A 15-tonne mega bomb is needed to destroy Iran's last nuclear facility – here's why Israel can't deliver it
Such a powerful weapon – the largest non-nuclear bomb in the US arsenal – is needed because the target, Fordow Fuel Enrichment Plant, is built some 300 feet inside a mountain near the city of Qom, two hours south of Tehran.
The heavyweight explosive is known as a GBU-57A/B Massive Ordnance Penetrator and was designed by Boeing for the United States Air Force.
Its huge weight means it can only be delivered with a B-2 Spirit stealth bomber – a jet Israel's air force does not possess.
'The United States controls the bomber and the bomb,' John Spencer, chair of urban warfare studies at the Modern War Institute at West Point military academy, told The Post. 'It would be an American plane and an American munition.'
The missile cost over $500 million for the US Army to develop, and was built to specifications which would allow it to penetrate deep enough into the Fordow plant to destroy the nuclear centrifuges in the complex, according to a 2013 article in the Wall Street Journal, which said at that time 20 of the bombs had been manufactured for the US military.
If the US does opt to help Israel with this extraordinarily powerful weapon, it will almost certainly turn the nuclear facility, protected by layers of granite and steel, to rubble.
'By weight and kinetic force, the GBU-57A/B Massive Ordnance Penetrator is designed to penetrate a certain amount of distance into the ground before it blows,' said Spencer.
'That's why these bunker busters are called Penetrators. They penetrate the ground before they explode. The explosion is strategically delayed.'
Although the US has sold less powerful bunker buster weapons to Israel, they have declined to share the Massive Ordnance Penetrator with any of its allies, partly to ensure it retains an upper hand, according to various reports.
As to what an explosion from a Massive Ordnance Penetrator would feel like, Spencer can only guess. 'I've seen 500 pounders, and they'll shake your teeth when they go off. It's like an earthquake. This will be much more than that.'
However, minimizing the likelihood of a nuclear explosion or leak, said Spencer, 'this [explosion] is pretty contained,' He explained that since the bunker buster explodes so far underground, under such strong armor, it is unlikely to cause a nuclear reaction. Instead of breaking through the surface, rubble would cave in. 'The risk is for leakage, not an explosion.'
US intelligence has long agreed Fordow is strategic to disabling the Iranian nuclear program.
'If you don't get Fordow, you haven't eliminated their ability to produce weapons-grade material,' Brett McGurk, who served as Middle East coordinator for several American presidents of both parties, recently told the New York Times.
In a less than ideal scenario, a state-of-the-art bunker buster is not the only solution.
It's also possible, said Spencer, that, without help from the US, Israel could do a jerry rigged attack on Fordow.
'Israel has cornered the market on what they call drilling,' said Spencer. 'They drop one bomb that reaches a certain depth, then another and another, at different angles, within seconds, to get to where they want to go. But you put multiple people and multiple aircraft at risk. The GBU is one and done.'
Considering that option, Spencer concluded, 'There are many ways to destroy the nuclear program in Iran. But this is the effective and efficient one. It gets to the objective quicker and is the perfect solution.'
Originally published as A 15-tonne mega bomb is needed to destroy Iran's last nuclear facility – here's why Israel can't deliver it
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
3 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Trump makes unusual deal with world's most valuable company
Nvidia and Advanced Micro Devices have agreed to pay 15 per cent of their revenues from Chinese AI chip sales to the US government in an unusual deal that threatens to set a precedent for American companies doing business in the Asian nation. Nvidia, which is the world's most valuable public traded company with a market capitalisation of about $US4.5 trillion ($6.9 trillion), plans to share 15 per cent of the revenue from sales of its H20 AI accelerator in China, US President Donald Trump said in a briefing with reporters on Monday. AMD will deliver the same share from MI308 revenues, a person familiar with the situation said, asking not to be identified discussing internal deliberations. Trump said he'd originally told Nvidia that he wanted a 20 per cent cut for the US if he cleared H20 sales to China but eventually settled for a 15 per cent share. The two negotiated 'a little deal,' he said. The arrangement reflects Trump's consistent effort to engineer a financial payout for America in return for concessions on trade. His administration has shown a willingness to relax trade conditions like tariffs in return for giant investments in the US — as with Apple's pledge to spend $US600 billion ($921 billion) on domestic manufacturing. But such a narrow, select export tax has little precedent in modern corporate history. Beijing, which has grown increasingly hostile to the idea of Chinese firms deploying the H20, is unlikely to warm to the idea of a chip tax. Yuyuantantian, a social media account affiliated with state-run China Central Television that regularly signals Beijing's thinking about trade, on Sunday slammed what it described as security vulnerabilities and inefficiencies of Nvidia's chip. Loading The move comes amid a CNBC report that Trump is extending a tariff truce with China for another 90 days, stabilising trade ties between the world's two largest economies. The agreement had been due to expire on Tuesday. AMD shares gained 1.2 per cent to $US174.84 in New York on Monday. Nvidia shares were up about 0.3 per cent. 'Both Nvidia and AMD already said they would start shipping to China, so that market reaction already happened,' said Jay Goldberg, an analyst at Seaport Global Securities. The big question is exactly when they're going to start delivering to China again, especially now that there are strings attached, Goldberg said. 'This seeming quid pro quo is unprecedented from an export control perspective. The arrangement risks invalidating the national security rationale for US export controls,' said Jacob Feldgoise, a researcher at the DC-based Center for Security and Emerging Technology.
The Age
3 hours ago
- The Age
Trump makes unusual deal with world's most valuable company
Nvidia and Advanced Micro Devices have agreed to pay 15 per cent of their revenues from Chinese AI chip sales to the US government in an unusual deal that threatens to set a precedent for American companies doing business in the Asian nation. Nvidia, which is the world's most valuable public traded company with a market capitalisation of about $US4.5 trillion ($6.9 trillion), plans to share 15 per cent of the revenue from sales of its H20 AI accelerator in China, US President Donald Trump said in a briefing with reporters on Monday. AMD will deliver the same share from MI308 revenues, a person familiar with the situation said, asking not to be identified discussing internal deliberations. Trump said he'd originally told Nvidia that he wanted a 20 per cent cut for the US if he cleared H20 sales to China but eventually settled for a 15 per cent share. The two negotiated 'a little deal,' he said. The arrangement reflects Trump's consistent effort to engineer a financial payout for America in return for concessions on trade. His administration has shown a willingness to relax trade conditions like tariffs in return for giant investments in the US — as with Apple's pledge to spend $US600 billion ($921 billion) on domestic manufacturing. But such a narrow, select export tax has little precedent in modern corporate history. Beijing, which has grown increasingly hostile to the idea of Chinese firms deploying the H20, is unlikely to warm to the idea of a chip tax. Yuyuantantian, a social media account affiliated with state-run China Central Television that regularly signals Beijing's thinking about trade, on Sunday slammed what it described as security vulnerabilities and inefficiencies of Nvidia's chip. Loading The move comes amid a CNBC report that Trump is extending a tariff truce with China for another 90 days, stabilising trade ties between the world's two largest economies. The agreement had been due to expire on Tuesday. AMD shares gained 1.2 per cent to $US174.84 in New York on Monday. Nvidia shares were up about 0.3 per cent. 'Both Nvidia and AMD already said they would start shipping to China, so that market reaction already happened,' said Jay Goldberg, an analyst at Seaport Global Securities. The big question is exactly when they're going to start delivering to China again, especially now that there are strings attached, Goldberg said. 'This seeming quid pro quo is unprecedented from an export control perspective. The arrangement risks invalidating the national security rationale for US export controls,' said Jacob Feldgoise, a researcher at the DC-based Center for Security and Emerging Technology.
Perth Now
3 hours ago
- Perth Now
Women in media to discuss challenges, hopes for sector
The future of media, gender equity in workplaces and backlash against programs that promote diversity, equity and inclusion will be in the spotlight at a national conference. The Women in Media conference brings together women from across the sector, including public relations, marketing, journalism, arts and entertainment, production, screen, digital, publishing and advertising. The annual conference in Sydney on Friday comes as many women are being driven out of the industry by financial pressures, stalled growth and lack of progress on gender equity. An industry report released in June found career dissatisfaction among women in the media had risen to 59 per cent - the highest level in four years. More than a decade after she first visited Australia to promote her book The End of Men: and The Rise of Women, journalist and podcaster Hanna Rosin is returning to headline the conference as a keynote speaker. Rosin, a senior editor at The Atlantic, will be joined by high-profile speakers including actor and director Claudia Karvan, Minister for Women Katy Gallagher, journalist Bridget Brennan and award-winning author Shankari Chandran. When she published The End of Men in 2012, Rosin said she believed the world could go in one of two directions. Either gender roles would be loosened, with more men taking on roles in care and education, or there would be backlash, Rosin thought. "When you have a rise of women, there can be a lot of backlash," she told AAP. "The manosphere was fringe back then and we associated it with incels. Now it is mainstream." The election of President Donald Trump for the second time has also hardened gender roles in the United States, with the administration shutting down diversity, equity and inclusion programs it says are a form of discrimination. "It is surreal living here (in the US) now and feeling the force-back of decades of women's rights," Rosin said. Her keynote speech will be about the changes she has observed in gender, power and politics in America in the past decade. She will discuss how the media and workplaces have changed and the age of social media. "The conference has caught me at a good time because a lot of American women were stunned into silence after Trump 2.0," she said. "There was no revolt like there was in 2017 but I feel like we are all now waking up again."
