Govt report biased, argue Ambazari residents, demand removal of Vivekanand statue
2
Nagpur: Petitioners in a PIL concerning the Ambazari flood disaster have challenged a report submitted by the Central Water and Power Research Station (CWPRS), Pune. They accused the report of legitimizing the unauthorized construction of Swami Vivekananda statue in the spill channel of Ambazari dam.
In a new affidavit filed before the Nagpur bench of Bombay high court, 91-year-old Ramgopal Bachuka and a group of senior citizens alleged that the CWPRS report was commissioned by Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC), which is under scrutiny for regulatory violations. The affidavit is part of a PIL seeking accountability for the flood on September 2023 that caused extensive damage.
"The CWPRS study cannot override legislative provisions, including the Irrigation Act and Wetland Rules, under which the statue's location is in a prohibited area," petitioners argued through counsel Tushar Mandlekar.
"The report is designed to justify an illegal structure rather than evaluate the flood dynamics accurately."
They objected to the minutes of the High Power Committee (HPC) meeting held on April 29, which accepted the CWPRS report and declined to consider relocating the statue. The HPC, they contended, failed to address key concerns, including prior affidavits by departments such as irrigation and urban development, which acknowledged the illegality of the site.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
It's Affordable and Actually Works
www.telidesk.com
Undo
The petitioners also noted that the CWPRS admitted to discrepancies in its data sets but proceeded to prepare simulations using a peak flood discharge of only 116.10 cumecs — the design standard for a 1-in-100-year flood. In contrast, the Ambazari dam is built to handle a discharge of 320 cumecs, or a 1-in-1,000-year event, according to the National Institute of Hydrology.
They alleged that the statue and associated amenities — including a pedestal, library, and public seating — obstruct the dam's tail channel, reducing water-carrying capacity and creating a bottleneck that contributed to flooding in the city.
Citing a 2024 affidavit from the principal secretary of the urban development department, the petitioners reiterated that the statue lies in a zone where development is restricted by govt resolutions issued on August 2, 2013 and March 8, 2018.
They also submitted reports from Hitbhav Engineers, and the Command Area Development Authority, which showed the tail channel's width had been reduced due to construction, aggravating flood risks at the confluence of the Nag and Pili rivers.
The petitioners have urged the court to reject the CWPRS report and direct authorities to restore the Nag River's natural flow by removing obstructions. The next hearing is scheduled for July 9.
BOX
Challenge To CWPRS Ambazari Flood Study
#Core Arguments:
CWPRS flood study termed a 'sham report'
Petitioners say it was influenced by NMC
HPC meeting failed to consider statutory violations
#Technical Disputes:
Dam discharge capacity: 320 cumecs
CWPRS simulation: 116 cumecs
Tail channel narrowed by statue platform, creating bottleneck
#Legal Grounds:
2013 & 2018 GRs prohibit any construction at site
Principal secretary's 2024 affidavit admits location is a 'prohibited area'
#Demand:
Court must reject report and restore Nag River's natural flow
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
5 days ago
- Time of India
Vidhan Bhavan Extension Gets In-Principle Nod Of Heritage Panel
Nagpur: The heritage conservation committee granted in-principle approval on Wednesday for the long-awaited expansion of Vidhan Bhavan, Nagpur — a significant step towards modernising the state legislature's Nagpur seat. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Under the plan, Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) will hand over approximately 2,000 sq m of its land to the state government. The panel also directed the civic body to coordinate with the Zero Mile redevelopment team to identify alternative land for parking arrangements. The Maharashtra State Infrastructure Development Corporation (MSIDC) will execute the expansion plan. Executive engineer of MSIDC N V Borkar, in a letter dated July 18, 2025, informed the NMC about a detailed presentation on the proposed construction at Vidhan Bhavan, Nagpur. According to the government-approved heritage list, the site named "Vidhan Sabha, Nagpur" appears at serial number 15 and is listed under Grade I. The ownership of the heritage site rests with the government of Maharashtra. The meeting, chaired by former divisional commissioner Anoop Kumar, with NMC chief engineer Manoj Talewar as member secretary, also paved the way for the removal of illegal constructions along the historical Jumma Darwaza, popularly known as Gandhi Gate. Gandhibagh zone's assistant municipal commissioner, Ganesh Rathore, will be tasked with removing illegal structures abutting the iconic Jumma Darwaza. The Grade I listed gateway has faced repeated encroachments despite its status as a protected heritage asset. Equally historic was the panel's green light to the Nagpur Improvement Trust's ₹6.70 crore project to restore and beautify the neglected resting place of Gond King Bakht Buland Shah, the 18th-century founder of Nagpur, in Sakkardara. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The Grade I heritage site, which also houses the graves of 27 royal family members, had languished in decay for decades. The revival plan promises structural restoration, landscaping, and amenities befitting its historical stature, more than three centuries after the king laid the city's foundations. The meeting also considered proposals to display historical information at the Zero Mile monument to increase public awareness, to host the 2025 Mahamarathon at the Grade II listed Kasturchand Park, and to organise Garba events there. The heritage committee, comprising experts, archaeologists, civic engineers, and representatives from INTACH and the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), stressed that heritage development and urban expansion must move in tandem, with strict enforcement against encroachments and sensitive planning for public infrastructure.
Time of India
5 days ago
- Time of India
HC warns Nagpur officials of legal action on stray dog menace
Nagpur: The Nagpur bench of Bombay High Court issued a stern warning to civic and police officials over persistent stray dog menace, declaring it will now hold "every responsible officer from top to bottom personally liable for failures in enforcement". During Wednesday's hearing of a public interest litigation (PIL) filed by activist Vijay Talewar, the bench of Justice Anil Kilor and Justice Vrushali Joshi said for over two decades, the court was passing orders on this issue without tangible results. "We will not keep issuing reminders. If there is failure in implementation, legal action will follow," the court observed. The bench ordered Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) to submit a complete list of all officers responsible for stray dog control, stating notices will be sent to each of them. "They will be given an opportunity to respond, and accountability will be fixed individually," the court said. The petitioner's counsel, senior advocate Firdos Mirza, argued that slapping notices on municipal commissioners have proved ineffective. "Every officer in the chain needs to be made answerable," he told the court. The judges referred to earlier directions that police issue notifications under Section 44 of the Maharashtra Police Act, and NMC take action against those feeding stray dogs in public spaces — both of which, they noted, were not complied with. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like The T-shirt you've been waiting for—comfort and style in one lininco Undo Mirza sought contempt proceedings against the municipal and police commissioners, but the court noted that in earlier cases, unconditional apologies shielded them from consequences. "This time, once notices are served, action will follow," the bench warned. The court even hinted at possible contempt proceedings against the state's principal secretary (urban development) if failures persist, emphasising the matter will not be closed without "something concrete" being achieved. The next hearing is scheduled next week, with liberty granted to the petitioner's counsel to submit further recommendations for effective implementation. "This will be your last complaint," the bench told Talewar, signalling its intent to end decades of inaction. # Key Observations (Oral) by the Nagpur Bench of Bombay High Court 20 years of court orders on stray dog control failed to yield results All responsible officers, from top to bottom, will now be held personally accountable NMC must submit a list of every officer involved in implementation Notices will be issued individually, with an opportunity for response before action Orders under Section 44 of Maharashtra Police Act remain unimplemented Civic body yet to act against those feeding stray dogs in public spaces Prior unconditional apologies allowed officials to avoid consequences. Contempt action may be taken against principal secretary (urban development) if lapses persist Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Indian Express
6 days ago
- Indian Express
Respect food habit, diversity, says Ajit Pawar after 3 civic bodies ban meat sale on Aug 15
Hours after the Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) on Tuesday announced that all slaughterhouses and meat shops within city limits would remain closed on August 15 on the occasion of Independence Day and Janmashtami, Deputy Chief Minister Ajit Pawar on Tuesday admonished the decision taken by some civic bodies that also invited severe criticism from the Opposition. The civic bodies of Kalyan Dombivli, Nagpur and Malegaon have issued an order for closure of all slaughterhouses and meat shops in their jurisdictions for 24 hours on August 15. The Kalyan-Dombivli Municipal Corporation (KDMC) had issued the order on Monday. Deputy CM Ajit Pawar, also the president of ruling ally Nationalist Congress Party, disapproved the decision and said, 'It is an individual's choice what one should eat or not eat. Nobody has the right to impose the decision. There are some people who are vegetarians and others who are non-vegetarians. It is part of an individual's habit, culture and inheritance and geographical conditions.' 'While it is important to keep public sentiments and faith in mind on certain religious occasions such as Ashadi Ekadhasi or Mahavir Jayanti…, there is no reason why there should be a ban on meat and non-vegetarian food on Maharashtra Day, Independence Day or Republic Day,' Pawar said. Pointing out that in rural Maharashtra, people indulge in non-vegetarian delicacies during celebrations, Pawar said, 'If we look at the coastal Konkan region, people mostly eat seafood. The tribals are used to non-vegetarian food. The food habit and diversity has to be respected.' He also assured that he would take up the matter within the government. Later in the day, following hue and cry from Opposition and alliance partners, the ruling BJP issued a statement saying the decision was not new and has been a part of the administration since 1988. 'Some municipal corporations across Maharashtra have ordered the closure of slaughterhouses and meat shops in its jurisdiction for 24 hours on August 15, Independence Day. This is not a new decision. It was taken way back on May 12, 1988. It has been in practice since then. Every year an individual civic body takes a call,' said the BJP in its statement. While a senior BJP leader said it was a 'foolish decision' and wondered 'whose idea was it', Maharashtra BJP Media cell incharge Navnath Ban said, ' The decision to keep slaughterhouses and meat shops closed on some important days such as Independence Day, Gandhi Jayanti, Mahavir Jayanti, Ram Navmi, etc. was taken by the then government in 1988. Since then some civic bodies follow it.' According to the BJP spokesperson, 'Even during the rule of Maha Vikas Aghadi when Uddhav Thackeray was the CM, such a decision was implemented. The Nagpur Municipal Corporation, which was under state administrator, had enforced the ban on slaughterhouses and meat shops in 2021 and 2022.' Criticising the move, Opposition NCP (SP)'s Jitendra Awhad questioned why residents were being told what to eat on Independence Day, while Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Aaditya Thackeray demanded the suspension of KDMC commissioner. 'Who is the commissioner to tell us what to eat and what not to? Bridges are collapsing, roads are in terrible shape, and instead of fixing them, the administration is busy banning food,' Thackeray said.
