Toxic Thailand rivers pinned on Myanmar mines
A sprawling new mine is gouged into the lush rolling hills of northeast Myanmar, where civil war has weakened the government's already feeble writ, and pollution levels are rising downstream in Thailand.
The complex is one of around a dozen extraction operations that have sprung up in Shan state since around 2022, in territory controlled by the United Wa State Army (UWSA), one of conflict-wracked Myanmar's largest and best-equipped ethnic armed groups.
A few kilometres away across the border, locals and officials in Thailand believe toxic waste is washing downstream from the mines into the Kok River, which flows through the kingdom's far north on its way to join the mighty Mekong.
Thai authorities say they have detected abnormally high arsenic levels in their waterways, which could pose a risk to aquatic life and the people further up the food chain.
The price fisherman Sawat Kaewdam gets for his catch has fallen by almost half, he says, because locals fear contamination.
"They say, 'There's arsenic. I don't want to eat that fish'," he told AFP.
Tests in Chiang Mai and Chiang Rai by a government pollution agency found levels of the toxic element as high as 49 microgrammes per litre (mcg/l) of river water -- nearly five times international drinking water standards.
Experts say that while the effects on human health would not be visible immediately, the fish-heavy local diet risks a cumulative impact over several years.
"We already know where the contamination is coming from," says fisherman Sawat.
"They should go fix it at the source."
- Fivefold rise -
Pianporn Deetes, campaign director of the International Rivers NGO, blames the arsenic levels on Shan state's unlicensed mines, which operate outside any regulation or control by the central government.
It was Thailand's "largest-ever case of transboundary pollution", she added.
The mines are believed to be run by Chinese companies with close links to the UWSA, whose members themselves have longstanding ties to China, speak Mandarin and use China's yuan currency.
It is unclear whether the mines are digging for gold, rare earths or a variety of minerals, and it is also difficult to gauge the size of an industry operating in a secretive grey zone.
But videos on Chinese social media suggest much of what is produced in Myanmar ends up being sold to Chinese buyers.
In a report Tuesday citing Chinese customs data, think tank ISP-Myanmar said the country was the source of around two-thirds of China's rare earth imports by value.
The Asian giant had imported five times as much rare earths from Myanmar in the four years since the 2021 military coup than in the equivalent preceding period, it added.
Many modern mines use a system of tailing ponds to reuse leftover waste and water and stop it being released into rivers, said Tanapon Phenrat of Naresuan University's civil engineering department.
But "in Myanmar, they reportedly discharge it directly into natural waterways", he added, increasing the risk of contamination spreading into the food chain.
"What we need is for mines to treat their waste properly and stop discharging toxic substances into shared waterways."
AFP was unable to reach UWSA officials for comment.
- 'Legal and orderly' -
From its Myanmar headwaters, the 285-kilometre (177-mile) Kok River is a vital resource for thousands of people as it wends through Chiang Rai province on its way to feed the Mekong.
In Chiang Rai City, a tranquil place popular with tourists, environmentalists dressed as wart-afflicted fish dance in protest.
The Thai government has proposed building a dam to prevent contaminated water from entering the country, but campaigners say physical barriers alone cannot stop pollution.
Bangkok acknowledges that Myanmar's junta may be unable to stop Chinese companies operating mines in militia-controlled areas.
And Chonthicha Jangrew of Thailand's parliamentary foreign affairs committee met senior Beijing officials last month, urging them to supervise Chinese mining firms "in order to stop the impact on people downstream", she said.
The Chinese embassy in Bangkok posted on Facebook Sunday that it had instructed Chinese companies "to comply with the laws of the host country and to conduct their business in a legal and orderly fashion at all times".
The Myanmar junta did not respond to questions from AFP.
"But this is a clear signal," he added. "We need to act now."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
a day ago
- News.com.au
Toxic Thailand rivers pinned on Myanmar mines
A sprawling new mine is gouged into the lush rolling hills of northeast Myanmar, where civil war has weakened the government's already feeble writ, and pollution levels are rising downstream in Thailand. The complex is one of around a dozen extraction operations that have sprung up in Shan state since around 2022, in territory controlled by the United Wa State Army (UWSA), one of conflict-wracked Myanmar's largest and best-equipped ethnic armed groups. A few kilometres away across the border, locals and officials in Thailand believe toxic waste is washing downstream from the mines into the Kok River, which flows through the kingdom's far north on its way to join the mighty Mekong. Thai authorities say they have detected abnormally high arsenic levels in their waterways, which could pose a risk to aquatic life and the people further up the food chain. The price fisherman Sawat Kaewdam gets for his catch has fallen by almost half, he says, because locals fear contamination. "They say, 'There's arsenic. I don't want to eat that fish'," he told AFP. Tests in Chiang Mai and Chiang Rai by a government pollution agency found levels of the toxic element as high as 49 microgrammes per litre (mcg/l) of river water -- nearly five times international drinking water standards. Experts say that while the effects on human health would not be visible immediately, the fish-heavy local diet risks a cumulative impact over several years. "We already know where the contamination is coming from," says fisherman Sawat. "They should go fix it at the source." - Fivefold rise - Pianporn Deetes, campaign director of the International Rivers NGO, blames the arsenic levels on Shan state's unlicensed mines, which operate outside any regulation or control by the central government. It was Thailand's "largest-ever case of transboundary pollution", she added. The mines are believed to be run by Chinese companies with close links to the UWSA, whose members themselves have longstanding ties to China, speak Mandarin and use China's yuan currency. It is unclear whether the mines are digging for gold, rare earths or a variety of minerals, and it is also difficult to gauge the size of an industry operating in a secretive grey zone. But videos on Chinese social media suggest much of what is produced in Myanmar ends up being sold to Chinese buyers. In a report Tuesday citing Chinese customs data, think tank ISP-Myanmar said the country was the source of around two-thirds of China's rare earth imports by value. The Asian giant had imported five times as much rare earths from Myanmar in the four years since the 2021 military coup than in the equivalent preceding period, it added. Many modern mines use a system of tailing ponds to reuse leftover waste and water and stop it being released into rivers, said Tanapon Phenrat of Naresuan University's civil engineering department. But "in Myanmar, they reportedly discharge it directly into natural waterways", he added, increasing the risk of contamination spreading into the food chain. "What we need is for mines to treat their waste properly and stop discharging toxic substances into shared waterways." AFP was unable to reach UWSA officials for comment. - 'Legal and orderly' - From its Myanmar headwaters, the 285-kilometre (177-mile) Kok River is a vital resource for thousands of people as it wends through Chiang Rai province on its way to feed the Mekong. In Chiang Rai City, a tranquil place popular with tourists, environmentalists dressed as wart-afflicted fish dance in protest. The Thai government has proposed building a dam to prevent contaminated water from entering the country, but campaigners say physical barriers alone cannot stop pollution. Bangkok acknowledges that Myanmar's junta may be unable to stop Chinese companies operating mines in militia-controlled areas. And Chonthicha Jangrew of Thailand's parliamentary foreign affairs committee met senior Beijing officials last month, urging them to supervise Chinese mining firms "in order to stop the impact on people downstream", she said. The Chinese embassy in Bangkok posted on Facebook Sunday that it had instructed Chinese companies "to comply with the laws of the host country and to conduct their business in a legal and orderly fashion at all times". The Myanmar junta did not respond to questions from AFP. "But this is a clear signal," he added. "We need to act now."
ABC News
2 days ago
- ABC News
Mount Isa copper smelter's planned closure prompts fears production will move overseas
What would Queensland's "Stack City" be without its smoking stack? By 2030, the outback city of Mount Isa will find out. The famous candy-cane-striped copper smelter, or stack, gave the mining town of more than 18,000 residents its nickname. Swiss multinational Glencore has set a five-year deadline for its closure. However, if it is unable to receive government support to rebrick the smelter in 2026, that date could be brought forward. It comes after the mining giant announced it would shut the historic Mount Isa copper mine, which will finalise production next month. With the smelter and its closure date looming over Mount Isa's skyline, industry experts fear Australia's domestic copper production could be pushed to the brink. North West Queensland is one of the most mineral-rich regions in the world, and copper is arguably the star in the soil. The critical mineral is one of the most in-demand commodities in the world. Australia has two copper smelters, and Mount Isa's unique all-in-one facility comprising a mine, smelter and concentrator is a major investor drawcard. Copper from all over Queensland, New South Wales and South Australia is sent to the Mount Isa smelter. Mining analyst Gavin Wendt said that without the Mount Isa smelter, Australia's domestic copper processing industry could be headed offshore. "[The smelter] has potentially decades of life ahead of it, but it needs significant investment now," he said. Mr Wendt said another copper-producing country, such as China or the United States, would respond differently to a smelter closure of this magnitude. For example, China's government heavily subsidised its smelters, giving the country the upper hand, he said. "If we allow facilities like this to shut down across the Western world, it reinforces China's strategy, which is to subsidise its own infrastructure, subsidise its own production, to undercut Western-world production so that it closes, and then eventually China will raise the price of its products. "We will be paying more and [China] will be in a position of market dominance." Queensland Premier David Crisafulli told the ABC last week that losing the Mount Isa smelter would remove a major national capability. "There's a sovereign risk with not having that," he said. "Particularly how important copper is at the moment for some of the things we're looking to do, including in the renewable space." Mr Crisafulli said the closure would raise doubts about the future of surrounding mines that relied on the smelter's gas and would make the region a less attractive site for new mines. Queensland Minister for Natural Resources and Mines Dale Last said the government was working towards a solution. "I'm working collaboratively and urgently with Glencore on a path forward," he said. "We are working through several options to support its continued operations." Glencore interim chief operating officer Troy Wilson said the company's smelter could not survive in the international market without government help. The amount of bailout money the company has requested from state and federal governments has not been confirmed. However, it has acknowledged other industrial bailouts, including Whyalla Steelworks's $2.4 billion package in February this year. Independent corporate analyst and previous Mount Isa Mine worker Peter Strachan said a local smelter was a strategic asset and was irreplaceable in today's market. "To build a new smelter in Australia somewhere now would be a huge job from an environmental-permitting [and] land-rights point of view," Mr Strachan said. Even if approved, he said a replacement smelter would cost about $1.5 billion. "You can't replace those realistically in Australia," he said. Mr Strachan said the mineralisation from surrounding copper mines, including Ernest Henry and Duchess Copper Gold Project, could provide enough copper to keep the smelter working for the next 15 years. "But it really relies on being able to maintain those assets in a way that works economically and to ensure that the project keeps going," he said. Mr Strachan said the solution could come from mining companies with big pockets, but also governments and junior mining companies working together. "There needs to be a multi-party deal that includes the smaller miners who say they've got mineralisation in the ground, it's ready to dig, and there needs to be some sort of deal worked out to enable everyone to move forward in unison," he said.
News.com.au
2 days ago
- News.com.au
Indonesia revokes most mining permits in dive hotspot after outcry
Indonesia revoked permits on Tuesday for four of the five mining companies operating in the eastern archipelago of Raja Ampat after activists shared videos of islands damaged by nickel extraction. The cluster of islands and shoals in Southwest Papua Province sits in the Coral Triangle and is thought to be one of the world's most pristine reefs, with its clear blue waters making it a popular diving spot. Indonesia has the world's largest nickel reserves and is the biggest producer of the metal, which is used in electric vehicle batteries and stainless steel, and a 2020 export ban has spurred a domestic industrial boom. Last week, Greenpeace Indonesia published videos showing environmental damage to three islands because of nickel mining projects, including one clip which racked up more than 15 million Instagram views. President Prabowo Subianto "decided that the government will revoke the mining business licence of four companies in Raja Ampat", state secretariat minister Prasetyo Hadi told reporters. Energy and mineral resources minister Bahlil Lahadalia said "they have violated" regulations. "We believe this region must be protected," he said. Greenpeace said nickel exploitation on the islands of Gag, Kawe and Manuran had led to the destruction of more than 500 hectares (1,200 acres) of forest and vegetation. Environmentalists say coral reefs and marine life are threatened by the operations, but Bahlil denied the surrounding environment had been harmed. "If people say the coral reefs and the ocean have been damaged, you can see for yourself. Please be careful to differentiate which one is real and which one is not," he said. - 'Make sure they stop' - The NGO's campaign led to growing calls by politicians and celebrities for the licences to be withdrawn. The four companies impacted by the immediate ban are PT Anugerah Surya Pratama, PT Nurham, PT Kawei Sejahtera Mining and PT Mulia Raymond Perkasa. PT Nurham received its mining permits this year and has not started production but the other three have had them since 2013, according to the energy ministry. One more company -- PT Gag Nikel -- will continue to operate on Raja Ampat's Gag island but be closely monitored, said Bahlil. It received its operational permit in 2017. The three affected islands are categorised as small islands that under Indonesian law should be off-limits to mining, Greenpeace said. Greenpeace Indonesia said the decision was a good start but the government needed to take further action. "We appreciate this decision but we need to make sure the decision will be implemented. We need to make sure they stop," forest campaign team leader Arie Rompas said. He warned the government could reissue the permits later or the companies could appeal the decision in court. The activist said the government should also revoke the operating permit for the fifth company. A report last week by Climate Rights International alleged the Indonesian government was allowing environmental damage and violations against Indigenous people to go unchecked by nickel mining firms in the eastern Maluku islands. Processing and mining operations have grown there around Weda Bay, the world's largest nickel mine by production, but have led to locals reporting a spike in air pollution from smelters and rivers polluted by nickel tailings in soil carried by rain. An AFP report last month detailed how the home of the nomadic Hongana Manyawa tribe was being eaten away by that mine, with members issuing a call for nickel companies to leave their tribal lands alone.
