Trade group warns Stirling's proposed 'tourist tax' could 'harm' the region's tourism
The trade group has warned that Stirling's proposed 'tourist tax' would harm tourism in the region and called for an economic impact survey to be carried out.
Another hospitality trade body has warned that the proposed ' tourist tax ' which could be introduced in Stirling could 'harm tourism' in the region.
UK Hospitality Scotland has urged Stirling Council to carry out a full economic impact assessment on the impacts of the proposed visitor levy.
The levy would see visitors to the city hit with an additional charge on overnight accommodation.
Stirling Council last month launched an online survey over the plans, which runs until Sunday.
But UK Hospitality Scotland this week said that it did not agree with the introduction of a levy.
UK Hospitality Scotland Executive Director, Leon Thompson, said: 'Hospitality and tourism is so important to Stirling, as a major employer and driver of the local economy.
'That economic and social contribution to our communities must be protected and we fundamentally believe that introducing a visitor levy could harm tourism in Stirling.
'That's why Stirling Council should carry out a detailed impact assessment to understand the potential impact on visitors, tourism and the economy, before it embarks further on potentially introducing a levy.
'We're keen to work with the council so they understand the perspective of accommodation businesses and I look forward to engaging further with them during this process.'
They have become the second trade group to raise concerns over the proposals.
Last December, one national trade association warned the council to 'tread carefully' over its plans.
The Association of Scotland's Self-Caterers (ASSC) said that the introduction of a visitor levy scheme on tourists in Stirling would mean that small businesses could become 'de-facto unpaid tax collectors'.
ASSC chief executive, Fiona Campbell said the implementation of the tax must 'be done right'.
Last month, a campaign group against the proposals warned the move could see the city's hospitality sector left with high levels of cancellations.
The Back British Holidays campaign warned that as much as 21-per cent of potential holidaymakers could cancel their trip over the additional tariff.
Additionally, they said another 21-per cent would reduce their spending while on holiday.
Now, Back British Holidays is calling on policymakers to reconsider proposals over fears levies could significantly harm local tourism economies costing local businesses millions in lost revenue.
A Stirling Council spokesperson said: 'We welcomed the input of all stakeholders, including UK Hospitality Scotland, to our initial public engagement on the draft visitor levy for Stirling.
'More than 660 people and organisations had their say on how the levy could work in the online survey before it closed on Sunday 4 May. This feedback, coupled with the responses gathered at drop-in sessions, face-to-face meetings and via paper surveys, will help ensure the draft scheme, if implemented, maximises the potential benefits for everyone, from residents to accommodation providers and visitors.
'We are also considering additional research and analysis that could inform a potential scheme.
'While a visitor levy could offer opportunities to reinvest revenues in key infrastructure used by visitors and residents, such as roads, pavements, leisure facilities and parks, it would also need to reflect the needs of Stirling's key tourism sector.'
Stirling Council's consultation on the proposed charge ends on Sunday, May 4. Residents can provide their feedback in an online survey – with paper copies also available at the council's libraries.
A series of drop-in sessions have also been held for businesses, accommodation providers and anyone wishing to share their views on the scheme.
Once the draft scheme has been produced, a formal consultation on it will begin on July 13 and run until October 11.
The final version of the scheme will be presented to council for a decision on December 11, this year.
If the levy is given the go ahead, it would be subject to a minimum 18-month period of implementation between its announcement and the scheme coming into effect, meaning that the earliest it could be introduced in Stirling would be in June 2027.
The council says that it's estimated the introduction of a one-per cent visitor levy could generate between £1.5million and £2.3million each year, while a five per cent levy could generate as much as £7.5million.
All money raised would be reinvested locally in facilities and services that are substantially for, or used, by leisure and business visitors.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
2 days ago
- Daily Record
Work to begin on Stirling Council's first new primary school in 30 years
Corbiewood PS will serve the 800-home South Stirling Gateway housing estate, with completion for the project expected in time for the 2026/27 academic term. Building work is to begin on Stirling Council's first new primary school in almost 30 years. Ground will be broken on the new primary school serving the new major housing development at South Stirling Gateway in the coming weeks. Work on the site is due to begin in late June where a seven-classroom facility will be built in the heart of the development site by McLaughlin & Harvey. It is anticipated to be completed by the beginning of the 2026/27 academic term and will be followed by a four-classroom extension in 2033/34 depending on roll estimates. The new school will be constructed alongside external sports and landscaping and be linked to active travel routes to and from Bannockburn and its surrounding areas. Planning permission for the school was granted at the Planning and Regulation Panel in February. Pending approval from councillors, the new school will be named Corbiewood Primary School. It will be the first new school built within the Stirling Council area to support population growth since Newton Primary School in Dunblane opened its doors in 1996. Children and Young People Convener, Cllr Danny Gibson said: 'An exciting milestone in the South Stirling Gateway development has being reached with the appointment of a contractor to build this brand new primary school that will serve this emerging community. 'This modern, state of the art school epitomises Stirling Council's commitment to its ongoing investment in learning infrastructure for our children and young people and will help the new community to continue to thrive. 'Work will get underway shortly and we will keep local people updated throughout the construction. I can't wait to see the progress of the new school as it develops in tandem with the new housing development over the coming months and years. This is another sign that Stirling is continuing to flourish and grow.' Chris Boyle, Framework Director at McLaughlin & Harvey said: 'We are delighted to be delivering a new primary school for Stirling Council that will be at the heart of the South Stirling Gateway development. This project offers the chance for us to deliver a modern, exciting building, which can help achieve educational excellence. 'Our early partnership with the council, facilitated through the SCAPE Framework, has been the catalyst for designing a truly sustainable project within the agreed budget and timescales. We look forward to continuing our work with Stirling Council to construct a building which can inspire future generations of young people.' Children from South Stirling Gateway will be accommodated at Bannockburn Primary School while construction is underway and will initially feed into Bannockburn High School. The developers are in the first phase of housebuilding on the site following planning permission being granted in April 2024 for the first 150 homes. The South Stirling Gateway Development will deliver around new 800 homes with almost 200 allocated for affordable housing.
Daily Record
3 days ago
- Daily Record
Stirling schools music tuition in new cuts confusion
Campaigners say proposals to slash the service's budget by £200k were outlined to staff earlier this week without the knowledge of councillors - but council denies the department faces any savings Music tuition in Stirling's schools was this week at the centre of cuts confusion ... just two months after councillors unanimously rejected an option to slash it by £250,000. Staff from the council's instrumental music service were said to have been called to an urgent meeting chaired by a service manager on Tuesday of this week and told that education officers are seeking £200,000 of 'efficiency savings' from the service in this financial year. Specific details of where the axe could fall were said to have been outlined at the meeting. With councillors across the board unaware of the move, questions were then being asked over just how a cut of almost the same level was being brought in 'under the radar' without the knowledge of elected members. But yesterday (Thursday) the council denied any such cuts were being considered. Earlier, one campaigner told the Observer: 'The people of Stirling, through their elected members, have made it quite clear that they value and wish to see the music service remain intact and enhanced. 'Unelected council bureaucrats appear to be wilfully disregarding the wishes of Stirling councillors and are bringing forward these efficiency savings behind the backs of elected members.' A Stirling SNP group spokesperson meanwhile said: 'From what we have discovered, [the 'efficiencies'] could be over £200,000, with cuts to tuition at McLaren, Balfron and Stirling High Schools. 'Stirling SNP councillors remain resolute in avoiding the annual stress to families of such cuts at budget time and indeed our motion to protect music tuition was passed earlier this year. 'As such we are now concerned these proposals, if true, run contrary to this motion with cuts nonetheless being brought in 'under the radar' as 'operational efficiencies'.' SNP Group Leader Susan McGill said: 'The SNP group proposed to protect music tuition for the remainder of this council term, but if this is true, these services won't last past the summer holidays.' Stirling MP Chris Kane (Labour), a former leader of Stirling Council, said: 'Music education opens doors, nurtures confidence, and helps young people thrive. 'I've asked the chief executive of Stirling Council for urgent clarity on reports of cuts to the service. Any decisions must be transparent, accountable, and reflect the clear support all councillors have shown for protecting music tuition in Stirling's schools.' Local Scottish Conservative MSP and Shadow Minister for Local Government & Public Finance, Alexander Stewart, who was preparing to put an urgent question to First Minister John Swinney at Holyrood, said the move 'could have a detrimental effect on music teaching at Stirling, Balfron and McLaren High Schools, in addition to all associated primaries - potentially leaving pupils without a music teacher'. He added: 'Music has long played a central part in Scottish culture and the removal of this service could have a disastrous effect on these children's life chances. 'Also this situation is certainly not in the spirit of the unanimous motion in support of the music service passed by councillors only two months ago, which I welcomed in Parliament. 'So I have written to Stirling Council's chief executive requesting an urgent meeting regarding this awful situation.' As the Observer went to press, however, council leader, Labour's Cllr Gerry McGarvey, said: 'The administration stands by the budget motion of earlier in the year and is concerned that inaccurate information has been circulating.' A Stirling Council spokesperson also denied music tuition was being targeted for savings. They added: 'The 2025-26 budget saving proposal to review the music tuition service (achieving a saving of £200,000 in the current financial year) was rejected by councillors when this year's budget was set and therefore it wasn't implemented. 'All council services continually assess service delivery for improvement and to ensure best value. Work to identify service delivery transformation which may achieve savings is underway across services - but no savings are being taken forward in relation to music tuition.' The music tuition service has been a target in budget options tabled by council officials for savings for a number of years. However, the move has also consistently attracted strong protest and successive council political administrations have baulked at the idea of the cuts. Earlier this year protesting musicians - including teachers, pupils and supporters - struck up their instruments outside Stirling Council's headquarters, helping to cement the message on the controversial budget cut proposals. And ultimately councillors, while entertained by the musicians, were not entertained by the thought of slashing the music tuition budget. Campaigners have argued that such cuts would remove many instrumental music teachers currently working in Stirling schools, with serious implications for the staff concerned and hugely damaging consequences for young people learning music in Stirling. The local campaign against the budget cuts, which attracted more than 5000 signatures, was backed by international composer and former Gartmore resident Sally Beamish OBE. Former Stirling High School pupil and Emmy-winning musician John Lunn - who has composed for hit shows Downton Abbey, Shetland, and Grantchester - also backed the campaign, as did Jeffrey Sharkey, principal of Royal Conservatoire of Scotland.
Daily Record
4 days ago
- Daily Record
Council's 52,000 lost working days due to staff absence equates to £6million
The figures are an improvement on the previous year but, when combined, anxiety, stress and depression remain the main driver for workers staying at home. Staff absence throughout Stirling Council saw more than 50,000 working days lost in a year - equating to over £6million in pay. Figures due to be reported to this week's finance and economy committee, show a reduction in working days lost (WDL) for the financial year 2024-25 - with the total number 52,593. But, in their report, officials said: 'While this is a decrease by 8403 WDL from 2023-24, in pay costs alone this rate of absence amounts to over £6million. 'Teacher absence has reduced to 8.07 WDL (down 0.76 compared to 2023-24) and absence for all other employees (AOE) has reduced to 16.78 WDL (down 1.31). 'Overall this reduced council-wide absence level to 14.25 WDL (down 1.93 WDL since 2022-23).' HSCP (Health and Social Care Partnership), Education (non-teaching) and Environment and Place, accounted for the highest levels of annualised days lost per FTE (full time equivalent). However, in each of these service areas, the working days lost have reduced from the previous year. Children and Families, however, experienced the most significant increase in WDL - by 3.08 WDL to 15.25 WDL. The report added: 'It should be noted that an ongoing factor which may adversely impact attendance at work in these service areas, is the nature of some roles being more physically or mentally/emotionally demanding. 'In 2023-24 Stirling ranked 31st for AOE (all other employees) and 30th for teachers. The 2024-25 absence figures are not yet published, however, based on improving figures, the placing for Stirling based on the 2023-24 figures is expected to be 28th for AOE and 18th for teachers.' When combined, anxiety, stress and depression remain the main driver for working days lost in 2024-25. However, when these reasons are considered separately, musculoskeletal absence is the main reason for WDL in 2024-25 at 10,200 - an increase from 2023-24 when a reduction of 1601 WDL was recorded against 2022-23 figures. Personal stress is the second main reason for absence, although this has reduced by 317 WDL. Work-related stress had a slight reduction by 236 WDL to 3114 WDL. Anxiety/depression also had a small reduction of 59 WDL. Coughs/colds/flu have recorded a higher number of WDL than was anticipated, with an increase by 2174 WDL to 6752 WDL. The increase is said to reflect the prevalence of respiratory illness during the recent winter months. Gastrointestinal absence reduced by 530 WDL to 5613 WDL. The report says the council's approach to the management of health-related absence is based on providing early intervention support and, where the Supporting Attendance process is progressed, methods such as return-to-work meetings, attendance support meetings, and attendance review meetings are held which also identify any support needed. During 2024-25 there were 1205 such meetings. Staff absence due to an underlying health reason which makes it difficult for an employee to attend work, or to maintain a reasonable attendance level at work, is supported via the Attendance Capability Process which saw 148 meetings in 2024-25. Ongoing sickness absence, for which there is no underlying medical condition, may be progressed in accordance with the council's disciplinary procedures - and nine disciplinary investigations were held in 2024-25 due to an 'unacceptable level' of attendance at work. There is said to have been an 'incresasing trend' in individual cases progressing to Attendance Capability since 2022, with 148 individuals in 2024-25 - 11 whose employment has been terminated. Separately, the Disciplinary Procedure is progressed for absences where staff have been supported through the Supported Attendance Policy but have been unable to sustain an acceptable level of attendance at work, and where such absences are not due to an underlying health reason. In 2024-25 there were nine disciplinary hearings held due to unacceptable levels of attendance. The sanction in the majority of hearings due to attendance levels, was a first warning. Among a range of measures outlined in the report to support staff are the Employee Assistance Programme (EAP) which provides staff with free and confidential counselling at any time they need it; support services for immediate family; access to a wellbeing portal which can be downloaded to personal devices; and monthly wellbeing seminars. The report said: 'During 2024-25 there were 107 calls and 143 sessions of counselling. Of these, telephone counselling has been the most used method, with 72 sessions delivered. Uptake of counselling has dropped significantly from the 2023-24 figure by 718 sessions. 'Staff calls to our EAP are received by a professional counsellor who can provide real time support and advice. This may contribute to the reduction in additional referrals required. 'The EAP provides a wide range of support beyond counselling. This includes access to an online portal and app offering self-help resources such as financial advice and wellbeing tools. Increased use of these resources may have contributed to a reduction in calls to the helpline.'
