioane are both hoping for spots as wingers with the All Blacks. Photo / Photosport Robertson, fairly, decided not to invest in Mark Tele'a this year after the Blues wing announced he will be moving to Japan in 2026, but by the same token, Reece doesn't inspire as being any more likely to still be in selection contention by the next World Cup. Reece, it could be argued, is holding his place partly because Robertson and his selection panel have not yet been convinced that any of the younger, emerging wings such as Emoni Narawa, Leroy Carter, Chay Fihaki or Caleb Tangitau are quite ready yet. But there is also this lingering possibility that Robertson sees Reece as a Cheslin Kolbe figure – a small but powerful, fast-footed runner with the ability to pull off the impossible in confined spaces. If he does see Reece in a similar light to the magical South African, he's probably the only one. Reece doesn't induce the same sense of possibilities – his top-end speed isn't there, his instincts are not as sharp and his skillset is not as diverse. It says something problematic about the All Blacks that they continue to try to manufacture an inferior product to the Springboks in a position they used to lead the world. There seems to be more upside and less risk in the All Blacks experimenting with Narawa and Carter during the Rugby Championship than there does persevering with Reece. But whatever choices get made, the All Blacks need to rekindle that sense of fear they used to induce every time they started moving the ball towards the wing. Gregor Paul is one of New Zealand's most respected rugby writers and columnists. He has won multiple awards for journalism and written several books about sport.
NZ Herald
3 days ago
- NZ Herald
Silver Fern Irene van Dyk calls for open talks on menstruation in sports
Experienced sportswomen are calling for a shift in attitudes – breaking the bias and normalising discussions around menstruation in sport. In the first of a four-part series, Bonnie Jansen speaks with netball great Irene van Dyk on her silent struggle of competing while menstruating – hiding the reality and avoiding conversations. Irene van Dyk – one of New Zealand's greatest adopted athletes - still remembers the way she had to hide the cramps, the blood and shame. She was playing netball at the highest level – but she couldn't ask for a tampon. There was a time when she wouldn't even take the court when it was her time of the month. 'When I grew up, you wouldn't even play netball [when you had your period],' van Dyk told the Herald. 'You'd say 'I just started vomiting or I've got diarrhoea'. 'You would literally not play.' Two decades ago, playing elite sport while on your period wasn't just uncomfortable – it was taboo. Periods were whispered about, and athletes were forced to act like nothing was happening – because to acknowledge it might've made you seem weak. 'It was partly because you were bleeding, but also it was sometimes we wore short skirts or your dress was a light colour and anything could show. Van Dyk laughed in disbelief as she recalled the moment. 'Hell no!' she said when asked if she'd ever told her coach the real reason she couldn't play. 'You'd name anything but the fact that you had your period.' It wasn't until van Dyk was playing international netball for South Africa, in her 20s, when she struck up the confidence to play through her period. She felt she had matured and was more prepared to take the court while menstruating. 'I would still not mention it. I would still not tell anyone else I have my period.' It was then, during the era when van Dyk switched allegiances and played for New Zealand, that open discussions about menstruation became more accepted. 'There was one year where I can remember [playing for the Silver Ferns] ... It must have been preparing for the 2003 World Cup or 2006, Commonwealth Games, where our whole team's [menstruation cycle] was in sync.' Irene van Dyk sings the national anthem ahead of the 2007 World Netball Championships final. Photo / Photosport Van Dyk is referring to the phenomenon often called menstrual synchrony – otherwise known as herding. It's the idea that women who live together or spend a lot of time together may begin to have their menstrual cycles at the same time. Though the concept is not scientifically supported, it was popularised in the 1970s. 'We started laughing about it because we were like, 'holy s**t', we never would have talked about it – and now all of a sudden, our whole team is going through the same thing.' Van Dyk – who is Netball New Zealand's participation manager – said it's changed quite significantly when comparing when she played to how menstruation is addressed today. 'The fact that now they have managers and people that are around the courts [carrying sanitary products] ... we didn't have that.' She touted the national Netball Smart programme that educates players more on the balancing act. 'They've definitely done a lot of research into it, and they talk around the whole stigma around and how to prepare your body for when you compete and when you have your period and how it impacts on your body and your wellbeing. 'It's just incredible.' Van Dyk said Sport NZ's period product rollout in 2024 was a 'genius move.' The governing body launched a one-year research project placing free period products in 48 community sport clubs nationwide. Funded by the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment as part of the legacy programme for the Rugby, Football and Cricket World Cups hosted in Aotearoa in 2022 and 2023 – the project aimed to understand the impact of free period products on inclusivity for female players. Last year, 48 sports clubs across the country received free period products for 5895 athletes. Sport NZ's report said 45,000 pads and 44,200 tampons were distributed. Van Dyk said it would be 'fantastic' if netball could be included in the campaign in future – particularly given that women and girls dominate the sport. 'We are the main female sport and that's something we'll have to look into to make sure we support our players and encourage them and actually normalise [periods] and being able to talk about [periods] in that sense.' 'All female sports should be able to celebrate being a woman and having that ability to regardless of your period.' Sport New Zealand's priority populations manager, focusing on women and girls, Emma Evans, told the Herald, she doesn't want periods to be a barrier for athletes participating in sport and recreation. 'You have access to toilet paper, you have access to soap. You don't necessarily have access to period products,' Evans said. 'Period products shouldn't be a luxury, but sadly, that's how they're often seen. 'For me, a really fundamental part of this is 50% of the population requires period products. 'It's not a 'nice to have' – it's a necessity for health, for dignity, for wellbeing.' Though a huge success, Evans said the legacy campaign wouldn't continue as the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment funding was specifically for that legacy project in 2024. 'After we did this one-year research project, naturally, we had a lot of clubs, sports, regional sports trusts coming to us and saying, 'Hey, we want to be a part of this, what can we do?' 'Unfortunately, there was obviously a limited amount of money and it was linked to those three World Cups, but what we hope is that actually during this one year across these 48 clubs across the country, it gets people talking about this being an issue and this being a barrier. 'I think the research has done that.' Evans said various clubs and sports are having discussions about how they can continue building momentum in the space – without the financial support of the government. 'That's expanded to several regional sports trusts talking with their local council around actually 'what does collaboration look like in this space - how what might we work together' to break down this barrier that is still facing so many women and girls. 'While at this point there are no concrete partnerships that have come from those conversations, I think it's a very exciting step in the right direction.' Van Dyk said normalising period chat is important in sport. 'It happens to everyone, every woman, it happens to every female. '[We need to] reduce barriers for players when it happens on the day. Sometimes the younger ones don't realise [when their period arrives] - they don't follow the track as it goes' 'It just happens and having the ability to just go into the changing room or grabbing something out of the gear bag or having a manager there or someone that has product that you know – it would just be incredible. 'It would be really really helpful.' 'Life is expensive – for some people it is quite hard to prepare for those things. So, to have [sanitary items] on tap and to [player's] availability and then having the confidence to go to ask for it or just grab it – that would be a game changer.' Tuesday: Irene van Dyk on her silent struggle playing netball while menstruating, hiding the reality and avoiding conversations. Wednesday: Aimee Didierjean on the stigma in gymnastics, competing in tight uniforms while navigating pads and tampons, and how intense training led to her period arriving late. Thursday: Sailor Liv Mackay on navigating the challenges of being the sole female on her team and how she manages her period while spending long hours at sea. Friday: Ultra-marathon runner Shannon-Leigh Litt on embracing her flow and how she adapts her training to align with her cycle. Bonnie Jansen is a multimedia journalist in the NZME sports team. She was named New Zealand's Best Up and Coming journalist in 2025. She's a football commentator and co-host of the Football Fever podcast and was part of the Te Rito cadetship scheme before becoming a fulltime journalist.
NZ Herald
3 days ago
- NZ Herald
Triathlete Hayden Wilde wins London T100 race after truck accident
Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech. Hayden Wilde during the Ironman 70.3 World Championship in Taupō in 2024. Photo / Photosport New Zealand triathlete Hayden Wilde has completed a remarkable comeback from injury to win the T100 series race in London in emphatic style. Three months after being hit by a truck on a training ride in Japan, an emotional Wilde returned to competitive action in spectacular style, clearing a way for a memorable victory in the race comprising a 2km swim, 80km cycle and 18km run. The 27-year-old couldn't hold back tears after crossing the line and later reflected on the low point of a hospital bed in Japan, where he began the recovery from four broken ribs, a broken scapula and a punctured lung after being knocked off his bike by a truck. NZ triathlete Hayden Wilde. Photo / Hayden Wilde He was in Japan for several weeks in May as he was unable to fly because of the lung damage.
