Voice actors can pursue some claims over AI voiceovers, US court says
U.S. District Judge J. Paul Oetken dismissed, opens new tab most of the federal copyright and trademark law claims in the lawsuit but denied Lovo's bid to dismiss claims that it violated the actors' publicity rights.
Oetken also permitted the actors to amend their claim that Lovo's AI training infringed their copyrights. The case is part of a wave of lawsuits in which tech companies have been accused of misusing content including books, news articles and song lyrics to train generative AI systems.
The actors' attorney, Steve Cohen of Pollock Cohen, called the decision a "spectacular victory" and said he was "confident that a jury will come to the same conclusions as Judge Oetken and hold big tech accountable." Spokespeople and attorneys for Lovo did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the decision.
Plaintiffs Paul Skye Lehrman and Linnea Sage said in the proposed class action filed last year that they were approached on freelancer marketplace Fiverr to provide voiceover work for anonymous clients. Lehrman was allegedly told his voice would be used only for a "research project," while Sage was told her voice would be used only with "test scripts for radio ads."
The actors said they later learned Lovo sold the use of Lehrman's voice to subscribers as "Kyle Snow" and Sage's as "Sally Coleman." According to the complaint, the company responded to a cease-and-desist letter by claiming that the actors' voices were "not popular" and that their sales were "negligible."
Lovo asked the court in January to dismiss the case.
"Plaintiffs continue to try to tell a tale filled with pathos and the woes of artificial intelligence," the company said in a court filing. "However, their story and concern do not relate to Lovo's interactions with named Plaintiffs and fails to state an actionable claim."
Oetken concluded the actors were not entitled to trademark protection for their voices and that Lovo's "imperfect mimicry" of them did not infringe their copyrights.
The judge, however, said the actors could file an updated complaint alleging Lovo's use of their voice recordings for AI training violated their copyrights. He also said the actors could advance their claim that Lovo violated their commercial rights in their voices under New York law.
The case is Lehrman v. Lovo Inc, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, No. 1:24-cv-03770.
For the voice actors: Steve Cohen of Pollock Cohen
For Lovo: David Case and Michael Lazaroff of Rimon Law
Read more:
AI voiceover company stole voices of actors, New York lawsuit claims
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
36 minutes ago
- The Independent
Ukraine-Russia war latest: Trump threatens Putin with ‘severe tariffs' as he pledges Patriot missiles for Kyiv
Donald Trump has once again expressed his disappointment with Russian president Vladimir Putin and announced 100 per cent sanctions on Russia as he pledged more weapons for Ukraine, including 17 Patriot missiles which Kyiv has urgently sought. "We're going to be doing secondary tariffs," the US president said, announcing sanctions on countries who trade with Moscow. "If we don't have a deal in 50 days, it's very simple, and they'll be at 100 per cent,' the US president said, adding that he was disappointed in Mr Putin. Mr Trump announced that billions of dollars of US weapons would go to Ukraine, and said: "We're going to make top-of-the-line weapons, and they'll be sent to Nato.' "We have one country that has 17 Patriots getting ready to be shipped... we're going to work a deal where the 17 will go or a big portion of the 17 will go to the war site,' he said, adding that some will 'come very soon, within days'. Mr Trump has grown increasingly disenchanted with Mr Putin after he resisted Washington's attempts to negotiate a ceasefire between Ukraine and Russia.
Daily Mail
41 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Bill Maher clashes with Hollywood actor John Leguizamo over immigration into US
Actor John Leguizamo told Bill Maher that America should take on more migrants because 'there's plenty of room here'. The liberal's assertion came during a fiery episode of Maher's Club Random podcast that laid bare the political fault lines between the two liberal voices. 'There's plenty of room in America, come on. There's no lack of room in America,' Leguizamo insisted, as Maher pushed back. 'It can't just be like, "come one, come all," Maher countered. 'It's never about room. It's about resources… Countries have to have a border.' The episode, which dropped on Monday saw the two clashing not just over immigration policy but race, identity, and even past personal encounters with Donald Trump himself. Maher, 69, a longtime liberal comedian known for skewering both the left and right, accused the Biden administration of mishandling the border crisis, prompting Leguizamo, 64, to launch into a passionate defense of immigrants and a scorching attack on what he sees as systemic racism in US history. 'We've been here since the beginning,' Leguizamo declared, referring to Latino communities in the United States. 'The first European language spoken in America was not English - it was Spanish. But we haven't moved up. We've stayed in the same place because this is the fourth mass deportation of Latinos since 1830.' He launched into a historical recounting of Latino persecution: 'After Mexico became America and they invaded and took from Mississippi to the Pacific, they started lynching people, stealing their land, stealing their political wealth. In the 1930s, with the Repatriation Act, two million Latinos - most of them American citizens - were deported.' Maher, who has been critical of both Trump and Biden's immigration policies looked at the modern day issue. 'Part of this is a backlash to how badly Biden handled the immigration situation… You can't just open the gates. 'Something like 200 million people around the world, when asked, "Would you come to America if you could?" - "Yes, I would." Why wouldn't they? Lots of countries, excuse me, are s***tholes, and they would love to be here.' Leguizamo was quick to push back: 'The places aren't s***holes.' 'Well, they are,' Maher replied. 'That's why they want to come.' 'It's usually because of America,' Leguizamo shot back. 'What America's done, especially in Latin America, is beat up every democracy that was burgeoning. They destroyed it to keep their oil or their resources or bananas.' The sharp exchange spiraled into more personal territory when Leguizamo recounted a past encounter with Trump, long before the real estate mogul entered politics. 'I met him a time I was giving an award at Trump Tower,' the actor recalled. 'He came up to me and goes, "Oh, you're so articulate."' Leguizamo said he interpreted that comment as a racist slight: 'White people always tell you that if you're a Latin person and you can speak, that you're so articulate -which I know is code for "I thought you were all dumb." Maher acknowledged the offense, calling the remark 'just obnoxious,' but rejected the notion that Trump himself was a racist: 'He's not a racist. He's a product of his time.' Leguizamo pushed back again: 'Some of us overcome our times.' 'That is true and fair to say,' Maher agreed. The exchange grew even more heated when the two addressed Trump's adviser, Stephen Miller, widely regarded as the architect of the Trump administration's hardline immigration policies. 'He's not on the level of racism that Stephen Miller is,' Leguizamo said. 'Nobody is at the level of Stephen Miller's racism. He grew up in Santa Monica with Latinos and I guess they bullied him - and he's got a chip on his shoulder.' Throughout the conversation, Maher tried to temper Leguizamo's moral urgency by citing how border towns and liberal cities were overwhelmed buckling under migrant inflows. 'Even the governor of New York was like, "We can't take all these people," Maher said. 'Mayor Adams was like - and he's right - it's like, you know, these people live here and now this is their burden.' Leguizamo, who hosts MSNBC's Leguizamo Does America, argued that immigrants were not a burden but the backbone of the country. 'The immigrants that are coming here are building the country,' he said. 'They're the essential workers. They're the first responders. They're doing all your construction, painting, plumbing, raising all your food, cooking all your food, serving all your food, taking care of your kids. We do all the work that nobody wants to do.' Maher responded, 'Yes, they are. Absolutely. But… there has to be some order to it.' Leguizamo seemed unmoved by the call for moderation. 'Let's fix the legal immigration,' he demanded. 'It's a broken system. People who've been here for 30 years can't be naturalized. That's insane.' In a rare moment of agreement, Maher conceded the legal system is failing many long-time immigrants. 'Fix the quotas,' he said. 'Fix the blockage.' The conversation went back and forth between barbed humor and some tense disagreements, with Maher even joking about the kinds of countries where 'you can take a chicken on a bus' being what he called 's***hole countries.' He clarified: 'It doesn't mean you're a s***hole person. You have the misfortune of being born there.' Leguizamo, while acknowledging the hardships, insisted that the answer was not shutting the door, but swinging it open. 'Immigrants are the life source of this country,' he said.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Pharmacy that outlasted Walgreens, CVS and Rite Aid to close in days after 117 years
Legendary California pharmacy Central Drug Store will be closing its doors for the last time on Tuesday after 117 years. Owner and operator Jerry Tonelli announced the San Francisco store would be shuttering following his retirement. The store has outlasted pharmacy empires like Walgreens, CVS and Rite Aid, along with various mail order services. While the closure has come as a shock to some customers, Jerry assured them that it was his decision to close the store and that he was leaving on his own terms. 'It is time for all of us to start a new phase in our lives and spend more time with our families,' he wrote in a Facebook post. The longtime store has been in the same building since 1918 and was purchased by the Tonelli family in 1965. Jerry took over the store in 1978 following the death of his father and has worked with family members like his brother, Paul, who also owns a share of the business. With other relatives uninterested in taking over the business, Jerry began measures to close up, including thanking loyal customers and patients. The Tonelli family's pharmaceutical run began when Dino Tonelli, Jerry's father, began working at the store in 1949. The late employee had graduated from a pharmacy school at UCSF and served in World War II before taking over the business, but not before meeting his wife. 'My mother started working here when she was 16, and she died in 2023 at the age of 96,' Jerry told CBS News. 'So, she had quite a run here, and this was her favorite part of the store because she used to do all the buying for the cosmetics, for the perfumes.' His parents teamed up in keeping the business strong before Dino's death, leaving Jerry to learn by 'trial and error' in his thirties. The soon-to-be-retiree managed to keep the business going and made new friends along the way that were grateful for his help. 'We get a lot of people from other countries that don't have health insurance and don't want to see a doctor,' he revealed. 'They'll come in and ask this and ask that and try to treat them with over-the-counter medication to help them out.' Several customers have shared memories and in store experiences on social media Many customers have shared memories and stories of how Central Drug Store has helped them in some way while growing up. 'As a young girl in the 50s my mom, Tosca Chiantelli and I came in your store every Saturday and looked at everything in the displays and picked up prescriptions and necessities,' a Facebook user wrote. The customer continued by saying she visited the pharmacy regularly in the 70s and 80s, and how happy she was about the pharmacy continuing to help her parents for decades. 'I used to love going into the drugstore with my mom as a little girl. Silvana was always my favorite at the make up counter,' another social media user commented. Longtime customer Fran Colombo has been going to the store for the last 50 years explained the family would make everyone feel special as soon as they walk in the door. She was also touched by Jerry escorting her husband to his car, saying his action went 'above and beyond.' Now that the store is shuttering, Colombo is trying to figure out what to do next, and is questioning what other customers will do. 'I'm kind of computer savvy, but what about the people who aren't, who are just used to the walking in and calling in a prescription and walking in and picking it up? What are they going to do?,' she asked. Jerry was concerned the pharmacy would shut down because of pharmaceutical empires Jerry admitted that one of his biggest concerns was independent pharmacies being forced out by various pharmaceutical empires. However, some of those companies have been struggling in recent years. Rite Aid, a once-popular chain with over 5,000 stores, filed for bankruptcy in 2023 and again in May this year. It is now planning to shutter all its stores. The status of CVS has also been concerning since the chain planned to close 900 stores by the end of 2024. Currently operating over 9,000 US locations, CVS is also set to shutter hundreds of stores this year. If that wasn't enough, Walgreens has been in the process of shuttering 1,200 stores, including 450 this year. While the pharmaceutical crisis continues to be on the rise, Jerry will be busy golfing, spending time with family, and continuing to help people by volunteering at hospitals or shelters.
