EXCLUSIVE Blake Lively suffers huge blow as judge issues devastating ruling in case against Justin Baldoni
Blake Lively has suffered another courtroom blow in her ongoing legal battle with Justin Baldoni after a New York judge threw a curveball in her attempt to withdraw her 'emotional distress' claims against the actor.
Court filings obtained by the Daily Mail reveal the two parties had been slugging it out over the actress's claims that her co-star had caused her emotional distress, with Baldoni's team demanding she provide proof from her medical records.
Lively's team instead then attempted to quietly drop that element from her blockbuster lawsuit on Friday but, critically, without prejudice – meaning the claim could be refiled at a later date.
She also filed a motion on Monday to block Baldoni's request for her medical records arguing that she voluntarily sought to withdraw the claim in 'good faith to streamline the dispute'.
Now, the Daily Mail can reveal that Judge Lewis Liman on Tuesday agreed to deny Baldoni's motion based on Lively's decision to drop the claims, however, he also ruled that both sides will now have to negotiate whether her emotional distress element will be dismissed from the case permanently.
In another blow, Judge Liman said even if the claims are not dismissed, Lively's team will no longer be able to produce evidence of emotional distress in court.
The 24-hour legal spat has already seen claims and counterclaims traded by both sides, with Baldoni's team saying the 37-year-old is trying to 'have it both ways'.
Last night, legal representatives for Lively hit back with a furious statement accusing Baldoni of orchestrating a 'press stunt' and saying they had offered to drop the emotional distress claims in 'good faith'.
In a statement released to the Daily Mail, attorneys Esra Hudson and Mike Gottlieb said: 'Once again this is a routine part of the litigation process that is being used as a press stunt.
'We are doing what trial lawyers do: preparing our case for trial by streamlining and focusing it; they are doing what they do: desperately seeking another tired round of tabloid coverage.
'The Baldoni-Wayfarer strategy of filing retaliatory claims has exposed them to expansive new damages claims under California law, rendering certain of Ms. Lively's original claims no longer necessary.
'Ms. Lively continues to allege emotional distress, as part of numerous other claims in her lawsuit, such as sexual harassment and retaliation, and massive additional compensatory damages on all of her claims.'
Then, in a fiery letter obtained by the Daily Mail, Gottleib and Hudson attempted to have Baldoni's motion to compel medical records dismissed, arguing it was based on 'two brazenly false assertions'.
But that move has now failed thanks to Judge Liman, with Lively's emotional distress claims now off the table.
Despite today's win, Baldoni will still have to defend himself over her other claims which include sexual harassment and the orchestration of a smear campaign against her.
The 41-year-old is also pursuing a $400million countersuit of his own that also claims defamation and accuses the glamorous blonde of damaging his reputation and career.
The legal spat has produced months of negative headlines for Lively who has also had to look on as her friendship with superstar bestie Taylor Swift deteriorates in public, largely due to the singer's fury at being dragged into the case.
Last month, the singer found herself on the receiving end of a now withdrawn subpoena and in the middle of a row over whether Lively had tried to force her to issue a supportive message by threatening to release a decade's worth of text messages.
The former provoked a stinging response from her rep who said the megastar had had nothing to do with It Ends With Us beyond providing a song for the soundtrack.
The statement read: 'Taylor Swift never set foot on the set of this movie, she was not involved in any casting or creative decisions, she did not score the film, she never saw an edit or made any notes on the film, she did not even see It Ends With Us until weeks after its public release, and was traveling around the globe during 2023 and 2024 headlining the biggest tour in history.'
Her spokesperson added: 'The connection Taylor had to this film was permitting the use of one song, 'My Tears Ricochet.
'Given that her involvement was licensing a song for the film, which 19 other artists also did, this document subpoena is designed to use Taylor Swift's name to draw public interest by creating tabloid clickbait instead of focusing on the facts of the case.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
34 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Nine women accuse Jared Leto of sexual impropriety in new report
Multiple women have accused Jared Leto of impropriety, with some calling the 53-year-old actor and musician's behavior 'predatory, terrifying and unacceptable'. In a new report by Air Mail on Saturday, nine women have come forward to accuse Leto of engaging in inappropriate behavior over the years, including flirting with teenagers. Speaking to the outlet, one woman said that back in 2006, when she was 16 years old, Leto approached her outside a cafe in Los Angeles. According to the woman, Leto, who was seated with the actor Ashley Olsen, who was then 19, grabbed her arm. 'I looked down and it was Jared Leto,' the woman told Air Mail, adding: 'We had a quick conversation, and he got my number.' She went on to say that Leto called her home a few days later, recalling: 'I don't know if he was on drugs or what … It was the weirdest, grossest voice … [But] for me, it's Jared, you know?' She said that Leto said he was hosting a party at his house that evening and that he invited her. The woman declined, telling the outlet: 'I didn't even have a driver's license.' Nevertheless, she said, Leto kept calling her, 'always at one, two, three AM'. 'And the conversations turned sexual. He'd ask things like: 'Have you ever had a boyfriend? Have you ever sucked a dick?'' she told Air Mail. Another woman, the model Laura La Rue, recounted a similar experience to the outlet, saying that when she was 16 years old in 2008, she was at an event in a private residence in Beverly Hills where Leto was 'watching her so intensely'. 'He asked how old I was. I said, 'I'm 16. How old are you?'' La Rue told Air Mail. Leto, who was 36 at the time, proceeded to ask for her number. The two began an email correspondence, which eventually led to her visiting Leto's home in April 2009, the outlet reports. 'I remember him teasing me the whole time I was there,' La Rue said, adding: 'He was flirting with me. He'd lean in close, then pull away, like it was a game.' In a statement to Air Mail, a representative of Leto said: 'Their communications contain nothing sexual or inappropriate … and Ms La Rue later applied to work as Mr Leto's personal assistant, further underscoring the absence of anything inappropriate in any of their interactions.' Air Mail reports La Rue denying ever applying for a personal assistant role with Leto. During a separate visit, La Rue said, Leto walked out of a room completely naked when she was 17 years old. 'He just walked out, dick out, like it was normal … I thought maybe this was just what adult men do,' she told Air Mail. Another woman who spoke to the outlet said that she and Leto began a texting relationship while she was still underage. According to her, Leto would ask her inappropriate questions during her visits to his house, such as: 'Do any of the little boys you hang out with fuck you?' The woman added that once, when she was 18, Leto 'suddenly pulled his penis out and started masturbating'. She told the outlet: 'Then he walked over, grabbed my hand, and put it on him. He leaned in and said: 'I want you to spit on it.'' Another woman, Allie Teilz, a Los Angeles-based DJ and music producer, last month on Instagram reposted a 2012 Facebook status in which she had said: 'Youre [sic] not really in L.A. until Jared Leto tries to force himself on you backstage… In a kilt.. And a snow hat,' Air Mail reported. In her Instagram stories, which Air Mail reviewed, Teilz said: 'I was assaulted and traumatized by this creep when I was 17 … He knew my age and didn't care. What he did was predatory, terrifying and unacceptable.' A representative of Leto has 'expressly denied' the various women's accusations reported in Air Mail, including Teilz's, which the representative said were 'demonstrably false'. Leto himself has yet to comment on the allegations. In the US, call or text the Childhelp abuse hotline on 800-422-4453 or visit their website for more resources and to report child abuse or DM for help. For adult survivors of child abuse, help is available at In the UK, the NSPCC offers support to children on 0800 1111, and adults concerned about a child on 0808 800 5000. The National Association for People Abused in Childhood (Napac) offers support for adult survivors on 0808 801 0331. In Australia, children, young adults, parents and teachers can contact the Kids Helpline on 1800 55 1800, or Bravehearts on 1800 272 831, and adult survivors can contact Blue Knot Foundation on 1300 657 380. Other sources of help can be found at Child Helplines International
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Robbie Williams goes head to head with Beyonce in pop superstars' North London derby
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) THE North London derby typically sees a clash between football rivals Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspur. But this weekend's version saw Robbie Williams go head to head with Beyonce at the clubs' home grounds. 11 Robbie played the third night of his Britpop Tour at Arsenal's Emirates Stadium Credit: 11 Beyonce played at Tottenham's stadium for her Cowboy Carter Tour Credit: Instagram The Angels hitmaker kicked off the third night of his Britpop Tour at Arsenal's Emirates Stadium last night. While just four miles away, Queen B played at Tottenham's £1.2billion stadium for her Cowboy Carter Tour. And Port Vale fan Robbie could not resist adding some rivalry at his gig on Friday night. During a singalong to Bon Jovi's Livin' On A Prayer, he told his fans: 'You won't get that at a f***ing Beyonce gig.' Robbie, who paid homage to his 1995 Glastonbury Festival look in a red stripe tracksuit, said he was 'anxious' in the run-up to his 38-date tour. He said: 'I turned to my wife [Ayda] in rehearsals and said: 'Babe, I'm anxious about this'. 11 'She said, 'Rob, you behave like this is normal, you behave like you have to do this for the rest of your life, you behave like stadiums is where you should be'. 'In that moment, it changed my perception.' But it seemed all the nerves had disappeared when Robbie was joined by Nineties boyband Five to sing their hit Keep On Movin', marking their first stage appearance in 25 years. And boyband fans were equally delighted when Lulu appeared on stage with Robbie to sing Take That's hit Relight My Fire. Is Beyonce's NFL Christmas Gameday show free to watch on Netflix or do I need to buy a Texans-Ravens pay-per-view? However, 35 years since he joined Take That as a baby-faced teen, Robbie said fans are now offering him 'Werther's Originals' instead of ripping off his clothes. He said: 'I might be in sniper's alley — but I believe I have got a lot longer on this runway to go. 'I look forward to getting even older with you and I look forward to seeing you at many shows to come, whatever size venue that is.' 11 Lulu appeared on stage with Robbie to sing Take That's hit Relight My Fire Credit: 11 Robbie was joined by Nineties boyband Five Credit: Leo Baron Robbie was joined at the gig by Ayda, with whom he shares children Teddy, Coco, Charlie and Beau. He joked: 'I remember why I do this. It is not for the glory, it is not for the money, it is because I have got four kids at home.' And Robbie could not resist impersonating his frenemy Liam Gallagher, who is set to kick off the Oasis reunion tour with Noel next month. In a rendition of Frank Sinatra's New York, New York, Robbie joked: 'You won't get this at Oasis.' I'm sure Oasis won't hold back . . . BEYONCE wasn't the only Knowles on stage in London this week. Her mum Tina was grilled at the Southbank Centre by fashion queen Stella McCartney for a special 'An Evening With' bash. Reflecting on home life with her two daughters, Tina said: 'Beyonce never wanted to go to bars. I was like, 'Go party, be wild!'. 'With Solange I did not have to do that . . . ' Stella also had a question from her Beatles legend dad, Sir Paul McCartney – although it wasn't the most imaginative: 'What's it like being a mother to Beyonce and Solange?' But Tina's answer more than made up for it. She replied: 'Wonderful, except when people chat s**t about my kids. Then I want to fight.' We wouldn't mess with her. BEYONCE'S backstage area sounds dreamy. Not only is she sent loads of Jo Malone candles, but I hear that US fast-food chain Wingstop sends her and her team unlimited buffalo wings, dripping in sauce. Yum. I'd expect nothing less for Queen Bey. And a quick thanks to Go Privilege for helping source tickets, including padded seats, to the spectacular event last night. Visit for more information. JACK AND CHLOE BACK IN BLOOM 11 Jack Fincham posed outside the Birdcage pub at Bethnal Green's Columbia Road Flower Market Credit: Instagram 11 Chloe posted from the same spot with a huge bouquet of flowers Credit: Instagram LOVE ISLANDER Jack Fincham and former Towie star Chloe Brockett are back together – after splitting for the sixth time. The reality couple broke up in April following a string of heated rows, with Jack moving out of their shared home. But I can now reveal they were spotted shopping at Swanley Market in Kent. A source said: 'Chloe and Jack have been on and off for months but have finally put their differences aside to give their relationship another chance. 'They really want to make it work so have been enjoying some low-key dates as they gradually build the trust. 'They have realised they have something special so want to put their time and energy into making it work.' Earlier this week they sparked rumours of a reunion when they shared snaps on their respective Instagrams from the same East London market. Jack posed outside the Birdcage pub at Bethnal Green's Columbia Road Flower Market on Sunday. Then Chloe posted from the same spot with a huge bouquet of flowers. Things must be coming up roses at last. PADDY IS RILEY SMITTEN 11 Paddy McGuinness has admitted he has a secret celebrity crush Credit: PA NEWLY divorced Paddy McGuinness has admitted he has a secret celebrity crush. The comedian, who has split from ex Christine, confessed on Celebrity Gogglebox to pal Vernon Kay that he fancies Countdown star Rachel Riley. He said: 'There's something about Rachel Riley. I don't know what it is. 'You know when you have, like, a celebrity crush that you're not supposed to have?' Her husband Pasha Kovalev might have something to say about that, Paddy . . . SHAGGY: 'I TRUST NO ONE' 11 Shaggy admits that he is always suspicious of people Credit: Getty IT'S been 30 years since Shaggy topped the charts with pop hit Mr Boombastic – and the reggae legend is still going strong. But speaking as he supports Pitbull on his UK tour, the American-Jamaican star admitted that he is always suspicious of people. He said: 'The biggest lesson I've learned is to trust no one. Everyone has an angle or a motive. Everyone has an agenda. Make sure if you're the brand then you are the agenda. 'You trust people, but there comes a point where you do some inventory and realise people weren't there to help you – they were in it for themselves. 'A lot of it is ego or jealousy. People look at you and think it comes easy but they don't realise the amount of work that has gone into it. 'People feel like they should be in your shoes, they feel like they should be you. But the truth is they can't carry the candle at all.' Noted, Shaggy. RITA EARNS HER STRIPES AT PRIDE 11 Rita Ora flaunts her figure in a leopard-print bra and striped hotpants RITA ORA got her groove on as she danced at the World Pride festival in Washington DC on Friday night. The singer, who dropped her new summer anthem Heat this week, flaunted her figure in a leopard-print bra and striped hotpants as she performed on stage at the LGBTQ celebration. Sharing snaps on Insta, she wrote: 'Pride baby! I love you!' We love you too, Rita. SCOOTER'S RACH SPLIT 11 Music exec Scooter Braun has split from his girlfriend Credit: Getty IT looks like Taylor Swift's nemesis has been dealt another blow. I can reveal that music executive Scooter Braun has split from his girlfriend, Canadian actress Rachelle Goulding. A source revealed: 'Scooter and Rachelle have quietly split after they were first linked last year. 'He has recently been spotted on celebrity dating app Raya after their romance fizzled out.' The couple were first linked in July 2024 after they were said to have enjoyed dates in California – including at the Stagecoach country music festival. Taylor's feud with Scooter started in 2019 when her former label, Big Machine, sold the masters of her first six albums to him without telling her. He later sold them on to Shamrock Holdings. But last month Taylor announced that she finally controls all her music after finally buying them all back. The Lover hitmaker confirmed she has bought the rights back to all six albums for a fee thought to be in the hundreds of millions. MOLLIE KING has opened up about how she and fiancé Stuart Broad juggle work and raising two young children, saying they are like a 'tag team'. The former Saturdays singer, who is back hosting on Radio 1 after maternity leave, shares daughters Annabella, two, and Liliana, five months, with the England cricket legend. She said: 'Stuart has moved from playing cricket into commentating. He still goes away for long stints. 'But we basically juggle it between the two of us. We are a bit of a tag team. 'He works most weekends and I work Monday to Thursday so it is a bit 'one in, one out', but we are making it work.' SHE'S no longer filming Love Island USA's Aftersun spin-off show, but I hear Maura Higgins has landed another exciting reality gig that will give her plenty of Stateside stature. The Irish beauty is set to head to Scotland to film the US Traitors, hosted by Scot actor Alan Cumming. It's not the first time a Love Islander from the UK has taken part in the American version of Traitors, after Ekin-Su Culculoglu was cast last year. A source said: 'Maura has been inundated with telly offers and she is very tempted by this big-money deal to film Traitors. 'She's a massive fan of the show and thinks it would be an amazing opportunity to introduce herself to US audiences and opportunities.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Somber Ben Affleck dines solo at pricey steakhouse after Jennifer Lopez locks lips with A-lister on film set
Ben Affleck looked deep in thought after enjoying a meal in Beverly Hills on Friday night. The Accountant 2 star, 52, was spotted exiting the high-end eatery Steak 48, one day after ex-wife Jennifer Lopez was seen in a lip-lock with Diego Luna in the sexy trailer for her new film Kiss of the Spider Woman, on which he serves as a producer. The Oscar winner looked relaxed, wearing a thick gray sweater over a blue button-down shirt and dark jeans tucked into his beige ankle boots. His dark hair and beard were closely trimmed as he made his way to the valet station to get his car. On Saturday morning, the Air star was up early, taking his German Shepherd for a walk. Affleck adopted him as a security dog in January amid safety concerns following the destruction of the Los Angeles fires. The pooch was well-behaved enough to be off-leash as they took their morning exercise. To keep warm in the chilly morning air, the Deep Water star wore a similar gray sweater over a T-shirt with a black jacket. He donned faded jeans, which he tucked into his beige ankle boots and carried one of his favorite coffee drinks. Affleck and his friend, business partner and fellow Oscar winner Matt Damon, 54, have teamed up again for the upcoming thriller The Rip. The two will star are Miami police officers in the crime drama The Rip for Netflix. Damon and Affleck are producing project, based on the experiences of real cop, through their Artists Equity studio, which they founded in 2022. The pair promoted their film, which was scheduled to debut on January 16, 2026 in a sweet spot with Cookie Monster, who along with his friends on Sesame Street, have joined the screening service. The two are wearing blue windbreakers with Police written on them when they burst through a door. 'Drop it,' Affleck says, holding a flashlight. 'Miami PD. Put your hands in the air,' commands Damon as Cookie Monster blissfully munches on his favorite food. 'Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa whoa! Me only got cookies here,' he told the officers. 'Oh, sorry Cookie Monster' Affleck apologized. 'Cookie Monster, love your work,' said Damon, appeasing the Muppet. 'We're big fans of your work,' the Town star added. 'Yeah, you know Ben Affleck, Matt Damon, you like the cookies and milk of actors.' The pair thanked him for his compliment and asked if they could grab a cookie on their way out. As they exited, Damon grumbled under his breath, 'I can't believe he's got a nicer dressing room than we do.'
