logo
Trump isn't ‘un-American', he's just transparent

Trump isn't ‘un-American', he's just transparent

Telegraph03-03-2025

A common reaction to that notorious Trump/Zelensky press conference is 'we haven't seen anything like this before'. Seen is the key word.
Bust-ups and walk-outs do occur in diplomacy, the difference is that Donald Trump does in the open what is meant to be conducted in private. An example: in 2022, NBC reported that Joe Biden had spoken to Zelensky by phone about a $1 billion aid package, and when Zelensky began asking for more, the US president 'lost his temper' and told him to be more grateful.
So, yes, America argues with its friends. Worse than that: it has a record of abandoning them. I'm struck by the parallel between Ukraine and South Vietnam, two regimes encouraged by the US to fight an invader – at huge cost in money and lives – only for Washington to cut and run.
America's stake was far greater in Vietnam (it lost about 58,000 soldiers trying to see off the Viet Cong) and Richard Nixon, unlike Trump, attempted to strengthen his ally's hand with devastating bombing raids. But Nixon had promised his voters peace and, in December 1972, his administration suggested terms to South Vietnam's President Thieu.
If you want a sense of how the sausage is made in foreign policy, read the transcripts of Nixon's conversations with national security adviser Henry Kissinger. Thieu, it seems, rejected a peace deal that would be generous to the Viet Cong; Kissinger called him a 'cheap, self-serving son-of-a-b----', 'criminal' and 'insane.' He suggested cutting off Thieu's economic and military aid and 'doing a Diem on him' – referring to a coup d'état in 1963 that resulted in the assassination of one of Thieu's predecessors, Ngo Dinh Diem. Henry and Dick were discussing murder, but that was part of the job.
To keep face, they decided to bomb the Viet Cong a bit more – then offered it ceasefire terms obviously unfavourable to their own ally. ('We bombed [the enemy] into accepting our concessions,' explained Kissinger). Thieu was left with a promise of ongoing US funding, what you might call a 'backstop', but Congress, including a young Joe Biden, soon voted to turn off the tap.
South Vietnam fell in 1975. Some politicians opposed accepting refugees almost as vociferously as Trump does today. Decades later, Biden applied the withdrawal method to Afghanistan, believing voters were tired of building democracy in exotic locales.
All foreign policy is domestic. Rightly so. Presidents are elected to represent Ohio and Alabama, not Kabul or Kyiv, and as circumstances change it would be madness to stick to a failed policy. What confuses outsiders about America is that its ideals are universal, all men created equal etc, so it sounds as if it's operating out of the goodness of its heart. 'We shall pay any price,' said John F Kennedy, 'oppose any foe to assure the survival and success of liberty.' (The Diem coup, incidentally, happened on Kennedy's watch.)
Historian Mark White's latest, very good book, Icon, Libertine, Leader, suggests that Kennedy believed those words, that he entered office in thrall to his generals and the novels of Ian Fleming. He approved a disastrous invasion of Cuba and, probably, some plots to assassinate Fidel Castro. His strategy likely agitated the Soviets and gave a pretext for sending nuclear weapons to Cuba in 1962, bringing us closer to World War Three than we've ever been. Some argue that Kennedy's diplomacy during the Cuban Missile Crisis, though brilliant, de-escalated a drama he had helped to cause.
Trump would have been 16 years old during Cuba. Does he remember it? Most people my age have no memory of living with the fear of a nuclear exchange, but it conditioned an entire generation's attitude towards Russian relations – and Donald mentions the risks often.
That's why he's reluctant to provide security guarantees for a country outside Nato, which puts him in the tradition of non-interference adopted during the Soviet invasion of Hungary, in 1956. Today it is taken for granted that Ukraine should be allowed to join Nato if it so wishes, but as late as 1998, when senators discussed Nato's expansion, politicians of a less utopian era warned about 'poking the Russian bear'.
As for fawning over Moscow's leaders, as Trump does Putin, even Harry Truman, the wisest eagle of all, wrote in his diary, 'I can deal with Stalin. He is honest – but smart as hell.' This did not stop him defending Europe or Korea when the communists went on the march, but the point is that politicians can be charmed, awed, fooled or irritated by choices as small as not wearing a tie.
While many historians agree that Trump is something unseen before, a few might conclude he's the most American president we've ever had – his chief novelty being transparency. Viewers of the press conference were shocked by his volatility, but when he said 'you don't have the cards', he expressed the way countless administrations have handled smaller countries, including our own. The reason why British policy consists solely of trying to persuade the US to support our goals is because the Americans previously undermined our ability to act as an independent power.
They made demolition of the empire a tacit condition for their support during the Second World War. The US insisted on creating a unipolar world and now complains about having to police it almost on its own. The irony.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Frantic moment CNN reporter is hauled away by cops live on air at LA protests as anchor screams ‘what's going on?!'
Frantic moment CNN reporter is hauled away by cops live on air at LA protests as anchor screams ‘what's going on?!'

Scottish Sun

time23 minutes ago

  • Scottish Sun

Frantic moment CNN reporter is hauled away by cops live on air at LA protests as anchor screams ‘what's going on?!'

Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) COPS have detained a CNN reporter live on-air as he covered the tense Los Angeles protests. Anchor Laura Coates yelled out, "What's going on?" after watching national correspondent Jason Carroll being led away with his hands behind his back. 7 CNN national correspondent Jason Carroll was detained live on-air while covering the Los Angeles protests Credit: CNN 7 Carroll, seen in 2014, was told to put his hands behind his back and leave the area Credit: Alamy 7 Cops have clashed with protesters in the days-long protests over President Donald Trump's ICE raids Credit: AFP 7 Carroll was told that he would be arrested if he came back to the area Credit: CNN Carroll had been covering the fourth day of protests over Donald Trump's crackdown on illegal immigration when he suddenly lost touch with Coates on Thursday evening. "Jason? What's going on? I hear you. What happened Jason?" Coates said live on air. "I am being detained," said Carroll in the distance as his cameraman filmed several feet behind him. Carroll then chatted with the cops, who confirmed that he wasn't being arrested. "We're letting you go, but you can't come back," said the officer before threatening to arrest Carroll if he returned to the scene. The two appeared to have a friendly interaction before Carroll was put behind a wall of cops and lost touch with Coates. Later, Carroll explained that the officers didn't put him in zip ties but did grab both of his hands and told him, "you are being detained." The reporter was stunned by the sudden change as he had been roaming the streets of Los Angeles covering the protests since that morning. "It is something that I wasn't expecting simply because we have been out here all day," he said. "Normally, the officers [...] realize the press is there doing a job." Trump sends another 2k National Guard to riot-ravaged LA as chaos spreads with arrests in NYC & Texas Carroll was led away around the same time that officials told demonstrators that they had to leave or else they would be arrested. They cuffed a number of protesters and charged them with failure to disperse to finally break up Thursday's demonstration. 7 Carroll said he was stunned by the detainment because he had been covering the protests all day with no issues Credit: CNN 7 PROTESTS RAGE ON The protests, which started over the weekend, heated up after Trump sent around 2,000 National Guard troops to help keep the peace, despite California Governor Gavin Newsom warning him to back off. Newsom claims that the peaceful protests criticizing Trump's immigration crackdown turned into a protest once the troops arrived. Meanwhile, Trump has insisted that Los Angeles would have "burned to the ground" if he hadn't sent the soldiers, as he plans to send 700 Marines to the city. "If I didn't 'SEND IN THE TROOPS' to Los Angeles the last three nights, that once beautiful and great City would be burning to the ground right now," Trump wrote on Truth Social Tuesday morning. California has filed a lawsuit against Trump, accusing him of breaking the 10th Amendment when he sent in the guard. The protests have spawned more protests across the country, and hundreds of participants have been arrested. Trump has vowed to maintain law and order despite Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass begging him to pause the ICE raids. "There is a real fear in Los Angeles right now. Parents, workers, grandparents, young people scared to go about their daily lives," she said. "We are a city of immigrants. Washington is attacking our people, our neighborhoods and our economy."

White House says it will spare some Aids programs that were on the chopping block
White House says it will spare some Aids programs that were on the chopping block

The Independent

time31 minutes ago

  • The Independent

White House says it will spare some Aids programs that were on the chopping block

The White House is trying to reassure House Republicans that Donald Trump's plans to slash funding to Aids projects around the world will spare a number of key prevention programs. House Speaker Mike Johnson and his fellow GOP leaders in the lower chamber of Congress are racing to shore up support ahead of a vote on a $9.4bn package of spending cuts Thursday. Congressional Republicans have expressed particular concern over planned cuts to former commander-in-chief George W Bush 's signature President's Emergency Plan for Aids Relief (PEPFAR), which has been credited with saving millions of lives across the globe since 2003. As part of an effort to allay those worries and rally the troops, the House GOP leadership has vowed to retain treatments offered under PEPFAR as well as a number of other prevention schemes, according to Capitol Hill sources cited by Politico. Speaker Johnson's whip team reportedly spent Monday evening frantically texting Republicans and calculating probable votes for the 'rescissions' package, which, in addition to cutting hundreds of millions of dollars in foreign Aids funding, also targets public broadcasters like NPR and PBS, both of whom are currently suing Trump's administration over the withdrawal of federal funding. Russell Vought, Director of the Office of Management and Budget, told appropriators last week that the administration is seeking to take 'an analytical look' at Aids prevention and instead prioritize funding for 'life-saving treatment' for sufferers as part of its scaling back of PEPFAR. 'It is something that our budget will be very trim on,' he said of prevention funding. 'We believe that many of these nonprofits are not geared towards the viewpoints of the administration. And we're $37 trillion in debt. So at some point, the continent of Africa needs to absorb more of the burden of providing this healthcare.' Trump's cuts to Aids prevention funding, enacted under an executive order he signed within hours of returning to the Oval Office in January, have been forecast to have disastrous results. A crisis that had been on course to be brought under control by 2030 will now be extended at the cost of an estimated 4m more lives, according to forecasts from the United Nations Aids agency. The disruption to global HIV programmes by the U.S. is also projected to lead to more than 3m more Aids orphans than was previously anticipated by the end of the decade. But the president himself has insisted that it is Europe that needs to step up and invest more to help the nations worst-hit by the disease. 'Nobody does anything but the United States… Other countries should be helping us with that,' he told reporters onboard Air Force One last month. 'We're the only country. Where are the others? Where is France? Where is Germany? We've spent billions and billions of dollars.' documentary investigation by The Independent, which includes reporting from remote areas in Uganda and Zimbabwe, has recently demonstrated that Trump's brutal severing of aid – and abrupt halt in medication – is already tearing lives apart. Earlier this year The Independent revealed Trump's slashing of foreign aid has derailed the projected end of the Aids pandemic and could lead to four million extra deaths by 2030. Figures show the number of Aids-related deaths could jump from six million to 10 million in the next five years unless funding is reinstated, according to forecasts from the UN Aids agency (UNAIDS). The unprecedented disruption to global HIV programs by the U.S. is also projected to lead to more than three million more Aids orphans than previously expected by the end of the decade.

Trump administration live updates: Pentagon official says deploying National Guard to L.A. will cost $134 million
Trump administration live updates: Pentagon official says deploying National Guard to L.A. will cost $134 million

NBC News

time38 minutes ago

  • NBC News

Trump administration live updates: Pentagon official says deploying National Guard to L.A. will cost $134 million

What to know today NEW JERSEY ELECTIONS: Voters in New Jersey head to the polls today to pick the Democratic and Republican nominees for the governor's race in the first high-profile primaries since the November 2024 election. PETE HEGSETH TESTIFIES: Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth sparred with Democratic lawmakers while testifying this morning at a House hearing about the department's budget requests. LOS ANGELES PROTESTS: A top Pentagon official at the hearing estimated that deploying members of the National Guard and Marines to Los Angeles in response to immigration protests would cost the department around $134 million. TRUMP'S TESLA IS GONE: President Donald Trump's red Tesla, which he purchased to support Elon Musk, is no longer parked outside the White House after the duo's blow-up last week. Yesterday, the president told reporters that he may 'move the Tesla around a little bit.' House Speaker Mike Johnson says California Gov. Newsom should be 'tarred and feathered' Syedah Asghar and Rebecca Shabad House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., said today that California Gov. Gavin Newsom 'ought to be tarred and feathered" as punishment for his handling of protests in Los Angeles. Johnson stopped short of saying Newsom should be arrested — as Trump has suggested — saying he wouldn't offer that analysis, but claiming Newsom was an 'accomplice' in law enforcement agents being 'assaulted.' 'Look, that's not my lane. I'm not going to give you legal analysis on whether Gavin Newsom should be arrested, but he ought to be tarred and feathered. I'll say that,' Johnson told reporters at a press conference. Show more Cost of National Guard and Marine deployment in L.A. is approximately $134 million, DOD official says Megan Lebowitz The estimated cost of deploying the National Guard and the Marines to Los Angeles is $134 million, according to Bryn MacDonnell, a special assistant to Hegseth. She said the costs are largely related to temporary duty travel costs such as travel, housing and food. She was responding to a question from Rep. Pete Aguilar, D-Calif., who had asked for the estimated cost to deploy the National Guard and the Marines to respond to protests in Los Angeles. Rep. Mikie Sherrill hits Trump over military in Los Angeles Rep. Mikie Sherrill, a New Jersey Democrat running for governor, criticized Trump's decision to send Marines to Los Angeles amid unrest over immigration raids. 'It's a dangerous situation to put military on the streets of the country,' she said after casting her ballot in today's primary. Sherrill, who previously was a Navy helicopter pilot and federal prosecutor, said law enforcement and military personnel are trained in 'something very, very different.' 'If a governor feels that that is not the case, that governor can always go to the federal government to ask for support. That is not the case here,' Sherrill said. Sherrill is one of six Democrats running for governor of New Jersey. Abigail Spanberger has cash advantage in Virginia governor's race Bridget Bowman Former Democratic Rep. Abigail Spanberger has a sizable cash advantage in the Virginia governor's race, according to new campaign finance reports filed yesterday. Spanberger's campaign had $14.3 million in its account as of June 5, while GOP Lt. Gov. Winsome Earle-Sears' campaign had almost $3 million on hand. Spanberger raised $6.4 million and spent $3.2 million from April 1 through June 5, while Earle-Sears raised $3.5 million and spent $4.6 million over that same period. Spanberger and Earle-Sears are facing off in this year's gubernatorial race in Virginia to replace term-limited GOP Gov. Glenn Youngkin. Rep. Ed Case to Hegseth: 'I don't think you're talking to the right people' Megan Lebowitz Rep. Ed Case, D-Hawaii, challenged Hegseth about whether he thought cuts to foreign aid programs, much of which are outside the Defense Department's jurisdiction, affected Hegseth's job and the U.S. military. Hegseth said no, arguing that programs like USAID were "wasteful and duplicitous." He said that he has "heard nothing about" allies' problems about international organizations, arguing the organizations were not "serving U.S. interests." "I don't think you're talking to the right people," Case interjected. Show more Hegseth spars with Democrats during hearing Rep. Betty McCollum, D-Minn., clashed with Hegseth over the cost of deploying the National Guard and military to Los Angeles. McCollum asked Hegseth for information about the funding for troop deployments in Los Angeles, as well as whether any trainings were not taking place because troops were deployed. Hegseth began by referring to the George Floyd murder protests, prompting McCollum to interject multiple times and urge him to address the budget question. Show more Rep. Rosa DeLauro criticizes DOD firings and handling of war in Ukraine Rep. Rosa DeLauro, D-Conn., criticized staffing shakeups at the Defense Department, including the firing of the department's inspector general and the Joint Chiefs of Staff chairman, CQ Brown. "Mr. Secretary, of all the Cabinet departments, stability at the Department of Defense is the most critical for Americans' safety and security," she said. She also highlighted the administration's handling of the war in Ukraine, accusing the U.S. of turning its back on allies. "Why would anyone trust us or partner with us when we are busy undermining our allies' economies and encouraging China to fill the vacuum we are leaving by abandoning our humanitarian mission?" she asked Share Hegseth kicks off testimony before Congress Megan Lebowitz Hegseth has begun his testimony before a House Appropriations subcommittee hearing focused on the department's budget. The hearing is one of several congressional hearings that Hegseth is attending this week. Rep. Betty McCollum criticizes administration on L.A. response and decision to fire military officials Delivering opening remarks before Hegseth's testimony begins, Rep. Betty McCollum, D-Minn., criticized the administration's handling of the Los Angeles protests, saying that deploying National Guard troops was "premature" and that the order to deploy Marines was "downright escalatory." McCollum also criticized the administration's decision to fire Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman CQ Brown and other military leaders, saying it "appalled" her. "Many Americans, myself included, have witnessed what is a deliberate effort to silence and diminish the achievements of minorities and women in the military," she said. "Their dedication, their heroism, their sacrifice on behalf of our nation deserve recognition, not erasure." Sen. Bill Cassidy raises 'fear' RFK Jr. will stack vaccine committee with vaccine skeptics Ben Kamisar Louisiana GOP Sen. Bill Cassidy, who heads the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, raised concerns in a brief post on social media about the Health and Human Services Department's gutting of an independent vaccine advisory committee. Cassidy wouldn't elaborate on that warning when Capitol reporters asked about it last night. But the decision comes weeks after Cassidy praised the health secretary for having "lived up" to the commitments Kennedy made to secure Cassidy's confirmation vote, one of which was to "maintain the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices without changes." Yesterday, the CDC announced all 17 members of that vaccine advisory panel were being removed, with Kennedy saying the 'committee has been plagued with persistent conflicts of interest and has become little more than a rubber stamp for any vaccine.' Cassidy, who is a physician, said in his post that "the fear" is the committee "will be filled up with people who know nothing about vaccines except suspicion." Trump's red Tesla is no longer parked outside the West Wing After reports last week that Trump was considering selling or giving away the red Tesla that he purchased this spring in a show of support for Elon Musk, NBC News' White House team has been tracking the location of the vehicle. As of this morning, the car was no longer parked outside the West Wing. Yesterday, the president told inquiring reporters that he may 'move the Tesla around a little bit' and that he has 'a lot of locations' at which he could keep it, as he seemed to dismiss the idea that he intended to offload it entirely. Trump and Musk had a public falling out last week following the billionaire tech mogul's criticism of the massive Republican domestic policy bill, prompting the two to engage in an escalating feud on social media. The White House did not immediately respond to NBC News' request for information on the Tesla's status. Sen. Ruben Gallego endorses Rep. Angie Craig in Minnesota Senate primary Sahil Kapur Sen. Ruben Gallego, D-Ariz., is endorsing Rep. Angie Craig for the Democratic primary in Minnesota's Senate race, jumping into what is shaping up to be a contentious intraparty contest. In a statement first reported by NBC News, the freshman senator explained why he's backing Craig over Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan, who was endorsed last month by Gallego's fellow Democratic senator, Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts. 'Washington needs more people who are focused on getting things done. I'm supporting Angie because I've seen firsthand her ability to bring people together, listen to everyone and actually get results,' Gallego said. 'Angie is a fighter and is someone who leads with integrity, reason and a deep patriotic belief in our democracy.' Show more Congresswoman from Los Angeles says community is 'very scared' Democratic Rep. Norma Torres, who represents parts of Los Angeles County, said today that her 'constituents are very scared' of the sweeping Immigration and Customs Enforcement actions taking place in communities there. 'They don't want to get caught up in a situation where ICE is profiling and detaining them because of the color of their skin,' Torres said on MSNBC's "Way Too Early." Torres added that she and other Democratic members were barred from entering an ICE facility in downtown LA. 'It's not supposed to work this way. In the last Trump administration we made sure we changed the law so members of Congress would not be blocked from entering and doing oversight. … Imagine if your loved one just didn't come home one day and you tried to locate them but ICE is playing a shell game, transferring them from one location to another because they aren't interest in due process.' Show more U.S.-China trade talks kick off second day in London The U.S. and China are resuming trade talks in London today after yesterday's session. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick are leading the U.S. side. "I expect to go all day today," Lutnick told reporters. "So they're going well, we're spending lots of time together." Trump spoke with Chinese President Xi Jinping last week and said in a post on Truth Social that it "resulted in a very positive conclusion for both Countries." "There should no longer be any questions respecting the complexity of Rare Earth products," Trump had said after the call, going on to point to the talks between the two countries' representatives. In recent weeks, both countries have accused each other of violating a preliminary trade agreement, which had walked back the steepest tariffs. Hegseth to testify before House Appropriations subcommittee this morning Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth will appear before the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense for an oversight hearing, marking the first time the Pentagon chief will deliver testimony to a House panel since his Senate confirmation. Hegseth will be joined by Air Force Gen. Dan Caine, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. The House subcommittee is chaired by Rep. Ken Calvert, R-Calif. NBC News reported yesterday that the White House has struggled to hire senior advisers to Hegseth, with three people rejecting potential roles and Vice President JD Vance and White House chief of staff Susie Wiles poring over potential candidates on his behalf. Hegseth came under intense criticism after media reports that he shared sensitive information about a U.S. military operation in Yemen on Signal group chats, including one that inadvertently had a journalist added to it. 'We're happy to have this fight': Trump administration leans into California protests Trump's immigration agenda has met a groundswell of opposition in Los Angeles, the country's second-largest city. At least 56 people have been arrested so far in massive protests against the administration's immigration raids in the city Friday. The demonstrations have spilled over onto one of the region's largest freeways, and federal authorities are facing criticism after they arrested, and apparently injured, a prominent labor leader. In response, the White House has threatened to arrest California's governor and mobilized Marines to support National Guard troops in defending federal property — even though state officials say they don't want the assistance and are now suing the administration. For the White House, this scene — Trump battling a blue state over his signature issue — is a political win, officials said. It's a nationally watched saga of the sort that has long defined his career: a made-for-TV moment.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store