Conspiracy theorist reprimanded by coroner at inquest into daughter's death
Paloma Shemirani, 23, died at Royal Sussex County Hospital in Brighton on July 24, 2024 after declining the treatment for non-Hodgkin lymphoma.
She grew up in Uckfield and attended Roedean School for sixth form.
Her mother, Kay 'Kate' Shemirani, rose to prominence on social media while sharing Covid-19 conspiracy theories, the inquest at Oakwood House in Maidstone, Kent, heard previously.
In written statements submitted to the family division of the High Court in Spring 2024, Paloma said she declined chemotherapy partly because of her 'background in natural healing', the inquest heard on Monday.
The proceedings, which involved the Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust, were on the appropriateness of her care and Paloma said she was 'delighted' with her alternative treatment and 'sure' she would 'make a full recovery' if left to continue it, the inquest was told.
She also claimed her human rights had been violated by NHS practitioners in the statements, which were read by lawyer Alison Hewitt.
Ms Shemirani, who attended the inquest via video link, wept and held pictures of Paloma to the camera as they were read.
It said: 'I am far from being a vulnerable young adult. Apart from becoming independent after I moved to Cambridge for university, I have practised the same principles that I grew up with.
'I have always been extremely health conscious: sticking to all-organic produce, I prepare all my own meals and I absolutely do not drink or cook with tap water.
'I have never taken drugs, despite pressure to, and I rarely drink alcohol.
'If I became ill, I've always turned to my mum first for advice as she is a trained nurse and qualified nutritionist.
'Practically fanatical about my health, my close friends know me as a staunch advocate for all proven natural healing'.
Gabriel Shemirani, outside Oakwood House in Maidstone, Kent, for the inquest into the death of his sister (Image: PA) She also described her mother as 'an extremely forceful advocate for natural health' who is 'misquoted' by people claiming 'those natural solutions are conspiratorial'.
Ms Shemirani was struck off as a nurse in 2021, with a Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) committee finding that she had spread Covid-19 misinformation that 'put the public at a significant risk of harm', the inquest heard previously.
Another statement in Paloma's name added 'my friends know me as a staunch advocate of the Gerson therapy' and she stated that she is 'anti-vax'.
She said she had been using Gerson therapy as one mode of treatment on the advice of her mother's ex-fiancé, Doctor Patrick Villers, and that at 15 years old she spent three weeks in his camp in Mexico where it was practised.
Gerson therapy involves a strict organic vegetarian diet and enemas and has been used in cancer treatment, though Cancer Research UK says that there is no scientific evidence it can be used as a treatment for cancer.
Her GP was also monitoring her blood and progress, she said.
The former Cambridge student went on to deny having the disease and said 'I was not diagnosed with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma… I have never had a shadow on my lung, this is absurd fantasy, no proof'.
She described the diagnosis as 'suspected and unconfirmed', and said a 'differential diagnosis' only meant cancer could not be ruled out.
Paloma understood that she had a one in five chance of surviving the commonplace R-CHOP treatment that was offered, and feared it would likely make her infertile, the inquest heard.
'I do not want to undergo such a harsh treatment that could even kill me when there is a possibility this is not cancer', she said.
The High Court statement alleged multiple violations of human rights in her care, the inquest heard, including Articles 3, 6 and 8 and possibly Articles 1, 5 and 12.
'I am so shocked, as are others assisting me, especially my mother, that this could take place today', the statement said.
'These were put in place forever to prevent what Dr Mengele did in the Second World War. How could this happen today?', it continued.
Notorious Nazi doctor Josef Mengele performed experiments on his victims in Auschwitz.
The patient said symptoms she presented in hospital with – including a swollen face, excruciating chest pain and being unable to move her arm – had subsided.
Coroner Catherine Wood reprimanded Ms Shemirani multiple times during proceedings.
Ms Shemirani cross-examined Dr Amit Goel, a consultant histopathologist at Maidstone Hospital who carried out a biopsy.
She repeatedly put to him that insufficient tissue was taken to carry out a FISH test that could rule out other diseases and alter Paloma's treatment plan.
The doctor denied that this would have influenced Paloma's care multiple times, and the coroner told Ms Shemirani the inquest is trying to look at 'how Paloma came about her death' but 'you are apparently trying to get information which is incorrect, factually incorrect, in the statements you are making'.
'I think your questions are just designed to take up time and delay matters by the way you're asking them repeatedly,' she added.
The mother accused participants of mis-pronouncing her name, which eventually led Ms Wood to say: 'I am going to rise, for Ms Shemirani to reflect on her behaviour in court, this is unacceptable.
'Let's have a pause for tempers to die down because you are clearly becoming over-fixated on a detail.'
At the opening of the hearing Ms Shemirani made an application for a lawyer to recuse herself.
The coroner rejected the application and said had seen the 'hundreds of emails that have been sent in' and that 'you have requested that everybody recuse themselves at various times', including the coroner herself.
The inquest continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
7 hours ago
- The Hill
Fewer kindergarteners are being vaccinated, CDC data show
Vaccinations among kindergarteners declined during the 2024-25 school year compared to the year before, according to new data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Rates dipped to 92.1 percent for the diphtheria, tetanus, and acellular pertussis vaccine (DTaP) and to 92.5 percent for the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine (MMR) and polio vaccine, the data show. The drop in vaccination coverage comes as the U.S. grapples with rising cases of the measles—one of the most contagious diseases in the world. There have been 29 outbreaks of the virus this year, resulting in more than 1,330 confirmed measles cases across 40 states, according to the latest CDC numbers. Herd immunity against measles requires roughly 95 percent of the population to be vaccinated against the disease, according to the World Health Organization. Vaccine coverage decreased in more than half of states during the last school year compared to the year before, with about 286,000 kindergartners attending school without documentation showing they completed the MMR vaccine series. Vaccine exemptions for one or more vaccines have also gone up, with a total of 138,000 kindergarteners exempt from a vaccine in the last school year. The number of exemptions rose to 3.6 percent during the 2024-25 school year from 3.3 percent the year before. Exemptions increased in 36 states and Washington D.C. with 17 states now reporting an exemption rate of more than 5 percent, the data show. The Trump administration has shaken up the country's federal vaccine policy, sparking concerns among the medical community about the future of vaccine access. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, who has a long history of vaccine skepticism, has changed the process for vaccine recommendations as well as who is eligible for COVID-19 vaccines. 'The decision to vaccinate is a personal one,' a spokesperson for the Department of Health and Human Services told The Hill. 'Parents should consult their health care providers on options for their families.' The spokesperson added that vaccination remains the most effective way to protect children from serious diseases like measles and whooping cough which can lead to hospitalization and death.
Chicago Tribune
7 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Vaccination rates of children in US fall again
U.S. kindergarten vaccination rates inched down again last year and the share of children with exemptions rose to an all-time high, according to federal data posted Thursday. The fraction of kids exempted from vaccine requirements rose to 4.1%, up from 3.7% the year before. It's the third record-breaking year in a row for the exemption rate, and the vast majority are parents withholding shots for nonmedical reasons. Meanwhile, 92.5% of 2024-25 kindergartners got their required measles-mumps-rubella shots, down slightly from the previous year. Before the COVID-19 pandemic, the vaccination rate was 95% — the level that makes it unlikely that a single infection will spark a disease cluster or outbreak. The vaccination numbers were posted as the U.S. experiences its worst year for measles spread in more than three decades, with more than 1,300 cases so far. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention traditionally releases the vaccination coverage data in its flagship publication, the Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. CDC officials usually speak to the trends and possible explanations, and stress the importance of vaccinations. This year, the agency quietly posted the data online and — when asked about it — emailed a statement. 'The decision to vaccinate is a personal one. Parents should consult their health care providers on options for their families,' the statement said, adding; 'Vaccination remains the most effective way to protect children from serious diseases like measles and whooping cough, which can lead to hospitalization and long-term health complications.' Public health officials focus on vaccination rates for kindergartners because schools can be cauldrons for germs and launching pads for community outbreaks. For years, those rates were high, thanks largely to school attendance mandates that required key vaccinations. All U.S. states and territories require that children attending child care centers and schools be vaccinated against a number of diseases, including, measles, mumps, polio, tetanus, whooping cough and chickenpox. All states allow exemptions for children with medical conditions that prevent them from receiving certain vaccines. And most also permit exemptions for religious or other nonmedical reasons. In the last decade, the percentage of kindergartners with medical exemptions has held steady, at about 0.2%. But the percentage with nonmedical exemptions has risen. The rates can be influenced by policies that make it harder or easier to obtain exemptions, and by local attitudes among families and doctors about the need to get children vaccinated. Online misinformation and the political divide that emerged around COVID-19 vaccines have led more parents to question routine childhood vaccinations, experts say. According to the CDC data, 15.4% of kindergartners had an exemption to one or more vaccines in Idaho in the last school year. But fewer than 0.5% did in Connecticut.
8 hours ago
Members of CDC vaccine panel ousted by RFK Jr. say committee has 'lost credibility'
The members of a federal vaccine advisory committee, who were removed by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., are suggesting alternatives to vaccine policy in the U.S. because the panel has "lost credibility." In early June, Kennedy dismissed all 17 sitting members of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), which advises the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) on vaccine recommendations. Kennedy replaced the group with his own, hand-selected members, many of whom had expressed skeptical views on vaccines. Since then, the committee has recommended against flu vaccines containing thimerosal -- a preservative that has been falsely linked to autism -- has said the childhood immunization schedule will be studied and has cast doubt on whether newborns need the hepatitis B vaccine. The members also expressed skepticism around the safety and efficacy of the COVID-19 vaccine, which Kennedy announced earlier this year will no longer be recommended for healthy children and healthy pregnant women. In a , the former members wrote that the rigorous process for recommending vaccines is "rapidly eroding." Dr. Noel Brewer, a former ACIP member removed by Kennedy and a professor in the department of health behavior at the University of North Carolina Gillings School of Global Public Health, told ABC News that since the upheaval of the ACIP, vaccination has changed in the U.S. in a "fundamental" way and that the committee has "lost credibility." "We no longer have a single authority that's trustworthy to tell us who should get vaccinated at what age," he said. "This is a change in vaccine policy that is unprecedented, and we felt it important to start thinking about what a future should look like, or what a future will look like." "There is no good alternative to ACIP; the most that we could do is try to limit the damage," Brewer continued. He said ACIP has lost credibility with health care providers, especially with the decision to cut COVID-19 vaccine recommendations, and that the recent ACIP meeting was disappointing to witness. In the commentary, the first recommended step is to have professional organizations work together to "harmonize vaccine recommendations." Brewer said this is already happening, with professional societies meeting and establishing vaccination schedules. The American Academy of Pediatrics will recommend pediatricians and parents follow its own immunization schedule, which it has published for decades. The American Academy of Family Physicians and the American College of Physicians will publish recommendations for adults and the Infectious Diseases Society of America will set a schedule for people who are immunocompromised. Brewer said that while the recommendations will clarify what good health care is, it doesn't ensure that private insurers or the federal Vaccines for Children program will cover those vaccines. The second recommendation is for an external auditor of the new ACIP recommendations. "It's unclear how exactly that would play out, but some organizations would listen in on the ACIP meetings and, once they've concluded, look at the data and look at the decisions and see if they're reasonable," Brewer said. "Former ACIP members have taken on some of this role and will be commenting on the recent meeting." The third recommendation is to have a parallel system that follows past ACIP practices, which Brewer said would consist of people with credentials in fields such as immunology, virology and vaccinology who would meet once a quarter or every four months to review data and generate recommendations. Brewer said this system would be unlikely to succeed, however, due to the amount of funding it would cost and whether the CDC would be willing to share data before it's publicly available. However, he said this does not solve the current problem that the committee is missing members who have expertise in child primary care and vaccine implementation. "Those gaps were quite apparent at the last meeting," Brewer said. "They need to fill those gaps that will help credibility, but will not fully take care of the problem that the committee has tilted from being pro-vaccine to anti-vaccine, and that change complicates their roles as a recommending body." In a statement to ABC News, an HHS spokesperson said the former panelists "have it wrong, just like their rubber-stamped decisions on COVID vaccines." "Secretary Kennedy has restored public trust through his reconstitution of ACIP with highly credentialed medical doctors and public health experts committed to evidence-based medicine, gold standard science, and common sense," the statement said. "By replacing vaccine groupthink with a diversity of perspectives, Secretary Kennedy is strengthening the integrity of the advisory process guiding immunization policy in this country. Additionally, you can't claim them as anti-vaccine when they recommended them at their first meeting."
